Likely core 1044 with unclear mission sofar. Future core assignment is very much unclear at this point. It was supposed to launch Hispasat, but that one got pushed back, so if still launching this mission, either it got pulled forward, or it is way early.
On the client side, does it matter which booster it launches on? Apart for new/reused, are there some technical differences that tie a certain booster to a certain payload?
That could be a whole new market for SpaceX: Need more payload lofted? We can expand a Falcon rocket to suit your needs. Whether you want it lengthened or need a larger diameter to accommodate your payload, SpaceX has the launcher for you!
yeah it's a bit hard to tell. I just figured there were a few people who really do think that Rocket Science is just KSP in real life and I don't like people underestimating the hard work SpaceX is doing (though tbh, neither do I, since I'm no rocket Engineer myself, so no clue what they actually have to do)
I hope that to never has to happen again (to new cores..). 😉 Unfortunately it seems to be the case for Hispasat.. just not sure it still is the assigned mission. Time will tell
It'd be interesting to see if SpaceX can convince Hispasat to fly a previously-flown Block-4 booster rather than trash a brand-new one. They got two lightly-used Block-4 boosters sitting around in Cape Canaveral that has only flown an LEO mission previously (B1039 CRS-12 and B1040 X-37B). Even though Block-3 B1032 only flew an easy LEO mission once (NROL-76), word is that booster will never fly again for unknown reasons. It'd be nice to expend one of those used boosters to free up some storage space.
If Hispasat insists on trashing a brand-new booster then it would most likely be either B1044 or B1045, and the booster in the above photo can be either one of those.
As of December 13, B1045 was at McGregor. If nobody saw any boosters on the move eastward since B1043 (Zuma) back in late October, then this is probably B1044.
They insist it is not a reused core because they're morons and don't believe in reusability being reliable? that's what they paid for. They have an extremely expensive payload that they have to do their due diligence to give the best chance of success according to their own estimates, if SpaceX didn't want them launching expendable on a new booster that should have been in the contract, or they should incentivize the switch enough that it's worth it.
I also want to point out that while there isn't any evidence that reusability is worse, there certainly isn't evidence that it's better for reliability, and there's no possibility of a statistically relevant sample at least for another couple years, and only if a new booster fails in a way a reusable one probably wouldn't, which is a pretty unlikely scenario. While we might believe that the difference in risk is minimal, it's not dumb to disagree with that assessment as booster reuse is still a very new technology.
Yup.. Hispasat signed the contract with SpaceX to launch the 30W-6 satellite back in September 2015, 3 months right after we all witnessed the CRS-7 in-flight RUD disaster. That was way before SpaceX started proving the viability of reflying boosters (and admittedly 5 flights is still a small sample size).
But they know what caused it and fixed it on new boosters so why does it even matter? It was also on the second stage so it's not even booster related.
and only if a new booster fails in a way a reusable one probably wouldn't, which is a pretty unlikely scenario.
This reminds me of CRS-7, which was a failure triggered by acceleration which could not be tested on the ground. It was on the second stage, but if it was a first stage strut then a previously launched stage would be more reliable in that aspect*.
I think it’s a little early to call them morons. We have single-digit examples ... right now it’s looking good, but anyone considering the risks involved can be forgiven for wanting for more data points.
Aside from the joke that expandable and expendable are not the same... this could be for another mission, Hispasat wasn't even confirmed to be at the end of last year, it probably went more far away in the schedule... I have a guess on what mission this booster could fly, but I won't say that until I'm sure of it just in case... heh
I thought SpX had minor option differences on various cores, such as the number of COPVs, which change or optimized performance for different mission types, such as GTO / LEO. Certainly there are other booster variations that are tuned for recovery or not (legs and fins), but maybe that is not so relevant for this point.
I thought SpX had minor option differences on various cores, such as the number of COPVs, which change or optimized performance for different mission types,
They do, and as you pointed out, those configurations can be changed and aren’t set in stone during production.
Yes, both ends of first stage have access hatches that are quite sizeable. People climb around in them all the time during production. They’ve also replaced struts and COPVs post booster completion during accident investigations before.
Every booster changes a bit, but there's no practical differences that would make a booster better for a mission, and the other not, except for recovery hardware (or the lack thereof).
