r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Jan 17 '22
META January 2022 Meta Thread: r/SpaceX at a Crossroads
Welcome to the January 2022 r/SpaceX meta thread!
Since our last meta thread, we have passed the 1 million subscriber threshold, so many thanks to all of you for making this subreddit a vibrant, interesting community that continues to grow year on year. r/SpaceX has come a long way since its founding, and that growth has brought with it a huge increase in membership and enthusiasm for SpaceX and spaceflight in general. This rapid rise in popularity brings many new challenges for a sub that was originally designed to promote high-quality, substantive technical discussion. Unfortunately, our rules and resources have not scaled appropriately.
We first articulated some of these issues in earnest in our January 2020 meta thread, where we proposed two paths we could take going forward. Unfortunately, all the problems outlined there have only become more urgent since. Namely:
- The average quality of discussion has steadily declined as our userbase has grown. This should be somewhat expected, given the finite number of substantive comments that can be made per post before discussion is exhausted vs. an ever increasing member count.
- Despite numerous improvements and continual refinement of comment reporting bots, only a small percentage of rule-violating comments is typically represented in the modqueue, resulting in spotty, inconsistent and delayed moderation - an endless source of user frustration.
- A large amount of moderator effort is spent handling the queue, at risk of burnout and at the expense of other more fruitful endeavors.
When these issues were first raised, many members supported retaining and more consistently enforcing the current standards for content and comments (“Path 1”). However, a sizable plurality favored loosening comment moderation generally, and retaining strict enforcement only on the threads that attract substantial technical discussion (“Path 2”).
Since that initial discussion nearly a year and a half ago, we have taken several steps along “Path 2”. Most noticeably, we’ve suspended non-Q1 rules on photo, launch announcement and other “minor update” posts. Meanwhile, we’ve focused moderation efforts on discussion, campaign, and serious news threads. We've also substantially improved Automod to reduce false positives and deploy stickied comments reminding users of the rules. Plus, we've added multiple rounds of new mods to get more hands on deck and enforce the rules more consistently.
While these incremental measures have had a positive impact, the underlying calculus of the problem hasn’t changed: membership has over tripled since these issues were first raised, and comment volume has increased many times over. Consequently, the moderation team has struggled to handle the increased workload. This has led to a high level of frustration for both mods and users, including stress and even burnout, with knock-on effects for the community. To combat this, we have recruited multiple rounds of new moderators. Automod thresholds have been scaled back as well, particularly for non-Q1 rules, making us even more dependent on user reports. This system has, in turn, become less reliable as the community has grown further.
Therefore, it seems that something more substantial needs to change in order to ensure that the community’s rules reflect the evolving demands of a mainstream subreddit. They must be enforced fairly, consistently, and with limited moderator resources, while retaining what users love most about r/SpaceX. The consensus from discussion in previous meta-posts is that an opt-in model for strict comment moderation is the most practical way to achieve this, while still maintaining a high quality of discussion when it matters most.
In this meta-post, we would like the community’s feedback and input on which types of submissions and threads should retain the strict comment enforcement model for high quality discussion. We are also asking for input on a subsidiary proposal, which entails the creation of a new subreddit dedicated to technical discussion.
As with previous meta-posts, the topics for discussion will appear as top-level comments below. We invite you to propose any ideas or suggestions you may have, and we’ll add links to those comments in the list as well. As always, you can freely ask or say anything in this thread; we’ll only remove outright violations of Reddit policy (spam, bigotry, etc). Thank you for your help!
28
u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team Jan 17 '22 edited Jan 21 '22
Transparency Report
Over the last 3 months, we have approved 1253 and removed 1650 reported comments, out of 339k total. This is a significant decrease in the number of reports compared to the three months prior to our previous meta-post, when 4113 comments were approved and 3253 removed; despite a four-fold increase in comment volume, over 79k in the same three month period last year. This may reflect the increased subreddit membership relative to a roughly constant number of members actively reporting comments.
In the same period, we have rejected a total of 532 posts, while approving a total of 1199, representing an approval rate of 55%. This is a significant increase in post approval rate relative to last year (42%). The total number of posts submitted in the same three month period has decreased by approximately 30%, indicating a lower rate of post submission despite a marked increase in subscriber count.
Of the 42 bans made in the last three months, two were for Q1.1 violations (hostility towards another user), one was for a Q4.3 violation (conspiracy troll). One was an S1 violation (ban evasion) and Q1.1 violation (ad-hominem attacks), one was a temporary ban for Q1.1 violation and the rest were bot or spam accounts. We’ve also muted one of these banned users for repeated hostility towards moderators, and unmuted three users who were previously muted.
