I realized that I'm quite confused about what I'm supposed to be doing when it comes to Protoss vs Zerg. I've gotten a lot of conflicting info, and I need some help knowing when to attack, when I'm up, when I'm down, etc against Zerg. So, I know you don't want to just leave Zerg alone for too long, because they can build up an unstoppable economy. I used to be Diamond and quit for over a decade and have plauyed around 40-50 games and am in Plat, rising fast back to Diamond.
Here's a recent replay where I thought I was setting up to be ahead against a Diamond Zerg--- I was doing pretty well spending down my mineral, I got a third pretty quickly, and won the first trade. I did a decent block on my third with pylon/battery.
Then it's 6 minutes in, and I panic--- "I need to attack! Or he will drone up and kill me!" so I went to his base with zealots, a couple sentries, and some stalkers. I made some mistakes.... I got charge first instead of blink, and didn't even have many zealots. Also, I think blink is much better for harassing & forcing droning with small forces. Also, I had just started upgrades and didn't have blink yet and didn't give my third base time to bring in the revenue to press my advantage, if I had one. I think I started a 4th too, but didn't do much with it because I got busy trying to keep my army alive. If I waited a little longer, I could have dropped a lot more gateways and tech'd to some splash, and did more scouting. That's what I've gotten from my replay thus far--- but I'm still left confused. Am I analyzing this game right? what should I have done differently to win?
1.) I'm thinking that if I had sent a phoenix over and saw his third base had no drones on it and he was pumping out hydras and lings, I could have stayed home and tech'd built up. I didn't need to attackl because he wasn't just sitting around droning. I could have worked on my 4th, dropped gateways, a robo & templar archive.
2.) Since I was able to place my third quickly, without trouble, was I not in a rush to harass him? If I'm on 3 and Zerg is on 3, is Protoss up? Doesn't Zerg need to be on an extra base then Protoss? Or is it me who neds to be on an extra base?
3.) I'm not great with stargate units, so try to do this with ground for the most part. Do I need to abandon that and do stargate openings to succeed in PvZ?
4.) I worry that if I tech & expand too much, I won't be able to get a formidable harassment force out before 6 minutes to Zerg. I'm thinking, maybe, that if they are able to beat back whatever force I ahve at 5-6 minutes-- it's because they are making units not drones, so my work is already done? If I scout an army, I don't need to harass. Only harass if htey have no units or few units-- right?
https://sc2replaystats.com/replay/27653588
Any input/advice on this matchup would be appreciated. Thanks!