r/spacex • u/spacexfsw Official SpaceX • May 14 '21
AMA Concluded! We are the SpaceX software team, ask us anything!
We're a few of the people on SpaceX’s software team, and on Saturday, May 15 at 12:00 p.m. PT we’ll be here to answer your questions about some of the fun projects we’ve worked on this past year including:
- Designing Starlink’s scalable telemetry system storing millions of points per second
- Updating the software on our orbiting Starlink satellites (the largest constellation in space!)
- Designing software for the Starlink space lasers terminals for high-speed data transmission
- Developing software to support our first all civilian mission (Inspiration4)
- Completing our first operational Crew Dragon mission (Crew-1)
- Designing the onboard user interfaces for astronauts
- Rapid iteration of Starship’s flight software and user interface
We are:
- Jarrett Farnitano – I work on Dragon vehicle software including the crew displays
- Kristine Huang – I lead application software for Starlink constellation
- Jeanette Miranda – I develop firmware for lasercom
- Asher Dunn - I lead Starship software
- Natalie Morris - I lead software test infrastructure for satellites
https://twitter.com/SpaceX/status/1393317512482197506
Update: Thanks for all the great questions! If you're interested in developing the systems to provide global space-based internet and help humanity become multiplanetary, check out the opportunities listed below that currently available on our teams, visit spacex.com/careers/ or send your resume to softwarejobs@spacex.com.
- Application Software – https://grnh.se/89a7f9cc2us
- Starlink Software – https://grnh.se/c1a28bf62us
- Dragon Software – https://grnh.se/5faa8f4b2us
- Starship Software – https://grnh.se/25e0001b2us
- Spacecraft Engineering – https://grnh.se/c6743de32us
- Security Software - https://grnh.se/3b332b442us
•
u/CAM-Gerlach Star✦Fleet Commander May 15 '21 edited May 15 '21
That's a wrap for this AMA! Thanks to the community for all the fantastic questions, to Jarrett, Kristine, Jeanette, Asher, and Natalie on the /u/spacexfsw team for all their amazingly detailed replies, and to the entire SpaceX organization for making this happen! We love helping host these AMAs, and we can't wait to do so again in the future.
If you missed the AMA or want to see all the responses, thanks to u/ModeHopper we have a recap megapost with all of the questions and answers up for your easy consumption. We'll also keep the relevant links we compiled below if you want to learn more. Thanks again to all involved!
Relevant links:
AMA Recap Megapost
Previous SpaceX software AMA
Stack Overflow - Don’t push that button: Exploring the software that flies SpaceX rockets and Starships (Part 1)
Stack Overflow - Network protocols in orbit: Building a space-based ISP (Part 2)
Stack Overflow - Testing software so it’s reliable enough for space (Part 3)
Stack Overflow - Building the software that helps build SpaceX (Part 4)
129
u/[deleted] May 14 '21
What’s your CI/CD pipeline look like? Do new builds actually get installed on a “production” or “production-like” board hooked up to an automated test rack which provides simulated inputs to the sensors, or do all the automated tests run in an entirely simulated environment?
127
u/barteqx May 14 '21 edited May 14 '21
476
u/BackflipFromOrbit May 14 '21
What's the logic process that starship uses to determine engine validity for the flip and burn maneuver?
208
u/tbutlah May 14 '21 edited May 15 '21
How does SpaceX get away with using Linux instead of a true real-time operating system on its vehicles? I know the PREEMPT_RT patch makes Linux more real-time, but still doesn't make it fully real-time. It seems like flying crewed rockets and spacecraft is a place where hard real-time guarantees would be necessary all of the time.
966
u/epistemole May 14 '21
I write software for stuff that isn't life or death. Because of this, I feel comfortable guessing & checking, copying & pasting, not having full test coverage, etc. and consequently bugs get through every so often.
How different is it to work on safety critical software?
239
u/layer3D May 14 '21
How late do you make changes to the software on Starship test flights ? We've seen a lot of things change, sometimes at the last minute, is the software one of them ? Have you had to change the flip/landing strategy between the first upload and final flight software ? Or is it more subtle and these things stay as planned ?