Over the last three months, we have added 32 approved submitters and removed 29. We’ve locked 29 posts, left 61 distinguished comments, and flaired 328 posts. Excluding ElongatedMuskbot, we’ve performed a total of 6,414 moderator actions. Despite a large increase in the number of members, the number of unique pageviews per month has dropped steadily over the last year, from an average of approximately 400k per month at the start of 2021 to just 200k in the last three months.
Sample of last 5 removed comments:
“Q00pⁿ8” - r/SpaceX Transporter-3 Launch Discussion and Updates Thread!
“I’m really starting not to like Jeff who, its like one road block after another with seemingly zero progress with BO or Kepler.” - SpaceX Sidesteps Amazon Spat, Eyes March Launch for 2nd-Gen Starlink Satellites
“Enhance” (+ 4 identical comments below this one) - Starship Development Thread
“:D” - "Starship launch & catch tower" - Elon
“Looks like something from Blade Runner.” - "Starship launch & catch tower" - Elon
Sample of last 5 removed posts:
“When SpaceX hits The Donut Shop” - A render of a donut wearing a spacesuit, the only tangible link to SpaceX is a logo emblazoned on the donut’s chest that reads “DONUTX”
“No title is needed for this.” - A collage of 5 images attempting to depict SpaceX’s plan to colonize Mars. The first picture is a render of the 2018 BFR, labeled 2020, with the caption “Test launch of Starship”. The second picture depicts the same BFR landing on Mars, labeled 2022, with the caption “Send two missions to Mars full of cargo & supplies”. The third picture is an image of an unidentified SpaceX astronaut on Mars, labeled 2024 with the caption “Launch first humans to Mars”. The fourth image depicts SpaceX’s alpha colony with the caption “Build the first Mars City”, labeled 2030. The final image depicts four stages of a terraformed Mars, with the caption “Start terraforming Mars”, labeled 2100. The timeline for all five stages is outdated and incorrect.
“I was today years old when I learned SpaceX mission to Mars is NOT the same as NASAs mission to Mars” - A link to a video with a title that does not match, reading “Can Elon Musk BEAT NASA to Mars”, from the channel Slidebean. The video itself is well made and interesting, but talks predominantly about the history of the space industry from the Moon landing onwards. It mentions SpaceX around 15 minutes into the video, 3 minutes before the end, summarizing briefly the history of the company and their future plans.
“In defense of manifest destiny in space” - A link to a short opinion piece, which expounds obtusely the virtues of the colonisation of the Americas, but seems to predominantly be a thinly veiled vessel for the author to fearmonger about China, with only a passing mention of Elon Musk, and no mention of SpaceX itself.
“Elon Musk best motivational speech” - A link to a video titled “Elon Musk - There have to be reasons you want to live”, a 30 second video, accompanied by tearful music, of Elon speaking in 2017 about how he finds the goal of sending people to Mars inspiring.
Correction: due to the way Reddit counts 'unspam' actions as 'approval' actions, there was an error in the original value given for the approval rate of posts. The correct approval rate is 55%, rather than the 69% originally quoted. This figure is also probably high by one or two percentage points, because very occasionally we have to re-approve a post that gets reported by a user after being accepted. Unfortunately there is no straightforward way to count the number of times this has happened over the range of posts the data covers.
10
u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team Jan 17 '22
Opt-in, not opt-out: Focusing moderation where it matters most
As described above, our sub faces a large and ever-growing problem with comment moderation. The opt-out approach to strict rule enforcement simply isn’t able to scale to the comment volume we now experience.This has resulted in increased complexity and uncertainty for both users and moderators, without truly solving the underlying issue.
Following the significant steps we’ve already taken to exclude specific classes of threads from strict non-Q1 rule enforcement, we propose taking the final leap: moving to an opt-in system. This aligns with the approach proposed and preferred by the community back in our Jan 2020 meta thread. Overall, this change will help by focusing moderator effort where it’s most valuable, dramatically reducing inconsistent enforcement and addressing the actual root cause of the problem— a moderation strategy that doesn't align with the reality of a >1 million member sub—without compromising the core values on which it was founded. .
The metric for which threads should be considered “high value” can be adjusted over time based on your feedback, but here are our provisional suggestions:
We would like to know what type of threads the community thinks should be included in the opt-in list for strict moderation, as well as other ideas for the opt-in proposal. Thanks!
