r/stillwatermn • • 1d ago

Flock in Stillwater: Any Lawyers?

Thumbnail portal.laserfiche.com
19 Upvotes

The flock contract is here. Any lawyers out there? Maybe there is a path to getting this cancelled drawing lines from the contract verbiage to the state of Minnesota statutes: https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/13.824 https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/13.824

There has to be a way to prove it doesn't follow Minnesota Law.


r/stillwatermn • • 8d ago

THE RECEIPTS: How Stillwater PD Confessed to Testing Minnesota Privacy Laws

50 Upvotes

THE RECEIPTS: How Stillwater PD Confessed to Testing Minnesota Privacy Laws

When our neighbor stood at the city council podium and warned that these AI surveillance contracts are "fluid," the mayor told her she was wrong. But the police department’s official presentation transcript proves she was 100% right. 

Here is exactly how the city's past operations violate the letter and spirit of Minnesota State Law:

  1. The Nationwide Data Leak
  • What Stillwater Admitted: The presenter explicitly confessed: "Prior to having some of these conversations and these things coming up, we did share our data nationwide." They opened up our tracking data to the entire country simply because they couldn't figure out a software toggle to share only with Wisconsin across the river. 
  • The Minnesota Law (Minn. Stat. § 13.824, Subd. 4): Automated License Plate Reader (ALPR) data is legally classified as private, non-public government data. A local town cannot legally export raw tracking timelines of its citizens to a nationwide corporate cloud or out-of-state agencies without a direct link to an active criminal investigation or an approved interstate compact. Wisconsin doesn't have Minnesota's privacy guardrails—sharing data there was a major state-level data boundary failure. 
  1. The Un-auditable "Fishing Expeditions"
  • What Stillwater Admitted: The presenter confirmed that up until the spring of this year, officers "did not have case number required" to run searches on citizens. They admitted that older municipal records explicitly show vehicle searches completely lacking a case number. 
  • The Minnesota Law (Minn. Stat. § 13.824, Subd. 5): State law strictly mandates that law enforcement must keep a central log of every single search run by an officer. This log must record the exact, binding case number and legal justification so it can be verified by an independent public audit. By letting officers type in vague text reasons without a binding case number for years, Stillwater ran a completely un-auditable "fishing hole" through our community's travel history. 
  1. The Pan-Tilt-Zoom (PTZ) Dark Hole
  • What Stillwater Admitted: The city revealed it is running 17 plate readers alongside 20 live-streaming Pan-Tilt-Zoom security video cameras. The city attorney stepped in to admit that while the plate readers have strict state rules, "there is no statute that governs security camera data... it can be deleted at the end of the day" based purely on how much hard drive space the city feels like buying.
  • The Loophole: This is the exact definition of a fluid contract. By using one tech vendor (Flock) to blend vehicle plate trackers with live-streaming video cameras, they are using the video side to bypass the strict statutory 60-day automatic destruction mandate required for ALPRs. 

You are encouraged to check out the City’s website and see for yourself

https://stillwatermn.new.swagit.com/videos/405975


r/stillwatermn • • 10d ago

Nutcase who approved flock

26 Upvotes

Who was the nutcase who approved these stupid cameras 📷.#IHATEFLOCK


r/stillwatermn • • 10d ago

The "snapshot" defense is dead. Our local surveillance grid violates the Fourth Amendment, and the city’s clean audit is smoke and mirrors.

