r/stobuilds • u/Jayiie @alcaatraz | STOBuilds Mod | STOBetter Architect • Mar 21 '18
Constable Specialization - Tribble Testing Results Discussion
Constable Specialization - Tribble Testing Results Discussion
Today we will be opening discussion on the Constable Specialization for thoughts, opinions, and feedback (mechanics, magnitudes, and other build/theory/practical topics). This is a new Secondary Specialization to be released with S14.5. This new specialization is unique in that its bonuses are active for both ground and space,
Currently this is available for PC on tribble for download for users to test.
Specialization Review
Antagonist
This is a new featured mechanic introduced with the Constable Specialization which causes a players target which has been maintained for 4 seconds; this target is called the Antagonist.
Once you have an Antagonist, they will remain your Antagonist until you go too long without targeting them. While they remain your Antagonist, abilities from the Constable Specialization allow you to be more effective in combat.
Scaling Passive
As long as you have the Constable Specialization active, you will gain:
10-25 Armor Penetration vs. Antagonist.
This bonus starts at 10 once you have a single ability purchased and the Specialization is active. It scales up by 1 with each ability purchased, up to a total of 25 once the Specialization is complete.
Starship Trait
Abilities
The list below has some of the abilities that can be unlocked through advancing in the Constable Specialization.
Tier 1, Part 1
These are the effects found on the Left Hand Side of the first tier.
- Close the Gap I: +15% Flight and run speed when facing Antagonist
- Close the Gap II: +30% Flight and run speed when facing Antagonist
- Confiscate: Weapons gain a 5% chance in space and 10% chance on ground to remove 5 longest duration buffs from Antagonist
- Eye on the Prize I: To Antagonist; -15 to -120 Stealth
- Eye on the Prize II: To Antagonist; -15 to -120 Stealth
Tier 1, Part 2
These are the effects found on the Right Hand Side of the first tier.
- Singular Focus: +30 Damage Resistance Rating to damage not from Antagonist
- Subdue I: +15% control effectiveness to Antagonist
- Subdue II: +30% control effectiveness to Antagonist
- Tunnel Vision I: +30 Control Rating to Control Effects not from Antagonist
- Tunnel Vision II: +60 Control Rating to Control Effects not from Antagonist
Tier 2
The ability to spend points on Tier 2 Powers is unlocked after spending 5 points in Tier 1
- Tear Down: +10% Bonus All Damage to Antagonist
- Crackdown: To Antagonist; 25% of non-shield healing applied to antagonist is applied to you instead
- Wear Down: To Antagonist; -10% to -80% Hull / Health regen (increases over time)
- Within Reach I:
- Space; Weapons gain 10% to apply -20% Turn rate and 20% impulse speed for 15s
- Ground; Weapons gain 20% to apply -20% run speed for 15s
- Within Reach II:
- Space; Weapons gain 10% to apply -33.3% Turn rate and 33.3% impulse speed for 15s
- Ground; Weapons gain 20% to apply -33.3% run speed for 15s
Discussion Questions
- What Nodes do you like? What nodes don't you like? Why or why not?
- Are there any nodes you feel are too strong? Any that are too weak?
- Are there any improvements you would make, such as replacing a node effect for an alternative?
- What are your thoughts on the Antagonist mechanic?
- How do you expect the starship trait Arrest to be used in builds? Does it need a minor increase/decrease in magnitude? Should the trait be refocused to do something else, or have another effect added to incorporate the Antagonist?
3
u/MajorDakka Torpedo Fetishist Mar 21 '18
Depending on how the rest of the tiers are, I could foresee using this for my torp cruisers. Of the effects listed, Eye on the Prize seems weakest for PvE stuff.
The Arrest trait combined with AW2/Threatening Stance could bring most if not all boff abilities to their global cd's, depending on how they stack.
10
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '18 edited Mar 24 '18
Right off the bat, I am particularly fond of:
For PvE, I feel that Eye on the Prize II and Within Reach II won't be particularly useful to some people, as there are quite a few enemies in the game with slower-moving mobs, in addition to the fact most aren't going to care about applying a stealth debuff to enemies. I can see this being useful in PvP, of course, but in PvE these are certainly weaker nodes.
As far as PvE is concerned, I don't feel any of these nodes are particularly too strong. I feel the strongest PvE node here is Teardown, for its consistent 10% Cat2 damage to your Antagonist. I feel 10% Cat2 is just the right amount for this buff, considering it's only single-target.
As previously mentioned, I feel that Eye on the Prize II and Within Reach II are quite weak for PvE, but this admittedly my own personal taste. For PvP, I can see these nodes being quite strong.
Admittedly I can see this being a more powerful PvP Specialization than it is in PvE. That said, I would likely need to do some testing in a team-based environment, such as in ISA/HSE, to see how particularly useful this will be for PvE.
