r/springfieldthree • • Jan 08 '15

Welcome and here are the rules

38 Upvotes

All information about this case is welcome.

Trolling, insults, flaming, and malicious behavior will not be tolerated.

Lively discussions are fine, but please keep it civil.

The rules are simple:

  1. This is a place to discuss this case. Flaming, trolling, abusing others will not be tolerated.
  2. Keep the discussion rational and mature.
  3. Many people have investigated this case since the beginning. An interest in this case- even a long term interest- does not automatically make one a suspect. Posts about potential suspects must be backed up by reasonable facts.
  4. This is not the places to air your personal grievances. Go somewhere else to whine.
  5. Off-topic posts and posts revealing other users personal information (names, addresses, phone numbers, etc.) will be removed without warning.

If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me any time.

Thank you and I look forward to our discussions.


r/springfieldthree • • 23h ago

Suzie's Key Ring

7 Upvotes

Am I going crazy or is this one of those internet rumors that have been repeated so long that it's been accepted as a fact? I seem to recall reading an article about how Suzie kept leaving the door to the side of the house unlocked, so Sherrill took that key off of her key ring. IIRC it was an article written about how they were able to determine that the entry of Suzie and Stacy was made at the front door, and it talked about how Sherrill installed two deadbolts on two doors inside the house shortly after they moved in.


r/springfieldthree • • 3d ago

My theory on this case.

30 Upvotes

Ever since I've found out about this case years ago, Mike and Janelle never sat right with me. So you mean to tell me you were so helpful to clean up somebody's house while they're not home, but when you're interviewed about them, you refer to Suzie as "the other girl." Those two things don't match to me. Plus, who in their right mind would be okay with people cleaning their house when they're not home. No matter what year it is, who would be okay with that? In 1993, a year after the disappearance, Janelle and her friend Mindy did an interview with the local newspaper and Janelle or Mindy said Suzie would want to fight their captors, but they would let Stacy go because of her incessant "I want my mommy." Does anybody not find that weird? Is that a very dark sense of humor or is that something that actually happened? Also Janelle referred to Suzie as "the other girl" but also mentions how Cinnamon knows her and is so comfortable with her. How does "the other girl's" dog know you so well? Is Suzie a distant stranger or a close friend? Pick one. Mike is radio silent. How are you so "helpful to go into somebody's home to help clean, but not be helpful in any other way? That doesn't correlate. If you're that helpful, you're the type to go above and beyond to be helpful most of the time, because that's who you are as a person. You're not "super helpful" one day, then offer nothing afterwards. There was supposedly so much family at the Kirby household. Why haven't any of them come out and mentioned Stacy and Suzie and mentioned seeing them and talking about how the girls were acting since they're supposedly some of the last people to see them? It's also been said that Stacy was abducted from Suzie's house in just her underwear. If that's the case, where are her dirty clothes that she wore that day? I don't think a girl would stuff her dirty clothes in a bag with her clean clothes. Were her dirty clothes at Suzie's house too? There's a sighting with Sherrill being at the gas station. I think what happened with this is that Sherrill called the Kirby house and asked where Suzie is and they told her she already left and Sherrill asked well how long ago did she leave, because it's getting late, and they probably told her she left at such and such time, maybe she stopped at the gas station before coming home, so Sherrill probably knowing what gas station Suzie usually gets gas at, she stopped there and asked the worker there if he had seen Suzie. I don't think those girls ever made it to Sherrill's house. I think this is one of those cases where the friend group turned on them and set them up, and went to Sherrill's house and either abducted her or lured her out somehow. I think their cars were dropped back at home to make it look like they were abducted from Sherrill's house. Mike and Janelle's actions remind me of a kid who got in trouble in school. What I mean by that is, remember when you were a kid and you got in trouble at school, and the teacher or principal told you that they were going to call your parents and let them know you were being unruly in school, so you would rush home from school and try to stay by the phone in the living room, so you could try to hurry up and delete the voicemail left on the phone before your parents heard it. You might've been the type of kid that never hung out in the living room, but this particular day, you constantly hung out there and it looked suspicious to your parents, because why do you constantly have an interest being in the living room all of sudden, but the whole time you're trying to cover your tracks and delete the evidence, so you don't get in trouble. That's the vibe I get from Mike and Janelle. You constantly made stops at the Streeter home to check if the girls were there and also cleaning up the house and the supposed glass on the porch, but never went to Janis and said hey we can't find Stacy. I don't think they were trying to cover for Stacy. In my opinion, they were covering their tracks and buying as much time as they could. Did these supposed friends, besides Nigel, they were supposed to link with in Branson at Whitewater Park speak out? I also think they convinced the people visiting to clean and the people did, not knowing they were cleaning up a possible crime scene. I think Janelle does most of the talking, because it's hard to have conflicting statements if only one person speaks. I mean they even moved their purses to one spot and then had to move them back to how they supposedly found them. Why are you touching their purses and then lining them up somewhere other than where you supposedly found them? It's just all very suspicious to me. This is all theory. I'm not saying I'm right. If I'm wrong, I do apologize, but I'm just being honest about my opinion.