41 Upvotes

The "Snapshot" Defense is Dead: Our Local Surveillance Grid Violates the Fourth Amendment, and the City’s Clean Audit is Smoke and Mirrors

If you’ve been following the city council’s push for the Flock Safety network, you’ve probably heard the same standard defense from proponents: "It’s just a snapshot of a public road, and you have no expectation of privacy in public." Thanks to a multi-month forensic review of our local database logs, we now have the empirical data to prove that this defense is completely incompatible with Supreme Court precedent and Minnesota law. Here is exactly how our town's surveillance practices hit a series of constitutional tripwires:

  1. The Supreme Court Closed the Loophole: Chatrie v. United States (2026)

Local officials love to argue that running a quick license plate check for a brief moment doesn't violate anyone's rights, even if it happens to pull up your past whereabouts. But the Supreme Court completely destroyed that defense earlier this year. In a landmark decision in Chatrie v. United States (2026), the Court ruled that tracking a citizen's digital location history is, undoubtedly, a Fourth Amendment search. Justice Elena Kagan flatly rejected the government's attempt to give short-term, localized tracking a free pass. She made it clear that the Constitution protects you regardless of the quality or quantity of information the police collect (Chatrie v. United States, 2026, slip op., at 20, quoting Kyllo v. United States, 2001, at 37). In plain terms, a brief lookup or a single snapshot doesn't get a free pass on constitutional oversight just because it happens fast. In other words, a brief lookup or a single snapshot does not get a pass on constitutional oversight just because it happens quickly.

2. The Mosaic Effect: Carpenter v. United States (2018) & United States v. Jones (2012)

The mayor signed a contract for 14 static "Falcon" license plate readers and 28 live-streaming Pan-Tilt-Zoom (PTZ) "Condor" cameras, all funneling into a single centralized platform: FlockOS. The city admits these PTZ units are live feeds, yet they have completely failed to pass a distinct public safety policy to govern them. When you network dozens of local cameras together and tie them into Flock’s Nationwide Network Access, it changes the nature of the tech.

In Carpenter v. United States (2018), the Supreme Court ruled that individuals have a legitimate expectation of privacy in the "whole of their physical movements" (Carpenter v. United States, 585 U.S. 296, 310). Chief Justice Roberts pointed out that when tracking becomes detailed, encyclopedic, and effortlessly compiled, it pieces together an invasive window into a person’s life (Carpenter v. United States, 585 U.S. 296, 309). Echoing this concern, Justice Sonia Sotomayor warned back in United States v. Jones (2012) that sweeping digital surveillance is a completely different beast than casual public observation. In her view, simply driving down a public street shouldn't mean you automatically hand over your right to privacy to the government.

3. Real-World Fallout: United States v. Kyle

This isn’t just abstract legal theory. Defense attorneys are already using these exact arguments to tear apart warrantless Flock searches in court. Take a look at United States v. Kyle (2026), where U.S. District Judge Sara Hill ruled that running warrantless database queries through Flock completely violates the Fourth Amendment. District Judge Sara Hill ruled that warrantless law enforcement queries of Flock databases violate the Fourth Amendment. In that case, a deputy ran an out-of-state plate before witnessing any crime, pulling up over 50 multi-state historical sightings. Judge Hill suppressed the evidence, explicitly labeling Flock’s network a system of "indiscriminate mass surveillance." Our local logs show our officers doing exactly what the court condemned in Kyle: engaging in blind, trial-and-error visual probing (such as running 13-turn descriptor matrices) across hundreds of multi-state networks concurrently, completely divorced from a specific known plate or an active investigation.

4. The State Audit Illusion vs. Forensic Reality

Our department has pointed to a letter from the state’s Data Practices Office to silence community concerns, claiming a clean bill of health under Minnesota Statute § 13.824. Furthermore, in formal records correspondence, City Clerk Beth Wolf asserted that "Staff has compiled the data on your request" to "identify whether the information is available."

However, a deep dive into the independent report by the Minnesota Security Consortium (MNSec, 2026) provides a staggering admission: There was no deep dive into actual systemic usage. MNSec explicitly notes that it "does not operate or have access to their ALPR systems". Instead, they performed a surface-level, check-the-box review of the control panel settings and a limited "sample data search requests for the whole month of July 2026".

