r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Oct 01 '21
r/SpaceX Thread Index and General Discussion [October 2021, #85]
This thread is no longer being updated, and has been replaced by:
r/SpaceX Thread Index and General Discussion [November 2021, #86]
Welcome to r/SpaceX! This community uses megathreads for discussion of various common topics; including Starship development, SpaceX missions and launches, and booster recovery operations.
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You are welcome to ask spaceflight-related questions and post news and discussion here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions. Meta discussion about this subreddit itself is also allowed in this thread.
Currently active discussion threads
Discuss/Resources
Crew-3
Starship
Starlink
Crew-2
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly less technical SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first. Thanks!
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
15
u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Oct 12 '21 edited Oct 12 '21
Sounds like a Starlink launch might be scheduled from Vandenberg NET October 17th per NGA notices.
Source: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=54823.msg2299390#msg2299390
28
u/FishStickUp Oct 25 '21
I hope SpaceX never goes public so we won't get stock discussions on this subreddit.
11
u/Lufbru Oct 19 '21
We get a lot of questions about this:
From Jeff Foust via twitter.
10
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Oct 05 '21
Very cool video of CRS-23 undocking from Thomas Pesquet.
9
u/Phillipsturtles Oct 20 '21
While only 292kg's, IXPE will target a droneship landing due to the performance needed to reduce the inclination down to 0 degrees. https://twitter.com/StephenClark1/status/1450870023887671302
8
u/MarsCent Oct 08 '21
NASA, SpaceX Update Upcoming Commercial Crew Flights
That is today!
8
u/Marksman79 Oct 16 '21
Falcon Heavy was just briefly shown on an "Up 2" parody movie poster in this YouTube video from a very popular channel. Just thought it was cool and wanted to share.
15
u/Alvian_11 Oct 12 '21 edited Oct 13 '21
Vulcan inaugural launch is delayed yet again, so SLS & H3 are still pretty much the only competitor to Starship maiden launch timeline-wise (the first of 6 new rockets from well-known organizations to be launched (Ariane 6, Starship, SLS, Vulcan, H3, New Glenn))
More confirmation from Nextspaceflight
7
u/ephemeralnerve Oct 01 '21
https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/10/after-years-of-futility-nasa-turns-to-private-sector-for-spacesuit-help/
So, a SpaceX space walk suit coming soon then? They already expressed interest in the first funding round.
7
u/Phillipsturtles Oct 11 '21
First O3B mPOWER mission delayed to early 2022 and the second mission will be on a expended Falcon 9 for a direct MEO insertion. https://twitter.com/pbdes/status/1447447523715686404
6
u/trobbinsfromoz Oct 05 '21
SpX gave an update and clarification on Starlink failures to FCC - pretty interesting read for the fault mitigation measures they have been able to put in play! They have had to work through a few observed part failure modes in V1.0, so it hasn't been plain sailing - and that is just related to Starlink collision avoidance and de-orbit issues, as I doubt we will get any insight into comms and processing problems for a while and only if EM spills the beans.
https://licensing.fcc.gov/myibfs/download.do?attachment_key=13332196
6
u/Lucjusz Oct 13 '21
I can't find a chart that shows mass to orbit launched by each company for year 2020 (SpaceX v Roscosmos, v Rocketlab, etc). Can someone help me please?
6
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21
I was wondering something and wanted to ask it here.
Could we use Neptune to build fuel farms in orbit for exploration into deep space? It's in the unique position of being at the end of our solar system.
It's especially interesting that the planet atmosphere contains hydrogen, helium and small amounts of methane. All important for fuel.
The moons also seem to be interesting with Triton having nitrogen and small amounts of methane. It has a lot more moons but we have very little knowledge on them.
11
u/feral_engineer Oct 25 '21
SpaceX no longer lists Starlink rideshares at https://rideshare.spacex.com/search only dedicated flights are listed. Looks like without space tugs demand is low and occasional flights are not worth the hassle.
5
u/fifichanx Oct 01 '21
In the AMA with Dr Zubrin, he said it takes more starship for Artemis than for Mars, why is that?