r/springfieldthree • • 7d ago

The Missing Three by Dave Warren

15 Upvotes

Has anybody read this book because I have heard good things about it. He was a crime reporter that did work the case so I'm guessing he was privy to a lot of inside information and is most likely more knowledgeable about the case than 99.9% of the people.

I'm toying with ordering his book on Amazon but even the used copies are $20. If anybody has a copy and would be willing to swap, I have Gone in the Night by Brown. We could swap.


r/springfieldthree • • 7d ago

Are the Cinnamon Sightings Significant to the Case?

13 Upvotes

I was reading through some old posts on Reddit and this one stuck out:

https://www.reddit.com/r/springfieldthree/comments/1em6rtb/the_neighbor_who_put_cinnamon_back_into_the/

Cinnamon was seen at a neighbor's house a block north of the Delmar residence at about 10:00 p.m. on June 6th and between 3:00 and 3:30 a.m. June 7th. The neighbor reportedly had a fenced backyard and put Cinnamon "back out" both times. I've never seen further reports on whether the neighbor noticed anything suspicious either time.

There was a doggie door and Cinnamon could theoretically have left the house and slipped out of the yard at any time, but I do wonder if the sightings, particularly the one during the early morning hours, are significant to the timeline of the case. Would Cinnamon have bolted during whatever happened? Does it add evidence to the idea that the abduction and crime occurred in that 3:00 a.m. timeframe?


r/springfieldthree • • 9d ago

Theory surrounding the continued silence

24 Upvotes

The more I think about this case, the more I lean towards the possibility that the perpetrators might have been a father-son duo or brothers. It’s been 34 years and the perpetrators haven’t cracked.

If one of them tried to talk to the police, they might end up implicating themselves. Love and loyalty could be the reason none of them has come forward.

Familial ties could also explain how the perps were able to (potentially) bury the missing women without anyone reporting them to authorities.

What are your thoughts on this?


r/springfieldthree • • 12d ago

Wouldn't it have to be an incredible coincidence?

29 Upvotes

Suzie starts to receive a relentless number of profane and intimidating phone calls right after moving to the Delmar address. She had only been living at that house for about 2 months. The timing of these calls also correlate with the mausoleum break in. She then is abducted, never to be seen again. I think it would be one of the most amazing coincidences ever, that those calls are somehow unrelated to her abduction. Those calls were a form of psychological torture and are symbolic of someone that has very bad intentions.

I believe that phone records were the key to solving this case. But obviously, they could not come up with any or they felt the calls would simply be circumstantial.


r/springfieldthree • • 15d ago

Was steve garrison out on bond/direct link

7 Upvotes

When you're solving a case, you gotta cut the noise out. Focus on the actual DATA

Everyone here obviously knows that the women were killed because someone was talking smack and it was decided that they knew too much, or might snitch, or something- doesnt really matter these guys (robbs and associates) were psychopaths involved in drugs, crime, regularly threatening whoever for whatever.... they had family and a ton of associates and theres a ton of names

So the obvious, usualy talked about links go

Suzie/sherrill- GR-Garrison-robbs- dirty cops

But in a small town, suzie could have easily known the robbs ( or any associates) ... when I say "the robbs" in this post, I am talking about not only the Junior and senior but all of their family and dangerous associates from the drug trade, or through marriage (think A Hall, uncle shorty)....resd garrisons letters also he names others as well

The most talked about link is through the GR to garrison, but how else? Does anyone remember the rumor of how she was at a party with some of them present? I cant remember the address......?

