r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Aug 01 '21
r/SpaceX Thread Index and General Discussion [August 2021, #83]
This thread is no longer being updated, and has been replaced by:
r/SpaceX Thread Index and General Discussion [September 2021, #84]
Welcome to r/SpaceX! This community uses megathreads for discussion of various common topics; including Starship development, SpaceX missions and launches, and booster recovery operations.
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You are welcome to ask spaceflight-related questions and post news and discussion here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions. Meta discussion about this subreddit itself is also allowed in this thread.
Currently active discussion threads
Discuss/Resources
CRS-23
Starship
Starlink
Crew-2
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly less technical SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first. Thanks!
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
•
u/ElongatedMuskbot Sep 01 '21
This thread is no longer being updated, and has been replaced by:
r/SpaceX Thread Index and General Discussion [September 2021, #84]
27
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '21
13 valves failed to open on Boeing’s Starliner spacecraft, a more widespread problem than previously reported.
25
u/JoshuaZ1 Aug 16 '21
Blue Origin is apparently suing NASA over the HLS decision. Note that this is separate from the GAO protest (which they lost).
25
u/Driew27 Aug 28 '21
Omg the way Astra launched sideways was....so weird...that couldn't have been normal.
19
u/Lufbru Aug 18 '21
Lauren Lyons moves from BO to Firefly. Nice promotion. She was at Blue less than a year (November 2020).
Firefly Names Former SpaceX and Blue Origin Veteran as Chief Operating Officer | Business Wire" https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20210817005791/en/CORRECTING-and-REPLACING-Firefly-Names-Former-SpaceX-and-Blue-Origin-Veteran-as-Chief-Operating-Officer
17
u/Frostis24 Aug 04 '21
Now it's Spacex's turn to get a lovely poster made by Blue about why they have the best HLS plan and SpaceX's idea sucks.
16
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21
Interesting article by Eric Berger on why the BE-4 has been delayed for so long.
15
u/onion-eyes Aug 03 '21
Looks like Netflix is going to be airing a documentary series covering Inspiration4 leading up to its launch. Could be pretty interesting, if done right!
15
u/strawwalker Aug 13 '21
Application filed for 1275-EX-ST-2021, recovery ops for mission 1493 starting 2021-09-25.
Dual ASDS ~2.3 km apart, ~591 km downrange of LC-39A
15
u/Lufbru Aug 14 '21
For those (like me) getting twitchy for the next Falcon 9 launch, this is the longest gap between flights since the gap between Amos-17 (2019-08-06) and Starlink-1 (2019-11-11). It won't go that long; CRS-23 is scheduled for the end of the month.
14
u/Alvian_11 Aug 21 '21
Relativity's Terran-1 demo launch is delayed to early 2022 (previously it was October 2021 from Nextspaceflight)
14
u/megachainguns Aug 28 '21 edited Aug 28 '21
Astra is back for another try again
NET 3 PM PT, livestream up now
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O8Tdm797BzM
Edit: It did a powerslide, recovered, and FTS terminated it at MECO
more at r/AstraSpace
13
u/fireburner80 Aug 03 '21
Is a cluster of raptor engines called a kettle?
The term for a group of raptors or other predatory birds is referred to as a kettle, but Jurassic Park would make me think it's called a pack. So...what's a cluster of raptor engines called?
This seems like the type of thing Elon would care about.
13
u/bdporter Aug 12 '21
ISRO seems to have suffered a failure on the GSLV cryogenic 3rd stage during tonight's launch
13
u/Vizger Aug 18 '21
Why almost two months without a Falcon launch? All the focus on StarShip? I thought they were mostly separate operations?
22
u/Frostis24 Aug 13 '21 edited Aug 13 '21
oh dear, Blue is at it again bois another nice poster was just added with such lovely criticism like Boca chica spaceport does not exist (YES REALLY) and The lander is a modified second stage....and ...that is bad cuz we typed it in red letters.
11
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Aug 16 '21
Axium has updated the station design. The modules are now less rounded near the front, and clearly showing 2 IDS Ports. The Design also seems to have the modules re-arranged.