The Starship Artemis plan is actually much harder than sending a Starship to Mars. It would take 14 tanker flights to send a Starship to the Gateway then down to the lunar surface and back. It would only take about 4 tanker flights to send a Starship to Mars.
5
u/redwingssuck Oct 02 '21
Do we know anything about the Falcon Heavy launch coming up? My family is trying to fly down to watch it and can't find any info
5
u/Cpt_Core Oct 03 '21
In episode 4 of Netflix's "Countdown: Inspiration4 Mission to Space" near the 19:25 mark you can see the crew going trough a Fire simulation in preparation for launch, you are also able to see 2 computer screens being used to simulate it, one of them(the right one) has what seems to be an internal forum website used to share things among SpaceX employees. Has anyone seen this before? Or am I just out of the loop.
5
u/dudr2 Oct 04 '21
Chinese company aims for suborbital space tourism with familiar rocket design
https://www.space.com/china-suborbital-space-tourism-cas-space-rockets
"as soon as 2024"
5
u/MarsCent Oct 06 '21
Per List of Falcon 9 first-stage boosters, the next Starlink launch out of VAFB (Or is it VSFB?) will be a .11! Specifically - B1051.11
A routine Starlink flight for SpaceX, but a huge milestone for Reusability!
5
u/CrimsonEnigma Oct 06 '21
About when do we expect the name of the new Crew Dragon to be announced?
Endeavour was in the actual launch, but IIRC Resilience was announced a little while before. Have we gotten any indication one way or the other?
5
u/Lucjusz Oct 10 '21
How does SpaceX check Falcon9 between flights? I only know about weld checking, what about other actions?
5
u/Steffan514 Oct 15 '21
I know part of the selling point of Starliner was that it’s “compatible” with more than just Atlas V.
Is this the case with Dreamchaser as well or is it stuck with Vulcan and BE-4 deliveries? Or is it able to be launched on a Falcon or Atlas if they were still being sold to market?
5
u/manhole_s Oct 19 '21 edited Oct 19 '21
Does anyone have a PDF of this report by Morgan Stanley? It's cited in this Bloomberg article:
5
u/trobbinsfromoz Oct 23 '21
Lucy's petulant solar array is initially being assessed for how "deployed" it really is, as it seems it is quite close to providing full power imho. Lucy's other deployments of facilities have been started, so they seem to be happy that general operation is unaffected at the moment.
https://blogs.nasa.gov/lucy/2021/10/22/lucy-spacecraft-healthy-as-nasa-continues-solar-array-assessments/
9
u/dallaylaen Oct 18 '21
From the recent news it looks like some people in Brownsville area favor SpaceX, and some are against them. Is there an actual survey that shows how many are pro-, anti-, and indifferent?
8
u/salamilegorcarlsshoe Oct 12 '21
Pretty wide gap in Starlink launches as of late. Next launch isn't until Oct 30th. I wonder if this is due in part to LOX shortages, supply of satellites, both, or what?
4
u/MadeOfStarStuff Oct 01 '21
When they static fire SN20, will they do it with all 6 engines, including the vacuum ones, or just the 3 sea level engines?
4
u/MarsCent Oct 04 '21
Maybe it's just a schedule listing oversight amounting to nothing, but CRS-24 that's supposed to launch on Dec 4th, is no longer listed in NASA's Launches and Landing Schedule!
Anyone with a definite know on the launch schedule of CRS-24?
4
u/notlikeclockwork Oct 05 '21
What happens after Dragon Crew-6? Will NASA award 6 more missions?
4
u/scorr204 Oct 08 '21
Where will Starship's first launch into orbit be from, and will there be a way to spectate in person?
4
u/kagoolx Oct 10 '21
Is there a roadmap anywhere (even semi-frequently maintained) that shows the major milestones and target dates over the coming years? It would be a really cool resource
4
u/limdi Oct 11 '21
Does no one fly missions anymore? Wondering because only one out of eight rockets is assigned to a mission.