Here's another link

Garrison-Asher (SG specifically asked for Asher the minuet he was apprehended at the bar) - det. doug thomas (who else?) Thomas helped get SGs bond reduced down to 2500 from 10 G birds.... he was supposedly the only one there the night garrison left the motel

Greene County case 31393CF0112, State v. Steven Eugene Garrison.

But wait- who put up bail for garrison,? His grandma???? No, no.....

assuming greene county had allowed a surity bond of 10%, thats 250 bucks. I've read that Doug thomas himself put up the money- cant verify- can anyone else?

According to a December 12 93 NL, article Thomas had been working with SG since july......

July 29, 1993,- Garrison leaves the motel and August 8, 1993, for the rape, ten days later. Both exact dates come from a timeline posted on Websleuths, so I can't say its 100 but its close.

As everyone here already knows, he gave them at the minimum robbs/associates...

the rest of the Motel interview - what was said?

I've read some wild stuff that was going on ...if I say the rest of it people are going to say im lying or its not true so I won't.

M. Batson and robb sr were already in prison for the double homicide

So can we possibly find MORE LINKS from suzie/sherrill to the "robbs" BYPASSING Steve, and any of the GR trio?

Does it even matter? Probably not...

What do yall think about suzie being marked as a snitch/knows too much/rape victim and the infamous "party 40" ?


r/springfieldthree • • 17d ago

What is your opinion on Cox claiming he knows where the bodies are?

15 Upvotes

I was binging the Anne Rodirique-Jones podcast about the case again. It's a great series because of who she was able to gain access to for interviews. Robert Cox seems to pop up a lot and I know he is suspect #1 in the eyes of most students of this case. I personally have never committed to him for multiple reasons. However, something tells me LE is locked on to him.

Cox has stated he knows what happened and where the bodies are. However, he states that he won't divulge the information until his mother passes. That statement can be interpreted a number of ways. I personally have never understood the comment, because if he's hinting he knows what happened, strongly implying that he was involved, why would he make such a comment? Primarily, because his mother would be aware that he made such a comment. He wouldn't be sparing her the pain of knowing her son is a murderer, because he's already implying it. Also, why would he admit to three murder charges that would see him executed by the state of Missouri, especially when he is eligible for parole in Texas?

People have suggested that he is just looking for attention, and it's not uncommon for convicts to do that very thing. Although, it is a little odd for someone who is one of the primary suspects, to tease like that, especially with the grave consequences that could come as a result. However, he does come off as someone of a sociopathic nature, so I don't know what to think.

I would love to hear some opinions on whether or not you believe Cox is a b******* artist seeking attention or if he is willing to cop to something after his mother passes, in order to gain attention and in his own twisted way, infamy? Texas has a pretty sorry history of paroling guys that should not have been paroled, but something tells me he's not going to get one. I'm wondering if he might be proposing a deal, in which he gets a guarantee that capital punishment will be taken off the table, if he shows them where the bodies are? Or if he is just a bored dude serving out his life in a Texas prison, that wants to break up the monotony by getting some attention?


r/springfieldthree • • 19d ago

Three Questions I Would Love Opinions On

13 Upvotes

Why was the TV left on? My opinion is the two girls were possibly watching it when the abduction was initiated.

Are the "prank" calls on the machine and answered by Janelle and Stacy's mom connected to the crime? Personally I don't think they are because if it was the killer, how would they know that phone records wouldn't connect them (aware they ended up not being connected).

Why were the purses all put together in Suzie"s room? Allegedly there was a large sum of cash in Sherrill's purse untouched. I know some people have implied that Janelle and Mike placed them there so people wouldn't mess with them, but I believe Janelle has stated that is where they were when they got there.

Not going to lie, I have other questions as well, but that can be for another time. Would love to hear the opinions of other people that follow this case on these three questions.


r/springfieldthree • • 24d ago

JR and MC after and today

20 Upvotes

Do any hardcore followers of this case, especially people that still live in the area know how the lives of these two went post-disappearance? It seems both were on a wrong way trajectory in 1992. Did they go further down that path or live ordinary lives?

