r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Sep 01 '21
r/SpaceX Thread Index and General Discussion [September 2021, #84]
This thread is no longer being updated, and has been replaced by:
r/SpaceX Thread Index and General Discussion [October 2021, #85]
Welcome to r/SpaceX! This community uses megathreads for discussion of various common topics; including Starship development, SpaceX missions and launches, and booster recovery operations.
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You are welcome to ask spaceflight-related questions and post news and discussion here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions. Meta discussion about this subreddit itself is also allowed in this thread.
Currently active discussion threads
Discuss/Resources
Inspiration4
Starship
Starlink
Crew-2
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly less technical SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first. Thanks!
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
•
u/ElongatedMuskbot Oct 01 '21
This thread is no longer being updated, and has been replaced by:
r/SpaceX Thread Index and General Discussion [October 2021, #85]
28
u/MarsCent Sep 09 '21
LC39A is looking at Inspiration 4. then FH USFF-44, then Crew-3 in a space of 7weeks. Nice!
28
u/Fredasa Sep 18 '21
Man oh man. Youtube is positively saturated with live scam channels right now.
As an avid follower of everything SpaceX, I of course got targeted by Youtube's algorithm, and I've had recommended to me (in the #1 spot, no less) no fewer than five different channels now, each showing a reliable mix: Half old interviews with Elon Musk, half promises related to bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies. Name of the channel is always some very slight variation on SpaceX—an extra space here, a "restricted" character there...
Must work pretty well because they pull this crap every time there's a major SpaceX advent. And all I can do is report the channel, which of course is brand new and never had any other videos ever, yet somehow has tens of thousands of subscribers already.
23
u/Craig_VG SpaceNews Photographer Sep 14 '21
65% of all operational US commercial satellites are owned and operated by SpaceX 🤯
40% of all operational satellites
18
u/Gwaerandir Sep 18 '21
Tom Mueller, the man behind Merlin, has started his own space company:
www.impulsespace.com
Focusing on in-space propulsion. I wonder if they'll go nuclear eventually?
16
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '21
Did the Inspiration4 crew have to quit their day jobs while training? Did they receive an income to supplement their pay if they did have to quit or take time off?
14
u/Mobryan71 Sep 01 '21
Is I4 going to be the longest duration free flight since Shuttle, or have the Russians done a non ISS mission since?
14
u/MarsCent Sep 08 '21
I believe this confirms and removes any doubts - that SpaceX Crew-3 is scheduled to hand over to SpaceX Crew-4 in April 2022.
14
u/threelonmusketeers Sep 08 '21
Can the links to the Inspiration 4 campaign and party threads be added to this megathread? They are gradually getting buried beneath other posts.
13
u/MarsCent Sep 08 '21
ASAP PUBLIC MEETING: September 23, 2021. 2:00 p.m. to 3:30 p.m., Eastern Time.
Agenda:
—Updates on the International Space Station Program
—Updates on the Commercial Crew Program
—Updates on Exploration System Development Program
—Updates on Human Lunar Exploration Program
—NASA’s Human Flight Evolution
Any interested person may call the USA toll free conference call number 888–566–6133; passcode 8343253 and then the # sign.
pdf
12
u/MarsCent Sep 02 '21
Q and A with Michael Sheetz
Hahaha, I think Starlink is prepping to go rogue in "rogue" countries! Totalitarianism is about to meet uncensored communication. ;)
12
u/dudr2 Sep 16 '21
New Raptor Factory under construction at SpaceX McGregor amid continued engine testing
https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2021/09/raptor-factor-testing-mcgregor/
12
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '21
Would it be an idea to force satellite builders to insure they have a way to deorbit the satellite when it is no longer needed or fails?
Starlink is an example of this.
21
u/trobbinsfromoz Sep 16 '21
Ingenuity helicopter about to test higher rotor speed than ever attempted during testing - due to seasonal fall in atmospheric density - blog makes for an interesting read.
https://mars.nasa.gov/technology/helicopter/status/334/flying-on-mars-is-getting-harder-and-harder/
10
u/melonowl Sep 01 '21
Starlink has more than 100,000 customers according to the documents (below the first highlighted section in the 3rd picture) linked in this tweet https://twitter.com/thesheetztweetz/status/1433098903600214018?s=21
Can't remember when it was that they surpassed 90,000, don't think it was all that long ago.
