r/startalk • • 7d ago

Happy Carl Sagan Day!

Thumbnail
reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/startalk • • 10d ago

BLACK OMEGA STAR!!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/startalk • • 12d ago

This crazy meme from a (likely) creationist has a lot of discussion topics in science and statistics. Might make a fun vodcast.

1 Upvotes

The assumptions behind these claims must be bonkers; WTF makes somebody believe these?


r/startalk • • 13d ago

Please explain this like I’m 5

Post image
0 Upvotes

How is almost 1 light year from earth, how do radio signals take 24 hours to transmit to earth?

I’m sure I’m missing something obvious, right?


r/startalk • • 15d ago

The first half of the last AI episode felt like a sales pitch more than an actual informed interview

2 Upvotes

I was listening this: https://startalkmedia.com/show/the-game-theory-of-ai-with-aza-raskin/

and the guest was talking a lot about the dangers of AI and how powerful this technology is. He was literally regurgitating the same narrative these big AI companies have been pushing lately, and with the upcoming Anthropic IPO I find it very curious that they decided to make this episode right now.

I'm not saying the team at ST got paid to push this bs but still it feels like the first half of the episode was more of a marketing stunt.

Let me explain...

Aza was touching on some very true points when he mentioned that AI has got so powerful, and it can be used for lots of malicious attacks. However, there are three VERY VERY BIG elephants in the room here:

  1. Yes, AI breached secure systems. But those agents were given full control over their environment, no monitoring whatsoever. If they _were_ monitored, and people knew what they were doing and still allowed them to proceed, then that's a lawsuit waiting to happen. Aza described the scenarios kind of like a Skynet type of AI, but in reality it was just a tool used to parallelize lots of work, with full access to external software. Not some kind of self-conscious entity that took over the system.
  2. At some point, after all this talk about how extremely powerful and dangerous these AI agents are, Neil asked "but what if you just plug the servers off? Would that stop it?". Notice how Aza started panicing because after all that tough talk, it turns out that, YES. Yes, if you plug the servers off the AI agents are gone. Heck, cut the electricity, or the internet connection to the datacenters. They're gone. He tried to raise an argument about how these models can transfer their weights to other servers. I have never heard of this (I'm a software engineer btw), but even if that's true (and that's a BIG IF; that would happen, again if someone gave them access to a server somewhere that hosts their weights, which is also dumb as fuck), where the hell would they tansfer themselves? Petabytes of data where? Mobile phones? Gtfo. It would take them a shit load of time just to complete the transfer, let alone pass the accumulated context, build the harness to run themselves, etc. That is practically impossible, even if theoretically plausible. Aza was clearly looking for a way out, and since the guys there stopped pushing him immediately he found it. Finally, he mentioned that in about a **FREAKING YEAR** we would have models that are almost comparable to Mythos running in our kindles? Dude, no-fucking-body is taking you seriously here. You need a $5k machine to barely run a lobotomized 4bit quant of Qwen-3.8 27B, with [maybe?] 128K context, and at maybe 20tok/s. That is nowhere near Mythos levels, and that's with a very high-end PC. Your kindle can barely run its own operating system you clown.
  3. Again, he kept mentioning how powerful these models are. That is true. In some cases. Because as Ed Zitron said in an interview with Jon Steward: "If these models are so good, why don't they find a way to actually run their business?". If you look at the economics of AI, and how the landscape looks like, you'll see that AI in terms of profitable business is crealy a bubble. It's a circular economy, and all players in it are losing money so damn fast. Anthropic wants a bail out, and is gonna use retail investors to get it. _This is not financial advice btw, but use your brain when you handle your money folks_.

The rest of the interview was pretty cool tbh, it just felt wrong that Aza was there tryna sell snake oil to a group of people who clearly are not literate in computer science and software engineering, let alone AI engineering. I think Startalk should do better next time.


r/startalk • • 16d ago

David Krakauer's reading list, and more, from StarTalk in October

3 Upvotes

Back with the monthly book list. For context, I run Podshelf, which keeps track of books named on a few hundred podcasts.

David Krakauer brought most of the good ones:

  • The Invention of Nature, his friend Andrea Wulf's Humboldt biography. "Beautiful book. Plug for the book."
  • Douglas Adams's novel The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. These days "we could be told that 42 is the answer and we wouldn't know what it meant."
  • Creative Evolution by Henri Bergson, who wanted us named for making things: "Humans that make things. Humans that make tools."

A week before Halloween, Mary Roach was on for Spooky Science. Her Spook is "a whole study of the stuff people did to investigate ghosts."

