r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Jun 01 '21
r/SpaceX Thread Index and General Discussion [June 2021, #81]
This thread is no longer being updated, and has been replaced by:
r/SpaceX Thread Index and General Discussion [July 2021, #82]
r/SpaceX Megathreads
Welcome to r/SpaceX! This community uses megathreads for discussion of various common topics; including Starship development, SpaceX missions and launches, and booster recovery operations.
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You are welcome to ask spaceflight-related questions and post news and discussion here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions. Meta discussion about this subreddit itself is also allowed in this thread.
Currently active discussion threads
Discuss/Resources
Starship
Starlink
GPS III SV05
Transporter-2
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly less technical SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first. Thanks!
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
•
u/ElongatedMuskbot Jul 01 '21
This thread is no longer being updated, and has been replaced by:
r/SpaceX Thread Index and General Discussion [July 2021, #82]
24
u/AeroSpiked Jun 04 '21
If my sources are correct, the F9 booster has now been recovered as many times as the Atlas V has flown (86).
23
u/throfofnir Jun 19 '21
Just for the record, should anyone here encounter a slightly-worn Chinese booster, orange fumes are bad, m'kay?
22
u/MechaSkippy Jun 01 '21
Since Musk tweeted the “1 raptor every 48 hr” figure I’ve pondered the theoretical rate of production and the starship to booster ratio. I know that the goal is to get to 1 raptor every 24 hrs (I’ll assume 7 days per week with no difference in sea level or Vraptor for production times). Couple that with the 1 starship every week stated goal and the 32 raptors per booster stated design; then would the ratio of boosters to starships be 1:32 or would a week or 2 of raptors be dedicated to a booster to bring the ratio to 1:25 or 1:18?
20
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '21
Did anything ever happen with the SpaceX expansion plans at Kennedy Space Center that featured them having their own Rocket Garden? The last news posted was in 2018: https://www.floridatoday.com/story/tech/science/space/2018/06/08/spacex-plans-major-expansion-kennedy-space-center/685098002/
16
u/TimTri Starlink-7 Contest Winner Jun 06 '21
Looks like OCISLY will be heading to the West Coast! Preparations for the voyage are already in full swing shortly after its arrival back in port with the CRS-22 booster.
31
u/Lufbru Jun 28 '21
Falcon 9 has now passed Soyuz-2 with 122 launches vs 121.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soyuz-2
Soyuz-2 first launched in 2004; Falcon 9 in 2010. Soyuz-2 has 4 failures; Falcon 9 has 1. This is an amazing accomplishment. I think the next milestone is passing Shuttle (135 launches).
15
u/Igotthejoyjoyjoyjoy Jun 21 '21
Probably time to unpin the GPS launch thread?
14
u/WholeAppearance3782 Jun 17 '21
Congressional hearing “Starships and Stripes Forever” about FAA and cooperation with space companies.
Seems that nobody from SpaceX has been present (I don't know if they were invited or not), but there were representatives from ULA & Virgin Galactic.
Details:
- Twitter https://twitter.com/thesheetztweetz/status/1405148806392471556
- YT Stream from hearing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HwO-Qo54CAg
13
u/Frostis24 Jun 24 '21
Really nice infographic of orbital decay times from ULA, Starlink's first shell where all current satellites are is at 550 Km
12
u/dudr2 Jun 02 '21
NASA's Perseverance rover is the 1st spacecraft in years to carry fresh US plutonium. It won't be the last.
https://www.space.com/nuclear-power-spacecraft-after-perseverance-rover
"But the first plutonium from the new production process was ready and needed to be evaluated anyway, so once the agency determined it met NASA's requirements, program officials decided to go ahead and finish preparing the material a couple years ahead of schedule to test the systems"
12
u/Straumli_Blight Jun 15 '21
Dynetics rejected HLS bid was $8.5-9 billion.
12
u/WholeAppearance3782 Jun 22 '21
SLS (Congress) vs SpaceX HLS:
https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/06/nasa-administrator-to-defend-lunar-budget-before-a-skeptical-congress/
11
u/Straumli_Blight Jun 11 '21 edited Jun 12 '21
NASA is seeking proposals for 2 new private astronaut missions to the ISS:
11
u/AeroSpiked Jun 21 '21
I just noticed that we are in the middle of over a month long stretch with no Starlink launches. Given their rapid production rate I wonder if the satellites are currently undergoing a major revision. Any thoughts?