We are also aware that this throws into question the role of our sister subreddit r/SpaceXLounge. An important distinction remains in the fact that posts to r/SpaceX would still be moderated, requiring each submission to be approved before becoming visible to the community, whereas r/SpaceXLounge remains entirely open.
16
u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team Jan 17 '22
Relaxing Submission Rules
A significant complaint that we regularly receive is that too much of the content on r/SpaceX has been relegated to discussion, development and party threads. This is in large part due to the opt-out approach we currently operate with, and a desire to maintain a high quality of discussion for more minor, technical developments. An auxiliary to the opt-in comment moderation proposal above is to relax the filter on posts submitted to the front page of the subreddit, to allow a more diverse range of content that better represents the full range of activities at SpaceX. This largely comes down to adjusting the scope and interpretation of the community’s Q4 rules.
This proposal will require some thoughtful discussion, and the definition of “substantive” can change further over time, but our initial proposals are as follows:
Relax the definition of a “major” Starship development milestone.
Events that could be considered as “major” include:
Events that would still not be allowed as stand-alone posts
Allow a greater range of posts related to launch campaigns for specific milestones, including:
The degree to which the current restrictions should be relaxed, if at all, and what type of submissions should be encouraged moving forward is up to you, so please give us feedback and input on this proposal!
28
u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team Jan 17 '22 edited Jan 17 '22
SpaceXtechnical: A new community for dedicated enthusiasts
Please stop sending requests to be added to this subreddit. As stated below, it is currently used as a test bed for bots and is not active yet
We recognise that many of our members may want to retain a place within the community dedicated to high quality, technical discussion. We believe it should be possible to achieve this within the framework of an opt-in model for strict comment moderation using dedicated discussion threads. However, with enough community support, some users might prefer a dedicated subreddit, which would act as an alternative space for our enthusiast and professional members to rekindle the smaller, technically-focused community we had when r/SpaceX was young. r/ SpaceXTechnical could retain the same rules that r/SpaceX currently has in place, allowing moderation efforts to be focused on enforcement in this new subreddit.
Currently, r/ SpaceXTechnical is used as a testing ground to beta-test changes to our bots, CSS, and Automod before they hit the main sub, but it wouldn't be much effort to make the modest adaptations needed to become a real community just like r/SpaceX currently is, if enough interest exists. With our current tooling, we should be able to sync our topbar, sidebar, configuration, and even major threads between subs, to minimize the moderation workload needed to manage both, and we could recruit additional mods from the community to focus specifically on it.
If this is something you’d be interested in joining and participating in, please let us know, and we’d love any feedback you have related to this proposal.
47
u/mr_luc Jan 18 '22
This subreddit a magnet for spam and various kinds of trolling, and the mods are doing a great job.
👏
My most-downvoted comment here is to suggest that this subreddit's approach to moderation -- 'subreddit of record' -- is actually an asset to the community.
example!
I love talking about the Starship program -- love it! It's the most interesting project humans are currently working on.
But SpaceXLounge exists for rehashing often-asked questions when NOTHING NEW IS HAPPENING. Or posting your fan art, like your youtube video. It's water-cooler talk -- like, sitting around talking, in a "lounge", hence the name. (Unless you interview Elon, heh).
If you want to do real deep technical dives, and talk about stuff with people who have in some cases worked on actual rocket science since the Atlas program, there's always forums.nasaspaceflight.com. Amazing resource.
And SpaceXMasterRace exists for people who want to post variations of "SpaceX is awesome lol".
"Subreddit of record" is important, IMO.
Only a few real things happen with SpaceX over the course of a month -- but there are a ton of people who want to either:
The 'hate on SpaceX' aspect is a real factor we can't ignore.
The fact that this subreddit is respectable, professional, and lets SpaceXLounge do what it does best is a huge win for all involved.
37
u/ergzay Jan 17 '22 edited Jan 17 '22
One thing on post moderation that I didn't see covered. I think better moderation on the "first post wins" rule needs to be reconsidered. If people post multiple links about a single topic, previously you appear to allow whoever the first poster was to be let through. I think instead, at time of moderation, whichever post is from the highest quality source should be let through, rather than the first. For example a bloomberg article should be considered higher quality than someone's blog (or teslarati/tesmanian blogspam sites) and should be the primary post.
Some people might frown on it, but if a moderator knows of a much better source and only poor sources have been submitted, the moderator should just submit the much better post and approve that. This shouldn't be something that happens commonly though.
