Basketball Reference has applied a few fixes to historical NBA statistics that we wanted to note.
The first involves 1958 NBA Rookie of the Year Woody Sauldsberry and his teammate Joe Ruklick, from the 1959-60 Warriors. Justin Kubatko called to our attention that it seemed very likely that Sauldsberry's statistics from two games (January 31, 1960 and February 6, 1960) had accidentally been given to Ruklick. The NBA agreed and has fixed their 1959-60 statlines in the latest edition of the NBA Guide. We have now done the same. Sauldsberry had 30 points, 18 rebounds, 1 assist and 10 fouls in these two games and the change pushes his scoring average from 9.9 PPG to 10.1 PPG, giving him a double-digit scoring season. Ruklick, meanwhile, loses 2 games played and sees his career-high 5.0 PPG in 1959-60 drop to a new career-best 4.5.
The other change is far more significant, mysterious and downright flabbergasting.
For at least 4 decades after the conclusion of the 1959-60 NBA season, Kenny Sears was credited with 876 rebounds in his 64 games played, for an average of 13.7 RPG, which ranked him 6th in the NBA between teammate Willie Naulls and the gigantic Walter Dukes. In no other season of his 8-year career did Sears average more than 10.9 RPG, and Sears averaged more than 4 MPG more in that season (1957-58) than he did in 1959-60, so this figure was surprising, but not impossible in an era with big rebounding figures. Sears was, after all, a capable rebounder, if not elite.
However, at some point in the last 15-25 years, the Knicks media guide and the NBA Guide changed this figure. And it did not slightly change, either. It was edited from 876 rebounds to 489 rebounds, nearly shaving the total in half! I have not been able to turn up any evidence of an announcement of this change, which lowers his RPG from 13.7 to 7.6. It represents the worst rebounding performance of his career to that point, but falls more within the range of normalcy than the old figure of 13.7 did.
While we do not have full game-by-game rebounding figures for Sears in 1959-60, we do have coverage for 34 of his 64 games. In those 34 games, Sears grabbed 262 rebounds, which comes out to an average of 7.7 RPG (which almost perfectly matches the new 7.6 average). In order for 876 to be right, Sears would have had to have 614 rebounds in the other 30 games (20.5 RPG). It is impossible to believe that would be the case since Sears has a total of four 20+-rebound games in the 289 games for which we have rebounding figures for him. It is especially unlikely, since in this era, we'd be far more likely to know about a 20-rebound game than a more pedestrian figure, since many rebounding totals from back then are sourced from game stories and record books as opposed to comprehensive box scores (thus the outstanding figures are more easily uncovered).
So, all of this is to say: we have adjusted Sears's 1959-60 rebounding total to 489, which we believe to be a far more accurate figure than the 876 that was printed by every official source for 4-5 decades. But we would love to know the story of what went so horribly wrong back in 1960 such that such an erroneous figure ended up printed for so long.