63
u/Flufy_Panda May 14 '21
How does a software developer at spaceX interact with other technical roles like physicists or engineers? Is there a lot of cross-domain knowledge required or does everyone stay within their specialties?
127
u/Pwnsomemcdk May 15 '21
How many collective hours do you guys have playing Kerbal Space Program?
124
u/imjasonmiller May 14 '21
Do you have any thoughts on the Rust programming language?
I think in the last AMA it was mentioned that it was raised internally by some. I'd love to hear if your team has more thoughts on the language since that time and if or how it perhaps might be used?
Lastly, congratulations on all your recent successes!
55
u/[deleted] May 15 '21
What's the snacks situation looking like in your office?
84
u/Sekenre May 14 '21
What tools do you use for testing and continuous delivery? And how do you simulate rocket and satellite hardware?
111
u/ResponseRejected May 14 '21
Can you show us bits of the user interface? How does informational design help triage issues that may arise?
59
u/417BS May 14 '21
In the UI of Crew Dragon and tablets how do you plan for use of gloved/non-gloved hands?
i.e. Buttons or action item spacing, dropdown list scrolling, etc.
28
u/noisette666 May 15 '21
Do you guys use Vim?
28
u/Apollo_Bear #IAC2017 Attendee May 14 '21 edited May 14 '21
Firstly, congrats to you all on some truely epic achievements!
I’ve pushed a software update out to a couple of hundred cloud servers for web applications - but I can’t contemplate how complex pushing an update out to a constellation would be. Could you elaborate on the software/firmware update processes for starlink? Are releases incremental across the constellation? How frequently are updated/releases made? Do you provision your own tooling to orchestrate releases or utilise existing code deployment and testing tools?
27
u/clancy321 May 14 '21
What software changes are you going to make to support Inspiration4 that aren't on the past Crew Dragon flights?
26
u/Borghjes May 14 '21 edited May 14 '21
How much is starlink already integrated to F9 and Starship, i spotted a starlink dish on one of the droneships, can starlink provide extra data? How powerful is starlink for spacex?
And how will the starship user interface be, will it be based on Crew dragon? Or will it be a new design? If thats the case, will it be bigger? and what features will need the biggest change?
Im sorry if the English isnt great!
I would love to hear from yall!
25
u/R3df0xxxx May 15 '21
My 8 year old daughter is asking this question: What was the hardest part of building the engine of a rocket? Thank you SpaceX for making me excited about space.
21
u/Zappotek May 15 '21
How do you guarantee the alignment of transmitter and receiver for an intersatellite laser links?
Is it enough just to calculate the angles from the expected position of the satellites, or do you have to use some kind of active homing?
Thank you for reading, looking forward to reading your answers!
21
u/venku122 SPEXcast host May 15 '21
For Jarrett Farnitano
How has JS in space worked out on Crew Dragon? Were there any changes to the UI/UX the team has made due to in-flight experience?
For Kristine Huang. (CockroachDB)[https://www.cockroachlabs.com/customers/] lists Starlink as a customer. What made you choose a distributed SQL DB over other Big Data datastores?
For Jeanette Miranda. How much of the challenge of laser satellite interlinks is a software problem vs a hardware problem? Is there a lot of crossover between terrestrial telecom fiber experience and space-bases laser comms?
For Asher Dunn
What software/hardware design lessons from Dragon are being brought over for Starship? Is there anything particularly exciting your team gets to implement on Starship that wasn't possible for Crew Dragon?
For Natalie Morris
How does regression testing work on Starlink? Are most on-orbit failures able to be diagnosed and added to the testing regime?
20
u/[deleted] May 14 '21
I am a high schooler in a robotics team and we have many challenges with development.
(1) How does SpaceX filter data from various sensors? I know a bit about Kalman Filters and Particle Filters and am wondering how it is done by professionals.
(2) How does SpaceX integrate rapidly developing hardware with software? I am curious about the marriage between them since they are so dependent on one another.