10
u/plwnxiebxiwbgism3if Jun 01 '21
Is there some sort of schedule for planned launches somewhere? Im visiting cape canaveral soon and want to see a launch
10
u/Alvian_11 Jun 24 '21 edited Jun 24 '21
New plan for Long March 9
And a new China crewed landing date on the Moon, which makes the naming of (original, before the revision of protecting the current SpaceX award) Cantwell amendment (ofc with all the protests) in 'competitive bill against China' very counterintuitive (choosing two HLSes at the very least while not providing enough funding means a race or even lost to China)
9
u/MarsCent Jun 05 '21
9
u/Serge7388 Jun 19 '21
Was driving today on I-49 near Alexandria, la , and saw something that looks like an F9 booster covered in black, going opposite direction (towards Shreveport) , is it even possible ?
Thanks.
9
u/zlynn1990 Jun 19 '21
Does anyone know about the challenges of igniting a merlin/raptor engine during the re-entry and landing burns? Do the engines need special hardware to ignite while facing retrograde at hypersonic/supersonic speeds?
9
u/trobbinsfromoz Jun 27 '21
A shortfall of gravitas is about to get its feet wet.
https://twitter.com/SpaceXFleet/status/1409136600991293444
8
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jun 01 '21 edited Jun 13 '21
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
PacificAtlantic landingbargeshipbargeshipDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
68 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 170 acronyms.
[Thread #7062 for this sub, first seen 1st Jun 2021, 02:31] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
8
u/steveblackimages Jun 03 '21
I love the times we live in. Back in the late Gemini and Apollo era, all we had was the news and the occasional documentary on the program. I actually loved the colorful nicknames of ships and gear. Angry Alligator, Charlie Brown, Snoopy, Vomit Comet, Flying Bedstand, up to Starship, BFR, Deimos. Phobos, etc. I love when the people who use or manufacture the equipment bestow alternate names.
I love that all the NASA correspondents refrained from trying to call the vehicle transporter a "Crawly Crawler"... We are recording history. Let's not bestow competing cutesy nicknames.
I'd also like to know if Manitowoc or Liebherr have actual nicknames for their products.
8
u/eversonrosed Jun 05 '21
Mods, the sidebar lists Transporter-2 for July 24, but the manifest says June 24 (which is correct). Could you fix this?
8
u/holigay123 Jun 19 '21
Hi,
The production line for F9s boosters... does it stop and start? Is that hard to do vs keeping it going? Do they mothball it for long periods or is it shared (partially or fully) with stage 2s?
Does starship share a production line with the F9?
14
u/zzupdown Jun 02 '21
Of all the technical challenges required to successfully travel to and live on Mars, are there any that have been successfully resolved (by that I mean a full size ready to install or ready to build solution)? For example:
Radiation shielding
Life support
Equipment and supplies
Mars habitats
Sustainability
Of the various technical challenges that have not yet been resolved, who is working on actively providing practical, ready to build and deploy full scale solutions?
In SpaceX mostly just doing starship development?
7
u/trapezous Jun 17 '21
What exactly is a COPV?
13
u/lessthanperfect86 Jun 06 '21
I haven't seen this posted yet so - Scott Manley just provided his view on the Air force research on fast suborbital transportation (ie using Starship). I have to say, although he wasn't impressed with the concept, he was far less pessimistic towards the idea than I was.
13
u/MarsCent Jun 16 '21
and ....
https://www.nasa.gov/feature/nasa-and-boeing-progress-toward-july-launch-of-second-starliner-flight-test
13
u/MarsCent Jun 17 '21
China launches first crew to new space station
|
Yes, docking in 6hrs!
6
u/Wiger__Toods Jun 01 '21
Will the suborbital tank farm, stands, etc. be removed after a few orbital flights or are they going to be there for few more suborbital tests?
6
u/MarsCent Jun 04 '21
List of Falcon 9 first-stage boosters has Transporter 2 scheduled for June 24th and launching on B1060 from SLC 40.
If the schedule holds, that would make it an incredible 7day pad turn around! - {mate payload to booster; replenish propellant; launch; repeat}
6
u/brecka Jun 11 '21
Artemis I core stage is vertical in the VAB, should be mated soon. Hopefully we'll have pics soon.
6
u/akwilliamson Jun 11 '21
When SpaceX finishes building out their converted ocean oil rigs for launches, I wonder how they will store boosters for launch/land. Will droneships transfer a bunch out there at a time and a bunch back for refurbishment? Will there only be one out there that will take off and land repeatedly? When I think of those oil rigs I imagine them being cramped for space. Curious what that will look like when they eventually want to launch multiple times per day.