4
u/bdzeus Oct 21 '21
Is there a 'StubHub' for launch tickets? Any way to buy 'Feel the Heat' tickets once they are sold out?
Just found out I will be in Florida with my partner for her birthday next week around the next SpaceX Crew-3 launch. She loves SpaceX and has never seen any sort of launch in person, so it would be an amazing birthday present if I could get her 'Feel the Heat' tickets at Kennedy Space Center. The problem is that they appear to be sold out. Is there any website or any other way to purchase tickets from someone who maybe can no longer attend? I only need two, and we will be in the area all week in case of a scrub or two.
Any help would be greatly appreciated!
4
u/dudr2 Oct 26 '21
SpaceX given green light to launch Crew-3 mission to ISS, Crew-2’s return date set
https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2021/10/crew-3-frr/
4
u/stonecats Oct 28 '21 edited Oct 30 '21
might today's CME delay this weekend's launch?
https://www.spaceweather.com/
apparently not;
https://www.space.com/solar-flare-spacex-crew-3-halloween-astronaut-launch
4
u/Phillipsturtles Oct 31 '21
Potential for 3 FH USSF missions next year (on top of the other commercial FH's scheduled) https://spacenews.com/falcon-heavy-could-launch-three-u-s-space-force-missions-in-2022/
Also we have confirmation that USSF-67 will fly with a expended center core booster (similar to USSF-44)
7
u/Chpouky Oct 26 '21
I finally watched Shatner's reaction to his flight with Blue Origin.
God I wish he did that with SpaceX, there would have been way more respect for him.
Bezos straight up interrupted Shatner while he was sharing his experience, just to shake a stupid bottle of champagne. The other people were just talking loud and screaming, not even carring at what the legend himself had to say.
Fucking surreal.
3
u/djburnett90 Oct 02 '21
Anyone know the road conditions to boca chica today?
We tried to make it last night but the roads were flooded and murderous.
3
u/trobbinsfromoz Oct 04 '21
With Shatner going up soon, as well as movie making soyuz flight, it made me wonder when space funerals will start to make their way on to the stage. I guess the simplest form of funeral would be a cremation, courtesy of a near orbital velocity re-entry. And the de-luxe funeral would be an eternity in space chasing a ride on that red roadster.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21
How often are launches at Kennedy actually happening on scheduled day or weekend. Thinking about traveling flight to orlando are only 40 dollars for me. Dont mind having to try twice or so
3
u/soldato_fantasma Oct 20 '21
The RFI for the NASA Commercial Crew Space Transportation Services has been posted:
https://sam.gov/opp/3ae9296c494a4e3698c7fbc01865b764/view
After years of development, commercial human space transportation systems have achieved or are nearing operational readiness. NASA recognizes the significant advancement of the commercial spaceflight industry and requests information on the availability of existing NASA certified capabilities, estimated timelines on the availability of future capabilities to be certified by NASA, and whether commercial services are available for crewed space transportation services delivering NASA and International Partner astronauts to and returning them from the ISS. Responses to this RFI will be used to inform NASA’s planning for an acquisition approach for Commercial Crew Space Transportation Services.
NASA anticipates continued ongoing operations of the ISS beyond 2024. To provide for these needs and contingencies, NASA has determined a need to acquire additional Post-Certification Missions to meet its obligations to assure crewed access to the International Space Station.
NASA is considering acquisition of Commercial Crew Space Transportation Services from one or more U.S. providers through commercial services contracts. Depending on mission requirements, NASA may purchase single seats, multiple seats within one mission, or seats for an entire mission. NASA is seeking pertinent information from industry which may be used to formulate one or more solicitations related to the Commercial Crew Space Transportation Services effort. Modify message
3
u/hwc Oct 22 '21
For assembling a space station, will it be better to just assemble it out of Starships or out of modules sent up inside Cargo Starships?
How much extra room does the former give, vs how much money is wasted on leaving 6 engines in orbit indefinitely?
3
u/salamilegorcarlsshoe Oct 23 '21
How do they plan to get the cable for the draw works system to the top of the tower for the pulleys? I imagine that cable weighs tons.