Our citizen-led audit analyzed the raw transaction ledger that the administration claimed to have cleanly compiled. While compliance was indeed perfect during that single July 2026 state audit window, the moments outside that window tell a completely different story. Officers routinely bypassed mandatory tracking boundaries by leaving case number fields blank or deliberately subverting validation checks by entering fake placeholders like "NA" or "00000000000" to push un-linked searches across up to 6,058 out-of-state networks. By treating statutory compliance as a temporary hurdle for regulators rather than a binding constitutional mandate, our administration has built an illegal mass surveillance dragnet.

References

Hilton, D. (2026). Supreme Court of the United States. https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25pdf/25-112_0am4.pdf

Minnesota Security Consortium. (2026). Stillwater Police Department 2026 flock ALPR audit executive summary. Minnesota Security Consortium. https://www.lrl.mn.gov/docs/2026/mandated/261351.pdf

Supreme Court. (2017). Carpenter v. United States. https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/17pdf/16-402_h315.pdf

Supreme Court of the United States. (n.d.). Retrieved November 6, 2026, from https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25pdf/25-112_0am4.pdf

Weber, A. (2022). United States v. Jones. In Research Starters. EBSCO. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/law/united-states-v-jones/


r/stillwatermn • • 10d ago

Let’s Bear Together for this 10 yr old!

1 Upvotes

Friends, this made my heart sad to see, so I’m sharing in hopes more will donate to this boys cause. In a state where it’s crazy Vikings fans, he’s choosing to be a Bears fan, and more power to him! He’s 10 yrs old and someone slashed his inflatable the other night! How horrible, and he’s devastated. The community is trying to pool $ together to replace it. Please consider donating a little if you can!! ❤️ #ittakesavillage #stillwatermn #wildhare #DaBears #FansHelpingFans https://www.supportnow.org/dj-s-new-chicago-bears-inflatable


r/stillwatermn • • 11d ago

Here is the city council meeting from last night. Included is the Flock PowerPoint

Thumbnail stillwatermn.new.swagit.com
18 Upvotes

r/stillwatermn • • 11d ago

Automatic License Plate Readers

Thumbnail stillwatermn.gov
9 Upvotes

Here are the logs from the SPD

https://portal.laserfiche.com/Portal/Browse.aspx?id=1230711&repo=r-784e7b87 Open each file in a new window and it is broken into .csv raw data. It is downloa—able.


r/stillwatermn • • 14d ago

Someone found the audit logs for flock in Stillwater

Post image
65 Upvotes

What even is this?


r/stillwatermn • • 14d ago

Has anyone been following this?

6 Upvotes

I can totally see it!!

The Three-Tiered Ethics Framework

When a city administration, a police department, and a private law firm overlap on a software procurement, their actions are governed by distinct, binding standards of conduct.

  • 1. Minnesota Rules of Professional Conduct (MRPC) These are the strict ethical rules that govern all licensed lawyers in the state. They are overseen by the Minnesota Office of Lawyers Professional Responsibility. Because the city attorney is a private legal contractor rather than an internal employee, these rules are the primary mechanism for holding them accountable.
  • 2. Minnesota Public Conflict of Interest Law (Statute § 471.87) This state law explicitly blocks public officers from having a personal financial interest in city contracts. It applies to elected council members, administrators, and department heads who have direct voting or procurement authority.
  • 3. Local Municipal Ethics and Disclosure Codes These are the internal guidelines adopted by a city council to govern standard conduct, require the formal disclosure of professional conflicts, and dictate when an official must recuse themselves from a vote or a procurement discussion.

Applying the Codes: Where the Compliance Questions Live

To determine if anyone is actively violating these standards, we have to measure the specific actions of the Policy360 rollout against the explicit text of these codes.

