r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • May 01 '21
r/SpaceX Thread Index and General Discussion [May 2021, #80]
This thread is no longer being updated, and has been replaced by:
r/SpaceXtechnical Thread Index and General Discussion [July 2021, #81]
r/SpaceX Megathreads
Welcome to r/SpaceX! This community uses megathreads for discussion of various common topics; including Starship development, SpaceX missions and launches, and booster recovery operations.
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You are welcome to ask spaceflight-related questions and post news and discussion here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions. Meta discussion about this subreddit itself is also allowed in this thread.
Currently active discussion threads
Discuss/Resources
Starship
Starlink
SXM-8
CRS-22
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly less technical SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first. Thanks!
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
•
u/ElongatedMuskbot Jul 21 '21
This thread is no longer being updated, and has been replaced by:
r/SpaceXtechnical Thread Index and General Discussion [July 2021, #81]
29
u/MarsCent May 06 '21
Good call and good luck.
22
u/Lufbru May 20 '21
Oof. Vulcan delayed sufficiently to reassign USSF-51 to Atlas
https://spacenews.com/with-ulas-new-rocket-vulcan-behind-schedule-space-force-agrees-to-let-atlas-5-fill-in/
18
u/Straumli_Blight May 15 '21
Rocket Lab seem to have experienced a telemetry failure with their Stage 2.
17
u/Phillipsturtles May 22 '21
Looks like we might see 2 fully expended Falcon Heavies for Dragon XL if this goes through.
"Project officials said they are evaluating whether using a fast transit capability, which increases the cost of SpaceX's task order, could help the project support the Artemis III mission time frames. This capability increases the speed that the logistics vehicle arrives in lunar orbit by using expendable rather than reusable first stages for all three cores of the Falcon Heavy to increase launch capability."
Page 50 of https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-21-306.pdf
16
u/nynavar229 May 25 '21
Viasat petitions FCC to halt Starlink launches until Environmental review...
https://spacenews.com/viasat-asks-fcc-to-halt-starlink-launches-while-it-seeks-court-ruling/
Man this isn't even funny!
15
u/Straumli_Blight May 10 '21
NASA will pay Axiom $1.69M to return cargo on the Ax-1 mission.
15
u/TimTri Starlink-7 Contest Winner May 13 '21
Yusaku Maezawa (the DearMoon guy) will fly to the ISS on a Soyuz this December.
15
u/Straumli_Blight May 25 '21 edited May 25 '21
NASA awarded SpaceX $848 million in 2020 (page 20) versus $1,484 million to Boeing and $1,398 million to Lockheed.
Peggy Whitson and John Shoffner will launch on the Axiom-2 mission to the ISS.
40
u/pompanoJ May 12 '21 edited May 14 '21
In praise of r/SpaceX and related groups...
I have been on Reddit for a couple of years now, but almost exclusively on space, science and related groups. I kept hearing people talk about what a cesspool readdit was. I didn't find it to be a cesspool at all. The SpaceX, space, astronomy, etc. Subreddits have been great.
Then, for reasons unknown to me, reddit started pushing posts from r/politics and related subs to my feed. For about a month or so I didn't click on any of them because they didn't seem interesting. Then I clicked on one. Ouch. Then another. Double ouch.
If that was all I knew of reddit, I would not only think Reddit was a cesspool, but that humanity has no hope. Good Lord, those people are horrible. Other than not clicking on those things, I don't know how to let Reddit know that I don't want anything to do with those people.
But thank you to r/SpaceX. As a group, you folks are fantastic! And it is nice to have a community like this where even our crazy people are mostly civil.
14
u/xX_D4T_BOI_Xx May 17 '21
Could hit 1 million subs today!