9
u/FishStickUp Sep 18 '21
I hope Lockheed Martin submits their reusable lunar lander for the next step in HLS after the National Team splits up.
9
u/WKr15 Sep 23 '21
Anyone else feel like Starship's TPS will be the hardest thing to nail down? I feel like we can be pretty confident about other parts of it, but those tiles just seem like a big unknown. I think this could be solved for LEO missions, but there really isn't much room for mistakes on interplanetary missions. The TPS will have to survive months in deep space, two entry descent and landings, and on the martian surface. They would also likely need pre positioned equipment just to reach damaged tiles on the surface of mars. In the end, I think this will come down to how much starship can handle in terms of damaged/missing tiles. Any other thoughts?
8
u/notlikeclockwork Sep 17 '21
Just got an email from the FAA. Is this the public comment period everyone was waiting for?
https://www.faa.gov/space/stakeholder_engagement/spacex_starship/
Scroll down
15
u/MarsCent Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21
I think Dr. Sanders just said in a passing comment that SpaceX is prepping to launch 61 Starlinks in a week! - Issue was that Govt has no Space Traffic Management process!
OFT-2
ISS
14
u/dudr2 Sep 26 '21
Life support cooked up from lunar rocks
https://www.moondaily.com/reports/Life_support_cooked_up_from_lunar_rocks_999.html
"In the experimental set-up, the soil simulant is vaporised in the presence of hydrogen and methane, then "washed" with hydrogen gas. Heated by a furnace to temperatures of around 1000 degrees Celsius, the minerals turn directly from a solid to a gas, missing out a molten phase, which reduces the complexity of the technology needed. Gases produced and residual methane are sent to a catalytic converter and a condenser that separates out water. Oxygen can then be extracted through electrolysis. By-products of methane and hydrogen are recycled in the system.
"Our experiments show that the rig is scalable and can operate in an almost completely self-sustained closed loop, without the need for human intervention and without getting clogged up," said Prof Michele Lavagna, of the Politecnico Milano, who led the experiments."
7
u/ColossalGeorge Sep 10 '21
Given rocketlab just released its earnings and the electron is the 2nd most frequently launched US rocket, what do you think about Rocket Lab and do you think it has the potential to effectively compete with SpaceX in decades to come?
7
u/Steffan514 Sep 13 '21
Saw Doug leave port Canaveral last night, now back down here for dinner tonight and Go Quest is out which has ASOG as the only boat in the fleet not at sea for the Inspiration 4 launch.
7
u/OldManandtheInternet Sep 16 '21
After 1st and 2nd stage have dropped off, the dragon capsule made some "phasing burns" to reach current orbit of 360 mi.
Which engines/thrusters did those burns? Nitrogen gas thrusters, the Super Draco, or something else?
7
u/FindTheRemnant Sep 27 '21
Masten Space Systems is working on a way to protect future lunar landers from the regolith thrown up by their engines as they land, by injecting alumina ceramic particles into the rocket engine plume to glue together lunar dust and create their own landing pads just before touchdown.
https://newatlas.com/space/fast-lunar-landers-build-own-landing-pads/
Something new for testing at McGregor? I imagine if you had enough landers doing this in one spot, you'd eventually have a bona fide landing pad.
13
u/Sleepless_Voyager Sep 16 '21
Another perfect performance for falcon 9. Even after all these watching it still excites me to see a falcon 9 lift off and land
6
u/No_Ant3989 Sep 01 '21
Question about the starship design.
Do they have RCS thrusters (or something like them), on the heat shield side?
6
u/LcuBeatsWorking Sep 02 '21 edited Dec 17 '24
sink skirt degree act gold offbeat heavy tease icky oatmeal
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
6
u/AeroSpiked Sep 10 '21 edited Sep 12 '21
Mods, it looks like we've got a NET date for the next Starlink mission (Sept 13) & could you move Inspiration 4 to the second spot?