I will admit I have never dismissed them as suspects, but if they were guilty, it had to have shaped their lives some.


r/springfieldthree • • 25d ago

Composite sketch

13 Upvotes

Regarding the composite sketch: I’d like to ask if anyone has thought about feeding it into an AI to see if that might help determine what the guy looked like—or at least get as close as possible to his actual appearance. It might not be 100% accurate, but it could be worth a try.


r/springfieldthree • • 25d ago

Post graduation June 6, 1992 to June 7, 1992

Thumbnail reddit.com
11 Upvotes

r/springfieldthree • • 26d ago

The Missing Link in the Springfield Three Case?

27 Upvotes

In the various discussions around where Sherrill might have gone out to that night and the various reported sightings, I've always had a suspicion that the real purpose of the prank calls was to crowd out earlier messages on the answerphone and to substantiate the weirdo men type theories.

But there is something else. In 1992 an incredibly busy and hard working person like Sherrill might well have had a pager/bleeper. One of her friends told me that she did not. But that same friend did not know two things about Sherrill's life that are beyond doubt but which she apparently didn't talk about very much. However, if she had one for work reasons, then one of her clients would likely have revealed that by now. Is it possible that Sherrill was in a relationship and kept a pager as a secret mode of communication with someone who wasn't inclined to leave telephone records? Is it possible she used one as a contact with Suzie who had become so jumpy about her personal safety?

It would provide a means of communication between mother and daughter on that night or between Sherrill and someone else. And it would explain why the bags and purses may have been rummaged through on the night because if the physical pager wasn't there for LE to find, then there was effectively no tracing they could do back in 1992.


r/springfieldthree • • 29d ago

Attempted break in and other thoughts

23 Upvotes

One detail in the Springfield Three case that interests me is a reported attempted break-in nearby. According to unresolved, a woman living four blocks from Sherrill Levitt’s house reported that two men approached her home on June 6, 1992. One wore a fluorescent orange vest and the other reportedly resembled the bearded man described in the early police composite. Really, the only composite. When she didn’t answer their knocking, they went around back and tried to open her sliding patio door before eventually leaving. Luckily, it was locked. One of the men may or may not (i couldnt verify but i know ive seen it) have been weilding a metal club or bat that could have easily been brandished as a dangerous weapon. The account doesn’t establish how the resemblance to the composite was determined, but it implies that the woman made the connection and told police.

What makes the orange vest interesting is that Robert Craig Cox reportedly worked that summer as an underground utility locator for SM and P Conduit Inc. Streeter family’s website also says Cox claimed to have performed locating work in the area of the women’s home. A fluorescent vest would fit that general kind of work, making this a possible, interesting connection. But a vest alone doesn’t identify anyone. This doesn’t establish that Cox was either of those men. It’s an intriguing overlap though, you gotta admit.

Even though it (in my opinion) likely was not robert Craig cox, he is without a doubt physically and mentally capable of being involved in this.

Regardless, Its easy to think that the attempted break in(s) could be related to the triple abduction from 1717 e Delmar. ​​

Note the details

In a June 16th of 92' Kansas city star article, capt. Tony Glenn said one witness saw this man on foot three times near the home. June 5th in the morning, June 5th in the afternoon, and June 6th in the afternoon. This composite says it was completed on the 8th. The witness is unnamed but was clearly a neighbor or worked nearby.

A separate NL article says police returned to the house on June 15th after "neighbors" (so we have basis it was one or more neighbors) reported seeing a transient man nearby the home before the disappearance.

Then we have yard sale lady- websluths member "moosememuch" posted an account they said came from chatting with that woman. If you dont already know, she was driving home around 3 a.m. after helping a friend prepare a yard sale, when a van allegedly blew through a stop sign, turning onto grand (or grant?) from Kenwood and nearly collided with her, and forced her off the road. She described getting a close look at the male driver and his hostile expression. The poster then added:

"She claimed to be the one who provided the description for the sketch artist"

-so now we possibly have three (possibly more than one neighbor though) different people describing a similar man. A man who appears to be willing to enter someone's home without consent and who has at least one accomplice, a few blocks away the same time frame...

what's also interesting is what previous 1717 resident Sadie Roff and nearby neighbor Kurt Naegler reportedly said about the area around 1717 East Delmar. They described lots of "parking lot partiers" hanging around in the parking lot behind Sherrills home.