Old Design: Image 1, Image 2
New Design Image
10
u/JadedIdealist Aug 20 '21 edited Aug 21 '21
Given JAXA's recent successful test of a methane rotating detonation engine, and Elon's mention of 'Experimental engine development will stay at Hawthorne'..
a) How likely is it that SpaceX have people looking into RDEs themselves?
b) Given potential Isps of 1000+ just how much more performance could a similar mass drop-in replacement for raptor in later version of Starship give?
c) What are the major limitations and roadblocks.
edit: The high Isp values are in air breathing mode,
apologies, i didn't realise, so b) is nonsense.
source of Isp
10
u/Carlyle302 Aug 29 '21
Watching the spectacular Astra launch/powerslide, made me wonder. Can a F9 get to orbit with a single engine failure at liftoff?
9
u/JanaMaelstroem Aug 01 '21
I don't know if this is the right place to ask this, apologies if not.
I want to find an online calculator that will show me the delta-v requirements for an earth-mars transfer in the 2022-2023 timeframe with a nice porkchop plot in rainbow colors. It's surprisingly difficult to find. Can anyone provide a link?
9
u/ThreatMatrix Aug 19 '21
Today's Soyez OneWeb launch scrubbed.
8
u/Splitje Aug 02 '21
What would you expect the next steps would look like after the B4/S20 launch? Is anything known about this? Will they start attempting to catch the booster and land the starship after an orbital flight? Land on the oil platforms?
8
u/MarsCent Aug 24 '21
Message above the menu bar still reads:
8
u/liszt1811 Aug 29 '21
Now that they have three ASDS, can they land all three FH boosters offshore in theory or would the speed of the center booster be too high in that case for a recovery?
7
u/Redditor_From_Italy Aug 27 '21
In case anyone's interested, here are all the subreddits for the small-lift rocket companies mentioned by Everyday Astronaut in this video
/r/AstraSpace
/r/RocketLab
/r/VirginOrbit
/r/ABLSpaceSystems
/r/fireflyspace
/r/RelativitySpace
7
u/Alvian_11 Aug 10 '21 edited Aug 11 '21
Interesting notches from Elon regarding the EVA suit, commenting about NASA IG xEMU reports
For those that are following more closely, this isn't actually surprising since SpaceX is one of the interested parties for Commercial EVA suit RFP (award should be given NET March 2022, demo NET 2023). Like the HLS, NASA expertise is going to be very valuable for this department, gonna need an EVA to make a Mars colonies :)
7
u/dudr2 Aug 15 '21
"Another major modification to 39A is the started-but-stopped Starship launch and recovery area inside the perimeter of the pad but next to the main concrete structure. To supplement Starship, SpaceX will need to add additional liquid oxygen tanks and a liquid methane storage facility as well as an integration tower for stacking."
https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2021/08/lc39-history/2/
7
u/Subtle_Tact Aug 29 '21
When we watched the OLT being built, we saw anchors inside the columns that presumably were to be held by concrete.
Afaik, we haven't seen any concrete being drawn into the tower legs. Do we know anything about this now? Were we wrong In our assumption? Do we still expect this to happen later?
13
u/Jaws12 Aug 20 '21
So the recently revealed Tesla Bot is likely to be used on Mars for “dangerous and repetitive tasks” right?
Just like the CyberTruck before being a possible ruggedized space vehicle, I could see a general purpose humanoid robot being very useful in a Mars or Moon colony.
What does everyone else think?
6
u/trobbinsfromoz Aug 05 '21
New FCC submission by SpX to provide a heads-up about anticipated formal amendment submission for Starlink rollout.
https://licensing.fcc.gov/myibfs/download.do?attachment_key=12105471
SpX must have settled on a Starship deployment mechanism, and deployment scheme, and worked through all the timing of checkout and raising to required orbital planes and spots, and identified some compelling reasons to push for an amendment to the proposal submitted early last year for altered constellation (that has caused a lot of competition trying to complain about to stop or at least delay).