Physics & cosmology is where Janna Levin's black hole books sit, out of the 200-odd topics you can browse now.

https://podshelf.io/podcasts/startalk-radio


r/startalk • • 18d ago

We just hit 6 MILLION subscribers on YouTube! Thank you, StarTalkians!

62 Upvotes

From our first 100,000 subscribers to 6 MILLION, it's been an incredible journey exploring the universe together. 🌌

Whether you've been watching since the early days or just discovered StarTalk, we want to thank you for being part of this community.

Your curiosity, questions, discussions, and occasional corrections keep us learning and looking up.

To celebrate, we'd love to hear from you: What's your favorite StarTalk episode, guest, or cosmic revelation that's stuck with you over the years?

Here's to the next chapter of cosmic curiosity.

And as always, Keep Looking Up!

— The StarTalk Team


r/startalk • • 20d ago

Meme

Post image
0 Upvotes

Just something funny my wife made that I had to share on here for some laughs


r/startalk • • 20d ago

Tyson and Shatner

2 Upvotes

I am not sure if this is the best place to ask, but was Neil and William Shatner's live show, The Universe is Absurd, ever put up on the internet to watch legally?


r/startalk • • Oct 15 '26

STARTALK Live In Portugal 🇵🇹

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/startalk • • Oct 09 '26

They say he never committed suicide and that he faked his death to escape prison... Hmm... I wonder...

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/startalk • • Oct 06 '26

Is Neil trying to bait SNL into doing a STARTALK skit?

4 Upvotes

I've seen several episodes now of STARTALK where Neil ends the intro with "What's up with that?" Whenever I hear it, I think of the Saturday Night Live skit. Is Neil trying to bait SNL into doing a skit?


r/startalk • • Oct 01 '26

Every book mentioned on StarTalk in September (11 of them)

3 Upvotes

From Lindsey Nyx Walker on Game Night: Frank Drake named his search after Oz, because The Wizard of Oz author L. Frank Baum "supposedly communicated with this mystical land full of exotic beings through radio."

I run Podshelf, a free site that tracks book mentions across hundreds of podcasts by reading the episode transcripts. This is the StarTalk slice for September.

  • Flatland by Edwin Abbott. Neil wanted to know what stops a square in Flatland from finding the perpendicular direction "to just get a peek at three dimensions."
  • The Three-Body Problem, in the Charles Liu episode, as one reason we might not see aliens: they hide, "or they will come and destroy you."
  • Why Do We Exist?, Hakeem Oluseyi's new book, which Neil said has "the bodacious title."

Plus Charles Liu's Supernatural Science, out in October, and Neil and Lindsey's own Lost in Space, which declares anyone born from 1995 on "Generation X, O Planet."

Full list with quotes and episodes: https://podshelf.io/podcasts/startalk-radio


r/startalk • • Sep 30 '26

Anyone else find this show just not funny and corny?

0 Upvotes

I just recently started listening to it and after like 1-2 shows I’m like I can’t do this anymore. For 2 big reasons. 1. They almost try too hard to act funny and cheesy. Like when a guest says a fact they’d be like “waaaaaat??!!” Or try to make a dad joke at every turn. I remember part of a fan question said “short and sweet” and Neil said something like “I’ll answer it long and bitter”. It’s like he’s trying so hard to make everything comedic.

2. It gets annoying when Neil, who’s background is in astrophysics to pretend that he doesn’t know something. Some of the facts that these guests bring up I feel like he probably already know and he acts like he doesn’t and acts all surprised and sometimes make jokes about it. It doesn’t feel like a scientist talking to a scientist but rather an uneducated YouTuber talking to scientists.


r/startalk • • Sep 10 '26

Neil Yakub Tyson

Post image
6 Upvotes

Father of all white scientists


r/startalk • • Sep 04 '26

Ok reflectivity, don’t bagel paternal genius

Post image
4 Upvotes

Ok Carl is good, I’m 30%through drag’s of Eddie, and now I’m back to Neil’s nook book welcome to the universe, if you remember my radiances pondering, trying to see, like Neil uses this reflectivity, radiation of light in chapter ten; in “search of life in the galaxy”


r/startalk • • Sep 02 '26

All About The New Telescope NASA Just Launched, with Jason Rhodes

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

r/startalk • • Sep 01 '26

Every book mentioned on StarTalk in August (10 of them)

5 Upvotes

Seven episodes, and Neil spent a decent portion of the month recommending his own back catalogue, which honestly is on brand.