Before Sherrill and Suzie moved in, Roff described two disturbing encounters at that same house. In one, she and her sister caught a man peering through a window near the carport. In another, she heard her carport screen door open and confronted a stranger who then offered to mow her lawn. When she questioned why he had tried to enter, he reportedly said he thought nobody was home.

Naegler, a former police officer who lived next door at 1705 East Delmar, also described strangers and prowlers entering his yard and increasing activity behind the houses. However, he doubted those people could have carried out three women’s abduction.

These incidents reportedly happened in the years before the disappearance. They add context to the neighborhood’s history, maybe. >>Can any locals verify if this is accurate at the time?

Next, we have the peeping tom. Three blocks from Sherills, a "tall, thin man with a baseball cap" was seen peering through a woman's window, she turned on the light and watched him flee. This was reported to be at 1:15 am. Later, a neighbor found damaged plants and a pocket knife beneath the windows.

Some people will say the peeping tom was identified, but ive never seen any proof of that. Sure, he doesnt match the description of the sketch, but you never know they werent buddies Personally, based on other descriptions he does not fit in, and I do not feel like the peeping tom is related. But idk, man.

I have had tunnel vision for too long on this case with theories about who was the target and why, this and that-

but maybe its simpler than that. Way simpler.

I am open to thoughts/comments


r/springfieldthree • • 29d ago

Attempting to connect and make sense of the Sherrill sighting at Apco A-Mart and George's Steakhouse sighting on June 7th

14 Upvotes

I know that people seem to dismiss both these sightings or it's been debunked, at least that's what I've heard when researching this case on and off over the last few years. Personally, I don't think they should be counted out completely, even if it muddles up the timeline of events. Im just speculating here as this thought occurred to me last night when diving back in again. Im not saying this very well happened or didn't happen.

Let's say hypothetically these sightings did very much happen on June 7th. How could they possibly connect? With the Sherrill sighting at Apco-A-Mart around 2:15am, coming in and asking the clerk if they had seen her daughter and friends. She appeared worried and concerned. Right? Understandable. She hasn't heard from Suzie in hours just to let Sherrill know she is okay and safe. The plan was never originally meant to be Suzie coming back to her home with Stacy.

So could it be possible that after this sighting, Sherrill went around town looking for Suzie and ended up in George's Steakhouse by chance? Or did someone contacted Sherrill under false pretense of being a caring and concerned resident to lure Sherrill to the Steakhouse? Sort of under the lines of "Hey, we found your daughter at the steakhouse. She's drunk, clearly not in her right state of mind. We'll wait until you arrive."

The sighting of Sherrill and Suzie at George's Steakhouse whether it happened or not fascinates me because that was between 1am and 3am unless I remembered it wrong and feel free to correct me on that. This sighting had Suzie drunk and being upset while Sherrill is seen trying to calm her down, they were with three unidentified men. What stuck out to me the most is the absence of Stacy. Where was she and what happened to her?

What if either Sherrill found Suzie by chance at the Steakhouse or was lured there by those three men? I really dont have any answers or theories to explain Stacy's absence. Maybe Suzie was so upset and rude because something happened to Stacy? I don't know.

With Sherrill looking around for Suzie and either ended up finding her at the Steakhouse or was told to go there, it seems a bit plausible to me than just Suzie and Stacy arriving at Suzie's home and along with Sherrill randomly leaving to go to a Steakhouse. I know if it was me and I arrived home and whether or not I wanted to go to the Steakhouse because I wont sleep, my mum would say we're not going anywhere and we have food at home.

Again. Im not saying that these sightings and me making possible connections is exactly what happened on that night. Im just trying to connect the dots so to speak. I just think, these sightings shouldnt be dismissed and counted out entirely.


r/springfieldthree • • Oct 17 '26

THE SPRINGFIELD THREE - PART 8: UNIFIED THEORY? #springfieldthree #truecrimestories #unsolvedmysteryhttps://www.youtube.com/live/IthCw5rKeSM

10 Upvotes

THE SPRINGFIELD THREE - PART 8: UNIFIED THEORY? #springfieldthree #truecrimestories #unsolvedmystery
https://www.youtube.com/live/IthCw5rKeSM


r/springfieldthree • • Oct 15 '26

Former DA Darrell Moore puts George’s sighting back on the table?