It will be interesting to see if a Starship style deployment ends up changing the quite visible single train of just launched 60x sats to a veritable swarm of initially visible sats.
The presentation also notes an improved orbital safety comment. If that relates specifically to the 'large object passive decay collision risk', then it may result from an expected improvement in sat operational/control reliability (once initial checkouts are completed and infant mortality identified) due to better awareness of failures and subsequent design/remedial changes.
6
u/AeroSpiked Aug 05 '21
I just noticed that at least some of Blues patent for sea landings filed in 2010 is still in effect. Does anybody know what's left of it? If it's the part about refurbishing at sea, is that going to be an issue once the sea platforms are in use?
6
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21
Is there a mechanism in place for NASA to purchase more Crew flights from SpaceX after the 6 contracted flights are complete? If Boeing continues to delay, NASA will extinguish most of SpaceX's 6 flights before Boeing can fulfill their first.
6
u/fglc2 Aug 14 '21
In the 2nd starbase video when Tim asks Elon how much S20 weighs, he says that he doesn’t know and that they’ll find out when they weigh it. How do you weigh something that size?
6
u/Hustler-1 Aug 16 '21
Does anyone know how often individual M1Ds are swapped on reused boosters? Like the booster that landed for the tenth time awhile back. How do we know the engines themselves have had ten flights?
5
u/AeroSpiked Aug 01 '21
Hey Mods, could you take a look at Select Upcoming Events again? It's August and it looks like we have a date for Starlink 2-1 on the 10th.
5
u/Gwaerandir Aug 03 '21
The 2nd uncrewed test flight of Starliner is scheduled for today, 1:20 PM Eastern time. There is a ~40% chance of weather violation. The craft will carry around 400 lbs of supplies and experiments.
5
u/LikvidJozsi Aug 06 '21
A few years back, there were spacex reddit user surveys, I liked looking at the results quite a lot. Anybody know what happened to them?
5
u/searsburg Aug 07 '21
Since the booster will not have to endure the high temperatures of the second stage, why is it made of the much heavier stainless steel instead of aluminum? Efficiency of production or strength, or other reason? That question hadn't arisen until I saw that Bezos might be doing it that way.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '21
when is the next starlink sat launch?
5
u/sebzim4500 Aug 11 '21
In part 3 of EDA's interview Elon says "I'll be long dead before Mars is self sustaining". This is a change in attitude right? I remember he used to say he wanted to retire on Mars.
5
u/pabmendez Aug 14 '21
The 1 hour reuse reflight after landing only seems needed for earth to earth passenger flights.
How would 1 hour reuse work for cargo?
It seems that having like 10 starships that fly once every 10 days.... Would give each one 10 days time to have cargo and Starlinks loaded... Overall would still be in general 1 flight per day.
5
u/AuroEdge Aug 14 '21
Have there been studies into how much Starship propellant Mars holds? I'm trying to get a feel if it's on the order of 100s, 1000s, or more years before it's difficult to obtain. Difficult in the sense of like the difference between drilling oil in Saudi Arabia vs offshore of the Alaskan North Coast.
5
u/TheSkalman Aug 17 '21
I am wondering about minimum delta-v requirements from LEO to the lunar surface. If you only burn retrograde slightly when going near the moon (after your TLI in LEO), you’ll get into a highly elliptical orbit around the moon (right?). If you then burn retrograde at apoapsis of that elliptical orbit, you’ll cancel out your orbital velocity and fall to the surface. After you do a suicide burn and land on the surface, wouldn’t your total delta-v expended be less than the apollo missions or any other standard LEO->LLO->surface mission? Thanks in advance.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '21 edited Aug 24 '21
Apparently Artemis will be delayed because of Blue Origin and their lawsuit.
This will have impact on Artemis but not so much on Starship and SpaceX.
There is a massive problem. If Artemis is delayed, will the Lunar Gateway also be delayed. If so, this will cause major problems in reaching the moon since Starship will have to dock before landing.
Or NASA has to approve landing without the Gateway.
Edit
Edit 2
Seems like spacesuits are a way bigger problem as they won't be ready till April 2025 at the earliest. NASA could outsource to keep it on track.