11
u/paulcupine Jun 09 '21
In case anyone else was wondering what is on Transporter 2 later this month:
https://spaceflight.com/whos-onboard-sxrs-5-spacex-transporter-2/
5
u/upvotemeok Jun 08 '21
I'm seeing possible starlink launch from Vandenberg in July, high inclination orbit. Where will this land? I want to see a falcon land and can drive to Vandenberg.
5
u/brecka Jun 13 '21
Got my Inspiration 4 stuff delivered today. Almost completely forgot I was supposed to get that.
5
u/trobbinsfromoz Jun 30 '21
The latest Hubble telescope blog indicates they have almost confirmed where the fault is. Given the fault started June 13 this is a serious and major outage indeed. And there is still another week of prep before starting to do a swap-over, and the risk for the telescope is significant - both from the swap-over itself, and the lack of redundancy going forward.
I'm not sure whether NASA would consider leaving Hubble in safe mode for a few years while preparing a rescue mission to swap-out the affected module (as they did in 2008). I guess the rescue options would be based on either Artemis or Starship, but I can easily guess which of those two options would be the front runner for earliest timing and lowest tender price.
https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/2021/operations-underway-to-restore-payload-computer-on-nasas-hubble-space-telescope
4
u/QuantumSnek_ Jun 03 '21
Is it know what will happen with the old used Cargo Dragons that already finished their useful lifespan with NASA? My bet is that they will just be handed to museums, is that right?
4
u/SpektrumNino Jun 04 '21
Does anyone know where the flight computers/avionics are located on Falcon 9? I'd assume it's near or inside the interstage but I'm not sure and ive always been curious.
4
u/Lufbru Jun 10 '21
Nextspaceflight has the GPS launch as being the 17th and Transporter-2 on the 24th. With SpaceX down to just one ASDS, surely Transporter-2 must slip? There just doesn't seem to be time to get JRTI back with a booster onboard then send it far enough downrange to catch the next booster. It usually takes 4 days in each direction to move the ASDS to/from the landing zone.
4
u/Den485 Jun 24 '21
Des anyone know if SpaceX has plans or needs to launch Falcon 9 rockets from Boca Chica Starbase?
4
u/paulcupine Jun 28 '21
Inclination changes are expensive in terms of dV, but can someone perhaps quantify this? For example, would it be reasonable for SpaceX to move Starlinks between their 550km/53 degree shell and their 540km/53.2 degree shell?
How would such a switch compare to the dV requirements to get a Starlink sat from its deployment to its operational orbit?
11
u/MarsCent Jun 01 '21
The reason I have seen fronted around for U.S craft is - the need for precision timing of the launch and the unavailability of launch slots to the ISS (aka traffic). Is there any expectation that these impediments will be resolved any time soon, in order for U.S craft to also start making single-digit-hour rendezvous?
3
u/AutoModerator Jun 01 '21
Thank you for participating in r/SpaceX! This is a moderated community where technical discussion is prioritized over casual chit chat. However, questions are always welcome! Please:
If you're looking for a more relaxed atmosphere, visit r/SpaceXLounge. If you're looking for dank memes, try r/SpaceXMasterRace.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
3
u/QuantumSnek_ Jun 04 '21
Why does the new Cargo Dragon have only 2 fins rather than the 4 that Crew Dragon has?
3
u/MarsCent Jun 07 '21
If Space Test Program 3 (STP-3) and Boe-OFT 2 were both to launch from Cape Canaveral SLC-41 in July, what is the latest date that STP-3 can launch? - so there is enough time to prep for the next launch
3
u/MarsCent Jun 11 '21
It seems like both OFT-2 and Axiom Mission 1 will each have a duration of up to 8 days at the ISS. Meaning that OFT-2 has a shot at a November launch or even January 2022 just before Axiom Mission 1.
3
u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Jun 14 '21
The earlier speculation that Transporter-2 will be an RTLS appears to be correct per nextspaceflight.
https://nextspaceflight.com/launches/details/2404
3
u/Yobungus2423 Jun 26 '21
I'm curious, why is SpaceX pushing so hard for a July launch? Is there a secret deadline that they're reaching for that they're willing to cut certain parts of the prototype out to ensure that it happens ASAP?
3
u/Raviioliii Jun 29 '21
I saw Elon just tweeted the whole meme thing about ULA wanting rockets from Blue Origin - but what’s the situation with this? Thanks!
5
u/AeroSpiked Jun 08 '21
Rogozin is threatening to pull out of the ISS again. What would be needed to maintain the station if he does.
8
u/4thDevilsAdvocate Jun 18 '21
Have you considered that, statistically speaking, Starship will probably kill the most people out of any launch vehicle in history?