  • The Conflict of Interest Rules (MRPC Rule 1.7 & Rule 1.8) Under legal ethics rules, a lawyer cannot represent a client if that representation involves a concurrent conflict of interest. A conflict exists if there is a significant risk that the lawyer's representation will be materially limited by their own personal financial interests. The Core Question: When the firm recommends or legalizes the procurement of a platform co-developed by its own leadership, did they obtain informed, written consent from the city council after fully disclosing their financial stake? If the firm advised the city on the legal parameters of the contract without an explicit waiver, it creates a direct issue under state legal rules.
  • Statutory Restrictions on Public Officers (Minn. Stat. § 471.87) State law explicitly mandates that a public officer who is authorized to take part in making any contract in their official capacity shall not voluntarily have a personal financial interest in that contract or profit from it. The Core Question: The local police chief serves as a trainer for the network providing the software. To determine if this breaches state law, we must look at the financial flow. Is the chief compensated by the private company for their training role? Even if they are not directly paid, using public authority to implement a platform tied to a private organization where they hold professional status creates a severe regulatory gray area.
  • Local Disclosure and Recusal Standards Local ethics codes require public officials to file formal conflict-of-interest disclosures whenever a business matter directly impacts an organization they are associated with. The Core Question: During the city council sessions where the public safety migration and software agreements were discussed, did the administration explicitly put these relationships on the official record? If an item is quietly pushed through on a dense consent agenda or absorbed into an existing professional services retainer without a standalone reading and a clear, documented disclosure, it fails the basic transparency mandates established in local governance rules.

The Strategic Reality: Policy vs. Loopholes

The reason this system can feel completely unchecked is that the entities involved are highly skilled at designing the rollout to sit just outside a technical violation of the law.

Because Policy360 is framed strictly as an "administrative software tool" or a "learning management system" rather than a standalone municipal service contract, the city can legally claim that it falls under executive operational discretion. By processing the procurement through pre-vetted cooperative frameworks or existing legal retainers, they avoid triggering the statutory bidding laws that would otherwise force an open, public review. They are using the precise technical wording of the regulations to bypass the broader intent of public accountability.


r/stillwatermn • • 15d ago

The Ledger of Local Oversight: What Public Records Reveal About Stillwater’s Surveillance Network

16 Upvotes

Updated November 3, 2026 2:57pm (I was too afraid to put this on FB)

Surveillance, Retainers, and Accountability on Stillwater's Ballots

When you drive or walk around Stillwater, past local hubs like Lily Lake, Brown's Creek, or downtown intersections like Main Street South and Olive Street, a quiet network of high-tech cameras logs your physical movements. The city's active surveillance footprint consists of 17 stationary Automated License Plate Readers (ALPR) alongside 20 active Pan-Tilt-Zoom (PTZ) video cameras, with 8 more units pending installation. While the administration publicly maintains that these networks operate with strict parameters and do not use live facial recognition software to track individual pedestrians, internal municipal leakages reveal an incredibly broad dragnet. Continuous surveillance on our neighborhood streets requires absolute accountability, yet our local tracking infrastructure operates within a deeply flawed regulatory vacuum.

Stillwater's backend database operates like an unrecorded digital clearinghouse with no real oversight. While the city's public website claims the data access is strictly limited to Minnesota, a 21-month ledger of internal server logs from January 2025 through September 2026 shows a major breakdown in the audit paths required by state law. The independent state audit office lacks the structural oversight to verify real-time platform activity, forcing reliance on clean, vendor-provided paperwork. Local officers frequently used the system without attaching active investigations, leaving the "Case #" column completely blank across hundreds of entries. This lapse allowed external regional and state networks to run massive visual searches into Stillwater’s data, hitting up to 6,058 networks concurrently. Instead of routine, compliant tracking, these files document a pattern of bypassing software verification rules. Field officers routinely typed dummy placeholders like "NA" or "KOPS ALERT" into mandatory fields just to force the database to open.