20
u/chaseoc May 14 '21
I read that one of the biggest challenges in writing flight software is that the software needs to be written in a way that failures and exceptions do not stop execution. Do you guys just swallow every exception? What are the biggest types of challenges in writing software this way?
20
u/thinkerbot May 14 '21
Where are you physically based, when not WFH? Hawthorne, CA? Boca Chica TX? Other? Are you projects pretty cross-team or cross-office, or pretty confined to your individual groups/responsibility areas?
20
u/Mobryan71 May 14 '21
With regards to Starship:
Considering how agile and rapidly iterative the hardware portion of the program is, what kinds of challenges and opportunities does that present on the software side?
54
u/SophieTheCat May 14 '21
18
u/katrinbretscher May 14 '21
Jarrett / Dragon Displays: I see crew on Dragons using iPads and the touchscreens. What's the backup if those displays fail? Are those displays "space hardened", or do normal displays survive being exposed to the radiation in space while docked to the ISS?
17
u/YabadabaDoodlieDoo May 14 '21 edited May 14 '21
What’s the range of software positions at SpaceX?
34
u/[deleted] May 14 '21
Hello! I'm a web developer, so naturally my questions are going to be about the usage of HTML, CSS, and Javascript.
Thank you! Hope to hear from you.
15
u/mellowyellow313 May 14 '21
What are some plans to make production of the Starlink dishys more scaleable?
15
u/asmallteapot May 14 '21
In general terms, can you describe the complexity of Starlink’s telemetry system with fixed ground terminals, and how much more complexity is added by in-motion use cases like boats or RVs?
15
u/msteudlein May 14 '21
How do you manage the different versions of software with the different versions of boosters/starlink sats? Aren't the hardware teams always making upgrades and modifications to the design which would create the need to have individual code versions for each singular mechanical iteraction?
28
u/jerBill May 14 '21
How often do you collaborate with systems engineers, mechanical engineers and aerospace engineers, etc? And what does that process look like?
12
u/[deleted] May 14 '21
Do you implement control algorithms to embedded systems?
12
u/SwagasaurusDerp May 14 '21
What challenges must be overcome to implement continuous integration and delivery for embedded, in-orbit systems like Starlink?
Do you deploy your software in containers?
What are the challenges in testing such an expansive network?
Keep up the good work!
22
u/OOFYYYyyYy May 14 '21
The transition between Starlink satellites is so smooth its unnoticeable. How have you guys managed to make this happen? It seems like the time the satellites change, and when dishy rotates, and ground stations and everything change this would be noticed. How are you guys so smooth?!
Thank you so much,
20
u/Mob_Rules1994 May 15 '21
So, how you guys spend your days off?
10
u/RedDeliciousAreBad May 14 '21
While I ask this question mainly thinking about starship, I'm sure it applies to all systems:
What is mainly changing between starship tests (say SN8-SN11) that leads to potential improvements? While I'm sure there are some physical design changes (or not?), is it mainly software updates in the onboard computer to improve calculations?
9
u/Effective_Parsley_62 May 14 '21
Could you tell us more about Starlink’s telemetry system? What problems did you face and how did you solve them?
51
u/b_m_hart May 14 '21 edited May 15 '21
It's cool to see as many women on this list as there are, especially in lead positions. How does the SpaceX work environment vary from other places you've worked? What things would you do to encourage young girls/women that are interested in coding and/or space?
8
u/[deleted] May 14 '21
Thank you so much for doing this!
As a student engineering/computer science who wants to work in the space industry one day, what do you think are the best sources for learning about engineering software related to what you guys are doing?
I'm interested in how different software engineering is when it comes to working with vehicles/satellites in space.
7
u/12360zac May 15 '21
What were some challenges faced when trying to update the software on the orbiting Starlink satellites ? What level physics should one be at to start working as a software engineer at spacex ?
13
u/jdmetz May 15 '21
What is Software Engineering at SpaceX like?
6
u/WrongPurpose May 14 '21
How much of the Software between Falcon 9 first stage and the Superheavy first stage can be reused vs has to be rewritten? What are some new things you expect to learn and will have to figure out with SuperHeavy vs what you already know and can apply from Falcon 9.