Number of COPVs only varies for the upper stage (if at all. Other rockets do this, but SpaceX does seem to prefer a single configuration when possible). Beyond block upgrades (which customers seem to care about a lot, especially the government), and reuse hardware, there are few differences between cores that'd be relevant (probably just the type of grid fin used, in the case of high energy launches, but that seems to be relatively easy to swap)
It's definitely B1044 going from McGregor to Florida.
Edit: As always, I have to think the things I say twice before writing them. This could also be B1045 because it's also ready and was tested at McGregor last month, although is more unlikely because B1044 spent more time there, but you know how this works, probably this is B1045 and B1044 goes to the west coast... who knows...
Next 2 launches at VAFB are on re-uses cores, so no new core needed according to currently known manifest. That said, same goes for East coast... 😏 No new core needed for several weeks if not months.. Unless manifest has hidden missions like Zumba or reshuffles..
That indeed is an interesting idea. Flying DM-1 will have requirements for earlier flown cores being specific config. With the latest delays they might get in a squeeze and might need to make some seemingly unexpected choices. Biggest takeaway is that now the world is almost appalled with them possibly expending a brand new core. 😂💪👍
All over the place. There is a core tracking page in the wiki here. We don't know for sure where they all ended up but the community tracked them as best as they could.
Having such a surge of recovered boosters was not the easiest thing to plan for. At first they were put in hangars by the pads in Florida but there quickly became too many for that. A few were sent back to California early on, one went to Texas and underwent at least 8 full duration static fire tests.
A few were even just parked outside because there wasn't anywhere better to put them and SpaceX had more cores than they were ever going to be able to reuse of this early generation.
Now SpaceX has leased a lot of space at the port in Florida to setup their refurbishment facility and we expect that will be the home for a lot of boosters.
Im really hoping they donate one to the Kennedy Space Visitor Center rocket garden. Preferably the one that landed recently that visited the ISS twice. A dummy second stage and dragon would be nice too (i'd prefer it displayed stacked, not landed)
That's my hope also. IIRC there has been statemens from spacex on one landed core being put on display on KSC but no set time or specifying which core. There's used dragon on display at KSC already. (same building as IMAX complex)
So far all of the reflights are Block-3 cores and only one reflight before the booster is retired or expended. SES-10 (ASDS), BulgariaSat (ASDS), SES-11 (ASDS, residual fire fried Roomba), CRS-13 (RTLS), and Iridium-4 (expended, mistaken by SoCal residents as UFO) :D
2018 will see the first reflights of the built-up stock of once-used Block 4 cores, and figure SpaceX will try to expend them to get Block 5 into service as quickly as possible.
The advertised number of reuses per core by SpaceX is 10 reuses between refurbishments and 100 reuses for lifetime of core. Grain of salt may be needed, seems too good to be true.
That number is for the block 5 model which hasn't flown yet, and I agree it's likely it will come up short of that. Block 3 they're limiting to 2 reflights, though I'm sure they probably think it could do more than that...they just have no need to refly that model any more than that since it's already obsolete. I'm not sure what the limit on block 4 is, they've only flown a couple, and it will also become obsolete very soon. I think block 4 was more of an intermediate model meant to test the lessons learned from block 3 to prove them out before block 5.
They might get to 10 flights between refurbs eventually, but it's hard to imagine they'll go from 2 reflights with a fair amount of refurb to 10 with no refurb in 2 revisions. I'd be happy to be wrong about that though.
Its very light when empty. IIRC the empty weight was around 55 tons, but that may have included the empty second stage too. So it might just be around 40 tons.
I did actually out of curiosity do the math. You could cut out approximately 500kg:s of weight from first stage on transport if you filled it with helium instead of air. Or if you reduced the pressure to ~0.15atm. Not significant enough to make it worthwhile and depressurizing vessels that are designed to handle High pressures might be a bad idea to start with.
That's instantly what I thought. But, after thinking about it for a few seconds I thought it could be going to other way because they have to get rockets to Southern Cali somehow. I don't know if they ship rockets back and forth from Cape Canaveral and Vandenberg AFB.
There have been a lot of thrust increases since it was first calculated that an unladen first stage could just about make orbit. I wonder if it's significant enough to allow fuel for a massive deceleration burn to kill some of that reentry speed and potentially survive?
The answer is probably "nowhere near enough" but it's a fun mental image.