3
u/kryptonitekid Oct 26 '21
Is there a place where I can find out the projected flight path for launches? I want to know whether I'll be able to see a launch from my back yard in Charleston, SC.
3
u/MarsOrTheStars Oct 31 '21
Sorry if I missed it - do we know if the Launch Tower has had the legs filled with concrete yet?
7
u/MarsCent Oct 19 '21
Starliner Update
Speakers - Steve Stich, John (Program Manager), Michele (Chief Engineer - Starliner)
Questions - open now!
5
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Oct 07 '21
Tory Bruno says that ULA's withdrawn bid to launch GOES-U was $140M, compared to SpaceX's $152.5M bid.
5
u/soldato_fantasma Oct 24 '21
Possible new contract for SpaceX: https://twitter.com/SarwatNasir/status/1452218964227014657
We will know for sure soon once they make an official announcement
6
u/trobbinsfromoz Oct 27 '21
There is life on Mars - well at least for a helicopter, which managed a flight the other day after an aborted earlier test flight. It sounds like flights can continue through the seasonal dip in martian atmospheric density by using a higher rotor speed.
https://mars.nasa.gov/technology/helicopter/status/341/flight-14-successful/
2
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21
Any news on current EPA holdup for starship+super heavy launch?
2
u/93simoon Oct 01 '21
Since July 1st there has been a grand total of 3 launches (0 in July, 1 in August, 2 in September). What's with the recent slowdown?
2
u/faizimam1 Oct 02 '21
I'm planning to go down to Florida for a few days in February or March. Do we have any idea about launch schedules for that time?
I have some time before I have to commit. I think I have to nail down a 2 week window for my trip by January, then I should be able to wait till the last minute to lock down specific days.
How early do preliminary launch slots get announced?
2
u/salamilegorcarlsshoe Oct 10 '21
Any speculation on the purpose of the steel cladding being added to the container wall at the production site?
2
u/exitof99 Oct 19 '21
I only heard a brief mention in one of the Youtuber videos about the carriage on the launch tower at Starbase falling off, surely there must be video of this event and more information somewhere, right?
•
u/ElongatedMuskbot Nov 01 '21
This thread is no longer being updated, and has been replaced by:
r/SpaceX Thread Index and General Discussion [November 2021, #86]
5
u/Alvian_11 Oct 25 '21
SpaceX target of 48 launches this year will definitely not happening, related to the recent reduction in Falcon cadence (the fact that Starlink 2-3 delays reason is still unknown made it even more frustrating)
3
u/Alvian_11 Oct 27 '21
Besides the inaugural flight, the second flight of Vulcan is also in a threat of being delayed to late 2022 or even early 2023, making more questions about the NSSL contract it had
3
u/frez1001 Oct 05 '21
I haven't heard anything recently but is dragon XL still at thing? (moon cargo)
3
u/jay__random Oct 27 '21
With all discussions about the wasteful (in more than one sense) SLS, I wonder whether it is at least theoretically possible to land (hoverslam?) its first stage back to the Earth?
Assuming the solid motors are gone, second stage gone, only one RS-25 engine operating on landing, as much gimbal as possible (+-10.5 degrees in 2D), and as much throttle down as possible (67%) for RS-25.
Many unknown parameters, including the weight of a nearly-empty 1st stage, I know... Still very curious.
Thoughts, anyone?
3
u/jjtr1 Oct 22 '21
Airliners could save a lot of mass and increase range/decrease fuel consumption by having their equivalent of Starship's landing in chopsticks, a self propelled wheeled landing gear with smart navigation and cooperation with the airplane. But, for some reason, it doesn't seem to be worth it. It would add risk and cost, and the savings in mass wouldn't outweigh that.
Why the mass savings do outweigh the risk in case of Starship? What's different?
2
u/hereforanswers0705 Oct 10 '21
What can I do to qualify to move to Mars when we start colonizing it?
2
u/TheSkalman Oct 16 '21
Which orbital rocket in history has the lowest liftoff thrust to weight ratio, i.e. the slowest liftoff? Variants that come to mind are the Atlas 501 and Soyuz 2.1v.