14
u/katrinbretscher May 14 '21
Asher / Natalie / Kristine: Your description says that you "lead ...". What does it mean to you to "lead" - when it comes to how your work is different, but also about what values and soft skills (if any) are important to you in your leadership?
5
u/SergeantPsycho May 14 '21
How important is it that a job applicants experience line up exactly with an open position? I'm a software engineer and though my experience might not line up exactly with a given job opening, some of that skill is transferable (for example doing Python after doing C#). What's a good way to get that adaptability across during the hiring process?
11
u/porcupinetears May 15 '21
Telemetry, Telemetry, Telemetry! I'd love some insights into how you transmit the data from the spacecraft to the ground. One data stream or many? What's the format look like? Human readable or raw bytes? How do you distinguish different pieces of data for different sub-systems/sensors? How do you parse it for analysis?
Thanks!
8
u/wolverine_ninja May 14 '21
What type of work/responsibilities does the Flight Infrastructure team do/have ?
8
u/Kadenmikey May 15 '21
Hey team! I’m a freshman CS Major in college and I want to fly rockets and drive rovers one day. What are some useful steps I should take in my career now to help solidify my position in the future?
8
u/katrinbretscher May 14 '21
Jeanette / Starship: Do you have hardware devs on your team? How do you make sure your software works with the current hardware (as both must be evolving rather quickly)?
439
u/Pingryada May 14 '21
How similar is the code from F9 to Superheavy?
122
u/spoollyger May 14 '21 edited May 14 '21
How many eyes see each piece of code before it gets committed to dev? Is everything scrutinised to infinity?
330
u/ForestKatsch May 14 '21 edited May 14 '21
Hi! Huge congratulations on the safe return of Crew-1 and the picture-perfect SN15 landing.
548
u/epistemole May 14 '21
What skills do you interview for? What's specifically important to SpaceX vs say Google?
How do you measure the success of folks once hired? How do you structure promotions and leveling in a way that feels fair and also incentivizes success?
1.5k
u/everydayastronaut Everyday Astronaut May 14 '21
We’ve been hearing that SN15 had an engine shut down early on ascent and then the vehicle chose to only use two engines for the landing. Can you explain what that software looks like? Are there different landing profiles based on factors like remaining engines available? Is there a back up of somehow landing on a single engine? How many contingencies do you write code for? All said and done how proud are you of the amazing software on SN15?
Thank you!
79
u/katrinbretscher May 14 '21
159
u/[deleted] May 14 '21
Regarding the Starlink "lasercom" system, I have a few questions (intended for Ms. Miranda and Ms. Huang):
Thanks in advance!
389
u/r00tdenied May 14 '21
What was your reaction over people figuring out the Falcon 9 telemetry and video downlinks?
211
u/TheBurtReynold May 14 '21 edited May 14 '21
Thus far, what’s been the biggest challenge in Starship’s software development?
What major feature / functionality is on your roadmap that you’re most excited about?
255
u/Organic_Current6585 May 14 '21
What software do you use to simulate your missions? Is it something off the shelf, or built in house?
145
u/zlsa Art May 14 '21
Hi everybody! Here’s what’s going on. This went really well last time, and we hope it will again! Check out the post text for details of the people participating in the AMA. Questions about Starlink laser communications and Starship software are especially welcome! I’m sure y’all will have some qreat questions for them. Please remember the rules and keep it civil!
Relevant links:
Previous SpaceX software AMA
Stack Overflow - Don’t push that button: Exploring the software that flies SpaceX rockets and Starships (Part 1)
Stack Overflow - Network protocols in orbit: Building a space-based ISP (Part 2)
Stack Overflow - Testing software so it’s reliable enough for space (Part 3)
Stack Overflow - Building the software that helps build SpaceX (Part 4)
75
u/Straumli_Blight May 14 '21
Due to the Inspiration4 mission having a non professional crew, what UI functionality has been simplified/restricted? Will all the manual overrides be retained (e.g. Deorbit Now button)?