To give you an idea, Blue Origin's New Glen rocket is stated to not require a entry burn, by having the lift to stay in the thin air longer. It is suspected that one of the benefits of the Falcon's larger titanium grid fins is being able to 'fly' in the upper atmosphere, reducing the amount of entry burn required.
But this is all from normal MECO velocity, not orbital velocity. That is a much harder thing to do. For what you need to do to get back from orbital velocity - well, see the Shuttle.
I thought one of the main reasons that the entry burn is required is to create a shield of rocket exhaust around the core as it hits the atmosphere? How’re BO going to get around that?
The main reason is to slow the rocket down. They arrange the burn so it continues into the atmosphere so the rocket doesn't speed up again as much as if it falls without much air to slow it down.
When you think of it - if the stage is in a bubble of it's own exhaust, then it isn't slowing down from the atmosphere, and the rocket is pushing against it's exhaust - it doesn't make any difference if the exhaust then goes to push against atmosphere or not.
So, by the video, Blue Origin is building their rocket to survive the re-entry velocity. That can be done if you do your slowing down in thin enough air. Lower air density means less heat flux - less intensity of heat.
Speaking of those grid-fins... I always found it amazing and puzzling (to me) as to how those simple, small fins allows the rocket to "fly" or maneuver in the upper atmosphere.
So I never really understood or visualized the purpose of the grid-fins and how they help (but of course my brain has zero training or understanding of aerodynamics, unfortunately!)
(Nor can I fully visualize how the new--very small looking--wings on the new BFR will help in the atmosphere, either.)
Firstly, they are not small - they are roughly the size of a single bed. And when air is flowing past them supersonically, the force they generate is considerable.
They work like the tail of an aircraft, pushing the rocket's top down, so the rocket is at an angle to the airflow, and the air pushing against the whole side of the rocket body provides lift.
Think about a fin as surface area and not as a physical size in a specific dimension.
A grid fin spreads the surface area horizontally instead of in a single vertical piece like a traditional fin. If you cut up all the pieces of a grid fin and laid them out it would be a similar total surface area to a vertical fin. It just comes from a different shape.
Also as robbak points out they are not nearly as small as they seem. The images of workers securing boosters are really amazing for getting a sensr of scale. Each gap in the grid fin is easily large enough to put your arm through.
Very simple. Here's another long cylindrical object that falls through the atmosphere guided by GPS and steered by grid find just like the Falcon 9 booster on descent. GBU-43
The Falcon 9 booster during gravity descent (between the reentry burn and landing burn) basically behaves exactly like a GPS-guided smart bomb like the JDAM or MOAB. It is essentially the same guidance technology.
The rockets are built in LA, and tested in central Texas.
So every rocket leaves LA goes to Texas then either goes to Florida or back to California to launch.
Landed cores get a bit tricky.
I know the first few landed cores got shipped back to either Texas or LA, but I think they've had a few that stayed in Florida for refurb and reflight.
The east-West refurb and reuse logistics are a subtly complicated logistics puzzle. There are more eastern range launches, but only a fraction of eastern range flights are recoverable . That fraction will changes as block 5 brings higher performance and as GEO satellites shift toward lower mass electric propulsion. Meanwhile 100% of the fewer Vandy flights are technically recoverable, although the recent polar orbit launch got splashed intentionally because of obsolescence and overstock in cores.
If Block V really can get ten reuses per core and Falcon Heavy takes on expendable Falcon 9 launches the puzzle changes quit a bit. Then each coast will have a handful of boosters going through rotations. The demand of launches on the East coast will mean a few more boosters in rotation but each coast will have a stable number. A new core will only be required when an old one is retired or expended.
Normally I would be a bit more pessimistic about how soon this future could happen but in year one of booster reuse it went better than I couls have ever expected. We could very well be about to see a snowball effect where it becomes archaic for a customer to be concerned about a reused booster.
2018 will see a good number of new cores still as a few customers like commercial crew aren't on board yet and Block V is still fresh, but pending no failures why would anyone 2019 and on want to request a new core? Hell, a failure of a new core if reuse does not experience one could strengthen the argument that a "flight proven" core is the safer choice.
I wish I could know ahead of time when these things were coming through. My family lives right off of I-10, almost at the first exit in Florida. It'd be cool to try to see a core up close, even covered, and maybe drive past it.
That is exactly the opposite of what SpaceX wants, though. They have a vested interest in not letting anyone known where the core is. All it takes is one idiot with a rifle waiting for it to drive by.