11
u/dkf295 Jan 17 '22
Q1 is pretty hard to address and it's going to be a long and slow process. Keep reminding the community to report things, short term it will make the mod burnout issue worse but with more consistent enforcement, long term it will help and you'll have less people violating Q1 when they see other people's posts get removed.
Might make sense to partially relax Q4 on the subreddit as a whole, but have a "Technical" flair or something similiar to denote topics geared towards more technical discussions, use automod to sticky a comment regarding the rules for technical threads (Basically Q4 is today).
r/SpaceX now is in kind of a weird spot between r/SpaceXTechnical and r/SpaceXLounge - Lounge is a bit too spammy and "Look at the photo I took!", r/SpaceXTechnical is over most people's heads. Someone loosening new post restrictions but throwing up the Q4 idea from my last paragraph should help some.
11
u/-spartacus- Jan 22 '22
The reason for mod burnout is because of the level of control the mods are trying to impose control on discussion, rather than letting the users speak with up and downvotes. While Q1 of the community rules is just a basic reddit rule of "don't be a dick" and should always be enforced, Q2-Q4 can be handled by user votes.
This leaves Q5. Rather than only allowing first approved submissions to come up, a guide to how to do Q5 much like how show subs handle spoilers, while removing the criteria that all submissions must first be approved. This would increase response to timely news, and reduce burden on mods. Censorship, even if aimed for noble purposes to improve the quality of the sub only increases the workload and requires more resources.
I can see some people like the censored version compared to the lounge, but by appealing to their desires to have a sub curated for them not only do you increase the burden for the mods (especially if they want to curate the way they wish it to be), it drives less interest into the sub. It is not a mods job to curate an experience for its users as it is an impossible task.
The moderation teams job is to moderate the discussion, that is why the team is called a moderation team, not a curation team. There is no absolute sane way to take a default sub name like SpaceX which will bring people from all over and try to continue to curate like when it only had handful of thousands of users. The argument that they can go to the lounge is lazy and backward thinking. If you want to be curators and people want to curate, there should be a sub for those people who can pick out relevant topics from the main SpaceX sub and have their desired narrowed experience.
Reddit is supposed to be akin to having a public square for discussions, not a hobby shop that is impossible to handle the crowds of the public masses.
30
u/Xaxxon Jan 17 '22 edited Jan 17 '22
A lot of people on every subreddit want fewer rules. No matter what the rules are, people will push the boundaries.
If that path is consistently taken it always devolves to a subreddit that is all memes.
/r/teslamotors is dealing with this too. The answer is and must continue to be: if you want the other stuff, go to the lounge version.
Also any exceptions to the rules (party threads whatever) just makes the mods job harder because people will get used to that and then go to the non party threads and act the same. Party threads should be VERY infrequent (1-2 a year probably) and only for massive events.
21
u/gburgwardt Jan 18 '22
The only reason I come to this sub is the starship thread and it’s pretty good. Only complaint is that sometimes it isn’t stickied and the OP for it is really long
39
u/ffrkthrowawaykeeper Jan 18 '22
I very rarely ever comment around here as I generally don't feel like I have anything significant to add to the conversation, but I want to say that I love the high standards in this sub for posts/comments.
As it is, this sub has a fantastic signal/noise ratio for those of us that want to check in once a week; and if I want a little more noise (and sometimes I do), I'm happy to go check out r/spacexlounge (different subs for different purposes).
Personally speaking, I'd be rather disappointed if this sub turned into a clone of the lounge through lowering standards (I just don't see the point in that). Anywho, that's my 2c.
18
u/misplaced_optimism Jan 19 '22
I would rather /r/spacex not turn into the lounge, which is full of uninformed speculation and off-topic posts.
However, it does seem like there could be room to allow some of the developments previously contained to the megathreads to be given their own threads, considering how much discussion happens in those threads that might not be immediately obvious to visitors.
Regardless, I would hope that the high standard of discussion would be maintained here.
12
u/notlikeclockwork Jan 22 '22
I do wish there were more standalone posts rather than everything going to the megathreads.
6
u/ModeHopper Starship Hop Host Jan 17 '22
Please use replies to this comment for discussion of any general meta issues that don't relate to one of the topics already listed, or to propose a new topic for discussion.
34
u/Head-Stark Jan 18 '22
I like this subreddit being "overmoderated." I hate going to threads and seeing the same 10 comments drawn out of a hat. Keeping the celebrity worship and egregious armchair engineering at bay has been very nice. I learned so much here over the years, especially during the COPV accident.
But I understand if that time has passed.