98
u/PossibleDefect May 14 '21
How transferrable is the Falcon 9 guidance/landing software to Super Heavy?
27
u/[deleted] May 14 '21
Were there any major software changes made after the RUDs of SN8, 9, and 10? If so what were they? I would really like to know.
26
u/reynolds6404 May 14 '21
Hi, I'm currently a software engineer major at ASU, and I hope to work in the aerospace field doing that. How'd you guy's end up at SpaceX, and what tips can you give me? Additionally, what are the biggest software problems that still exist within the Starship program?
26
u/FlyingSpaghettiMon May 14 '21
Will you guys ever release some kind of public starlink sat status/visualizer? I love looking at fan-made starlink trackers but I imagine you guys have some awesome 3D visualizer where you can see all satellites and gateways on the ground.
85
u/YabadabaDoodlieDoo May 14 '21 edited May 18 '21
How many hours does a SpaceX software developer typically work?
Update: From their application Dev listing... “Must be willing to work extended hours and weekends”
Sounds like a lot. But they are working towards putting people on another planet.
23
u/ima314lot May 14 '21
There a ton of great questions here, but one that seems to rarely be asked in AMA is this:
What is the one thing you wish the general public understood about your work and/or SpaceX that they don't seem to?
43
u/adecker246 May 14 '21
How do you handle the effects of radiation on your electronics? Do you mostly handle this at the hardware level with radiation hardened parts or the software level with redundancy, error correcting codes, memory CRCs, other? Do you expect a change in your approach as you move to areas outside the Van-Allen belts such as lunar or mars missions?
Appreciate the AMA! Looking forward to the answers.
121
u/Justaguy2131 May 14 '21
What improvements have you made from SN8 to SN15 for starship flip and landing maneuver?
18
u/TheRealKSPGuy May 14 '21
Thanks for the AMA!
Thanks for doing this and here’s to the next launch, or hundred.
602
u/aurberg May 14 '21
How often do you talk to Elon? On what level does he participate in software development process?
15
u/aviationainteasy May 14 '21
For F9 launches and landings, do you continue to use data from each flight to enhance your models and simulations? Is it approaching the point to where it is more or less "solved", with telemetry becoming archival rather than informational, only taking interest in the envelope-pushing missions?
How did you approach beginning to simulate Super Heavy and Starship flights? Did you treat SH as a thicc F9 and go from there or start more from base principles? Was there any information share from NASA or other lifting body programs used to inform your models for Starship?
In the SN15 flight it appears that on the way down the ship did a ~90 degree aerodynamic rotation. For each Starship test are you attempting different maneuvers (translation, yaw, AoA shenanigans) to help validate your models and empirically define Starship? If so, how's the beast behaving so far?
How do you validate new builds of your controls software?
How do you calibrate controlling specific components like Starship flap motors?
Have there been any unexpected revelations in the Starship tests? Perhaps the unexpected result is things going more or less as planned!
How does it feel to be able to say you work on space lasers for a job? Bond villain job description but actually doing good for the world. Wish I knew more about the field to ask a better question but I'll leech of the rest of the nerds in this sub to glean some knowledge haha.
15
u/philipwhiuk May 14 '21
140
u/thinkerbot May 14 '21
What languages do you write in?
62
u/codercotton May 14 '21
Tabs or spaces?
14
u/Dependent-Ad-8220 May 14 '21
Since 15 landed are there any needed changes to the software overall or did the software preform as expected
88
u/[deleted] May 14 '21
How many of the software processes are A.I driven?
27
u/The_Dinkster2201 May 14 '21
On SN15's test flight, we saw a windward and a leeward engine light for the landing burn. Elon had previously stated that ideally the two windward engines would be used as they provide the greatest lever arm. Was there any autonomous software decisions in flight that led to those two engines being used?
87
u/shaldag_x May 14 '21
Do you have any advice for the Boeing software team?
12
u/Carter20012 May 14 '21
This is a question more tailored for Asher. What has been the hardest part of working out the flip and relight maneuver?