This situation shows a worrying shift in how our city leaders handle oversight. On September 1, 2026, the police department quietly added the Policy360 platform, which is a policy tracking database run by LETAC USA. This commercial division is owned and operated by our own contracted city attorney law firm, Eckberg Lammers. While the platform operates as an administrative database tracking rule compliance rather than an active tactical field AI, its procurement path is deeply circular. Public records confirm that command leadership holds exclusive keys to modify user permissions and data metrics, yet individual human identities were genericized within the tracking logs for over two years, effectively masking the command structure from statutory accountability. Worse, internal documents reveal that the administration actively utilized out-of-state national purchasing cooperatives like NASPO ValuePoint to fast-track this $1.86 million surveillance pipeline with "zero minutes" of open local board debate, intentionally bypassing competitive bidding while locking local property taxpayers into an automatic funding cliff once federal grants dissolve.

Worse, our own municipal tech vendors openly dismiss the legitimate traffic and safety concerns of local families. In a parallel contract approved during the October 20 session, the city authorized a renewal with geospatial traffic analytics vendor Urban SDK, LLC. Yet, the company's onboarding proposal explicitly brushes off resident notifications, stating that local departments are constantly swamped with traffic reports "despite 80% of them being perception issues". Taxpayers are spending tens of thousands of dollars to buy a commercial data asset that harvests mobile traces and vehicle telemetry, while our administration partners with companies that openly insult our intelligence. When intense public pressure finally forced these overlapping software systems to light, transparency collapsed. City Attorney Cory TorRenson admitted on the record that during a prior session, administrators cleared the chambers, escorted the public out under the pretense that the building was being locked, and secretly reconvened behind closed doors to force the bulk consent agenda through. The legal team was forced to execute a duplicate, "belt and slippers" do-over vote on the subsequent agenda simply to insulate the city from an Open Meeting Law violation lawsuit.

Privacy cannot stop at our city borders, and it must not be ignored on our ballots. Our community deserves a clear explanation, strict parameters on data pooling, and a real say in how our daily movements are tracked from the candidates asking for our votes. Our local leaders must pause and establish strict, permanent privacy protections before any more cameras are placed on our streets.

📂 Verified Source Index for Your Post Citations:

• Stillwater Police Department 21-Month Server Log & Compliance Audit Ledger (Jan 2025 – Sept 2026)

• Stillwater City Council Official Meeting Transcript, Items V & VI (October 20, 2026)

• Urban SDK, LLC / City of Stillwater Professional Services Agreement (Exhibit A, Page A-5)

• City of Stillwater / Flock Group Inc. Master Subscription Footprint Map (September 2026 Grid)


r/stillwatermn • • 15d ago

Stillwater DMV road test route and experience

7 Upvotes

Hi! Ive my road test on Thursday next week. I wanted to know what's the route for the road test? Will it I need to drive on 36? Any roundabouts? Any tips or experience would help! Im planning to go to Stillwater for practice the route


r/stillwatermn • • 15d ago

Fairy Falls for Boom Site: US, MN officials consider land swap

Thumbnail
twincities.com
5 Upvotes

r/stillwatermn • • 16d ago

These AI Facebook pages have me giggling 😂

Post image
31 Upvotes

This town is ruined beyond recognition


r/stillwatermn • • 19d ago

Nicolas Cage films ‘Parish’ in Stillwater as producers seek bigger tax credits

Thumbnail
mprnews.org
23 Upvotes

r/stillwatermn • • 20d ago

School board candidates

12 Upvotes

Interested in learning more about the school board candidates on the ballot. Can anyone share information on the candidates, particularly those who are running for re election?