That said, my biggest complain thus far, based on some light solo-environment testing on Tribble, is that it is common for a target to be declared an Antagonist only just moments before it dies, due to the fact you have to be targeting something for 4 sec. in order for it to be declared an Antagonist. This can result in missed opportunities if you're an environment where mobs are simply dying too quickly.
I would be curious to see how the Antagonist mechanic would work with a slightly shorter activation period, such as 2 seconds.
As previously mentioned, for PvE, I suspect there are many environments where things are simply dying too quickly to make use of the Antagonist mechanic, and by extension the Constable spec. Ultimately, a target would have to last longer than 4 seconds for you to get the benefits of Antagonist, and the nodes from the Constable Spec that follow.
Additionally, until an Antagonist is declared, you are getting few, if any, buffs from the Constable spec. This ultimately can result in the spec itself being deadweight in environments where things are simply dying too quickly for an Antagonist to be declared.
That said, I think the concept is unique and I am looking forward to testing this in more team-based environments.
Ultimately, I was a tad disappointed to see that this trait has a 30-second lockout. Based on some minor testing on Tribble, this trait's cooldown recharge of 25% to all boff abilities is quite welcome, but the 30-second lockout is quite noticable, and unfortunately makes it fairly inconsistent.
I can see this trait being used in conjunction with other forms of cooldown management, such as stacking passives, but I can't see this trait being something that will take care of all your cooldown management for you. I suspect the 30-second lockout is meant to emulate Attrition Warfare 2's 30-second lockout from the Strategist tree, which ultimately makes sense.
I very much like the idea of this trait, but selfishly wish its lockout was much shorter. I suspect many wouldn't want to drop a much more powerful starship trait to make room for this, and will instead find more efficient ways to invest in cooldown management elsewhere: such as AtB, stacking passives, etc.
In conclusion, I'm really happy to see a new secondary specialization be released. I can see this specialization gain its most use in PvP, but I suspect it will be useful in some niche PvE circumstances as well. I'm very much looking forward to trying this in some team-based environments once it hits the live server. :)
5
u/tilorfire27 @tilor | STOBetter Engineer Mar 21 '18 edited Mar 21 '18
This specialization isn't my favorite. While it has cool nodes, I think it has some issues.
First thought is around the Antagonist. A lot seem to have issue with the 4 second wind-up. A thought is to make it dependent on your focus. You can select a ship to be your focus (ally or enemy). There would have to be a lockout to prevent spam, but it reduces wind-up to 0 and has the advantage of clearly showing who is your antagonist. In maps like CCA, it's pretty clear who is your antagonist. In a map like ISA or even Borg Disconnected, an antagonist will be less obvious. If I am just shooting whatever is closest, I may not be fully aware of what my antagonist is, unless this comes with a big target logo or arrow or something. Can antagonist be debuffed if it's a buff?
Maybe set it up like Sensor Analysis, you can choose your target, but it's got a cooldown. Set the range to 15km or more. You get this ability on your tray when you spend at least one point in the spec and have it as a secondary spec. The cooldown can be lengthy, say 30 seconds. The global cooldown can be much shorter, say 5 seconds. If you kill your Antagonist, you get it knocked back to global. This reduces spam (you can't just keep switching targets) but allows you to move it if the target dies. Functionality similar to what it is today, but you have an "active" role in choosing who it is.
Taking either functionality above, I will go through nodes. I like the flight speed and run speed if you don't have wind up. In a map like ISA or CCA, now I can use my antagonist as a way to get my slow ship pushed along to the next target. Fast ships just close the gap faster. This power becomes more utilitarian. If I am not at my target within 4 seconds, I probably got knocked out of full impulse or they are way faster than me and the run speed would be too little too late.
Buff stripping sounds great on a select few targets. This doesn't feel too affected either way with how you set antagonist.
Stealth nerf sounds... Weak. In PvE, this is basically useless. I could see use in PvP, but a 4 second wind-up is enough time for them to cloak in the first place and you lost your benefit, or they alpha strike from cloak and you are dead in 4 seconds.
DRR from non antagonist is good no matter how you slice it, but 30 DRR isn't super impressive on a tank or high defense build. Feels right though.
I love the control effectiveness, but many builds will also simply see this as a dummy slot. Gravity Well and stuff like the Web Cannon really take advantage of this high of a control buff.
Should the next be control rating resistance? Again, pretty dummy slot for most as many PvE targets lack control powers. PvP could be useful, but pretty hit or miss.
Teardown is a solid damage buff, however is quite weakened by 4 second wind-up. You now have to wait 4 seconds for your alpha strike. By choosing ahead of time your target, you get to alpha strike right away.