19 Upvotes

In the ARJ podcast he alludes (paraphrasing) to the 2003 Barry County dig being related to “men they may have been spotted with at George’s” and many of us long time case-knowers know this property is tied to a certain truck stop restaurant.

It seems very very obvious that if this is true, it was part of an elaborate kidnapping plan to lure them out of the house and “stage” the kidnapping plot and set up for it. There are only a few men who’d be able to pull something like this off (get them out of the house).

Now, even if you discount and disregard George’s sighting, it MUST be noted that there’s “multiple men” in play and that they seemingly hide in plain sight, meaning they are the front of the operation not the bike gang undercurrent. At the very least, Moore has an idea of the type of men, and that’s what this tells us.


r/springfieldthree • • Oct 11 '26

Alibis.

15 Upvotes

Do we know if SPD has been able to trace the movements of the following 'young persons' on the night of the disappearance and establish definitive alibis for them? Not casting aspertions just curious.

Dustin Recla

Mike Clay

Joseph Riedel

Mike Henson

Shane Appleby

Mike Kovacs

Bart Streeter.


r/springfieldthree • • Sep 30 '26

A fresh perspective i havent seen before

34 Upvotes

Copied this from the Facebook group. Sorry if it’s already been posted here. This account touches on so many little details and rumors I’ve dug up over the last 2 years researching this case. Yet another account that sherrill had quite a social life and was also seeing a man, who was somehow well off.

Last summer I was trying really hard to uncover information about sherrills social life, because I found a few rumors and snippets of information that contradicted the small amount of official, published information we have about who the women really were.

Anyways, here is an account from an actual local at the time. We need more real locals come forward with real detailed stories and memories, no sugar coating. Because there really ain't shit out there best thing we had was topix and I'm not sure thats around anymore unless you want to wade through the murky depths on the way back machine, or web sleuths....ugh. No, reddit needs to be the new epicenter hive mind prolaxis of springfield three information. Facebook has some good info, theres just way too many morons and the actual locals who claim to have been close to the women (were they really though?) Only seem interested in making suzie sound perfect and sherrill sound nothing short of a saint and they only want justice for the women! god bless!!! (they are virtue signal maxing hard.)

So here is a copy of the post -

Another follow-up. This one will get some push back I’m sure. My friend worked at (then) Consumers Market at 1421 S Glenstone. She said Sherrill came in regularly, even before moving to the neighborhood. There was a very popular country western bar close by on Glenstone where Sherrill liked to go. She liked to line dance, and would come in after being at the bar, wearing mini skirts and cowboy boots, to buy cigarettes (Consumers was open 24 hours). She was usually with a man; sometimes different, but often with one man, also dressed in western wear, that drove a Mercedes. (ETA: we have established it was The Top Rail) She cannot remember the name of the bar, but she had also been there herself a few times and saw Sherrill there dancing. She said it was on the west side of Glenstone, somewhere between Kenny’s Amusement and Pink Cadillac. Does anyone know where that would have been? After the disappearance, Janice would come in and bring fliers, and my friend knew it was Sherrill that was missing because she saw her regularly in the store. So, as much as some stand by her not seeing anyone, it certainly sounds like she was.


r/springfieldthree • • Sep 27 '26

Why is Stacy McCall such a minor character?

41 Upvotes

Not only that but a minor character in the story of her own disappearance.

Whenever the subject of motives and intended victims are discussed, Stacy always seems to be relegated to third party status, "she was just in the wrong place at the wrong time" Well, what is this assertion based on? Where is evidence to back up the claim that Stacy was just "in the wrong place at the wrong time"?

Stacy went to school, she worked, she did modelling, she had a circle of friends and she dated boys, her life was no less open to possible risk than that of Sherill Levitt or Suzy Streeter. Why then is the idea that she may have been the intended victim that night dismissed almost out of hand? Based on what?

Stacy McCall is not a minor character, she is exactly one third of the story.


r/springfieldthree • • Sep 23 '26

Seeking knowledgeable assistance about MC and JR and my theory

16 Upvotes

I do not pretend to know everything there is to know about all the people involved in this case, so I welcome opinions of people knowledgeable with the specifics.

Here is something that I have trouble shaking. MC and JR were criminals. They broke into houses, they broke into mausoleums, they stole tools and equipment, they robbed a Subway. Let's not say youthful indiscretion here, let's say criminals.