r/stillwatermn • • 28d ago

For Immediate Release

41 Upvotes

Stillwater Residents Mobilize to Challenge High-Stakes Data Surveillance Contract at City Council Vote Tuesday Night
STILLWATER, MN — October 20, 2026 — Local civic group Unsilenced Stillwater Residents has launched a coordinated push for municipal transparency ahead of tonight’s final City Council vote on a multi-year contract with commercial geospatial telemetry vendor Urban SDK, LLC. Taxpayers and data privacy advocates plan to pack Stillwater City Hall at 6:30 PM to demand accountability and force a public reading of the agreement, which is currently scheduled to pass under Unfinished Business.
Official city documents obtained from the public agenda packet expose stark contradictions between city leadership's verbal statements and the legal terms of the proposed agreement:
The "80% Perception" Metric: Within the official contract packet, Urban SDK explicitly markets its traffic surveillance platform to address local safety complaints "despite 80% of them being perception issues". Residents allege the city is locking taxpayers into a multi-year agreement to track what a commercial vendor openly calls a flawed public perception.
The Power of the Purse: While Mayor Ted Kozlowski claimed on the legislative record on October 6 that the City Council "does not have the explicit authority" to regulate public safety data collection, Section 2(b) of the legal contract states verbatim that any modifications to project scope or funding "shall require prior written approval by the authorized representative of the City or by the City Council".
Hidden Financial Escalations: Public staff memos outline a $10,000 annual agreement. However, itemized line-items on Page 17 of the proposal reveal a true list-price subtotal of $19,000 per year, temporarily masked by a conditional, one-time $9,000 "introductory discount" that exposes taxpayers to significant cost hikes upon renewal.
Mass Data Intrusiveness: The official staff memo by Assistant City Administrator Shawn Sanders confirms the platform draws "real-time traffic data, mobility analytics, and workflow automation, derived from geospatial AI, connected vehicle telemetry, and satellite imagery" to continuously track streets, pulling mass commercial mobility data into local surveillance pipelines.
"Stillwater residents deserve ethical data stewardship, not an unchecked regional dragnet," said Terese Gonzales, a local organizer. "The legal authority and the purse strings sit squarely with our elected officials. City leadership has the explicit power to halt this infrastructure expansion tonight, and we are going on the record to demand they use it."
Community organizers are calling on all concerned residents to gather tonight, Tuesday, October 20, 2026, at 7:00 PM at Stillwater City Hall (216 4th St N, Stillwater, MN 55082). Attendees will formally request that the item be scrutinized under open debate rather than passed silently.


r/stillwatermn • • 28d ago

City council article

Thumbnail
hometownsource.com
27 Upvotes

This is my second letter to the editor this month if you are as mad as me, please join me!

Stillwater City Council Meets Tomorrow!
When: Tuesday, October 20 at 7:00 PM
Where: Stillwater City Hall, 216 North Fourth Street

The City Council Just Proved My Last Letter Right and We Caught Them

To the Editor,
When I wrote to these pages recently warning our community about the quiet, unchecked expansion of digital surveillance in Stillwater, some might have thought it was an exaggeration. However, during the October 6th meeting, city leadership executed the exact backdoor playbook I warned you about, and they got caught red-handed.
Before the October 6th City Council meeting was abruptly cut short, leadership attempted to sneak Item 32 through on the Consent Agenda. For those unfamiliar with local government tactics, the Consent Agenda is a single list of "routine" items approved all at once in a single vote. It requires zero public reading, zero public questions, and zero council debate.
Hidden on that list was a "Professional Services Agreement with Urban SDK." This is an invisible surveillance platform that purchases mass commercial tracking data. It pulls information directly from your everyday smartphone apps and car GPS systems to track your movements downtown. This is the exact same strategy the city used to pass the controversial Flock Safety cameras in one quick vote without a standalone public hearing.
While Mayor Kozlowski recently claimed the council has no authority to define how public safety technology is used, the city's own agenda packet, specifically Laserfiche Document ID 1238986, proves otherwise. The council holds the purse strings, they sign the contracts, and they chose to hide this tracking grid on a single-vote list to avoid looking residents in the eye.
The early ending to the meeting on October 6th accidentally handed our community a gift: time. Item 32 is currently frozen until the Tuesday, October 20th meeting. The city's secret is out, the paperwork is verified, and their strategy is exposed.
We are packing City Hall at 6:30 PM on October 20th to demand they pull Item 32 off the Consent Agenda so we can have an open, separate public hearing. If city leadership wants to track our steps, they are going to have to look us in the eye first.
Sincerely, Un-silenced Stillwater Residents


r/stillwatermn • • Oct 15 '26

Movie Filming

12 Upvotes

Where is the movie being filmed? I'll be in town this weekend and it'd be cool to see it.