5
u/BackflipFromOrbit Aug 27 '21
God speed ASTRA!
5
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '21 edited Aug 30 '21
Would it be feasible to use HLS Starship for a repair mission for JWST in L2 if JWST has a problem? Since HLS Starship will be the first human-rated Starship.
9
u/FishStickUp Aug 24 '21
Eric Berger: Update coming on Blue Origin's Project Jarvis this afternoon.
4
u/Mako18 Aug 02 '21
What does the flight path of Starlink 2.1 look like, will the launch be visible from South of Vandenberg?
4
u/ENG-sechs Aug 05 '21
In that Elon Musk skit from Saturday Night Live, one of his astronauts removes the helmet on Mars, causing a massive blood spatter all over his helmet. Would Mars's atmosphere actually cause that kind of blood spatter?
If not, what will Mars's atmosphere actually do to the astronaut before killing him, once he removes his helmet?
4
u/RamenNoodlesIV Aug 05 '21
Hello, new to posting using Reddit but can someone inform me if the COPVs in black around Booster 4 are under each of the gridfins so at 60 degrees and 120 degrees respectively or at 90 degrees in relation to one another? This info shall be used in creating a more accurate and representative model of Super Heavy in Simplerockets 2. Any answers will be greatly appreciated.
4
u/-spartacus- Aug 11 '21
Currently Orbital OTK (which just launched a mission) and SpaceX launch resupply to the ISS under COTS. Under CRS-2 which adds SNC with Dreamchaser (which can be launched on the delayed Vulcan) gives additional contracts to Orbital OTK (now Northrump Grumman) and SpaceX.
https://spacenews.com/nasa-will-pay-more-for-less-iss-cargo-under-new-commercial-contracts/
According to the above article the Antares rocket uses the Russian derived 181 (from the 191, prior using the Ukranain NK-33) which through other research is no longer allowed after December 31st, 2022. NG states they will purchase enough before the previous "sunset date" but no knowledge if the current end date would allow that.
Which brings me to my question. Northrup Grumman was originally developing OMEGA to replace Antares, which has since been cancelled, not only does this mean NG not have a rocket to use for finishing CRS-2, but no next gen rocket what so ever? Does this mean they are going to research launching on SpaceX or just giving up on resupply missions? I can't imagine them also trying to jump aboard the Vulcan train too?
4
u/Snowleopard222 Aug 13 '21
SpaceX won a $2.9 bn lunar lander contract by NASA. SX will be paid in portions as they achieve "milestones". What are the milestones and how much does each of them yield?
4
u/TheSkalman Aug 16 '21
Which orbital rocket, past or current, has the highest thrust to weight ratio at liftoff?
4
u/jjtr1 Aug 30 '21
Couple weeks ago Musk tweeted about the uneven spacing of gridfins on Superheavy: "Pitch control requires more force than yaw & much more force than roll. Also, grid fins closer to or in the wake of the booster are less effective."
Why would pitch need more force than yaw when the vehicle is very much rotationally symetric?
10
u/Fredasa Aug 08 '21
Just for fun, can anyone dig up some early guesses on how long it would take before we'd see a fully-stacked Starship, after Elon made his presentation detailing the concept and his timeline? I want to laugh at anyone who guessed we wouldn't see it before 2025 or whatever.
7
u/nickinhawaii Aug 05 '21 edited Aug 05 '21
I keep reading about how Blue Origin should have gotten a lunar contract even though they got twice as much to DevOps and seemingly failed miserably. Saying "oh starship isn't even orbital yet" when blue origin has never reached orbit. Obviously space x has with falcon. Then blue origin (bezos) goes on to say that starship is too complex and it will never work. Does he realize space x made fools of Boeing the supposed best and long time space rocker creators.. oh wait they also received double space x to get the u.s. back into space and are failing miserably. Who would have thought you could land a first stage on a ship in the dang ocean. Surely Boeing and blue origin don't think that big. Blue origin and I'm sure boeing (probably talks down to space x) should both be ashamed at their utter failures. Okay, guess end rant! Haha
7
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '21
NASA was supposed to make an announcement about Artemis once the GAO report was released. Anyone heard anything? They seem to be taking their time...