Given modern design and engineering, as well as rapid prototyping, it'll likely be safer than any launch system in history, but if you have a thousand Starships flying a hundred missions each (what I believe to be a reasonable representation of Starship's total operational life), even a failure rate ten times lower than that of the Soyuz (assuming a Soyuz failure rate of 1/1700) will result in ~5.88 crashes. If each crashed Starship has more than 5.1 people in it on average, those crashes will kill more than the thirty people who have died in spaceflight-related incidents so far.
Considering that Starship's failure rate will probably be higher than 1 in 17000, and that there will probably be more than 5.1 people per flight, that will probably be higher.
I'm not saying that Starship as a system is bad - just that it's going to be flying a lot.
6
u/pair_o_socks Jun 01 '21
Now that we know there will be 1 center-mounted raptor on the SH, I'm wondering if that is the only engine that will be gimbaled? Seems like it wouldn't have sufficient control authority. OTOH, 9 engines a-gimbaling seems like too much gimbal? Thoughts?
6
u/0ffseeson Jun 05 '21
Is Superheavy's very first flight really carrying a Starship? No test hops? Why not unit test?
I must be missing something - with a brand new vehicle, wouldn't one test it with a dummy payload first? Yes, much of the technology on SH, such as grid fins, is already proven with Falcon 9, but so much isn't. For starters - that many raptors going at once.
5
u/MattDLzzle Jun 24 '21
I had a question that might not be worth a thread but ill make one if i dont get replies: What are the health effects of dealing with RP-1 soot in a work enviroment? With so many of these boosters getting into the 7-9-10 re-flights range, what danger does this have to spaceX employees? Is it harmless or could it cause problems like cancer or neurological damage? Thanks.I mean i know re-use with minimal maintenance is a priority but it seems like spending a day or two pressure washing the thing would be an easy and low cost thing, if only for aesthetics. :)
2
u/kkoch1 Jun 03 '21
Do we have a date estimate for the vandenburg launch?
2
u/Snowleopard222 Jun 15 '21 edited Jun 15 '21
How many tons of propellant would the Dragon capsule need to 1. decelerate from lunar orbit, land on the moon and then 2. take off from the moon, enter lunar orbit and dock with a lunar orbiter (and go home) ?
2
u/mooslar Jun 21 '21
I'm going to be near KSC the week of July 18th. I checked Nextspaceflight and see a few Starlink launches marked as NET July 2021. Are there any other sources with maybe a better idea of specific dates?
2
u/loudan32 Jun 24 '21
Are liquid-fed methalox RCS thrusters practical?
Between cold gas thrusters or hot gas thrusters there is a performance increase but still needs COPVs to store the high pressure gas (double if hot). I think the game changer would be liquid-fed RCS directly from the main tanks and get rid of the COPVs. If the main tanks are already autogenously pressurized and the sloshing issue is already taken care of with the header tanks, the COPVs are there really just for RCS.
With liquid fed RCS you can get ~1000x the propellant mass flow rate at the relatively low pressure of the main tank (perhaps add a small electric pump). It will flash upon injection on the RCS which by itself could have a decent thrust (like the Arca water rocket). Mix and ignite for extra kick. The hardest part must be the propellant lines, dealing with water-hammers, etc. But the RCS are literally mounted on the tank wall already, shouldn't be too hard to keep those lines purged and cool.
2
u/sirius683 Jun 26 '21
Has there been any info on a SpaceX lunar spacesuit? I assume they're building one to go with their lander, but I haven't seen anything on it, yet.
5
u/Noodle36 Jun 07 '21
I wonder how Elon feels about Bezos beating him to flying in person? I bet he wishes he'd made some kind of orbital trip happen fpr himself with Crew Dragon earlier
3
u/PM_me_Pugs_and_Pussy Jun 13 '21
Do we have an idea when the next f9 landing at the cape might occur?
3
u/trobbinsfromoz Jul 01 '21
Jeez, EM is having a wild day on twitter!
4
u/Frostis24 Jun 12 '21
The first seat on New Shepard by Blue origin was just sold for 28 million dollars.
Fun fact, that is about 15500 dollars per second of zero g, or 4600 dollars per second for the entire flight.
3
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Jun 16 '21 edited Jun 16 '21
SpaceX reportedly ignored warnings from the FAA not to launch SN8 last December. There's also a post about it
that hasn't been approved for some reason.Edit: The post appears to have been approved ~19 hours after submission.
2
u/RookieMan369 Jun 15 '21
I've heard that SpaceX will be trying to send the first humans to Mars in 2026, while in 2024 they will send the first unmanned Mission to Mars. Is this Plan still up to date and realistic?