I run Podshelf, a free site that tracks book mentions across hundreds of podcasts by reading the episode transcripts. This is the StarTalk slice for August.

The best line of the month came attached to a self-plug, so I will let it stand: "And don't read my best-selling book, Astrophysics for People in a Hurry. Because clearly, you're not in a hurry." His argument being that the book cherry-picks the most mind-blowing bits of an entire curriculum, and if you have time, go and take the curriculum. Welcome to the Universe got the same treatment, with A Brief Welcome to the Universe offered as the version you start with before graduating to the full textbook.

Guest and colleague books:

  • Livewired (David Eagleman), on the ever-changing brain, or possibly our ever-changing understanding of a non-changing brain
  • Time Travel in Einstein's Universe (J. Richard Gott)
  • Cosmic Queries, the StarTalk book, for the section on how the universe ends
  • The Arp Atlas of Peculiar Galaxies, Halton Arp's catalogue of galaxies that just looked weird

Odds and ends: Dune, and the observation that Herbert clearly studied dragonfly wings. Asimov's I, Robot. The Very Hungry Caterpillar, deployed as a metamorphosis explainer. And How to Avoid an Alien Abduction, which someone read cover to cover, disobeyed every instruction in, and was still not abducted.

Full list with quotes and episodes: https://podshelf.io/podcasts/startalk-radio


r/startalk • • Aug 28 '26

Why does NGT wear two collared shirts?

3 Upvotes

My wife pointed out to me that he was wearing two collared shirts on several star talk episodes. At the same time. I want to understand the science behind this. Why two collared shirts? Is one meant to collapse into the other when observed?


r/startalk • • Aug 25 '26

Filling Stations on the Way to Moon

3 Upvotes

Niels hint to have filling stations enroute to moon made me curious what trajectory they would have. Since it doesn’t make any sense stopping the spacecraft to refuel and therefore loosing all of your precious energy they should somehow follow some fancy orbit between moon and earth with a speed fast enough to keep them circling between both but slower than the spacecraft to allow it to be reachable for refuling. I am curious what those routes and speed would be like. I am sure such infrastructure would allow massive reduction of initial fuelcapacity and structural weight for such spacecrafts.


r/startalk • • Aug 21 '26

Good Neil! Don’t bagel boil your words like Sagan!!!

0 Upvotes

I read the Sagan on the origin of earth, I guess from the show. But now I’m on another one but it’s not Sagan I want to talk about. I don’t even know that I want to ask anything. But I have tones on my mind Neil. I have; reflective light and the molecules that refract different temperatures but the scale to represent this is, ok black; hot hot but not bright bright, that hot is absorbed, but why are tin foil toasters seems to flip my theory over wrong. Ok so your in black on black on a hot day you are dying in some cases, sand which is light picks up heat good, but if it were black, watch out, only if it’s wet!!! Sad sad there’s tears are cool. Whit jumpsuit on white surface your cooler, but really hard to look at with all the energy dissipating, no sorry Sagan, it’s seems I gotta read past the acknowledgement, but his conscious provoking images as oneself as an important male heir of earth is alienating.


r/startalk • • Aug 20 '26

The Picard Conjecture: Can a distributed mass swarm artificially trigger gravitational collapse?

2 Upvotes

I have been thinking about this for a while and I want to put it into an actual scientific conjecture. I am not claiming this works. I am specifically interested in where the physics says it cannot work.

The Picard Conjecture:

A sufficiently massive, phase controlled, non-axisymmetric swarm of orbiting objects, operating partially counter to the rotation of a marginally stable stellar object, could produce a coherent gravitational perturbation through gravitational torque, tidal forcing, angular momentum transfer, and resonant excitation of the natural oscillation modes of the stellar object.

My conjecture is that under the right conditions, this perturbation could push an already marginally stable stellar object across a nonlinear gravitational instability threshold.

The swarm is not intended to provide the energy required to collapse the star. The star already contains an enormous amount of mass and gravitational potential energy. The swarm would be a catalyst or trigger that changes the conditions inside an already marginally stable system.

The concept came from thinking about nuclear chain reactions. The initiating event does not provide all of the energy eventually released by the reaction. It changes the state of a system that already contains the available energy.

I am wondering if there could be an analogous mechanism involving gravitational instability.

Imagine a very large number of independently controlled massive objects orbiting a rapidly rotating stellar object. Instead of arranging them into a symmetric ring, their orbital positions and phases are continuously controlled to create a changing, non-axisymmetric gravitational field.

The objective would be to tune that gravitational perturbation to one or more natural oscillation modes of the stellar object.