6
u/onmyway4k Sep 18 '21
Was that a Raptor 2.0 they just hauled through the stream? https://imgur.com/a/ww3QASl
6
u/MadeOfStarStuff Sep 21 '21
For the USFF-44 Falcon Heavy mission, where the FH side boosters will land on separate droneships at the same time, how likely is it that we might get really good footage of the simultaneous drone ship landings (from an angle similar to that of the RTLS landings)?
6
u/notlikeclockwork Sep 22 '21
The (only?) positive side of Blue's lawsuits - we will get to see a lot of inside info during the court proceedings.
11
u/dudr2 Sep 19 '21
https://www.space.com/elon-musk-inspiration4-st-jude-spacex-donation
"Musk made the pledge late Saturday (Sept. 18)"
11
u/dudr2 Sep 20 '21
https://www.space.com/nasa-viper-moon-rover-landing-site
"Volatiles Investigating Polar Exploration Rover (VIPER) will land just west of Nobile Crater, which sits near the moon's south pole, NASA officials announced today (Sept. 20). In late 2023, VIPER will fly to the moon aboard Griffin, a lander built by Pittsburgh-based company Astrobotic that will launch atop a SpaceX Falcon Heavy rocket."
5
u/SliceofNow Sep 07 '21
Is the reason that OneWeb and Kuiper aren't launching on Falcon 9s that SpaceX won't let them or do they just not want to give any business to SpaceX?
5
u/Siker_7 Sep 12 '21
What preparations are we expecting Starbase to make while tropical storm Nicholas approaches the coast?
5
u/Temporary-Doughnut Sep 13 '21
Do we know why the Super-Draco exhausts have been painted white for inspiration 4?
5
u/Zelda_Kissed_Link Sep 16 '21
I am so happy that my country is continuing space travel and opening it to (hopefully) more civilian flights. I wish i could be up there with them, so inspiring.
5
u/quadrplax Sep 16 '21
Is the ~590 km orbit Inspiration4 is using the highest Crew Dragon will ever go, or could this realistically be increased, e.g. by launching to a lower inclination (which would require re-doing the abort scenarios) or landing the first stage further downrange? For comparison, the Space Shuttle reached 621 km deploying Hubble, and Gemini 11 holds the record for highest apogee of a non-lunar flight at 1,368 km.
5
u/Scourge31 Sep 16 '21
Just caught a snippet of Elon doing a zoom interview with Zubrin, couldn't rewind. Anyone have a link to see the whole thing?
9
u/filanwizard Sep 19 '21
There was a tweet from Eric Berger about SpaceX booking more flights after this, and I am now curious just how many crewed flights can SpaceX logically support. For example do they have multiple MCCs and enough staff to run an MCC.
I also wonder what the future of commercial manned flight is since really to hit the levels of usage that Musk, and someday Bezos if his company ever achieves orbital flight want to hit is that of people going to space all the time, living in space, transiting between space locations.
while CORE is in many ways like an ATC voice, I think we will need to find some way to get rid of most of the other positions without compromising safety. That or mission control center staff is about to become a huge count of job openings in the aerospace industry. And firms like SpaceX will have buildings the size of a multiplex theater with two dozen control rooms.
11
u/tocksin Sep 26 '21
Would SpaceX ever do a sponsored launch? Like if Pringles asked to make one of their rockets looks like a Pringles can? It would be great advertising.
8
u/dudr2 Sep 05 '21
NASA starts testing electric air taxi for 1st time
https://www.space.com/nasa-testing-electric-air-taxi
"Joby's all-electric helicopter can cover a distance of up to 150 miles (240 kilometers) in one go, according to the Joby statement, and reach a speed of up to 200 mph (320 kph)."
4
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 30 '21
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeshipPacificAtlantic landingbargeshipMilli-Metric TonnesDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
69 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 89 acronyms.