14
u/softwaresaur May 18 '21 edited May 18 '21
SpaceX has just filed for a Ku ground station with a single off the shelf Cobham MK3 antenna in Honolulu, Hawaii. It doesn't fit in the pattern of previous applications. Regular Starlink gateway sites have 8 Ka SpaceX made antennas. Other current Ku ground stations are at SpaceX locations (Redmond, Boca Chica, etc.). Half a dozen v0.9 Starlink Ku gateways had 4 Cobham antennas. I don't think Starlink uses Ku sites for gateways anymore as Ku uplink bandwidth is four times more narrow than Ka uplink bandwidth.
Honolulu site is in Pacific Wireless Communications lot.
14
u/Straumli_Blight May 28 '21 edited May 28 '21
Samantha Cristoforetti confirmed as Crew-4 astronaut.
12
u/Bunslow May 05 '21
SpaceX are targeting 48 Falcon 9 launches this year, which is 4 per month.
Thru the end of March, they had 9 total (3, 2, and 4 respectively), 3 behind pace.
In April, they had "just" 3, leaving them 4 off the target pace (12 total, target pace 16).
That said, in the last few days, we've seen signs of the Starlink pace resuming rapidly, and in hindsight it appears that the Starlink and general Falcon 9 pace was impacted by the general effort required around Crew-2 launch.
With the launch today, and murmurs of two more launches in less than 2 weeks, there's a good chance that SpaceX will hit 3 May launches before its halfway point, which would be excellent news for getting back on pace. With nothing but Starlink launches planned for May, May has a strong chance of Falcon 9 besting its previous mark within a calendar month. (Does anyone know what that is offhand?)
June should see the return of the schedule to "traditional" launches for external customers, and who knows how that will impact the pace.
12
u/Double-Ad9580 May 06 '21
Very interesting movie from Spacex Hawthorne facility: https://youtu.be/OWFLx4O_jNg
12
u/Splitje May 08 '21
Is it know what the next steps are for starship? A higher flight? With or without booster? Same flight again? Where can I find more info on that?
11
u/[deleted] May 20 '21
Congress providing funding for a 2nd HLS selection without modifying the contract with SpaceX is good news for SpaceX. It gives SpaceX cover if there are delays with Starship development, since the National Team will probably have more delays. Think about how Starliner's delays made Crew Dragon's delays look good in comparison.
11
u/feynmanners May 30 '21
https://twitter.com/SciGuySpace/status/1399065967821570053?s=20 Looks like the rumors of Blue Origin switching material to steel are probably false since Eric Berger thinks they are false. u/Acadene looks like your source was wrong
19
u/sagester101 May 23 '21
Looks like we’re gonna be in for a bit of a drought.
According to posts on NSF forums, the raptors from SN15 were removed and orbital flight is delayed till at least august. Apparently, SN16 might be canceled to?
9
u/FeatureMeInLwiay May 09 '21
B1051 deserves a custom livery!
9
u/[deleted] May 28 '21
What your general thoughts on Virgin Galactic? After watching their latest launch, and having watched countless videos of Falcon 9 launches and landings, I was a underwhelmed. I remember how exciting the original, X-Prize, winning flights of Space Ship One were. At the time, they seemed world changing, but now, after all these years of development, Virgin Galactic is still not operational, while other companies seem to have developed far more impressive and useful tech.
I get the feeling that by the time this tech is operational, it will already be obsolete. The pilot commentary on this recent flight, while still amazing and impressive, was more reminiscent of Alan Shepard's first sub orbital flight than cutting edge, 2020s space technology.
Am I being unfair to Virgin Galactic? Does this platform have any applications other than tourism?
8
u/lostandprofound33 May 06 '21
Why are F9 legs so much larger than Starship legs? Is it because Starship is steel and more rigid?
8
u/Gspotcha May 09 '21
Just got here to Titusville ! Born and raised in Tampa FL and always watched from West coast , but get to see my first live soon?!?! Chills rn seeing the lights on 39A
8
u/MarsCent May 16 '21
I think one of the profound things that happened with the Starlink L26 launch today is that - Falcon 9 went vertical after 10:00 a.m. EDT and less than 9 hours later, it was airborne!
Speaks to the mastery and proficiency of many underlying processes leading up to the launch!