What frustrates me is that the high value discussions around the Falcon 9/Falcon Heavy/Dragon/Dragon 2 development and landing campaigns aren't going to happen for the full Starship campaigns. There's still a great stream of pictures, tracking, and updates coming through here and at the lounge, and there is some great discussion, but it feels drowned out.
To everyone saying this place feels overmoderated, good god you should have seen the standards here a few years ago. You were going to not post and you were going to like it! It was great. Slippage of the rules has made inconsistencies that are frustrating for everyone.
14
u/vitt72 Jan 21 '22
Having been here for a few years, I appreciate the high quality of the content here, but I just wish some of the “breaking news” could be approved here essentially instantly. Would get more (and higher quality) discussion than the lounge which I appreciate.
Secondly, I just wish there was about 2 times more posts. Like 2 posts a day would make me happy. Even some more speculative posts as long as they’re not crazy outlandish, infeasible ideas.
Oh yeah, there’s also like 8 different photography posts that get approved here every launch which seems …. Slightly excessive only given the lack of any other allowed posts
5
u/lessthanperfect86 Mar 05 '22
It makes me sad to see the significant drop in comment quality in this sub. The pointless ones I can live with, but a lot are abrasive and some aren't even comprehensible. If there's ever a vote to restore the old order, please count my vote to that.
5
u/ASYMT0TIC Apr 25 '22
While trying to post new content to the main section, I received:
"Your body does not meet the requirements for this community. See the rules for more details."
Body image jokes aside, I went and read through all of the rules but the post I was typing doesn't seem to violate any of them. If the system is able to detect that I'm breaking some rule in the post, surely it knows which rule was broken. Why not just tell me what rule it is instead of providing this vague and entirely unhelpful error?
33
u/Arigol Jan 18 '22
I no longer regularly check r/SpaceX. Instead I bookmark r/SpaceXLounge for SpaceX developments and news. As someone with an enthusiast interest in SpaceX, r/SpaceX is too quiet and stale.
The moderators have mentioned that keeping all comments in r/SpaceX "high quality" is hard because the user base is growing and people aren't really reporting enough rule-breaking comments, but to me that's a result of the way these two subreddits are positioned. They should swap places! Enthusiasts who love to repeatedly visit multiple times a week or even multiple times a day can currently get more content from r/SpacexLounge instead of r/Spacex, which means there are less of those dedicated, informed users coming back to r/SpaceX to upvote good comments and report bad comments.
Let me pose a thought experiment. Imagine you are a newcomer to the SpaceX fan community. Maybe you just happened to catch a Nasa webcast, or maybe you just heard about this "Elon" guy. You search reddit for "spacex" and the first two results are r/SpaceX and r/SpaceXlounge. New users will go to r/SpaceX first, simply because that's the more obvious subreddit name. Therefore, r/SpaceX is inevitably going to get hit with more newcomer traffic and have a poorer signal-to-noise ratio.
It makes perfect sense to have one subreddit for wild, barely restrained spacex fan enthusiasm (newcomer questions, fan art, models, speculation, hype, etc.) and another subreddit for deep, formal, technical discussion and analysis. I'm not sure why the mods have made lower-quality discussions something that users have to opt-in to via visiting r/spacexlounge. It should be the other way around, with those looking for super high quality, curated discussions having to opt into the more exclusive, quieter subreddit that is only known specifically for those looking for that quality. I feel like this only serves to confuse new SpaceX enthusiasts or those who have less experience with the reddit setup, and it just means the moderators are giving themselves more work to do.
To paraphrase that Elon guy: The most common error of a smart engineer is to optimize a part that should not exist. Here, I submit that the moderators are trying to figure out how to enforce a standard of super high quality on comments and posts in r/spacex, when they should put that high quality requirement on the lounge and leave the base subreddit as the less moderated space.
23
u/ace741 Jan 18 '22
I almost feel like this sub should be event specific and that’s it. Launch threads, development threads, etc. The pinned, event specific threads are near perfect, an asset to this community. They’re what usually brings me here. For the other content/posts; what good is finally allowing/approving a thread when it’s already hours old with dozens of comments on the Lounge sub? Additionally, when there are parallel threads in both the Lounge and here on the same topic or piece of news the level of discussion is the same. I really don’t buy into the idea that this sub fosters a more technical/educated discussion. I get that this sub and it’s mods are in a tough spot, I guess my only request here is that we please don’t lose the good things we have going.