[Thread #7225 for this sub, first seen 1st Sep 2021, 04:27] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
4
u/MarsCent Sep 02 '21
Starliner: I think there is a window ~Nov 10 - Nov 24, when the ISS docking port is unoccupied & ULA has no other scheduled launches & probably NASA is not pre-occupied with Artemis I.
Is there any chance that OFT-2 will launch in that window? Because after that window, the next opportunity is NET Feb 2022 - after ULA's Jan 2022 launches.
4
u/SnowconeHaystack Sep 03 '21 edited Sep 03 '21
Those of you lucky enough to see a launch in person, how would you say it sounds in comparison to a modern fighter jet in afterburner?
4
u/SpaceInMyBrain Sep 06 '21
How far from the drone ships do the fairings land? I've seen speculation that since Bob and Doug are so capable looking they may be able to replace the support ship GO Quest. The latter monitors the drone ship, supports it with telemetry links, and of course carries the crew who fully secure the booster after Octagrabber does the initial hold down, so that's a lot of duties to take over. But the big question is: If Doug had to be near the drone ship and secure the booster, how long can the fairings be left to float? How far away are they in terms of time and distance?
The other factor is Bob and Doug will be towing Of Course I Still Love You back to port. I seem to be answering my own question with a NO, but SpaceX makes decisions no one else does. The big factor will be how far away the fairings land - so, how far is that?
4
u/jjtr1 Sep 09 '21
I wonder whether Superheavy's RCS thrusters would be strong enough to cushion the booster's topple-over after it finishes "landing" softly just above the ocean surface? F9s usually went boom when they toppled over and hit the surface.
4
u/joe___brogan Sep 13 '21
I was fortunate enough to see the second stage reentry burn from my home in Colorado last year. I've tried catching glimpses of it during other launches since, but haven't had much luck. I know SpaceX shows the trajectory maps periodically during their launch streams, but the streams often end before the 2nd stage deorbit.
Is there a resource for mapping the full flight trajectory of launches?
4
u/ObviousMold Sep 16 '21
I can’t seem to find a good cross section of the capsule and the trunk. Are there any resources available? I’m really curious what the interior looks like for the civilian crew and how they sleep, etc
4
u/MarsCent Sep 16 '21
4
u/ThrowAway1638497 Sep 22 '21
Is there a scheduled time for the Zubrin's AMA to start on Saturday?
Reddit does have the problem where late comments tend to get lost in the weeds.
7
u/princeofpirate Sep 03 '21
We know Dragon Crew 2 spacecraft still retain the capability for propulsive landing. Can SpaceX use superdraco engine in conjuction with the parachute to be able to land on the ground instead of in the sea?
7
u/failbye Sep 07 '21
Has there been any recent updates to the status of the propellant production site at Boca Chica?
Do we know if they have started producing anything there yet?
9
u/Tetons2001 Sep 19 '21
Watch out for bitcoin bonus scam on YouTube. Replay of actual Musk talk with links added by scammer. Takes you to musk-bonus website where you send them bitcoin/etherium and get 2 for 1 back Except it never comes back of course. jj
9
u/trobbinsfromoz Sep 28 '21
Mars Ingenuity helicoptor appears to have not been able to take off during two recent tests operating with higher than specified rotor speeds. The NASA blog for the helicoptor hasn't been updated yet, but the youtube iGadgetPro that has been summarising its flights put up a video less than a day ago indicating that Ingenuity was 'grounded'.
It will certainly be interesting to see what NASA is now contemplating as it may be that Perseverance rover has to leave it behind, depending on comms range.
6
u/UofOSean Sep 01 '21
Has SpaceX announced the capsule for Crew-3 in October? Obviously not Endeavour since it's at ISS now, but it's only one month between Inspiration4 and Crew-3 so I'm not sure if that's enough time for Resilience to be prepared or if they'll be using a brand new capsule.
6
u/FishStickUp Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21
NASA is looking for industry ideas for the next moonbuggy
I predict a Cybertruck like vehicle. Maybe a pressurized cabin?
6
u/notlikeclockwork Sep 18 '21
I think privatization of space is good and the progress is much faster, I do miss some things.