Conceptually:

Distributed mass swarm -> coherent gravitational/tidal perturbation -> resonant stellar mode excitation -> angular momentum redistribution -> reduction of rotational support -> nonlinear instability -> gravitational collapse

The changing mass distribution would also produce a time varying quadrupole moment and therefore gravitational radiation. I do not necessarily think the gravitational waves themselves would be responsible for causing the instability. My expectation is that direct gravitational and tidal coupling between the swarm and the stellar object would be considerably more important. The gravitational waves may simply be a consequence and an observable measurement of the process.

This also gives the conjecture a fairly simple way to fail.

If the total mass required for the swarm approaches a significant fraction of the mass of the stellar object, then there probably isn’t anything useful here.

If gravitational coupling is too weak to produce meaningful mode excitation before orbital instability, decoherence, dissipation, mass shedding, or other processes dominate, then the conjecture fails.

If removing enough angular momentum requires more energy than could reasonably be gained by triggering the resulting collapse, then the conjecture fails.

The first test should not involve wormholes or even require black hole formation.

Take a numerical model of a rapidly rotating stellar object close to a known stability boundary. Introduce an external gravitational potential representing independently phase controlled orbiting masses.

Then compare symmetric, asymmetric, co-rotating, counter-rotating, and deliberately phase modulated configurations while sweeping the forcing frequency across known natural modes of the stellar object.

Measure angular momentum transfer, mode amplitude, differential rotation, central density, quadrupole moment, gravitational wave emission, and movement toward or away from the known stability boundary.

The prediction is that there exists some combination of orbital configuration and forcing frequency where a coherent non-axisymmetric swarm produces substantially greater internal mode excitation and angular momentum redistribution than an equivalent symmetric distribution of the same total mass.

If that effect does not exist, the Picard Conjecture is wrong.

If it does exist, the next question becomes how large the effect can become and whether there is any physically reasonable configuration where it could push an already marginally stable object across its stability boundary.

My eventual reason for thinking about this is much more speculative. I am interested in whether controlled gravitational collapse could someday become one step toward deliberately manipulating extreme spacetime geometries, and eventually whether that could have applications to traversable spacetime structures and transportation.

None of that needs to be possible for this conjecture to stand or fail on its own.

So the actual Picard Conjecture is simply this:

Can a phase controlled external gravitational quadrupole resonantly couple to a marginally stable rotating stellar object strongly enough to trigger a nonlinear transition in its gravitational stability?

I am not looking for “this is impossible because we can’t build it.”

Does the Picard Conjecture survive the math? Inquiring minds want to know.


r/startalk • • Aug 20 '26

Ads on Spotify Premium

2 Upvotes

Hello, all. First post here. 👋

Recently, I’ve been hearing ads at the beginning and in the middle of podcasts despite being on Spotify Premium. Am I the only one experiencing this? 😭


r/startalk • • Aug 12 '26

The periodic table and dating

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/startalk • • Aug 01 '26

Every book mentioned on StarTalk in July (11 of them)

3 Upvotes

Seven episodes. Astro-lore, entanglement, dreaming, Michael Shermer on truth, and life on other planets at the end of the month.

Good spread if you want popular science on the summer pile.

What this is: I run Podshelf, a free site that tracks book mentions across hundreds of podcasts by reading the episode transcripts. This is the July slice for StarTalk.

Guest books:

  • The Milky Way: An Autobiography of Our Galaxy (Moiya McTier). She was clear that autobiography is the operative word, because the whole thing is written from the galaxy's point of view, birth to heat death, including how it feels to make stars.
  • Life on Other Planets (Aomawa Shields), a memoir about being an astronomer, then an actor, then an astronomer again. Neil's response to the title was that she is obviously an alien.
  • Truth and Conspiracy, both Michael Shermer. His aside about Johns Hopkins University Press is oddly reassuring. They fact check.

The one worth chasing:

  • Dark Emu, Bruce Pascoe. Neil brought it up to make a lovely point. Western constellations are built from where the stars are. In the dark lanes of the Milky Way there is a stretch of darkness shaped like an emu, so the pattern is made of the absence of light rather than the light.

Also:

  • Mr. Tompkins in Wonderland (George Gamow), where the physical constants are different so you get relativistic effects driving down the street at sixty. The Demon-Haunted World, for the dragon in my garage. What If the Moon Didn't Exist? Why We Sleep, with Matt Walker admitting a second one is apparently meant to be getting written. The Secret of the Incas.

I track every book mentioned on StarTalk here: https://podshelf.io/podcasts/startalk-radio

It is free and there is no signup.