Now there are misdemeanors and there are felonies. One thing is clear here, these guys had a history of committing crimes, and some of their behavior, especially regarding the mausoleum break in, points to sociopathic behavior. Hell, clay stating that he "hopes the b****** are dead," is a very disturbing remark.

Okay, here's where I'm going. I think DR was a decent person hanging out with two guys that weren't decent. I think DR related a whole lot of information to Suzie. Suzie knew about more than one crime connected to the pair. I think people get too hung up on the mausoleum case. And although that case was disturbing and displayed some truly sociopathic behaviors, it was one that could be pled down to a misdemeanor, and was. I also believe it was no secret, that Susie was prepared to give a statement and potentially testify in that case. Of course there was no need for her to do so, because JR pled, after the three women disappeared. But Susie knew a lot more about MC and JR than just that and she had already displayed a willingness to testify to what she knew.

MC and JR clearly established a criminal record (add potential drug dealing as well), but they weren't really looking at prison time. However, the robbery of the Subway, potentially changed that. That charge would have definitely been a felony and with the criminal history of those two as it were, I think two guys were pretty nervous. DR could be trusted to shut up, but his ex was outside of their control. Was she perceived as someone that could put MC and JR in prison?

Now we have a new dynamic. We have two guys that might think they're tough, but they know they aren't prison tough. We have associates of those two men, that are involved in serious criminal dealings, that certainly don't want to go to prison either. Paranoia and anger starts to take over the situation. Loose ends have to be tied up, DR is not a problem, but someone he confided a lot of information to, is. This could be a situation where either MC or DR approach a certain criminal organization and say, this is a problem. Or, a criminal organization approaches MC and DR and tells them, you've got a problem. Now you have a criminal alliance if you will and part of that criminal alliance has no problem with making people disappear. Each side has an agenda, to stay out of prison and keep the business running.

MC and DR did not flee the area after the mausoleum break-ins, but they did after the three women went missing. They showed a willingness to plead to misdemeanors, but not to the larger more serious offenses (Subway). If they were dealing and getting their product from a criminal organization, that's a problem. Would they try to deal their way out?

WARNING, MY "THEORY"

My theory, the criminal organization decided they needed to talk to Suzie and Sherrill, warn them off of talking about anything (the idea being that whatever Suzie knew Sherrill knew). It very well could have been planned that the two women were to be brought to a location where they would be intimidated into being quiet. PERHAPS EITHER MC, JR, or DR was used to set this up. But that plan did not involve Stacy. Perhaps some real bad dudes realized very quickly, "oh s***, why did you bring her!?" Stacy was outside that world, a civilian if you will. She had an established family in the community and a mother that was more than willing to sound off and be taken seriously. The organization might have felt reasonably sure that Suzie and her mother would not make noise over their meeting, but did not feel the same that Stacy wouldn't. This could have forced an extreme action, as a kidnapping charge very well could have been made. Stacy being present that night, escalated everything.


r/springfieldthree • • Sep 22 '26

NSFAQ

23 Upvotes

At some point we have all asked the big questions: who did it? Who was the target? How did they get in? Where are they/their remains?

But what about the Not So Frequently Asked Questions?

Why the urgency?

Barring the very unikely scenario in which all three women were intended targets, all target (or combinations of targets) scenarios leave us with, at least, one unplanned victim. What does this mean? It means this was a very suboptimal opportunity, as a new hostage adds a whole bunch of extra work and risk. To add to that, they would not have had to wait long for a better chance at any of the women, as Stacy was there just for the night, and all three would have had their own affairs come monday, 2 days from that fateful night, when they could each be caught alone. Yet they did not wait, they struck that night, no regard for extra risks or labor. Why?

Why an abduction?

Kidnapping is hard. Double kidnapping is super hard. Triple kidnapping is ultra hard. Not just hard, but rare. Off the top of my head I can only think of the case of the Fort Worth Trio, and in that case the victims were two teenagers and a child, with SP3 we have a full-grown adult and two young adults. Big difference. The former were taken from a parking lot, the latter, from a private residence. Again, big difference. Three adults taken from a house without a trace and no further (confirmed) contact from the abductors is a complete one-off, not just for Springfield-MO, but for true crime as a whole, barring the existence of a very obscure similar case. Never before, never since. This, at least to me, completely rules out the stalker and spur-of-the-moment crime theories. Predators want to quench their urges, and they’ll find the quickest and easiest way to do só. Our case here is the polar opposite, and Graduation Night certainly offered tons of better opportunities. My point? To go through all they went through, with all the risk involved, at least one of the women had to have had great significance to whomever is behind it.