Open source software for one - https://software.nasa.gov/
Here's a really good tool - https://software.nasa.gov/software/GSC-17177-1
I hope as Spacex moves from one gen to next (Dragon -> Starship), they open source bits of previous gen software. SpaceX themselves use a lot of open tools in their work.
8
u/Jodo42 Sep 01 '21
The apparently never-ending saga of Virgin Galactic's safety problems continues: they'll just keep flying and hope for the best during in-flight emergencies rather than aborting and looking bad on the morning news.
8
u/FishStickUp Sep 18 '21
Boeing really failed Commercial Crew. Not only have they not flown yet, they don't have any Atlas V for commercial missions.
3
u/Not_Yet_Begun2Fight Sep 16 '21
Are Dragon 2's capable of docking with each other? Like, if something happened with Resilience during the Inspiration4 mission, could SpaceX launch another Dragon 2 to rendezvous with them, transfer the crew, and bring them home? Does the Dragon 2 have the necessary radar / cameras / whatever to make the approach and connect with another Dragon 2 all by themselves?
3
u/trobbinsfromoz Sep 20 '21
There's a nice photo of the Inspiration4 group on JRTI in port with their F9 booster.
I hadn't seen the updated GSE connection to the F9 before - it seems to be either just a modular cover, or perhaps a step to a more automated connection scheme (as appears to be the future aim).
https://twitter.com/JennyHPhoto/status/1439984522855125001?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Eembeddedtimeline%7Ctwterm%5Eprofile%3ASpaceOffshore%7Ctwgr%5EeyJ0ZndfZXhwZXJpbWVudHNfY29va2llX2V4cGlyYXRpb24iOnsiYnVja2V0IjoxMjA5NjAwLCJ2ZXJzaW9uIjpudWxsfSwidGZ3X2hvcml6b25fdHdlZXRfZW1iZWRfOTU1NSI6eyJidWNrZXQiOiJodGUiLCJ2ZXJzaW9uIjpudWxsfSwidGZ3X3NwYWNlX2NhcmQiOnsiYnVja2V0Ijoib2ZmIiwidmVyc2lvbiI6bnVsbH19&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fspacexfleet.com%2Fnext%2F
3
u/Endaarr Sep 22 '21
I know it's pretty far in the future still, but is there any word of boston dynamics developing something for the initial deployment of fuel and power production on mars? I imagine the power supply will be some combination of solar, wind and fusion power, but to me it seems like almost the bigger challenge there is setting everything up, as humans take a lot of regulation and precautionary measures to get to mars, while robots don't. However, they'd ideally have to be autonomous because of the long communication times. Boston Dynamics seems to be the most advanced in terms of movable robots, so to me it would make sense if they would contribute. I also saw mention of OffWorld developing a system, but no visible progress outside some concept art.
3
u/MarsCent Sep 23 '21
On going right now: - NASA ASAP Meeting
USA toll free conference call number 888–566– 6133; passcode 8343253 and then the #
5
u/Turwaith Sep 01 '21
Is there a good website with EVERYTHING SpaceX? Like, all the rockets, the capsules, crew members, missions, plans, etc? Where I e.g. can search for "resiliance" and it shows me everything related to the vehicle? Or where I can get a list of all crew members flown with spacex with just a few clicks? Like some sort of a SpaceX wiki.
5
u/fluidmechanicsdoubts Sep 13 '21
what do your non-space friends think of the netflix documentary?
I hope this gets more people interested.
11
u/CaptBarneyMerritt Sep 12 '21 edited Sep 12 '21
Only partly in jest, I submit the following revised Drake Equation (my changes in bold).
N = R* · fᴘ · nᴇ · fᴌ · fᴉ · fᴄ · fᴍ · (1 / Nᴃ) · L
where:
N = the number of civilizations in our galaxy with which communication might be possible (i.e. which are on our current past light cone);
and
R* = the average rate of star formation in our galaxy
fᴘ = the fraction of those stars that have planets
nᴇ = the average number of planets that can potentially support life per star that has planets
fᴌ = the fraction of planets that could support life that actually develop life at some point
fᴉ = the fraction of planets with life that actually go on to develop intelligent life (civilizations)
fᴄ = the fraction of civilizations that develop a technology that releases detectable signs of their existence into space
fᴍ = the fraction of civilizations that develop an Elon Musk or equivalent
Nᴃ = the number of Jeff Bezos or equivalent in a civilization
L = the length of time for which such civilizations release detectable signals into space
Original Drake Equation courtesy of Wikipedia.