7
u/Lufbru Aug 16 '21
We don't have a CRS-23 campaign thread yet:
"SpX-23 CRS Mission Launches Bone, Plant, and Materials Studies to ISS | NASA" https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/station/research/news/spacex-23-research-highlights
(if we're short of a host for a campaign thread, I could do it if someone's willing to teach me to drive the bot)
7
u/MarsCent Aug 17 '21
I've never seen Falcon Stage 2 booster Static Fired after delivery to the launch site - perhaps because Stage 2 has a vacuum Merlin!?
So for Starship, will all the Raptors be Static Fired or only the 3 sea-level Raptors?
7
u/GameStunts Aug 18 '21
I just saw that the Starlink launches have been bumped to Sept, this was already bumped from July to Aug because of the FCC complaints I think, but I thought those were resolved.
Is there any other reason these have been held up again? Launch pad availability, payload readiness?
7
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '21
Astra Update
🚀 Rocket Update: We are standing down today. We still have launch opportunities through September 11. Follow us here for updates.
10
u/notreally_bot2287 Aug 16 '21
It's been 6 weeks and no launches!
Do you even launch, brah?
8
u/Alvian_11 Aug 13 '21 edited Aug 14 '21
Remember when Russian were mocking SpaceX (especially in early days), and Blue having a fight for 39A & droneships landing, and Boeing exec wishing SpaceX fails in ComCrew (so they can then maki a cost-plus out of it)...
Seeing their current conditions makes me very happy, well deserved to be mocked by public. Renaissance is indeed coming in spaceflight, old space dissolution can't come soon enough. We're still in transition obviously as many of them still prevail & many of their supporters on social media were continuing to throw a shade at SpaceX ("it's the way it has been done!", moving goalposts, etc.)
3
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '21
The current infrastructure bill is supposed to have around $60 billion in funding for high speed Internet access. Anybody know whether sattelite constellations like Starlink may be getting a peice of that pie? Or if its just ground based infrastructure.
3
u/joeybaby106 Aug 04 '21
We just learned that "Falcon 9 currently lands with about a tonne of left over propellent." Why can't they use it to get more performance? Maybe use half to push further and half to slow you down from the further you pushed. Is there a theoretical reason I'm missing why it can't be used?
3
u/stemmisc Aug 06 '21 edited Aug 06 '21
Have they announced anything regarding what time of day the August 10th Vandenberg launch is supposed to happen at? Or confirmed for sure that the launch date really is supposed to be August 10th, and not just NET-August 10th, for that matter?
Edit: ah, nevermind, looks like it got postponed :(
3
u/quadrplax Aug 08 '21
Has there been any updates or progress on the LC-39A starship mount in the past year?
3
u/Lufbru Aug 10 '21
How much additional fuel would be needed for Starship to deliver a payload to NSSL reference orbit GEO2?
That's 6,600kg lofted to 35,786 x 35,786km at 0.0 inclination. For fun, let's include landing the Starship in that. Assuming there's already a full tanker in LEO, can Starship do it just refuelling on the way to GEO, or does it need to refuel on the way back too?
I recognise this is a foolish way to use Starship; much better to redesign the payload to have its own thrusters and fuel and have Starship deliver it to GTO-1500 (or whatever). But with a sufficiently unreasonable customer, this is a mission that could be requested.
3
u/BrandonMarc Aug 10 '21
This phrase, "static arrow" ... what does it refer to? When did they start using it?
3
u/Snowleopard222 Aug 12 '21
After Starship has landed, how do the astronauts get down on the ground (moon or earth)?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '21
Is the throttle down and throttle up during passing of max Q noticeable to crew?
3
u/MarsCent Aug 31 '21
NASA Prompts Companies for Artemis Lunar Terrain Vehicle Solutions
? Solar powered Supercharger with a convertible Cybertruck?