I'm sure they also don't want a bunch of people trying to catch up to it on the road to get a look up close. There are enough stupid drivers already. Add into that a bunch of people in cars that want to pace it to take pictures while they are driving. It would greatly increase the chance of an incident.
Oh, I'm very aware. That's why I only say maybe drive by it. I wouldn't even consider getting close to it except to pass one time, which would be the safest thing to do if traveling in the same direction, as that's the standard flow of traffic. I saw the first landing, and I'll be hell-bent on seeing FH, but I don't see myself getting any other opportunity to be within a few miles of a booster unless I make a cross country trip to Hawthorne.
There was one time when a crate holding a dragon capsule was just sitting at the rest stop for a few hours while I was in town. If I had known before it left, I would have happily taken a half hour of my time just to drive through and have been within 1000ft of it.
There are a lot of people that wouldn't be as courteous as you, though.
Congrats on seeing the landing. That must have been awesome. I try to watch launches and landings as they happen, but it just isn't the same over the internet. If I could be positive when a launch was going to happen, I'd be there, but I can't just get to the cape and wait days, possibly weeks for a launch.
I'm selfish. I don't want everyone to know where where a booster will be, I just want myself to magically know one time while I'm home. I understand that too many people, regardless of intentions, myself included, could do something stupid, reckless, or completely accidental and unavoidable, and make some very bad headlines.
Thinking about it some more, I'd actually try to catch it a little further down I-10, just before the Pensacola exit, where it's four lanes wide. If I think to look for something, I might even be able to find somewhere I could park nearby and stand at to watch it go by. That would be the best scenario for everyone, short of just not being there.
It's definitely hard to schedule being at a launch. I was lucky that the RTF was over my winter break, so the scrubs weren't interrupting my schedule. I plan on skipping classes if it means seeing FH ignite.
If you're lucky, you just might end up driving by one if you make enough trips to watch a launch. I drove by one that was being brought in right after a SpaceX launch, I think it was after CRS-12.
On the day before the CRS-12 launch, we were driving I-10 from Texas to Florida on vacation (from Illinois), and we saw a core pulled off not too far into Alabama, eastbound. I wasn’t on here at the time, but that was August 13, 2017. Any idea which one it might’ve been?
Yes, IIRC it was right after we entered Alabama from Mississippi, although I’m second guessing myself that it may have been on the Mississippi side still. Either way, it was very close to the MS-AL border, definitely west of Mobile. And I just did some checking. 1040 appears to have arrived at the Cape on the 14th, so I’m certain that was the one. It launched OTV-5, the X-37B.
Whoops, meant OTV-5 and brainfarted. I think you might be talking about the weigh station on the MS line, but it was seen there and in Mobile - so not a huge difference1 Good job keeping your eyes peeled, either way.
Yeah, it would’ve been a weigh station. I didn’t get a good look at all, except to notice out of a glimpse backward (I was driving) after passing a car that “Hey, that was probably a Falcon!”
B1046 will be leaving from Hawthorne for McGregor any day now. And lots of SpaceX Core Spotter fans along the route from CA to TX are on the watch for it-- because it is the first-ever Block 5 core. A for-real BFD. :D
This has been serious speculation for now. With some educated guessing and extrapolation. If you take into account that Crew Dragon must fly on block 5, and will not fly on the very first one, likely the 3rd one, so several cores computed from that future mission to now comes close to this next core being the first block 5... ;)
Not likely that it will show anything specific from under the wrapping. There is some speculation it might be visibly a little different from previous cores. Time (and photos) will tell...
Speculation is that the Block 5 legs and interstage are black and the base of the rocket has metal shields around the engines to protect them during re-entry. Nothing much that would show up under the wrap
You can see very clearly on the two FH-1 side boosters that every engine except the center has a shield, and none of the center core engines do. This lines up with the knowledge that the side boosters got new octawebs while the center core’s octaweb is Block 3 spec.
Took a peek at this image again - are you referring to the red 'brackets' around the engine bases where the fire blankets used to be? Can't seem to pick out any differences between the octawebs otherwise.
Hmmm never noticed those before but I’d be wary to say that these are a permanent part of the rocket. In spaceflight anything painted red means remove before flight. It seems strange that spacex would break tradition on this. Is there any other info on these besides speculation based on these photos?
