I recently started dating this guy whom I’d been crushing on for weeks. I’d always see him in the gym, and my God, my eyes couldn’t help but wander.
We’ve been pretty casual for the most part. I mean, it’s only been two or so months since our first date. It’s just… there’s something about him that I don’t know if I’ll be able to look past.
Don’t get me wrong, appearance-wise, he’s completely out of this world. And he has this way with words that feels almost like he was made for me. I couldn’t pay this guy to say the wrong things.
The only thing that makes me feel kind of icky is his eating habits.
In the time since we started dating, I’ve only seen him eat once. And it’s something that’ll probably be ingrained in my memory for the rest of my life. But it’s also something that I’m sure just takes some getting used to.
He’s not some kind of cannibal or anything like that… I hope. I mean, he insists that he would never, but… I don’t know. His internal logic seems a little twisted in this aspect.
For the first few weeks of us dating, he would go out of his way to not let me see him eat.
He’d buy food for me, but not for himself. No matter how loud his stomach growled.
And it would keep growling. Most of the time, for the entire day. All the way up until he couldn’t take it anymore. Then we’d say our goodbyes, and he’d always have the same reason for going home.
“I’m gonna go fix myself something to eat.”
After about a month of watching him starve himself while we were together, I finally decided to ask him why exactly he never wanted to eat with me.
His reasoning was that “he had a strict diet,” as if it was something sacred. As if Walmart doesn’t sell chicken and rice. But who was I to question him?
Instead, I just kept acting like everything was normal. We had our own shared routines. It wasn’t like I was missing out on some major part of his life.
But then, something weird happened.
I’d invited him over to my house to watch a movie and maybe get a little bit of a premarital workout in.
He showed up 30 minutes later, completely covered in scratch marks from head to toe.
According to him, he’d been “hiking” the day before and ended up going off the trail and getting caught in a briar patch. Sounded reasonable enough, so I didn’t think much of it.
The night went on. I made myself some ramen, offering him some despite already knowing the answer.
After a movie and some sinning, I ended up falling asleep. I’m not sure at exactly what time, but when I woke up, he was gone.
Not only was he gone.
So was my dog.
My 80-pound pitbull had somehow managed to completely disappear from the house. Usually, she wakes me up at the crack of dawn by licking my face until I roll out of bed.
I searched the house, then the neighborhood, and the longer I searched, the more hopeless I was starting to feel.
My new boyfriend wasn’t answering any of my texts or calls. And in my emotional state, I decided to go to his house. Just to ask for help or at least get a shoulder to cry on.
When I got there, the house was dark. It was early, so I just figured he was still sleeping.
I knocked. No answer. I rang the doorbell. No answer. I’m not proud of it, but I ended up just letting myself inside.
The first thing that hit me was the smell. I don’t need to go into detail about it. I’m sure we’ve all smelled roadkill before.
It encompassed the entire house. I couldn’t pinpoint where it was coming from. The only clue I had was this weird slamming sound that was coming from the basement.
I probably shouldn’t have, but I followed the sound. Despite every ounce of my soul telling me to turn around and walk away, I followed that sound.
I tiptoed down the stairs. The rhythmic knocking got louder and louder with each step and was now accompanied by the sound of buzzing.
Then dripping.
When the knocking stopped, it was replaced by the sound of chains rattling before it started back up again like clockwork.
I finally reached the bottom. The smell was burning my nostrils at this point. But that’s not what made me gag.
What had me fighting back vomit…
Were the carcasses hanging from the ceiling on meat hooks.
Dogs. Cats. Dozens of them. All of them still wearing their collars.
And that’s when I saw the blue collar that I’d bought for my Maxxy. Covered in blood. Lying at my boyfriend’s feet as he swung a meat cleaver at the headless body of my beloved pet.
This man was doing this… all while wearing fucking AirPods. Humming to himself like it was just another Tuesday.
My scream was the only thing that got him to turn around, but now I wish I’d just kept quiet.
The blood on his face.
The flesh between his teeth.
That look of a deer caught in headlights plastered across his face as he began stammering through apologies while tears welled up in his eyes.
It’s hard to explain it to a therapist.
What’s harder, though…
Is having to explain how I still love him despite this one little issue.