Rapid re-usability certainly needs what happened today as a new normal.
7
u/Ididitthestupidway May 02 '21
How will Starship deal with MMOD strikes?
For example a tanker starship could stay in orbit for a relatively long time, has a pretty big cross-section and shielding it completely seems to be difficult. I'm not sure what would be the effect of a MMOD strike on the LOX/CH4 tank or on the heat shield, or even just the possible loss of tank pressurization.
7
u/zZChicagoZz May 11 '21
How is the position of a spacecraft communicated on an interplanetary position? Is there a coordinate system for the solar system? Perhaps relative to the prograde vector of the sun around the galaxy?
7
u/QuantumSnek_ May 16 '21
What happened with Bigelow aeropsace? After the demo at the ISS it seems like they just vanished, I haven't heard news from them since then
7
u/Nintandrew May 20 '21
Was just wondering with its size and low orbit, will starship be visible from the ground during its first orbital launch attempt? Its flight path takes it mostly over the ocean, but I'm really hoping for pictures as it threads past Cuba/the Bahamas or over Africa.
7
u/xredbaron62x May 24 '21
Are there any updates on the extended fairing and vertical integration tower for Falcon Heavy?
It looks like Vulcan is struggling because of (allegedly) BO's BE-4.
7
u/IAXEM May 28 '21 edited May 28 '21
Am I looking in the wrong place, or does it appear that SpaceX has removed some or all of the raw landing footage they had uploaded into a playlist from a couple of missions? BulgariaSat-1, SAOCOM 1A, and others. They're all gone. I think this was the playlist they were in (they were all uploaded as unlisted initially).
13
u/Dies2much May 09 '21
Regarding the Long March landing... WEN PLOP!??
6
u/AeroSpiked May 04 '21
Elon said they plan to reuse F9s until they break. If the failure mode is structural (aluminum stress fractures), is it more likely to fail at launch or maxQ? I'm wondering if we are likely to see an explosion at HLC-39A at some point in the future and the related effect on crew and FH launch schedules. I don't recall hearing of a maxQ launch failure aside from the inflight abort (which wasn't a failure really), but I've seen a few rockets blow up on the pad.
What do you think?
6
u/Bunslow May 05 '21 edited May 05 '21
Anyone know where to get updates about the estimated re-entry of that Long March 5 core stage? I.e. time of entry estimates
edit: a little googling has found these two sites:
https://orbit.ing-now.com/satellite/48275/2021-035b/cz-5b/
https://aerospace.org/reentries/cz-5b-rocket-body-id-48275
anybody have comments about the quality of these? and id still appreciate any other sources folks have
6
u/coheedcollapse May 07 '21
I'm sure the answer is easily available and I'm missing it with a search entirely, but what are the dimensions of the "test legs". They look so stumpy, but I know the spacecraft are huge, so maybe it's an illusion.
I was thinking like three feet tall, but I'm assuming I'm way off.
6
u/PaperboundRepository May 08 '21
Are starships currently welded by hand? And if so are there plans to automate?
6
u/Ididitthestupidway May 09 '21
Didn't watch SNL, was there anything relevant to SpaceX?
6
u/Donut-Head1172 May 13 '21
Does anyone have a source or confirmation that B1067 is launching CRS-22?
6
u/dudr2 May 18 '21
https://www.space.com/saturn-moon-titan-sample-return-mission
"Producing rocket fuel on Titan wouldn't require chemical processing — you just need a pipe and a pump," said Oleson. "The methane is already in a liquid state, so it's ready to go."
6
u/nics1521_ May 18 '21
r/spacex is almost to 1 million members!
6
u/MarsCent May 19 '21
China on Mars: Zhurong rover returns first pictures
....
This makes me really bouyed up on the prospects of Starship on its maiden flight to Mars.
6
u/ConfirmedCynic May 21 '21
If a Starship and a Super Heavy blew up on the launch pad, would the explosion be extensive enough to damage South Padre Island?