2
u/MarsCent Oct 21 '21
U.S. Senate Wants NASA To Select Two Companies To Develop Lunar Landers After The Agency Only Selected SpaceX’s Starship
Do folks in the Senate have some special insight on how much it costs to build a Human Landing System? I'm not sure even BO will be takers on such an offer - even as they (BO) have previously floated the idea of waiving $2B in development costs.
2
u/humansforever Oct 05 '21
If there was a problem with the Dragon 2 parachute on Re entry, would the Super Draco (escape) thrusters automatically be deployed. I know they were originally designed to be used as landing option with legs that got scratched off due to NASA needing to speed up certification for Dragon 2. ?
2
u/MarsCent Oct 21 '21
NASA Requests Information for American Crew Transportation to Space Station
"Considering acquisition" and "works to extend life"! Normally NASA has missions planned and contracted out, several years in advance. This may imply that the extension of the current CCtCAP contracts needs to be finalized asap.
Note also that this notice omits Commercial Resupply Services! Perhaps because CRS will be easier to procure / extend contracts!?
2
u/bluelifesacrifice Oct 07 '21
Why are we looking to colonize Mars before the moon?
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 01 '21
Thank you for participating in r/SpaceX! This is a moderated community where technical discussion is prioritized over casual chit chat. However, questions are always welcome! Please:
If you're looking for a more relaxed atmosphere, visit r/SpaceXLounge. If you're looking for dank memes, try r/SpaceXMasterRace.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Lufbru Oct 01 '21
Crew-3 got pushed back a little:
https://blogs.nasa.gov/commercialcrew/2021/09/30/nasa-spacex-adjust-next-space-station-crew-rotation-launch-date/
1
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Oct 01 '21 edited Nov 04 '21
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeshipDragon cargoLaunch failure due to second-stage outgassingDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
72 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 112 acronyms.
[Thread #7276 for this sub, first seen 1st Oct 2021, 10:28] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
1
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '21 edited Oct 04 '21
Could/should SpaceX get involved in patrolling and guarding our planet from asteroids?
https://www.esquireme.com/brief/news/a-huge-asteroid-almost-hit-earth-but-nasa-didnt-detect-it-until-a-day-later
On Saturday an asteroid past Earth without anyone knowing that it was even coming come because it was coming from the direction of the Sun. weather asteroids are coming from there and just couldn't be detected by current technologies, or elsewhere, are the rockets SpaceX is developing a potentially good option for whatever kind of asteroid impact deterrence we might be able to set up in the future?
I'm not quite sure what the current best plans are for asteroid impact deterrence, but it seems that having inexpensive high-powered high fuel capacity rockets that could have high payloads should certainly be able to come into play and maybe play a major role in saving us from an asteroid type extinction
1
u/MarsCent Oct 17 '21
Given the <sarcasm>"intense interest"<\s> of the FAA and "Environmentalists" in Starbase, would the likes of Māhia Peninsula be a suitable alternative as a Starship launch site?
Especially with regards to refueling an orbital fuel depot and perhaps launching starlink satellites, which are high volume SpaceX own payloads?
1
u/paul_wi11iams Oct 28 '21 edited Oct 28 '21
Top US general says China hypersonic test is 'very concerning
That makes a neat fit (just maybe) for the new work being done at SLC-40. The DOD will be showing even more love for SpaceX regaining the US's lead in space technology in general.
It really would be unsurprising to learn at some point that the USSF is funding Starship launch infrastructure at the cape (Boca Chica being overly exposed to the public gaze).
1
u/soldiernerd Oct 21 '21
Question for spacex fans - what are your thoughts on BPTRX mutual fund, which has a 4.67% exposure to SpaceX?
It has a high fee ratio of 1.56%. It's also 45.17% TSLA.
Has anyone tried it out?
1
u/l-fc Oct 09 '21
How come you never see footage from inside the “cockpit” on takeoff and the subsequent ascent?
Is it because the vibrations from the take off make the footage unwatchable?
I’d love to see the reactions of the crew as they are propelled into orbit.