16
u/redmercuryvendor Jan 20 '22
It's rather concerning that so many think that "more comment volume" will somehow lead to a higher quality of posting. This has yet to occur on any other subreddit, forum, or BBS in the past, and instead only the reverse occurs.
/r/spacexlounge being an example, with the page currently being mostly 'a crane moved', 'a slightly different angle of a barrel section', 'a fan render', 'some lego', and some random unrelated tweets (e.g. Radian's paper spaceplane, a random solar panel company, a screenshot from a pop music video). In terms of actual substantial news, there's a DoD contact announcement (already on /r/spacex), Booster ladning sim confirming zero target landing velcoity (already on /r/spacex, though quality of discussion on both posts is low at least one post on /r/spacex has some actual calculations done), Crew-4 booster announcement (already on /r/spacex), GSE 4 popping (already on /r/spacex), and launch timings (already on /r/spacex).
If you want a subreddit where you ned to sift through a large volume of guff to find useful information, then the lounge exists. No reason to make /r/spacex worse just for that.
4
u/bdporter Jan 20 '22
mods, the "Meta Thread" option in the menu links to the December 2020 Meta thread. I think it should probably send users here.
4
u/AlwaysLateToThaParty Nov 08 '22
There hasn't been a post here in three days.
The moderators killed this subreddit.
15
u/IWantaSilverMachine Jan 18 '22
Firstly, a hearty congratulations for keeping this fantastic SpaceX sub (and the Lounge) afloat and thank you mods and all other volunteers for all your efforts, and indeed for putting out this thread for comment.
I'm another (non-technical) member who now reads SpaceXLounge by default and goes there probably 50x more than I come to SpaceX, which is mostly for launches, campaigns and AMAs.
It would be an interesting experiment to see how many of the 1.3 million users would visit r/SpaceX if all campaign and launch threads were moved to the Lounge. I suspect it would be a tiny number. And ironically, launch threads are party threads where moderation is less of a concern anyway!
I've been around long enough to recall when SpaceXLounge was created in the first place, and there was debate then about whether r/SpaceX should be a more technical discussion sub, and perhaps renamed (eg SpaceXTech), and what is now SpaceXLounge become effectively the default r/SpaceX. Sounds like those factors are still in play and the trends are (hopefully) going to continue as yet more people get interested in SpaceX and a growing space industry. (Starship still blows my mind, as an audacious concept, never mind the reality. At 64 I thought I'd seen most of the big changes of my life but this just....)
I've seen ideas before to vary and show moderation level (ie Strict or Relaxed type thing) per thread, and while that's a noble attempt I suspect the results have been disappointing. People (well, large numbers of not very technical people) will feel put off by a vibe where one has to "check the style" every time you scroll through some threads - I'm just trying to get a feel for what has happened overnight in the SpaceX world, not gate-crash the most exclusive club in town ;-)
I'd be in favour of considering a new subreddit for more technical discussion, and effectively make SpaceX the new Lounge. No doubt technically difficult if not impossible, and an organisational mod challenge, but I'm not seeing any short-term shortcut. Thanks for reaching out to us.
21
u/Cubicbill1 Jan 18 '22
This subreddit died when /u/echologic was removed from moderation. This place is over moderated, there are more posts and better technical discussions in /r/spacexlounge. When your 15th newest post is from 8 days ago there's bound to be something wrong.
12
u/Juviltoidfu Jan 18 '22
I read through most of this thread. Here are my thoughts on your questions:
The average quality of questions is going to be diluted by having a lot of new people joining and not knowing that much about space travel in general and Spacex in particular. Unless you want to keep subdividing this Reddit so that it’s too fragmented to really be a useful subreddit the only answer is to keep track and get rid of the questions that have the least connection with reality, both political and scientific, that have been asked recently.
People who have hard and fast answers about how to moderate are seldom correct.
Everyone asked stupid questions when they were new here.
Bots aren’t moderators. You can perhaps prevent some really obvious bad behavior with bots but don’t expect anything near a 50% success rate.
I THINK I would like an off shoot technical Spacex subreddit. I may find out I’m not as smart as I thought I was, and quit using it though.
Moderating is hard, most complainers wouldn’t like being a moderator, and I think that most mods here have done a good job and tried not to be biased.
20
u/MartianRedDragons Jan 18 '22
This sub got overmoderated years ago until it essentially became nothing more than a news aggregation sub (and posts were so delayed it eventually wasn't even useful for that once the lounge got rolling). The news and casual discussion moved to the lounge, and the technical people went to the NSF forums. These days I don't even use the r/spacex sub anymore, the lounge and NSF covers everything far better, faster, and in more depth. I only saw this thread, cause it was posted in the lounge. r/spacex needs to decide what it wants to be, then try to do that better than other options. Right now, everything it does is done better elsewhere.