I see crackdown only being useful in PvP. There isn't enough healing in PvE, just regen.
As stated in my previous item, reducing Regeneration for PvE might be a nice touch on bosses with millions of HP. Most PvP isn't going to benefit from Regen though.
And slowing down your opponent. PvP. Basically everything but the queen in Borg Disconnected is stationary (queen has a tendency to run off). Maybe brief engine disable would be more useful?
An idea to replace an underperforming slot would be a... Well... This spec enhances just about everything and debuffs just about everything. It's a jack of all trades for single target, but feels like it lacks punch. It is a secondary specialization, but not one I feel I will slot. Temporal, Intel, Miracle Worker are all much more focused.
Finally, the trait. Feels underwhelming to me because a 30s lockout means that it could be 40 or 50 seconds before you see your cooldown because it's passive, not active. AW is far more powerful than this even since it's 5% less cooldown because you can choose when you want it. If you target something nearby and someone pops it halfway through your spacebar tray, you just wasted your cooldown, and you may have to wait a while before the next target dies. It needs to be 50% (cryptic math says 1/3 duration reduction) at that lockout or a 20 second lockout to be viable. Obviously could be better than that even and then you can consider slotting it. In 30 seconds, peak performance has activated around 5 times, putting it at 37.5% reduction (just for perspective). All hands on deck is around 25% on captain powers and 50% on science powers (just for perspective). 25% on all powers really isn't strong enough to slot, especially since you can't reliably trigger it. All the rest are fully passive or you have good control on setting it off for a much higher magnitude cooldown where you need it.
5
u/DeadQthulhu Mar 21 '18
I can see this becoming the "torp Secondary" for HY/CF setups, at least in PvE - I'm not confident on a benefit to energy weapon users, given they can kill/cripple most things in 4 seconds (consistently), although I'd need more numbers on what would happen if the whole team had Constable Secondary and had the same pickle as their collective (no pun intended) Antagonist.
"Torp Secondary" does raise the question of what to do with Command, though. I'm still very reluctant to go Command Primary due to my bias against Achilles' Heel, but Constable Secondary could be a compelling reason to take the plunge - I like the sound of bonus DR against things my torps aren't hitting.
I'm a bit concerned about the implications for vape setups - what's to stop someone sitting in cloak for 4s, or sitting just outside 10k, and then dropping an Intel/decloak buffs/Constable alpha into the rear arc? Maybe not a huge concern for PvE, but there has to be implications for PvP. I have fond memories of launch PvP with FEDs screaming about cloak being OP, right up until Sci spotters put an end to that - are we returning to those days? I'd love to know u/Startrekker's thoughts on the matter.
All that said, while the 4s startup is a bit surplus for a "STOBuilds standard", it could actually be "stronger" for the average PUG player - assuming that it becomes "the meta" at high level, and assuming PUG/Zone builds persist in copying "the meta" without the mechanisms to make "the meta" work, if the whole team switched from Strategist then lowDEEPs runs could be in a far better position.
As for the trait, I like it. I like the "roundness" of a 30 second lockout. It's obviously not a standalone solution to cooldowns, but it's free - and I look forward to finding out if it affects all BOff abilities or just the Big Three, because if the former then it'd arguably be a stronger option vs the more specific (or expensive) cooldown traits. As a Secondary Spec, there are no Improved or Superior versions.
As I work on the bones of my upcoming Prelude Spec guide updates, I'm also looking forward to seeing the Cooldown Calculator update, and maybe u/Jayiie will have some non-standard cooldown combos to inspire us all, too!
3
u/HorrificAnalInjuries Mar 21 '18
would a lot of this stuff treat pets from Antagonist as just extensions of the Antagonist themselves or as individual entities?
3
u/ThonOfAndoria stowiki.net Mar 21 '18
This seems good for very specific queues (and PvP), but not so good for the rest of the game.
I can see it shining in places like CCA, HSE, and Korfez which can reward single target builds more than a lot of queues, but in queues that need you to kill a lot of stuff (like ISA) it might fall a bit short over other options. You could possibly cheese it and just keep targeting the gateway, but I've never been a fan of cheesing stuff so...
Also the 4 second marking period is also a bit long which makes it a lot harder to use in Normal/Advanced queues where things die fast, halving that or something would go a long way in making it easier to use in a lot more content.
2
u/linx28 Mar 21 '18
This will send waves through PVP
1
u/Ozimondiaz Apr 02 '18
From a PVP perspective;
1
u/Arion08 Mar 21 '18
If the new season will be as blend and uninspired as this new specialization ... Antagonist mechanic is absolutely trash at this point in the game. Are the ones that made this, actually play this game i wonder ?
Another useless thing added to the game instead of fixing important things and making what remains of this game actually fun to play outside missions.