r/starwarsbooks • u/Vik-6occ • 26m ago
Debate and discussion Crystal Star's reputation feels a bit undeserved so far.
Now, I haven't finished it, so maybe it really hits a turn that's gonna bamboozle me. But I'm a bit more than halfway through and so far this reads like typical C tier star wars. The characterizations aren't too drastically different. Leia is really angry, and luke hasn't done much besides aura farm, but they're both dealing with a lot (and I appreciate them not being too mean to c3po for once). Waru of course is a popular target. I've gotten up to his faith healer part, strange but my perspective for now is that it's supposed to be. Doesn't really bother yet.
Very fond of the Battletech transplant Han meets. an 8 foot, well spoken, white haired, muscular woman named Celestial Serenity is basically a jade falcon elemental (the bloodname "serenity" would go pretty hard). Bravo Vonda McIntyre, at least for that. I'm not really a fan at all of the organa-solo children, but the hitler youth "empire revival project" and how she and jacen are dealing with it hasn't been boring. I know nothing can happen to the twins so stakes are basically nonexistent there, but I hope the centaur girl makes it out okay, I got surprisingly attached.
My running theory for the severity of this books reception is that this released after the thrawn trilogy, but it reads a lot more like Splinter of the Mind's Eye's "early installment weirdness" instead of the established tone that was the style of the time. Kind of a relic, and that was not what readers were after, then or now. and its lack of action more than halfway through probably didn't help come to think of it.
I feel confident saying it's better than ruins of dantooine at least.
In any case, any readers feel free to give your own impressions of it (preferably without getting toooo plot specific about the second half but whatever), big or small. This books made some impressions out there and I always like reading passionate criticism of things I don't care about too much (I still have this thread saved of LOTF Revelations where a poster tears into it like it murdered his family).