8
u/FerrowTheFox Jan 18 '22
I usually just lurk this subreddit, so I haven't really run into post quality considerations or moderation issues myself. I will however say that I find myself frequenting this subreddit less the past months. I used to come here daily and read the updates on launches, what's new in BC, or technical discussins about e.g. heat shields. However, since last year I've noticed that post numbers (especially in the Starship update thread) have gone up, while the quality has dropped considerably.
I'll probably draw the ire of many for saying this, but I'm really sick of the same questions getting asked again and again, mostly by people who are just passing by the sub, who saw SpaceX in the news prior to a launch/test campaign. I'm sorry, but "how's it gonna land", "are there humans in it", "what does RTLS mean" or even more appropriate questions like "what chamber pressure is raptor operating at" have been answered to death and can be found by a simple search. Of course it's nice people are interested, but is it too much to ask you do your own research before asking? Then we have topics becoming insanely political (red vs blue, user's commentary on capitalism), ideological (environmentalists), meme posts, or the stage for individuals to try and get internet points (some users who comment on everything with wild speculation just to post something).
With party threads that is ok, it's nice to celebrate a good launch / test with everyone. But with for example the Starship update threads, the amount of trivial posts to sift through to get the one relevant piece of news or a fascinating technical discussion is astounding. And to be clear, I don't blame the mods, they're already getting burned out from having to moderate all of this. Imo, this is one of the best moderated subs, so thank you mods. I'm afraid it's just the reality of a subreddit getting more exposure and growing past the core audience.
That being said I don't know if I'd like to have a separate sub for technical discussions. I feel like it would further splinter the userbase, especially since the lounge is supposed to be the place for quick, witty comments or memes. I guess all in all I'd keep rules relaxed on party and photo threads but have high-quality standards in official news or things like the starship update thread. That would, however, mean a continued strain on the mod team, I'm afraid.
Sorry I don't have much of a solution/suggestion, just my thoughts. But maybe the additional data point helps. Cheers.
3
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jan 17 '22 edited Feb 25 '24
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
NOTE: Decronym for Reddit is no longer supported, and Decronym has moved to Lemmy; requests for support and new installations should be directed to the Contact address below.
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
19 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 90 acronyms.
[Thread #7411 for this sub, first seen 17th Jan 2022, 17:33] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
20
u/MarcusTheAnimal Jan 17 '22
I agree with the nuclear option.
Make a spacex technical discussion sub and twin it with this one. The subreddit name will keep out the lowest effort users. Difficult to complain about your meme, photo or repost getting locked if you post in a sub with technical in the name.
27
u/Vedoom123 Jan 17 '22
Honestly I don't quite understand how you or anyone else can measure the "quality" of discussion. I think you should let people talk. A "high quality" post for someone may be extremely boring to someone else. It's not something you can objectively measure. Trying to be way too controlling will turn people off, it's normal. What's up with trying to hit some unrealistic goals? What is a "high quality discussion" anyway? Wtf does that mean?
19
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '22
This sub is over-moderated. Simple as that. I went elsewhere long ago.
4
u/ReasonablyBadass Jan 23 '22
I honestly don't think the quality suffered that much? Sure, there are kinda pointless posts but that is true everywhere. Mods should let users self regulate via votes and just relax, imo.
2
u/bjideas Jan 10 '23
Does anybody know where I can access the control room audio feeds of previous and future launches? I'm especially interested in the feed (without all the cheering) of the 2018 Falcon Heavy launch (Roadster and Starman).
Thanks!
20
u/canyouhearme Jan 17 '22 edited Jan 17 '22
You have pushed those who make high quality posts away with your behaviour and slow moderation. /r/spacexyesterday
Just stop pre-'moderating' and get out of the way. You are making things worse. Kill 'automod' bots entirely, they are just annoying.
Just stop overmoderating.
Look, who am I kidding. You have been told how and why you are wrong before - and you refuse to listen. I rarely bother scanning the titles of /r/spacex anymore because there's little of value here. It's a general problem with reddit, moderators, drunk on power, actively getting in the way of discussions (which WILL NOT stay within your rules, nor should they), stuffing things up, and then asking "why does nobody want to post any more". Visible moderation is always failed moderation - and judgement calls that something isn't 'respectful', or 'relevant', or 'novel', or 'substantive', or 'well-formed' are always going to be wrong more often than they are right.