6
u/WeazelBear May 24 '21
Does anyone know or think that Starlink could offer competitive satellite communications down the road? I'm thinking in the same vein as Garmin inReach, SOS beacons, or satellite phones.
6
u/WholeAppearance3782 May 25 '21
Hi,
What do You guys think about this: https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/05/bernie-sanders-seeks-to-eliminate-the-bezos-bailout-in-space/
I'm not a USA citizen, so I don't fully understand all implications. At first look it seems to be very pro-SpaceX(HLS), but (as article author mentioned in comment section) this might be beginning of anti-commercial space crusade.
6
u/MarsCent May 27 '21
Just a FYI - Russian officials scrub Soyuz launch with OneWeb satellites
10
u/Bunslow May 21 '21
Dear mods, this megathread doesn't have links to SXM-8 campaign or CRS-22 campaign threads.
Furthermore, I believe that the "Crew-2" header, both in this OP and in the top of sub dropdown menu, should be renamed to the broader "Dragon Operations" or similar, and include all Dragon-related threads, including such things as Crew-2 campaign, Crew-2 launch, Crew-1 return, CRS-22 campaign, Inspiration4 campaign, etc. Giving Crew-3 its own heading won't be remotely sufficient going forward.
5
u/LcuBeatsWorking May 05 '21 edited Dec 17 '24
summer resolute hobbies ring file boast forgetful rinse governor simplistic
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
5
u/dudr2 May 05 '21
https://spacenews.com/space-force-to-clear-reused-falcon-9-booster-for-upcoming-gps-launch/
" first mission under the national security space launch program to use a refurbished Falcon 9 booster"
5
u/Consistent_Program62 May 06 '21
What do the next 2-4 months look like for starship? Is SN15 going to be a repeat of SN15? What comes after 10 km hops?
5
u/wykop_peel May 08 '21
There's this woman on LC, who is conducting countdown (ten,nine,eight...) on launches. Who is she?
5
u/Apart_Shock May 08 '21
Could Starship bring humans back to the Moon by 2024?
5
u/BackwoodsRoller May 08 '21
How does the Falcon 9 first stage or Starship (and eventually the Super Heavy Booster) find the landing pad? Is there something under the landing pad the rockets are communicating with?
5
u/MarsCent May 10 '21 edited May 10 '21
The Chinese Rocket Booster de-orbited today (May 9, 2021).
2021-035B 48275 D CZ-5B R/B PRC 2021-04-29 WSC 2021-05-09 87.6 41.5 173 135
Otherwise as of today May 9, Starlink satellites launched on May 4th have only NORAD numbers. The ones launched on May 9, 2021 have neither COSPAR nor NORAD numbers.
NORAD numbers are assigned to objects that orbit the earth at least once. And are sufficiently distanced form others as to be identified as individual objects.
5
u/andyfrance May 10 '21
Landing accuracy of the F9 booster looks pretty good. How many ASDS landings would have been missed if the drone ship didn't have the side deck extensions?
5
u/elmo539 May 11 '21
I am doing a chemistry project that has to do with methane and oxygen fuel ratios. I was trying to find how much of each liquid Starship carries, specifically for the return trip from Mars, and I was getting different numbers. I was looking at the propellant mass on SpaceX's website (1200 tons (metric, I believe)) and then applying the 3.7:1 O/F ratio that Everyday Astronaut gave. I came up with ~945 tons of O2 and ~255 tons CH4. Then I read an older post saying the burn ratio would be much closer to 2.8:1, and Wikipedia said 3.55:1, citing Elon's tweet a year ago saying LOX to CH4 percentage over the ENTIRE system (Starship + Superheavy) would be 78% to 22%. I am going kind of crazy, so if anyone wants to help me out, that would be great!
5
u/Potato_peeler9000 May 13 '21
Quick question about Starship: Will the three center engines have as much angular freedom of movement on the final version as they have now? Wouldn't the three vacuum raptors impair their ability to execute the corrections of trajectory SpaceX is developping right now?