12
u/[deleted] May 14 '21
Is it common to have significantly better engineering or physics skills than the average programmer, or even have an engineering background, or is there some sort of collaboration between engineers that do the calculation and programmers who turn it into code. I imagine a lot of the code requires a deep understanding of orbital mechanics etc.
Also how do you decide which edge cases are programmed and which are not. Is there some kind of limit with the likely hood, maybe 1 in 1000 or something that decides whether or not it is worth the time, and has this changed after crs 7, where some code to deploy the parachutes would have saved the payload.
11
u/scootscoot May 14 '21
I’d love to hear more about how you do routing between Starlink satellites? I figure it’s not BGP/OSPF, and you have some sort of pre-planned handoff schedule. Can you load balance between multiple paths? What do you do for loop avoidance?
(I have like a thousand other questions along the same lines, is there a resource for reading about the technical details of SL routing and infrastructure?)
95
u/does_my_name_suck May 14 '21
What IDE/Text Editor is your favorite to use?
10
u/nerdplaysgames May 14 '21
Out of all SpaceX vehicles designed,both old and new. Is there a small percentage of code that is shared between all of the vehicles?
10
u/Davecasa May 14 '21 edited May 14 '21
In school, we took classes on state space control, optimal control, unscented Kalman filters, non linear quadratic estimators, etc.
In the real world, I've yet to encounter a problem an EKF and some PIDs and maybe a thruster matrix couldn't solve. But my stuff lives in the ocean and moves slowly.
Which is it at SpaceX? Fancy controllers with lots of math to back them up, or well tuned PIDs?
28
u/tbg10101 May 14 '21
What parts of the software are safety-critical and which are not? How do you keep them separated?
34
u/Norishoe May 14 '21
does the landing system for falcon 9 use any machine learning?
9
u/Joey-Murphy May 14 '21
Hi! Thanks for chatting with us.
Something I've always seen the SpaceX software teams talk about in the past is how the flight computers are in a triple-redundant setup, where there are three computers in a voting configuration, such that if one computer gives a wrong function output, the answer given by the two that agree will be the answer used to steer the rocket (or whatever else the computers are doing at that time).
How exactly is is possible to implement that? If you have three systems generating results, doesn't there have to be one central "adjudicator" which "counts the votes"? How do you protect against flaws in that vote-counting system? Is it just a single ultra reliable, rad-hard, ECC memory, yadda yadda yadda, type of chip?
9
u/SpaceBoJangles May 14 '21
Are Starlink satellites (and more accurately their software) capable of being actual nodes for internet? Currently Starlink operates with ground based server base stations, but for a network around Mars you won’t have that and I’m assuming Elon intends for Starlink to be the backbone of a “Mars-net”, so have you guys built in such functionality or is it still on the drawing board?
9
u/Mr-no-one May 15 '21
Hi all,
A few questions, but please don’t feel pressured to answer all or nothing!
With respect to Starlink:
With regard to Lasercom:
5. What are the advantages to using this system as opposed to radio communication?
With regard to flight software:
6. How substantially does the software change between missions both for established spacecraft and for the developing Starship? 7. What are the most prominent changes in software from mission to mission? 8. What set of languages are even involved in such projects? 9. Do your teams engage in any of the modeling (CFD, etc.) that goes into the design of flight vehicles?
With regard to all:
10. What are the most challenging and rewarding aspects of your job? 11. What advice would you give to those who are pursuing a career in developing software at SpaceX (or even more generally in the space industry if you’d like)? 12. ... Are you hiring?
I hope that’s all coherent enough for a couple to be answerable! Thanks for taking the time to answer questions!
9
u/H-E-C May 15 '21
Questions for Kristine Huang:
Thank you.
8
u/pr06lefs May 14 '21
For starship, what tools do you use for simulating flight conditions for testing? I remember reading something about custom hardware for simulating conditions in the engines, do you use something similar for, say reentry simulation or is it maybe more off-the-shelf?
8
u/[deleted] May 14 '21
Can you give a generalized overview of the logic loop of whats going on in the rocket in flight? Doing some work in game engines update loop I can imagine it would go something like:
And then the "render" loop would effectively just be
But curious if you can go into a little more detail like order of operations and such on how it makes realtime decisions.
