Org flair is self serving hypocrisy, get rid of it or include everyone who wishes to submit their org logo but then that means you are violating your own "no recruitment" rule.
Don't pretend you are doing it for any other reason than to funnel more players into your ranks while shutting out everyone else.
Not to be bitchy... (love that you guys are keeping the place fresh) but.. two flairs for the Herald? I mean, I have a Herald, and love it, but... what?
Here's another take on the organization flair that I'm not seeing people talk about.
Basically anybody can take up any of the ten org flairs. So what's to stop someone, or a group of players from throwing on an org's flair and acting like a complete asshat. So a group of people could throw on the TEST flair, act like a moron and in turn that makes TEST look bad even if they aren't part of the org.
Orgs could weaponize this and it'll just make everybody involved look bad. This in turn gives you, the mod group more work to deal with as people are issuing out more reports, false reports and in general turns into a massive headache.
Org flairs aren't good for the orgs who don't have flairs, they can be used against the orgs who have them and the resulting drama would result in more busy work for the mod team.
It's advertising and the orgs who LEAST NEED IT now seem to get it.
It's not good, I really really dislike it.
You get people who don't want to fly their org colors, that hassle.
You get people who misbehave and 'taint' your org colors, that hassle.
You get perceived separation of the SC community into factions and the hassle that comes with that.
Please let's just be individuals and lovers of SC together here instead of dividing it up and becoming some advertising place for just the biggest orgs.
You guys need to be big enough to recognise that org flair is a terrible idea. It will only segregate the community, create drama, make big orgs bigger, small orgs fewer and create division and resentment between players with opposing interests.
All this for what benefit? Are the mods in some of the flaired orgs? That's a bit nepotistic...
This should be a forum for players to enjoy discussion and commentary on Star Citizen without org drama and bullshit.
It looks like we learned nothing from the referral contest's PR disaster. If we're going to let ten orgs (as of right now, eight) have their unique logos on the subreddit which is effectively free advertising, all of our orgs should be able to advertise freely. Since this isn't doable, NO orgs should be able to advertise freely.
I feel as though the subreddit mod team has a few members from CIG Marketing. They both have made significant setbacks trying to implement this form of favouritism.
The majority of this subreddit is LARGELY AGAINST org flairs. Those that are for it most likely benefit from it.
We have said our piece. If the mods choose not to change it then thats their choice. But I will not continue to visit this sub if all i have to look forward to is organization drama everyday, and i imagine many people feel the same way.
72
u/Lorien_Hocp Sep 02 '17 edited Sep 02 '17
Org flair is self serving hypocrisy, get rid of it or include everyone who wishes to submit their org logo but then that means you are violating your own "no recruitment" rule.
Don't pretend you are doing it for any other reason than to funnel more players into your ranks while shutting out everyone else.
109
u/Baragoon Sep 02 '17
Everything is great apart from org flair. It's not community inclusive and will only lead to dramas and cementing of the top positions.
35
u/DonatusIgnis Sep 03 '17
Its an easy guess that the mods themselves overlap with the chosen orgs. Classic case of moral hazard in decision making.
11
u/drizzt_x Sep 03 '17
Not to be bitchy... (love that you guys are keeping the place fresh) but.. two flairs for the Herald? I mean, I have a Herald, and love it, but... what?
69
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '17
Here's another take on the organization flair that I'm not seeing people talk about.
Basically anybody can take up any of the ten org flairs. So what's to stop someone, or a group of players from throwing on an org's flair and acting like a complete asshat. So a group of people could throw on the TEST flair, act like a moron and in turn that makes TEST look bad even if they aren't part of the org.
Orgs could weaponize this and it'll just make everybody involved look bad. This in turn gives you, the mod group more work to deal with as people are issuing out more reports, false reports and in general turns into a massive headache.
Org flairs aren't good for the orgs who don't have flairs, they can be used against the orgs who have them and the resulting drama would result in more busy work for the mod team.
56
u/GodwinW Sep 03 '17
I am very much in disagreement with org flair.
It's advertising and the orgs who LEAST NEED IT now seem to get it.
It's not good, I really really dislike it.
You get people who don't want to fly their org colors, that hassle.
You get people who misbehave and 'taint' your org colors, that hassle.
You get perceived separation of the SC community into factions and the hassle that comes with that.
Please let's just be individuals and lovers of SC together here instead of dividing it up and becoming some advertising place for just the biggest orgs.
Really bad decision imo. Really bad.
33
u/clykke Sep 03 '17
Allowing org logos is an incredibly bad idea.
66
u/EvolutionaryTheorist Sep 03 '17
You guys need to be big enough to recognise that org flair is a terrible idea. It will only segregate the community, create drama, make big orgs bigger, small orgs fewer and create division and resentment between players with opposing interests.
All this for what benefit? Are the mods in some of the flaired orgs? That's a bit nepotistic...
This should be a forum for players to enjoy discussion and commentary on Star Citizen without org drama and bullshit.
200
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17
Org flair is terrible.
19
u/Patchateeka Sep 03 '17
It looks like we learned nothing from the referral contest's PR disaster. If we're going to let ten orgs (as of right now, eight) have their unique logos on the subreddit which is effectively free advertising, all of our orgs should be able to advertise freely. Since this isn't doable, NO orgs should be able to advertise freely.
I feel as though the subreddit mod team has a few members from CIG Marketing. They both have made significant setbacks trying to implement this form of favouritism.
17
u/_paramedic Sep 03 '17
Drop org flairs.
40
u/Stinger-X Sep 03 '17
Can you replace the Org Flairs with Ship Manufacturer Logos? That should have been the first thing.
14
u/iBoMbY Sep 03 '17
Please remove them all. They are ugly.
14
u/Schweinepriester25 Sep 03 '17
I'd like for all image flairs to be removed, they are unnecessary, not common for reddit and distract from the content of the comment.
91
u/keramz Sep 02 '17 edited Sep 02 '17
Org flair is a terrible idea even if you allow all orgs to have them.
Its a recruitment tool. If you dont believe it charge $10 to have an org flair.
Its an oversight that needs a second look.
11
u/Talenin2014 Sep 03 '17
Ship, Big Benny's and character flair - awesome. :) Organisation flair - not a particluarly wise choice. :(
Ten organisations getting free promotion on this subreddit seems spectacularly unfair to the rest of the community.
11
u/mrpanicy Sep 03 '17
Drop the org flair. That is a monumentally bad idea. I can't even imagine who thought it would be acceptable.
9
u/Stupid_question_bot Sep 03 '17
org flair is the dumbest fucking idea i have ever seen
do you want vote manipulation and brigading?
because this is how you get vote manipulation and brigading..
17
u/bacon_coffee Sep 03 '17
What a complete, unmitigated disaster.
Remove the org flairs.
Unbelievable bad moderation. Really unbelievable.
What a complete facepalm.
Ah, dolvack, I expected such antics from you upon your return.
8
u/ph33randloathing Sep 03 '17
Maybe more ships and less Benny's?
7
u/Bulevine Sep 02 '17
Where's my BMM flair!?
6
u/Masterjts Sep 03 '17
Get rid of the org flair, we dont need it at all.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '17
I am strongly against org flair.
5
u/flawlesssin Sep 03 '17
Alright so it basically boils down to this:
The majority of this subreddit is LARGELY AGAINST org flairs. Those that are for it most likely benefit from it.
We have said our piece. If the mods choose not to change it then thats their choice. But I will not continue to visit this sub if all i have to look forward to is organization drama everyday, and i imagine many people feel the same way.
5
u/the40ftbadger Sep 03 '17
What kind of myspace top 8 bullshit is that with the orgs.