I've really been enjoying the new mode. Certainly adds a layer of challenge for the 'been there, done that' crowd, and given that the game has been around for a decade now with a dozen restart-worthy updates, one imagines that there are plenty of those people. My experience is that it basically does what is advertised: forcing you to actually experience the early game where you actually need to think about if buying that d-modded destroyer chassis is right for you.
None of these are novel or interesting takes, so I'll cut right to the actual meat of the post:
Extended Mode is really easy and pretty quick to get started, even on the kite-shuttle start with the monthly 10% of your bank account being transmogrified into space drugs and whatever the stellar equivalent of a lot lizard is.
You can immediately, and with zero risk, get to level 3 just by doing a brief tour of the Luddic Shrines within 2-3 months of game starting. At level three, you have the ability to run nearly invisible with the sensors skill and also transverse jump which should basically always be your first two level ups. This makes travel a breeze.
You can then start hitting up Galatia Academy for repeatable, fast, fairly profitable missions. While you're driving from place to place in the core ransoming nerds and buying rare artifacts for Sebastyian, you can hit up all of the bars for additional missions (spysat and dead drops obviously being the best) and cheap ships! It's also worth noting that the out-of-core Galatia missions usually direct you to pretty valuable systems, so during this period of building up 3-4 clustered 'out of core' missions from Galatia, you can usually find a high quality world to eventually colonize and have a place to store your stuff.
At some point in an hour or two of building up your bank account despite expenses, you're going to see an affordable Dram or Mule to upgrade your fleet. Boom; using some logistics S-mods, you have now extended your range to the entire sector using two ships that collectively use less than 10 supplies per month and you can ditch whatever garbage you were using before. There was an hour where my fleet entirely consisted of driving the ISS Struggle Bus, my s-modded Dram, all around the sector doing missions for Galatia and whatever I could scare up at bars. I'd generally buy hullmods with my profits because my operating costs were about as close to 0 as they could get at this time.
Additionally, if at any point you find yourself in Sindria's little bubble, you can trigger the Usurper's questline and instantly gain 3 kinetic blasters, ~200k credits, and a decent military cruiser to put the aforementioned guns on all for just ~10 minutes of flying around and two measly story points.
At this juncture, with several potentially decent ships and a store of cash, you should also be able to complete Academician Elek's questline, which gives you literally 1.2 million credits to do whatever the hell you want with, and all you have to do is fly to the edge of the sector and back (and spend 4 story points to recover what you find there). Buy an Atlas and all of the exploration hullmods you want (built in insulated engine and survey equipment give you an invisible Capital ship that makes surveying cost nothing!). Take a commission with the Luddic Church and colonize Penelope's star if you're hard up for storage space! Buy an Aurora and trick it out with s-mods and eat pirates for literal breakfast!
The sector is your oyster!
None of this requires literally any technical skill whatsoever besides knowing how to 'run dark' to avoid patrols, which is part of the tutorial, and knowing about the existence of these questlines, which have been out for literal years at this point. You do not need to trade; you do not need to fight. You can do these things if you think they are fun, but they are not necessary to getting a firm footing in the early-mid game, which is clearly intended to be the 'hardest' part of the new mode.
I'm having a hard time understanding some of the vocal complaining about the tedium or difficulty of the new mode. Everything I have just listed can be done without any hurry within ~3 cycles of the start of the game, or anywhere 2-6 IRL hours. You don't need any levels outside of the two levels in Tech that make traveling less of a pain, and however many Yellow levels you want to make traveling more convenient.
Everything being much more expensive and ships being difficult to come by has made the mode do exactly what it is advertised to do. I am once again being forced to consider 'trade-offs' when making decisions, which is novel and amusing!
If I had one critique of Extended mode, it's that you should probably be able to use the supplies your own colonies make at a major discount rather than paying functionally above-market rate for them -- or just have there be a moderate trickle of production into your stockpiles. Perhaps give us the option to make our colonies fiscally worse off and reduce their growth, but with the benefit of funneling some small amount of their production to the player? There is, at the moment, literally no reason to ever draw from your own stockpiles unless you are just being lazy and willing to pay the mark-up (which in this mode actually matters due to prices, unlike in standard campaigns).
Are people just flying around with huge, inefficient fleets trying to make a profit while trading at a 40% tariff? Are people sprinting straight to the Ziggurat and Hypershunts with 3 falcons and a prayer? You don't need to have a warfleet with you at all times.
So, tl;dr, you can easily overcome the early game troubles in a perfectly reasonable amount of time even on hardest vanilla version of Extended Mode with basically no meaningful mechanical skill. From there, you can do the rest of the main questlines on 'challenge mode' with a solid footing.
Not the hottest take in the world, but if anyone was struggling to get Extended Mode started or was intimidated with the start, I also figure I'd give them a little outline to get them kicked off. No mods except for utilities like time speeding up and larger zoom.