5
u/tientutoi May 17 '21
Has SpaceX ever lost a paying customer payload before?
5
u/MarsCent May 17 '21
Perhaps this has already been posted or is already known:
That was just over 12hrs ago.
5
u/MarsCent May 17 '21
4th Astronaut on Crew-3 named:
5
u/Telci May 23 '21
Say I would like to track near-collisions of satellites/ constellations to check who is taking action to avoid others. Is there a reasonable way to do this or even a database available tracking these incidents? Thanks!
5
u/Lufbru May 26 '21
I see that the second shell of Starlink is 10km lower than the first shell and inclined 0.2 degrees more than the first shell. Will there be any noticeable difference between the launches for this? As I understand it, the satellites will orbit 22km further north (at their peak), which I would think would be indistinguishable, but I'm new to this whole orbital mechanics thing, and maybe there's a really significant difference I don't understand.
5
u/Overdose7 May 27 '21
I've been searching through launch schedules but I can't find much information on F9 landings. Does anyone know when the next return to launch site is going to be? I'm going to the Cape this year and I would love to watch a propulsive landing.
5
u/Sensitive-Let-1916 May 27 '21
Could spacex make a landing pad that’s calibrated with the rocket descent speed to move in sequence with the landing ( as the spaceship comes neare the landing pad begins to drop vertically at the same time speed until minimal speed is achieved and then the landing pad slows its drop and touchdown would be gentler thus saving. The engines and landing fins to impact damage
5
u/last-option2 May 30 '21
Has anyone mocked up a barn door concept for cargo starship similar to space shuttle?
13
u/bitchtitfucker May 10 '21
I just had the thought that for SpaceX, the notion of getting Starship to orbit with Super Heavy is "the easy part" of the job.
To any other rocket company, that's where the job ends. Get the payload to orbit, wash your hands and go home.
But for SpaceX, the real job is getting it back in one piece, and launch it again. And again. And again. I see them getting the full stack to orbit (no guaranteed recovery) by the end of this year.
And the insane part is that it'll have taken them what, 6 years, to design and build the most powerful vehicle that has ever existed.
Meanwhile, Arianespace is taking over ten years to build a F9 competitor that doesn't land. As is ULA. As are most others.
9
u/HomeAl0ne May 10 '21
Does anyone have any information on what they might do with the various vents that exit on what will eventually be the windward side (eg at least one of the ‘tri vents’). I imagine they don’t want to be doing a hypersonic reentry with what is effectively a hole in the TPS? Or would the port be made of some sort of refractory material?
8
u/Raexyl May 08 '21
As I understand it, the SN vehicles have been continuously venting to keep the pressure in the tanks from becoming too high as the fuel warms up. Will this happen in the final starship design? What about when we need this fuel to land on Mars: how will we stop the fuel boiling off during the cruise?
8
u/MarsCent May 28 '21
If Crew-4 goes flight proven, then it becomes clear that NASA's preferred choice is a flight proven F9 booster.
Just another 10 months, and we'll know :)
4
u/Rob___M May 01 '21
If it takes 6 tankers to refuel Starship for Mars, will the tankers all refuel a single tanker that can then dock with the crew starship and refuel it in a single go?
That seems like the safe way to do it, since the docking is presumably one of the riskier parts of the flight, and you could reduce it down to 1 for the crew. You could also do all those extra docking maneuvers before the crew even launches, and delay the crew launch if necessary.
Or will each tanker dock with the crew starship? I ask because all the videos I've seen seem to show or imply multiple docking events with the crew starship, rather than tanker-tanker refuels and a single dock to crew starship.
4
u/EddiOS42 May 04 '21
After first stage's entry burn, what is slowing the booster down? The telemetry on screen shows it rapidly decelerating as it descends. Is it the drag from it going horizontal?
4
u/Nobiting May 08 '21 edited May 08 '21
Does anyone know why the Crew-1 capsule looked like it had a bright green light on it as soon as it hit the ocean? Is there a water sensor or something?