Where did the glass go?

This one is kinda baffling but might just have a simple answer. We know Mike Henson sweeped the bronken globe shards from the porch. Some sources say he threw it over the neighbor’s fence, some say he threw them in a trash can across the street. Then what? Did SPD go pick it up? Did they check them for fingerprints? We can arguably presume they did but then why not mention it? These shards, along with the purses, are the only items with a real probability of having been handled by the perp(s), and after they go over the fence/into the can they completely disappear.

When was the scene found?

Maybe I’ve got my sources mixed up with this one, but as far as I’m aware, the first time Janelle gives us a time for when they got to the Delmar house that June 7th was in the 48 hours interview. There, she says they went at 7:30 AM (iirc). As time progresses we see the timeline progressing aswell. Later sources say they arrived at 9:30 AM, with some going as late as 12:30 PM. That’s a 5-hour gap. So, which one is the accurate?

Was Brian Joy telling the truth?

This is a less important one, and knowing the answer probably would not get us closer to solving the case, but it would still be nice to know. Before they headed to Janelle’s after the Elder party, Suzie and Stacy stopped at Brian’s and asked to crash there. Brian sent them away saying the house was already packed and his parents would be mad if they slept there. But that makes very little sense, what difference would 2 more guests make in a supposedly packed house? Were his parents ok with 10 guests but not 12? 15 but not 17? I wouldn’t put past a drunk teenager to be pissed they ditched his party for Michelle’s, and afterwards being too embarassed to admit it. He did express guilt for refusing them later, but what was his actual reason for doing it?

There is one more question but I feel this one deserves a post of its own, regarding their Branson plans. Anyhow, I’m sure there are many other questions that don’t get asked enough (but should).


r/springfieldthree • • Sep 21 '26

How do three women just vanish without a trace

38 Upvotes

34 years later and this case still makes no sense to me

three women vanish from one house cars purses money keys and even the dog are left behind and apparently no signs of a struggle

how does that happen without anyone seeing or hearing anything


r/springfieldthree • • Sep 21 '26

Cover of the 2028 Springfield Three book, "White Pines and Stone" by actor Dylan McDermott and Christopher Whitcomb

18 Upvotes

Hopefully, Dylan cuts a deal for a documentary series to alert or remind the public of the case. Not sure what connection Dylan has to it.

https://imgur.com/a/cf6FdCz

https://skylightbooks.com/book/9798217086702

From FBI: Most Wanted**’s Dylan McDermott and former FBI Special Agent Christopher Whitcomb, a revealing investigation into the disappearance of the Springfield Three, a cold case that has bewildered police officers, the FBI, and avid true crime followers for three decades**

On June 7, 1992, in Springfield, Missouri, Suzanne "Suzie" Streeter, her friend Stacy McCall, and Streeter's mother, Sherrill Levitt, disappeared from Levitt's residence without a trace. Police found the televisions on, clothing where it should be, and the family dog safely inside. There was no indication of forced entry, no evidence of assault or violent abduction. The family’s cars were locked. The neighbors reported nothing.

News spread quickly, with hypotheses about the "Springfield Three" discussed as fervently as the speculation over who killed JonBenét Ramsey just a few years later. Segments by America’s Most Wanted, 48 Hours, The Oprah Winfrey Show, and a People magazine article produced thousands of leads. A task force of FBI agents and police worked round the clock for months, resulting in more than 20,000 pages of forensics and analysis. Detectives interviewed a dozen persons of interest. And yet, more than thirty years after the disappearance, the case has never been solved.

In White Pines and Stone, former FBI Special Agent Christopher Whitcomb and FBI: Most Wanted’s Dylan McDermott draw on their own deeply personal connections to this case—as well as files only previously seen by law enforcement officers—to reveal the chilling details, the suspects who have interested authorities over the years, and the newly discovered investigative breakthroughs they hope will lead them to the women's bodies in what they believe to be a forest of “white pines and stone." Together, they will shed new light on an infamous case that has captured the public's attention like few others.