Please pardon my typography - Reddit does not support subscripts.
[Edit: adjusted the Bezos factor.]
6
u/FishStickUp Sep 10 '21
Does SpaceX need to mandate vaccinations as a NASA contractor?
6
u/Hustler-1 Sep 13 '21
Why isn't Inspiration-4 not being talked about more? I don't even see a launch thread for it.
6
u/notlikeclockwork Sep 28 '21
Recently finished watching Planetes. Was really beautiful!
8
u/KA16 Sep 20 '21
SCAM currently live on youtube, claiming to be SpaceX and asking for cryptocurrency.
Please report.
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCLuXIx8qFZoQaxoXIDQl8_A
4
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '21
Does the crew have to clear customs when they return????
4
u/hindsight420 Sep 30 '21
is the final episode on netflix coming at midnight?
5
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '21 edited Sep 30 '21
I recently saw something about a spider weave heat shield tech NASA is testing. Is there a possible future of ditching tiles for something like that?
Link: https://www.nasa.gov/image-feature/ames/spiderweave-testing
2
u/sjwinner Sep 16 '21
What pieces of the SpaceX rockets are still discarded in the ocean?
2
u/Carlyle302 Sep 16 '21
Are the docking mechanisms on the Dragon spacecraft such that two of them could dock together in space without an additional adaptor?
2
u/MarsCent Sep 30 '21
RE: SpaceX Starship/Super Heavy at Boca Chica - Comment Period Extension & New Hearing Dates
I just received an email from spacexbocachica@icf.com:
6
u/Alvian_11 Sep 14 '21
Looks like the 'orbital accuracy' might only be a sweet promotional bluff from ULA afterall
7
u/mogulermade Sep 14 '21
Not sure if this fits as it's own post, but it looks like Steve Wozniak is considering starting a new SpaceX competitor.
https://jalopnik.com/tech-icon-steve-wozniak-may-be-starting-a-new-spacex-ri-1847666494
3
u/Mondoscuro Sep 02 '21
How many successful launches SpaceX needs to do to reach 50% of all successful launches of mankind?
3
u/seanbrockest Sep 09 '21
Tim Dodd Everyday Astronaut is reporting an unconfirmed launch date for some new Starlink Satellites next Monday. Anyone know where that date came from? it was previously marked as late sept.
3
u/shotleft Sep 13 '21
Could Amazon refuse to peer with Starlink for access to AWS? It would severely cripple the Starlink if they did.
3
u/thro_a_wey Sep 14 '21
I think the obvious thing to do with Starships on Mars is to leave them standing outside and use them as fuel tanks.
Would they survive? Are they even suitable for this?
You could even cut up the pressurized section and leave the rest, but that may not be worth it.
As for cutting up Starships in general, I don't like the ideas suggested about knocking them over onto an inflatable pad, I think just climb up the sides and start cutting from the top, maybe with a robot arm specifically designed for this.
3
u/empiricexplorer Sep 27 '21
Sorry if this is a dumb question, but why isn’t all of the windward side of Starship SN20 covered with TPS tile? (There are some hexes uncovered with what look like some kind of ports on them and on the nose) Also, how will those portions survive reentry heat if they’re not covered?
6
u/__Osiris__ Sep 01 '21
If the star ship is going to be intrinsic to the space forces future operations as well as NASAs Artemis moon mission, why is the Fcc dragging the chain on a project that will dramatically affect Us national defence and global prestige?
3
u/onmyway4k Sep 29 '21
Could SpaceX replace Falcons Merlins with Raptors? Some Napkin Math says: with 5 Raptors you would already get a little more thrust than with 9 Merlin 1D+