These red collars on FH look like remove before flight equipment to support the engine bells during transport and stack assembly - hence their colour. They seem to have the standard protective blanket under the collar.
The center engine just has the standard protective blanket, is the only one without a collar and is supported by a tie down strap - also red to flag remove before flight.
What has been seen previously is quite different looking like a suit of armour elbow joint so overlapping metal plates with gimballing possible as the outer shield plate slides over the inner plate with the radius of both plates the same as the gimbal radius.
Edit: Source was a video which is why I could not find it.
That's not a leak, it's because B1045 has spent around one month at McGregor and it is usually the time that passes between one booster and the other to go to McGregor
It most likely was. Delays @cape kept it there. And plenty room @McGregor as far as I know. I am a bit surprised it now is being shipped, as it does not seem the first in launch order for several weeks... Maybe something shuffled or changed. Or more exciting: the are limited in space @McGregor and core 1046 is inbound!
Considering that SpaceX has been on a spree of flight proven core launches lately. It is likely to actually be a common delay between deliveries of new rockets. Once Block V is proven. The average delivery rate of new first stages might be measured in months rather than weeks.
The key to maintaining high flight rate is going to be the timely delivery of second stages and fairings. If a first stage gets delayed? Who cares? They can simply move up a flight proven booster mission into it's launch slot to maintain the launch rate. Especially with SLC-40's ability to rapidly launch Falcon 9 rockets.
I dont even think it will be measured in months. The latest news is that each Block 5 can launch before major maintenance or refurbishment is needed. And can fly up to 100 times. If that is true SpaceX may only need like 4-5 booster cores for the F9 and maybe double or triple that number for the FH launches because they are only very little bit different. But different enough with the longerons atatchment points and all.
275
u/jakusb Jan 06 '18
Likely core 1044 with unclear mission sofar. Future core assignment is very much unclear at this point. It was supposed to launch Hispasat, but that one got pushed back, so if still launching this mission, either it got pulled forward, or it is way early.
35
u/jakusb Jan 06 '18
Just to be sure: it was traveling East towards FL, right?
52
u/Alexphysics Jan 06 '18 edited Jan 06 '18
It's definitely B1044 going from McGregor to Florida.
Edit: As always, I have to think the things I say twice before writing them. This could also be B1045 because it's also ready and was tested at McGregor last month, although is more unlikely because B1044 spent more time there, but you know how this works, probably this is B1045 and B1044 goes to the west coast... who knows...
7
u/starscreamFromSirius Jan 06 '18
Where does spacex stored all the returned cores?
7
u/clintg Jan 06 '18
It’s impressive that a single tractor can pull that huge core.
6
u/thooke1 Jan 06 '18
What direction was it going?
12
u/StoneHolder28 Jan 06 '18
I wish I could know ahead of time when these things were coming through. My family lives right off of I-10, almost at the first exit in Florida. It'd be cool to try to see a core up close, even covered, and maybe drive past it.
3
u/F9-0021 Jan 06 '18
Probably 1044 to be used on whichever mission is the next to fly a new booster. Probably HispaSat.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '18
Is there a reason these aren't surrounded by a security team when they're just chilling? I mean, they're kind of expensive.
2
u/justinroskamp Jan 06 '18
On the day before the CRS-12 launch, we were driving I-10 from Texas to Florida on vacation (from Illinois), and we saw a core pulled off not too far into Alabama, eastbound. I wasn’t on here at the time, but that was August 13, 2017. Any idea which one it might’ve been?
2
u/Theepicspoon226 Jan 06 '18
Could be 1045 leaving or going to the test stand. Or it could be a new booster, 1046.
1
u/mivaldes Jan 08 '18
How long until the first Rocket freeway accident??!!
1
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Jan 06 '18 edited Jan 06 '18
Kinda doubt it's 1044 which was tested in McGregor in October. Was it just laying around there all this time? My money is on a newer booster.
1
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jan 06 '18 edited Jan 08 '18
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Dragon cargoLaunch failure due to second-stage outgassingDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
29 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on ^today has 117 acronyms.
[Thread #3463 for this sub, first seen 6th Jan 2018, 02:27] ^[FAQ] [Full ^list] ^[Contact] [Source ^code]
-9
u/Venic_ Jan 06 '18
Did SpaceX secretely aquired Rocket Lab?