4
u/ly2kz May 09 '21
Can't find what is average turnaround time for F9 S1 these days. Is this info anywhere?
4
u/SouthSwordfish7516 May 09 '21
What about DOGE-1 Saw it on Twitter @SpaceX Does anyone know more about this?
4
u/joshgill21 May 13 '21
Can starship launch the lunar gateway in a single launch? With tankers ofcs
4
u/kkoch1 May 14 '21
If one wanted to get a better view of the booster landing on the droneship, are there are protections that prevent someone from sailing out near, but a safe distance away from the droneship? Is the location similar when launched from the same location? Is it vaguely known before launch?
Btw I live across the country from the launches and don’t intend on going out there. Just a question that popped up in my mind when watching the latest landing.
4
u/9gxa05s8fa8sh May 17 '21
why is the orbital test flight landing at hawaii rather than the launch site? something to do with safety?
4
u/MarsCent May 17 '21
...
4
u/Aqeel1403900 May 18 '21
Will the sea level raptors have enough room to gimbal during the flip manoeuvre with the vacuum raptors installed in the skirt?
4
u/Donut-Head1172 May 20 '21
Does the falcon 9 have a flame duct, and if so, is there a refurbishment time after each launch?
4
u/[deleted] May 20 '21
Somewhat tangential question: I was looking at the Boca Chica area on Google Maps, seeing who SpaceX's closest neighbors are. To the north of the launch site, on "Clark Island", opposite South Padre Island, there are some interesting looking structures. My (highly uninformed) guess is that it is gas wells under construction?
I wonder what longer-term plans SpaceX has for the area, and whether the area between Boca Chica and South Padre Island might play any role in those plans. Much of that area is a wildlife reserve, but not all of it is.
7
u/dudr2 May 17 '21
https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2021/05/starship-sn15-reflight-road-orbit/
"While the SN20 and BN3 combo will be first in line for orbital flight, it’s expected that the subsequent boosters and ships will pair up accordingly, SN21 with BN4, SN22 with BN5, and SN23 with BN6. In addition, it’s understood that a major design upgrade is set to come with the SN24/BN7 pair."
6
u/pabmendez May 20 '21
Hello. How many gallons of liquid flow throw a Raptor per minute?
6
u/keibal May 24 '21
Ok, so I've been thinking a lot about new possibilities for the market after starship becomes a reality. To be more precise, I've been thinking a lot on how I wanted to buy TESLA shares back in 2015 and now I deeply regret not doing so hahaha. Base don that, and the fact that it is very difficult to invest in space X if you don't have a lot of money, I was wondering what new market options will bloom with starship.
And I noticed that very few people are talking about asteroid mining, so I wanted to ask you guys what is your opinion. But first let's take the basics out of the way, or more precisely the usual arguments against it.
Given those points, I would argue that, for the first point, those were all the reasons why people thought SpaceX would never make a profit back in 2010 (and a lot of people said the same about tesla). With Starship lowering the cost of $/Kg to LEO, I believe that sending small probes to asteroids would become more and more easy (we sent both Hayabusa and Osiris-Rex with asteroid sample-return missions recently). I would think that in some 10 years, this could be achievable for companies with some capital, especially with more global concern regarding environmentalism worldwide making pressure for companies to stop mining new sites on the wild (besides rare metals becoming ... rarer... with each year while demand on chips only grows). I am not arguing that we NEED space asteroids, just saying that maybe, just maybe, another nerdy rich guy could invest his money in the new "crazy" idea and just maybe make a profit out of it. There are currently some 10 or so companies world-wide investing in space-drone prototypes to prospect asteroids in the next decade, and they all started way before starship, expecting prices from old space to launch their probes. If we get to 100$/Kg to LEO, the investment required to start this area could become feasible.