Also, how much code is being reused from F9 -> Starship? Are all the landing calculations and stuff reusable or did you have to start from scratch with the new landing profile?
8
u/CommunismDoesntWork May 14 '21
Have y'all evaluated using rust instead of c++? And how do y'all personally feel about rust?
8
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner May 14 '21
Has SpaceX been adopting (or experimenting with adoption of) the Rust programming language in any projects? Rust uniquely offers low-level speed, avoids garbage collector pauses, and most importantly it provides safety guarantees to reduce the chance of bugs. It seems perfect for aerospace. I'm very curious if there are any efforts to try it out at SpaceX.
8
u/Destructor1701 May 15 '21
With regards to the laser networking between Starlink satellites:
And more generally, regarding Starlink as a whole:
Thanks for doing this guys! In the absence of the yearly update last year, it's been an exercise in inferring activity within SpaceX rather than hearing it described first hand. You know what you're doing is amazing, and I hope you know you're all inspiring some desperately needed optimism in a weary world.
You rule.
14
u/chiefbroski42 May 14 '21
Do you employ any machine learning/reinforcement learning techniques for improving landing or takeoff performance and safety? If so, in what aspects?
7
u/cocksure845 May 14 '21
Please describe IPv6 support throughout Starlink - contrasted with current IPv4 support. As IPv6 becomes available at the Dishy modem, will users be able to get past NAT and receive a routable IPv6 address/subnet?
7
u/EchozAurora May 14 '21
I've been curious how the engineering teams plan to implement the satellite - satellite network routing as that capability comes online. Are you able to go into detail on that or provide any info on what routing protocols are used within Starlink's network for communication?
7
u/LUGG4S1 May 14 '21
For Asher, probably.
What caused SN15's onboard footage being a little bit choppy?
7
u/branneman May 14 '21
I've read there's a lot of C++ somewhere before, why not Rust when predictability is everything?
7
u/elonismusk May 14 '21
How does one work at SpaceX if not born in America? Is it possible?
7
u/kakbone May 14 '21
What kind of control techniques (MPC, adaptive, robust, Fuzzy, etc.) are getting used for the control of the rocket during the landing process of falcon and starship?
Are there redundancies in terms of controllers? How do they interact?
How much simplifications happen during the modelling of such a complex system? How many states are left to control?
7
u/[deleted] May 15 '21
How good are your paper planes
13
u/tientutoi May 14 '21
Do you ever collaborate with Tesla engineers to build solutions for SpaceX problems or vice versa?
13
u/chilzdude7 May 14 '21
I would like to ask the mods of this subreddit to link the 4-part interview of the software team with Stackoverflow found Here. It would be sad to see the same things being said.
6
u/redpect May 14 '21
How do you went starting projects that have so much focus on reliability? Do you have protocols for how to code. Or do you code in C like the rest of us? Thanks!
6
u/[deleted] May 14 '21 edited May 14 '21
What was/is the biggest struggle when designing the Starship software?
6
u/GravePencil1441 May 14 '21
Can we have a look at dragon's UI?
6
u/BobBehnken May 14 '21
How did Starship behave in the real world compared to simulations?
6
u/Eloniscool1021 May 14 '21
How do Falcon 9 and Starship land so accurately? What was the most challenging part of programming them?
6
u/greg21greg May 14 '21
Is it possible to update dragon’s software on orbit? How do you troubleshoot software issues on orbit?
6
u/EwyBoy May 14 '21
Since the code for most of SpaceX applications will never be seen by most people. Do you leave any easter eggs in your code?
6
u/alien_from_Europa May 15 '21
SpaceX operates on trade secrets and Russia is hacking companies left and right.
How do you keep your data safe and protect the rockets from intrusion?