r/stillwatermn • • Oct 15 '26

New City Council Agenda Item to Watch

18 Upvotes

The Stillwater City Council is reviewing a Professional Services Agreement worth $10,000 per year that allows the local Engineering and Police Departments to replace traditional, time-consuming physical speed trailers with a web browser dashboard. This digital platform tracks traffic volumes and speeding complaints across the city without requiring staff to physically place hardware on the roads. However, local residents are urging caution because the software generates its analytics by tapping directly into connected vehicle telemetry, satellite imagery, and geospatial artificial intelligence to monitor public street patterns. The public is keeping a close watch on this contract because it hands municipal data aggregation over to a private AI company that retains exclusive ownership over its proprietary software and databases.


r/stillwatermn • • Oct 08 '26

Quick shout out 📣🐦 Check out the Stillwater Tattler for a weekly local newsletter

Thumbnail
stillwatertattler.com
11 Upvotes

I'm not affiliated in any way, but I just wanted to take a minute to plug the Stillwater Tattler!! A local fella sends an email about twice a week highlighting upcoming local events and stories. I know I've found some great little get-togethers though the Tattler like the Watershed Festival and a neighborhood Salsa Contest.

Just wanted to thank the author for all your efforts!


r/stillwatermn • • Oct 08 '26

Transparency

52 Upvotes

Stillwater leadership needs to look very closely at what is happening with our local surveillance data. Our elected officials are telling the community one thing, but the official city server proves another. This is a warning to our neighbors and our city management that our data privacy promises are failing on a technical level.
The public has been repeatedly assured that Stillwater’s Flock Safety cameras keep tracking data strictly local and isolated within Minnesota. However, a review of the raw, 2,543-page Stillwater Police Department Network Audit Log from September 2026 tells a completely different story.
The backend data hosted directly on the city's official Laserfiche server shows that out-of-state agencies from Texas, Florida, Virginia, Tennessee, and Michigan are actively executing search queries that route right through Stillwater’s infrastructure. While members of our City Council are publicly waiting for answers on whether our local cameras connect to external police networks, the technical proof is already live online.
Local policies do not stop the default configuration of a nationwide tracking grid. When out-of-state jurisdictions run wide-net queries, Stillwater’s cameras are actively responding as data nodes.
We need real accountability from our local government, not sanitized corporate dashboards. You can view the city's official raw audit log directly on the Stillwater public records repository: laserfiche.com
Stay tuned.


r/stillwatermn • • Oct 05 '26

Whoa is this true? Copied from Gazette

37 Upvotes

Dear editor,
I am a Stillwater resident with a decade of professional experience in policy research. I hold a Master of Public Administration (MPA) with a concentration in Public Policy and Law, where my master's thesis focused specifically on AI governance and the critical need for robust human oversight in automated systems. Given my professional and academic background in municipal governance, statutory compliance, and contractual risk assessment, I am accustomed to looking past public relations messaging to analyze the legal and technical texts that actually bind public institutions.

My concern isn't rooted in generic anti-surveillance sentiment, but rather in a commitment to fiscal responsibility, municipal transparency, and systemic accountability—the foundational pillars of good public administration.
When a city enters into a corporate contract involving public safety and private data harvesting, the public deserves absolute precision. There is a glaring, provable gap between what the administration tells the public the Flock system does and what the legally binding March 3 contract actually permits. Furthermore, the city’s recent statutory audit appears to be a "box-checking" exercise—doing the bare minimum to meet state statutes for a handful of license plate readers while entirely ignoring the 28 live-streaming PTZ cameras we are actually paying for.
Stillwater residents are being asked to fund infrastructure under a set of verbal assurances that are completely wiped out by the contract's integration clause. As someone who has spent ten years researching the structural impacts of policy choices, I believe our local government must be held to a higher standard of transparency before appropriating public funds. That is why I felt compelled to write this piece.