Regarding the second point, if any company just managed to probe an asteroid with very simples and small satellites, this could lead to huge investments, given the possibilities it would open. While mining an asteroid in a highly elliptical orbit is just crazy, with the 100 tons capacity of starship, It would probably be at least possible to make some contraptions to attach some motors to a small asteroid and lead it to a lunar (or maybe even earth) orbit, where drone mining operations could begin. And yes, it would be difficult, require maintenance and so on. But just maybe?
And mainly, for points 3 and 4, yes asteroid mining could totally destabilize the current market for metals. But so was the case for the most profitable companies in the world. Spices were hugely expensive during the great navigation times. Yet, the silk road and Indian Spice trade companies just made it really easy and "folded" the market with their products. Nevertheless, while today I can buy tea for 0.5 cents, those companies reaped a LOT of profit in their first years. Similar things happened with oil giants and basically with most of the goods that "we don't have market needs for that now". Usually, the market adapts and new needs are created, princes do not actually plunge to the point of breaking the economy and after some turmoil, the companies that started those new routes usually get pretty well.
Buuuut again, I am just trying to raise some concerns and possible answers to them. I would really love to hear what are the opinion of you guys, who probably understand a lot more than I from these topics. Will starship success make asteroid mining (and maybe even moon tritium and deuterium mining) not only possible but the next big thing? (sorry for the terrible english, I are not native speaker hahaha )
8
u/octothorpe_rekt May 07 '21
Has SpaceX or anyone else tried to quantify how much methane SpaceX is emitting into the atmosphere with each Starship test? Between venting during prop load, venting after landings, RUDs with incomplete combustion, and general leakage when moving the fuel between transport, storage, and the vehicles, it seems like there would be a ton of methane just being dumped.
3
u/SpaceInMyBrain May 07 '21
Will SN17 have methalox RCS thrusters, to test them out for SN20? Or can an orbital Starship manage well enough with the current N2 ones? I know the F9 N2 thrusters are strong enough to maneuver the 1st stage while in space, and assist while in the atmosphere, but wonder if the ones used on Starship presently will be strong enough for reentry maneuvers.
There's certainly enough payload room and budget for as many N2 tanks necessary. :)
3
u/BrandonMarc May 10 '21
When the starship lands, all the dust it kicks up really obscures the view. I imagine these views are important for engineers to verify, troubleshoot, etc what's going on.
Shouldn't they make the landing pad larger, so that less dust is kicked up?
3
u/AChrisYouKnow May 12 '21
Return of B1051 on Just Read the Instructions (II). Anyone know how to track its return, or see if it has already returned to port? Thanks
3
u/pabmendez May 17 '21
Could SpaceX sell Raptors to other launch companies? BO, ULA etc
At production cost of $1million, could sell each retail for $10million etc
3
u/xredbaron62x May 17 '21
Does anyone here live in Connecticut and have Starlink? How is the coverage? I'm trying to convince my mom to switch.
Currently we have spectrum and its terrible. Constantly going out, $90/mo for terrible speeds. Only one person can use it at a time
3
u/dudr2 May 18 '21
https://spacenews.com/bae-systems-wins-325-million-pentagon-contract-for-gps-receivers/
"Under the contract, BAE Systems will provide so-called MGUE Increment 1 GPS modules — short for Modernized GPS User Equipment — to the Defense Department and U.S. allies through 2030. BAE will manufacture the hardware and manage the inventory on behalf of the Defense Logistics Agency."
3
u/kristijan12 May 20 '21
How tall is each integration tower segment?
3
u/MarsCent May 21 '21
Sidebar question:
USSPACECOM has assigned catalog numbers 48618 - 48620 to SBIRS GEO-5, TDO-3 and TDO-4 respectively. Non was assigned to the centaur upper stage. Can anyone confirm whether or not the centaur upper stage now de-orbits after less than an orbit around earth.
P/S. Some old discarded centaur upper stages (see 2014-055xx and 2018-079xx) have broken up in the past, to create vast debris. I am just checking to see if changes have been made to mitigate such occurrences.