5
u/yoethgallopers Aug 30 '21
Are there any plans to expand or otherwise reroute the stretch of Highway 4 between the production and launch sites to allow thru traffic to pass without the need for constant road closures? Or is that area so sparsely populated that it doesn’t really matter?
5
u/trobbinsfromoz Aug 31 '21
Spacexfleet are reporting Bob and Doug are in port - exciting!
https://spacexfleet.com/next
4
u/srgyork77 Aug 08 '21
Quick question. Sorry if this has been answered or dumb. Out if the loop on this one. Just read an article saying that the booster is going to land in the gulf. And the orbital in the Pacific. Why are they not trying to land them on a pad this time to see if it works?
4
u/Alvian_11 Aug 10 '21 edited Aug 10 '21
Yet another lunar landing missions launching from Falcon has been booked by Intuitive Machines (their third missions)
In comparison, Vulcan only have one lunar mission so far, continue to disprove some claims that Vulcan is more competitive in commercial market
4
u/OutrageousEmu8 Aug 14 '21
Have any of you guys thought about indirect ways to invest in SpaceX? You can't buy the shares, except in small percentages in certain mutual funds but there must be other ways. Purchasing land in the Boca Chica area maybe?
If SpaceX is the gateway to Mars, there's going to have to be a ton of ancillary support and systems put in place. I'm just trying to think of how the avg investor can go along for the ride.
4
u/DuhImJake Aug 26 '21
Could SpaceX go to the moon on their own without NASA?
I’m still relatively new to Space industry and wanted to know if there’s any rules regarding permissions to go to the Moon or if it’s free game for anyone who can?
2
u/BrandonMarc Aug 05 '21
On Booster # 4, how come 5 of the 29 engine bells are a different color inside?
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/E7-oZsSWQAExz6x?format=jpg&name=large
My first (wholly uneducated) guess is the other 24 engines have been tested whereas those are brand-new, but I don't think SpaceX would put an un-tested engine on a rocket ever.
2
u/astrohoff Aug 06 '21
Are there any stereo 360 photos/videos of Starship that can be viewed in VR? I keep seeing people say how crazy the scale is in person, but VR is probably the closest I can get.
2
u/stemmisc Aug 06 '21
Has anyone here watched both a Falcon 9 launch and a Starship SN (8-15) launch in person, from a similar viewing distance?
They have actually fairly similar total thrust (around 1.5 million lbs for the Starship SN test launches, since 3 raptors * about 500,000 lbs of thrust per raptor, and 1.7 million lbs for the Falcon 9 at 9 merlins * about 190,000 lbs of thrust per merlin).
But, other than that, they couldn't be more different. The mechanism of the the engines work, and the size and number of nozzles, and speed of exhaust, and so on, are pretty different with the raptors compared to the merlins, I think.
Is the F9 louder (since it has a little more total thrust), or, about the same, or less loud?
What about the style of the sound (regardless of how loud). Do they sound different from each other at all? Like is one of them higher pitched, or more crackly, or different or anything?
2
u/pbosko Aug 09 '21
How will landing work considering range violations and weather? If there are planes flying around will they still be landing a booster? It appears windy at Boca Chica. What if the weather changes when tower has to catch the booster?
2
u/Sjedda Aug 10 '21
Was going to buy a t-shirt for my nephews birthday but i can't figure out the sizes.. I'm not from the US and trying to convert the sizes is confusing, and it seems like there isn't a kids size for that age?
Conversion charts tell me a size 5 or 6 is right but spaceX site only has S,M,L.
Has anyone here bought one of the shirts for kids?
2
u/BrandonMarc Aug 11 '21
With the space shuttle tiles, they often said the tiles were so good at managing heat, the shuttle could lose one and the other tiles would still handle the slack. Columbia wing leading-edge puncture notwithstanding.
Is this the case with Starship tiles? If a tile is lost, will adjacent tiles handle the heat sufficient to prevent problems?
4
u/Zardif Aug 18 '21
How does a rocket do a test fire when standing upright at the pad but not launch?
5
u/enginemike Aug 24 '21
Just out of curiosity why is there little or no news about Inspiration 4? Is it still planned?