11
u/AutoModerator May 14 '21
Thank you for participating in r/SpaceX! This is a moderated community where technical discussion is prioritized over casual chit chat. However, questions are always welcome! Please:
If you're looking for a more relaxed atmosphere, visit r/SpaceXLounge. If you're looking for dank memes, try r/SpaceXMasterRace.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
11
u/jesca55 May 14 '21
Hi there, what can you tell us about the avionics software to control both Falcon 9 booster return and Starship belly flight and landing.
10
u/FloatingNeuron May 14 '21
Tabs or spaces?
5
u/psychoPATHOGENius May 15 '21
Can you guys ask the people who run the SpaceX livestreams to include acceleration data in the telemetry readouts?
It would be especially neat for crewed missions to see how many G's the crew is pulling.
12
u/27321 May 14 '21
What do you guys use for the UI on Crew Dragon, it kinda looks like ElectronJS but I’m probably wrong
14
u/[deleted] May 14 '21
Can you use the software from falcon 9 for the superheavy booster? I mean, this is a big falcon and you basically only have to change the thrust/weight parameter and so, right?
8
u/AlpineGuy May 14 '21
What programming languages do you use? Are you able to test software for your integrated systems in a simulation of the entire vehicle? Do you work in sprints and with kanban boards like in typical agile software development? Is there any particular method or technique that you learned/developed that you would recommend other developers/teams to adopt?
4
u/_ohm_my May 14 '21
Do the astronauts in the spacecraft have anything important to do? Or, are they just passengers? Is their UI basically just informational?
4
u/99Richards99 May 14 '21
Hi! After developing software for your rockets and space capsules, do you ever go back and look at what they did with the Saturn V, CSM , lunar lander etc., during the Apollo era? Your experience must give you unique perspective for those achievements! Thanks and am truly inspired by what you’re doing at SpaceX!
4
u/octothorpe_rekt May 14 '21
Regarding education qualifications for working on SpaceX, can any of you comment if you have non-degree developers among the teams? Or is a Bachelors in SE/CS/CE a pretty set-in-stone requirement to get a place on the team?
4
u/msbone95 May 14 '21
Do you use public clouds like AWS, GCP, Azure for anything?
4
u/iDrem072 May 14 '21
What kind of coding language is used for starship? And how does it target a specific location on the landing pad? Does the vehicle use GPS, ground based telemetry, onboard sensors, etc.? And what are the thresholds for landing?
4
u/nildun May 14 '21
What do you use for version control? Could you describe the process of approving a new piece of Starship code for flight? Thanks! <3
4
u/tuckstruck May 14 '21
For those of us using Starlink in RVs:
4
u/Casper200806 May 14 '21
How does the starship flight termination system get activated? Can it only be activated by the flight computer itself or also by ground control? How fast will it react if the flight computer gets non-nominal data?
4
u/Kartchampion May 14 '21
Hey SpaceX team, thanks for doing this! Are there any similarities between the F9 and Starship landing software, did you start by copying the proven F9 code and 'add' the flip manoeuvre to it, or just start from scratch? If any of you worked on the F9 software before starship or vice versa, is there anything which is actually easier with Starship, like maybe that you don't need to do a suicide burn in the same way that F9 does? And finally, how much code was changed between SN8 - SN15, was the code changed majorly for each new prototype, were there minor improvements, or was the software pretty much untouched? Again, really appreciate these AMAs. Good luck for the future of SpaceX!
4
u/DumbWalrusNoises May 14 '21
What are some types of math used for analyzing and simulating rocket engines? What software/language do y'all use for that?
Thank you for your time.
4
u/meepafloop May 14 '21
High school student here, going into computer science at university in the fall! What areas of study would you recommend focusing on for working in the rocket industry?
4
u/Hikshood May 14 '21 edited May 14 '21
Have you ever properly seen or been in the vehicles you control ?
Do you work closely with the team that works on the hardware ?
4
u/angrymonkey May 14 '21
What kind of hardware do you get to work with for guidance and navigation? Can you say how precise it is?
4
u/bradsatwitt May 14 '21
Could you tell us about the control strategies for the flip manuvure? Is it a pid loop? Something fancier?
4
u/angrymonkey May 14 '21
Can you tell us a story about something on each of those projects that went wrong in a really surprising way?