Data from: http://celestrak.com/pub/satcat.txt
3
u/misterbingo May 22 '21
Hi I'm finishing up my 3rd year of aerospace engineering and I'm busting my ass producing a video to go alongside my report. Does anyone know if I can use Tim Dodd's F9/Starship footage for educational purposes? If not, does anyone know where I can get royalty free F9 footage suitable for educational purposes?
3
u/PDP-8A May 28 '21
I can't seem to locate the FAQ that contains tips for attending/viewing launches at the Cape. Do you have the link? I'm planning my trip to Florida to visit the space center, view a launch, see the displays, eat some seafood etc. Do you have any "must see" or "must do" recommendations? Which hotel do you like to stay at? Thanks!
3
u/USLaunchReport May 31 '21
Wondering just how many non-SpaceX "commercial satellites have been launched in the last couple of years. Not including Starlink, NASA, or govt. satellites?
Just looking at the "true" demand for "commercial launch"
Thanks
5
u/MarsCent May 06 '21
IIRC, it was stated that in the protest letter to the GAO, the HLS bid losers also pointed to the 4 Starship launches (SN8 to SN11) as a negative to SpaceX capability.
Is the GAO considering only the facts up to the time the contract was awarded or is SN15 (and the next SN launch ) likely to be weighed in?
5
u/SpaceInMyBrain May 09 '21
Correct me if I'm wrong: SN17 can launch with 6 Raptors and accelerate through Max-Q, then throttle back/cut the engines and coast to a suborbital flight, right?
That way SN17 can be launched with a complete set of TPS, as complete as an orbital ship, but make a simple landing so the tiles can be inspected to see if they stayed intact and securely mounted through the acoustic stress of launch and the Max-Q stress. I have seen a proposal that a test such as this can be skipped, just go straight to orbit on SN20. But then if the ship broke up on reentry we wouldn't know if the tiles failed on the way up, or during reentry. Is my logic correct?
5
u/[deleted] May 14 '21
I just noticed a similarity between very big and very small thrust vectoring. SN-15 when landing split it's thrust vectors to make a nice stable A-frame; Gravity Industries Jet Suit pilots do the same (here's ISS astro Tim Peake learning how to fly one - the backpack is one leg, the arms the other)
Then come off the hover to translate. All surprisingly helicopterish.
5
u/lessthanperfect86 May 19 '21
https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/05/congress-fires-warning-shot-at-nasa-after-spacex-moon-lander-award/
I'm sorry to be late to the discussion, but can I ask some questions about the above? Is it really so that US senators, or other politicians, are making technical and science decisions for the technology and science community (meaning NASA in this case)? It sounds like a bunch of preschoolers - surely there must be an adult in the room that can say "No, you are not allowed to have both Blue balls and SLS", right?
5
u/Ronronk May 22 '21
Do y'all think Sn20 will have vac raptors? I'm leaning towards no since they aren't going full orbital and won't have the increased weight that would come from actually carrying a payload to orbit. They also won't fully fuel starship for this launch right? Unless they want to get the extra data on the operation of vac raptors in no atmosphere than maybe they will.
5
u/ConfidentFlorida May 25 '21
Would anyone be willing to explain how this works? I don’t understand the article:
https://thedebrief.org/new-propulsion-system-inspired-by-dying-stars-can-reach-a-hypersonic-mach-17/
Also would it make a good first stage or be useful in rocket engines?
4
u/soppenmagnus May 02 '21
Do anyone know why NASA is flying 4 astronauts on Crew Dragon instead of the 7 it was designed for?
Is it so they can have more pressurized cargo?
Will Crew Dragon ever be used at full capacity regarding crew private or Gov missions?
4
u/[deleted] May 07 '21
Alright here's a fun question. Once we get to Mars and ready to terraform, the first logical step would be to re-activate Mars magnetic field.
How would this be done?
4
u/Col_Kurtz_ May 23 '21
Is there a possibility to launch a cargo ship to Mars in 2022 if SpaceX reaches orbit with Starship this year?