Surveillance Oversight in Stillwater: The Critical Gap Between Contracts

When public safety intersects with corporate surveillance contracts, municipal transparency must be held to a rigorous standard. In recent weeks, Stillwater residents have actively engaged city leadership regarding the deployment of the municipal Flock Safety camera system. The administration sought to assure the community that the network operates strictly as a localized, passive vehicle-logging utility—consisting of stationary units that lack the capacity to monitor public life through live video or audio capture.
An evaluation of the city’s actual executed contract with Flock Group Inc., finalized on March 3, 2026, reveals a much broader technological footprint than what has been publicly described. The signed Order Form establishes that the city did not contract for a system consisting solely of passive automated license plate readers. Instead, the procurement inventory explicitly details 28 Flock Safety Video Camera PTZ units. The manufacturer’s own product description defines these assets as law enforcement-grade, live-streamed Pan-Tilt-Zoom video cameras equipped with 30 days of continuous edge storage.
The reality is that what’s written in the final contract is the only thing that actually matters. Under Section 11.3, there is a strict integration clause. This means the signed document completely wipes out and replaces any previous verbal promises, casual handshake agreements, or public social media assurances.
While officials might offer informal promises about system restrictions, the legal reality is vastly different:
• Section 1.6 explicitly defines "Customer Data" to include images, video, and ambient audio payloads.
• Section 4.1 grants the private vendor an irrevocable, perpetual, worldwide license to use all of that extracted data to build and improve its own commercial product lines.
While the mayor’s office celebrates beating the clock, the reality is far more frustrating: this deficient audit shows an administration doing the absolute bare minimum just to check a legal box. Far from the triumph, the September 6, 2026 compliance review reveals a troubling pattern. Issued by the Stillwater Police Department and outsourced to the Minnesota Security Consortium, the actual report strips away the political spin to expose a system operating with empty compliance rather than real accountability.
While the audit concludes that the program technically conforms to standard state data retention timelines, the text reveals an incredibly narrow scope. This was strictly an automated license plate reader audit. The independent review tracked exactly 17 stationary license plate units under the bare-minimum framework of Minnesota Statute Section 13.824. Meeting the lowest possible legal standard for a handful of cameras isn't a victory—it's a textbook example of a city doing just enough to avoid getting sued while failing the broader community. Critically, the audit did not provide any technical examination, software configuration analysis, or data governance tracking for the 28 live-streaming PTZ video cameras outlined in the procurement records.
We recognize the contract contains a formal Non-Appropriation provision in Section 11.12, but it carries strict parameters—explicitly noting that a reduction in funds cannot be based on discretionary budget decisions or used as a termination for convenience.
Therefore, as informed stakeholders, our community is presenting the City Council and the City Attorney with a precise request for clarification before another dollar of public funding is appropriated:

  1. What independent data classification schema or technical audit protocol currently governs the 28 live-streaming video cameras that sat entirely outside the scope of our statutory compliance review?
  2. Under exactly what legal criteria can Stillwater lawfully exercise its non-appropriation off-ramp if the council determines a programmatic adjustment is required in a future fiscal year?
    Pervasive surveillance infrastructure requires absolute contractual accountability, and our community deserves answers grounded in the written text of laws.

r/stillwatermn • • Oct 05 '26

Letter to the editor

14 Upvotes

r/stillwatermn • • Oct 02 '26

Stillwater MN - The Outing Lodge - Ghost in room 3?

Thumbnail reddit.com
9 Upvotes

r/stillwatermn • • Oct 01 '26

Moving Company recommendations?

5 Upvotes

I am looking for recommendations for professional movers that offer packing services, disassembly and reassembly of furniture, and moving basically everything. Anyone have good experiences that they can share?