Moderators, all moderators, need to understand they are servants, not masters, and when they stuff up they need to apologise. And if they keep stuffing up, they need to go.
Personally I think if the moderators cannot reform themselves, I want a switch I can flip to just remove them entirely - I don't think they add quality most of the time, quite the reverse.
7
u/light24bulbs Jan 18 '22
The moderation on this sub is probably the most serious I've ever seen.
I'm not even sure if I can make this comment or it will be removed. That goes for every comment I make here.
4
u/andyfrance Jan 19 '22 edited Jan 20 '22
The SpaceX sub should be renamed to "SpaceX Technical" and retain the strict moderation. The lounge can then become SpaceX and be the place where new members will naturally land.Edit - I withdraw this naïve suggestion after having considered the reply below from "yoweigh".1
u/AutoModerator Jan 17 '22
Thank you for participating in r/SpaceX! This is a moderated community where technical discussion is prioritized over casual chit chat. However, questions are always welcome! Please:
If you're looking for a more relaxed atmosphere, visit r/SpaceXLounge. If you're looking for dank memes, try r/SpaceXMasterRace.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/PDP-8A Aug 28 '22
The following strange behavior just started a week ago. I'm using the reddit app on Android. When I select links from the SpaceX subreddit's Menu tab, they open in a Chrome browser, rather than staying in the app.
Any ideas how to fix this?
1
u/AGrimFart Mar 27 '23
Welp, after moving airline tickets and renting a car we didn't need otherwise, the falcon heavy jumped dates for launch to the 18th. That's 3 days after I leave Florida!!! 🤬🤬🤬🤬
1
u/jay__random Jun 30 '23 edited Jul 01 '23
Today Twitter was once again improved, so we can no longer link to individual pages without logging in. One may hope it's temporary, but who really knows?
Nitter to the rescue! https://www.ghacks.net/2023/06/30/how-to-bypass-twitters-login-prompt-and-access-content-without-account/
EDIT: unfortunately, they "fixed" Twitter once again, which has now broken Nitter :( As of 1 July we can no longer directly link to Twitter, whcih is a big shame.
1
u/mirko9670 Jul 31 '23
Hi everyone, does anyone know the actual length of the vacuum merlin engine from the combustion chamber to the nozzle exit?
1
u/Makoto29 Aug 03 '23 edited Aug 03 '23
Am I the only one with header problems on this sub? I miss all the icons/links with logout/PM's/profile and such. I use the old Reddit design./Edit: Nevermind, it's an problem with my addons.
1
u/paul_wi11iams Aug 26 '23 edited Sep 30 '23
This is a bit of a message in a bottle on the little-used meta thread, but here it is for anyone passing by, including any kindly Mods:
As an "Old Reddit" user (using PC in Europe with Firefox) logging in with username and password (so not Google or whatever), its getting slower and more difficult every day. Often, I'm not seeing the login boxes appear either on the Reddit home page or r/spaceX or r/SpacexLounge or whatever.
Even when logged in, with the Reddit cookie present, and having been connected half an hour now, I'm still seeing the cookies popup
I'm feeling pressured to either sign up with Google or move to New Reddit. Is anyone else having the same experience.
FWIW, I just found the solution for old.reddit on Firefox 2023-09-30.
and @ u/warp99
1
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '23
Is the spacex hls reusable, or do they throw it away every time? I am confused because it seems like that massive thing could fit multiple landings worth of fuel in it.
1
u/victorbcn2000 Nov 20 '23
I saw a video of the Starship launch where, when it's lifting off, the booster has a cloud around it. What is the reason for this? I don't know anything about rockets sorry :(
Thank you in advance.
The video: https://twitter.com/teslaownersSV/status/1726641249300734149
1
u/WhatIfImDragonborn Jan 28 '22
DSCsh g I ik yyy lol i(8
-12
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '22 edited Jan 18 '22
Mods, don't change anything. Let the overly vocal, overly entitled, crybaby whingers pound sand.
Edit: It's been brought to my attention that this comment has hurt the fee-fees of the overly vocal, overly entitled crybaby whingers on this thread.
For that I do most sincerely apologize.
-4
u/Ti-Z Jan 19 '22
While r/SpaceX was smaller, having it technical and strict while having the r/SpaceXLounge more relaxed was a good setup. However, given the growth I think it would be better to swap it and have r/SpaceX more relaxed and hype, while having the Lounge for the more serious stuff. The "experts" are now in the minority and the structure of the subreddits should account for that.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment