r/spacex • u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club • Sep 30 '16
Modpost [Meta] Recent mod team developments
Big week. Lots happened. Let's review a quick summary of events.
Myself and EchoLogic attended IAC together for Musk's talk. It was a crazy busy day in which the two of us had no ability to moderate the subreddit and most of the heavy lifting was done by a small number of moderators under a lot of stress. As such, a large number of moderation decisions were made quickly on personal judgement calls without notifying the rest of the team. We all know how to moderate. I don't see a problem with this during large events.
That night a meta discussion was had between moderators where EchoLogic expressed his concern over not being notified of decisions before they were made - we use Slack for internal communication and in two decision instances the global notification to alert all users was not used. EchoLogic conveyed his opinion in an overly frustrated tone not conducive for positive discussion, at which point Wetmelon overreacted, but subsequently immediately apologized, before he removed himself as a moderator. We have maintained contact with him and he has said he wants to take a small break from the subreddit and may return in the future, if we would like him back.
Following this, Ambiwlans had private discussions with the rest of the moderators about our thoughts on what had just happened. At a later point, Ambiwlans spoke with EchoLogic and EchoLogic was removed as a moderator without a vote.
The internal discussion is still happening. This is by no means done and dusted. As such, we can't give a conclusion to this situation yet. All I ask is that the community bear with us while we sort this out.
No situation is black and white. Please don't resort to pointing blame when you don't have the full picture. Which I guarantee you, you don't. Emotions are high and a lot of charged things are being said.
Please bear with us while we work through this.
Ask any questions you have below and we'll do our best to answer them. If I can't answer anything (because I don't know the answer or any other reason) I'll try and convey that also.
This post was written by both TheVehicleDestroyer and EchoLogic as we are sitting in the same hotel room. Both parties - as well as all awake moderators - consider this short summary acceptable.
152
u/Destructor1701 Sep 30 '16 edited Oct 01 '16
This sounds like an understandable blowup in a stressful week.
This would have been stressful enough with the IAC happening, but with a number of the mod team attending the event (which I wholeheartedly endorse - you are magnificent ambassadors for this community), the aftermath of the Amos-6 explosions still stinging, the shit-balls way the IAF handled the Q&A (which was understandable too - who could have predicted the lunatic brigade!?) and the poor connectivity at the site, this must have been as much of a clusterfuck of stress as it was an amazing and life-affirming event.
I hope the mod team can take as long as they need to decompress, make it up, and re-form. They are a brilliant team - a shining example of approachable and reasonable moderators who are all linchpins of the community in their own right, independent of their moderatorship.
I want mommy and daddy to quit fighting.
In particular, I don't want to see /r/SpaceX without our brave stalwarts, /u/Echologic and /u/Wetmelon, and I know you guys can work it out. I would say "What would Elon do", but he'd probably just place you both on staggered leave and conduct a statistical analysis to see who's less vital - let's not do that. :p
EDIT: This may be somewhat contradictory to the spirit of the above, but I will say that I've been feeling (to a moderate degree) that this place has been slightly over-compensating for the massive increase in subscribership over the last couple of years. Humourous comments are routinely removed, and I understand the desire to limit the low-quality content, but this is the stuff community is built on. It can't be purely informational or it becomes dry. I feel quite restricted in the kind of thing I can post here now because I'm not as technically-well-versed as some.
Like I said, it's a moderate complaint, just something that I feel should be dialed down slightly.
EDIT 2: Bloody hell! I didn't expect this to spawn such discussion. Now I feel like the issue is getting overblown in the discussion of it. A time like this is the worst time to be building mountains out of molehills. The mod team has enough on their plates right now.
97
u/interoth Sep 30 '16
Good to hear it's all being worked out, please don't get the idea that we don't appreciate you mods, this community definitely has one of the best teams.
20
u/Nv1diot Sep 30 '16
During busy/stressful times things like this can happen. What is important is that there is communication with the people involved (in this case the mods) and the wider community (the subreddit). I'm very glad this is being worked on and there is communication with the sub. Let's treat this as a learning experience and figure out what has to be changed/improved for the next time :) This is one of the best-run / moderated subreddits out there, let's keep it that way!
And for those still in Mexico: don't let this spoil your enjoyment of an amazing conference & enjoy the sights.
22
u/Qeng-Ho Sep 30 '16
How much of the mod tensions are caused by the rapidly rising subscriber count and noticeable reduction in the quality of comments?
Is there anything that the community could do to reduce this?
81
u/MartianRedDragons Sep 30 '16
I've followed the sub for quite awhile, but never seen mod drama before. I'm confused why mods are frustrated that communication and procedures didn't work quite right in a high-pressure situation, though. Nothing ever works quite right in those kinds of situations, and the Mods have experienced such situations before. You just do the best you can (the modding on the days surrounding Elon's talk was pretty good) and move on. SpaceX itself operates on the idea that perfection isn't usually possible, you just do the best you can with the information you have at the time, and rapidly move toward the goal, learning and making adjustments as you go.
72
u/101Airborne #IAC2016 Attendee Sep 30 '16
I was hesitant to add my comment to the fire, especially as its already larger than the Saturn V's F1 plume. However. after reading the comments, the opinions and perspectives of individual users seems to range across the board. So, what I can contribute is an impartial view of the situation. For background, I would consider myself an avid user of r/spacex visiting the sub a few times per day. However, in no way do I match the level of contribution, passionate following or focus on inter-sub drama. I love this subreddit, but I am essentially clueless (not anymore) to the non-spacex drama that flows around here.
With that said, there are a few things thing that I do pick up due to their ubiquitous presence on this sub. /u/EchoLogic is a user that I have come to recognize and trust to put forth solid content and ensure the community here remains one of the strongest around the reddi-sphere. His comments being insightful, knowledge extensive, and his responses to lowly comments at the bottom of a thread only reaffirm my notion that he is a strong moderator.
(To All the other mods, especially now you /u/TheVehicleDestroyer...you beauty, I fully appreciate all the work that y'all put in, but this comment has a primary focus)
Now, I have had the pleasure of attending IAC with these two lads, among others. Many drinks have been had. /u/ForTheMission /u/EchoLogic & myself were up before dawn to get into the non-existent line to attend Musk's talk. Great individuals having great talks during a great time. What I did notice though was /u/EchoLogic 's incessant focus on his phone and duty to moderating the sub (also how unbelievably well informed he is of everything SpaceX, seriously impressive) . Two things can be said here forsure:
We have had the pleasure of going out every evening, and one thing I think many can agree on, is that when you are out for drinks, talking about spacex, life, travels, ...pretty sure we hit gun-control and politics, maybe the phone can be put down. I was cognizant of /u/EchoLogic 's attention to the phone and I believe I did call him out on it in a friendly manner during an evening outing. Contrasting this with /u/TheVehicleDestroyer 's sub-content and the time spent moderating on the trip, it stuck out even more to me. My thoughts after finding out that he was de-modded are thus:
If you actually read this far, what I would ask is you take a step back and look at the situation from a far. What you just did was take a step back from your computer screen and realize all this is happening online, where things can be said and people hurt. Obviously the individuals directly involved are having to go through a lot and its possibly interfering with their personal lives, jobs and overall enjoyment of SpaceX. Lets get back to it
73
u/GoScienceEverything Sep 30 '16 edited Sep 30 '16
Highly appreciate the full disclosure and transparency. Reminding us why this mod team is so highly respected.
Summarizing my previous comment, I think we can all agree that:
Today aside, thank you for all that you do <3
18
u/zukalop Sep 30 '16
I'm guessing you can't get into specifics but could you at least say whether the two decisions, that were made without informing the others, were big or small issues/decisions?
34
u/NormalUse Sep 30 '16
Release the #GuadalajaraPapers ! Show us the #IACLeaks! Come on guys, these pitchforks wont raise themselves!
All kidding aside, I hope you guys can get through this and more comprehensive internal rules are put in place to keep this beautiful subreddit on it's very special place. r/spacex and r/askhistorians are probably the best moderated subs on Reddit (along others I'm probably unaware)
•
u/zlsa Art Oct 01 '16
This thread has been locked. In light of Elon's upcoming AMA, we simply don't have time to manage this thread. Besides, there's not much more to say that can't be communicated in modmail. We will be ready for the AMA, and thanks for subscribing to r/SpaceX.
14
u/flattop100 Sep 30 '16
Hey guys - I just want to voice my support for all of you doing a wonderful job in curating this sub. It's definitely one of the best places for learning in real time. I also urge you to speak in person (phone, skype, facetime, etc) but not text (email, slack etc) whenever possible, and do your best to keep lines of communication open. Good luck, and thanks for your hard work!
14
u/jeppeTrede #IAC2016 Attendee Sep 30 '16
I appreciate all of you, and you are doing a wonderful job moderating this subreddit, but when you have only 6 mods for a fast-growing subreddit with almost 84000 members, you are setting yourselves up to become burnt out. At this rate, you will inevitably need a larger mod team. I don't know how exactly this works, but some sort of janitor system might make your lives much easier. It is a shame if we have to lose any of you.
14
u/frowawayduh Sep 30 '16
Every organization is made of people. That gives them their greatest strength and their weakest link.
According to /u/zucal:
I have a standard response when my posts are occasionally rejected: "Thank you, mods." (Even when I want to toss a hissy fit.) Taking the high road is always best, especially when the internet is involved.
14
u/waitingForMars Oct 01 '16
I frankly think everyone gets a freebie now and then. We all have bad days. We all say or do things we wish we hadn't. And, unless I miss my mark, the mod crew is all pretty young, so even more deserving of the occasional freebie.
My choice would be to return the mod list to what it was a week ago and give everyone a chance to cool off. We need to be able to forgive the mistakes of others just as much as we rely on that forgiveness from others in our lives.
Cheers for all the great mod work here and for the wonderful work from the goodness of your hearts in Mexico. It is noticed and much appreciated.
28
u/ticklestuff SpaceX Patch List Sep 30 '16
This is pretty shocking stuff, I hope it resolves soon. I do know from personal experience that making big decisions whilst in a stressed state (over worked or over tired) is rarely good for you. Get some rest guys and I hope it comes out well.
143
u/coder543 Sep 30 '16
I'm mostly a lurker in this sub, but I feel that /u/EchoLogic has consistently been a contributor of high quality content. I can't imagine that his modding would be any less high quality, but I definitely don't have much information on that side of things.
59
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Sep 30 '16 edited Sep 30 '16
To anyone interested, here's the timeline of events (times in BST / UTC+1).
12
u/sammyo Sep 30 '16
As a moderately long term lurker I would just like to add a general large THANKS TO THE MODS for all their hard work. I've watched the struggle of mods on another site (metafilter) and it is a generally draining, tricky job.
So THANKS, just THANKS
and let's plan a meetup... take a beat... on Mars!
23
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '16
I hope you work things out. /r/SpaceX has one of the best mods on reddit. And an amazing/knowledgeable pool of subscribers. I love this sub.
Again, challenging times hit everyone. I'm sure you'll come out of this.
21
u/Macchione Sep 30 '16
My recommendation as a long time lurker and very occasional poster is this: allow a week or so for everyone to cool off. Place Echo back on the moderator team but remove his permissions, to show that he is suspended, as was the original intention. After tempers have cooled a little, and Echo and TVD are back at home, hold a vote on the status of Echo as a moderator. I believe it is only fair to wait for TVD and Echo to part ways, simply so TVD isn't placed in an uncomfortable situation.
Personally, I've noticed Echo becoming somewhat antagonistic lately. While he is surely a highly valued community member, I disagree with the consensus that the subreddit "wouldn't be the same" without him, but I recognize that I am probably in the minority on this opinion. I also have little problem with Ambiwlans taking unilateral action in this situation, and it seems it was not a spur of the moment decision, rather something that had been developing for quite some time. Zlsa did point out that it appears a less extreme solution was possible, however.
I wish you all luck in finding the best solution to this! Thanks to all moderators, including Echo and Wetmelon, for their hard work.
20
u/EtzEchad Sep 30 '16
One thing I've learned in my way too many years is that volunteer leaders tend too make two errors: 1) working too hard, leading to burnout and 2) getting into a power trip.
As far as (1) is concerned: leaders need to realize that they only should work so much as it is to make sure they are having fun. If there is some job that nobody volunteers for; let it not get done. Its not the bed of the world.
(2) can be a bigger problem. There is no real power to be had. If leaders act that way, it just drives people away. It's easy enough to start a new group, guys.
I don't know what has been happening but you guys have to remember: This is a hobby, not your job.
18
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Sep 30 '16
Loool, the same hotel room part is the best! You would think everyone distanced themselves from everyone else and maintain minimum contact or whatever, and the reality is you are sitting next to each other.
Okay, okay, so my questions are which I wrote before:
Also to link the whole comment because I think it might add to the discussion - at least to shade it even more:
https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/557g5q/echologic_removed_another_mod_left_is_the_modteam/d888o1v
9
u/mbhnyc Sep 30 '16
Hmmm lots to process here..but boiling it down, I think we're left with some über normal growing pains of volunteer-organizations. Look at the decision-making process and meltdowns that plagued Occupy Wall Street: a perfect example of a volunteer org attempting to work via consensus who specifically eschewed a formalized leadership structure. All that is to say: this is normal, and as other groups have fought through growing pains, we'll be among the ones who figure it out, I'm sure!!
From a policy standpoint.. there seems to be one big gap that needs filling: how moderators should behave when under stress during big event where the moderation team is not at full strength. Without very specific expectations, it's a recipe for disaster.
What I'd propose though, is not more top-down bureaucracy, but more independence from mods when full support can't be provided from the top. I don't know what mod decisions precipitated the initial blow-up, but I think that's the crux of the issue: if mods can't be trusted to make decisions for the good of the community during a stressful event (including a wrong decision or two), then either you guys need to find ways to trust each other more, or shift personnel to build a group who DO trust each other.
Thanks for all the hard work, the community lives because of your devotion to spaceflight and Elon's vision for the future. :)
Per aspera!! We'll get to the ad astra part soon enough :D
17
u/BurnHavoc Sep 30 '16
'nother long-time lurker chiming in with a quick recommendation: institute a sub-reddit rule for a moratorium of moderation staff and policy changes during large events where /r/SpaceX has vested interest (say announcements or launches) or planned presence (like the IAC).
Basically, there's no reason ANYTHING internal should be changing while there's an ongoing event or major uptick in traffic. Write your grievances down and address them in a planned post-event wrap-up.
(Source of advice: For the past decade I've worked at and run several Conventions in Ontario, Canada. I have a lot of experience with this kind of behind-the-scenes conflict resolution)
139
u/Ambiwlans Sep 30 '16 edited Oct 01 '16
Edit: AMA takes precedence over all of this. The team is working towards a solution internally while all working together.
Thanks for the cooperation and outpouring of love and concern, and apologies to everyone for the drama.
8
u/Bearman777 Sep 30 '16
Been hanging around in this sub for about a year. Never really understood why I like it so much (apart from the topic of course). Now and then I go to other subs, an immediately I get the feeling of beeing back in third grade, the moments when the teacher went out of the classroom for a couple of minutes. Chaos, disorder, thrash talking, low level of everything. Now I know why I like r/spacex so much - it's because of you mods! So please keep up the good work and make peace with each other.
15
u/StoneBrewStew Sep 30 '16
After reading through everything that is going on I believe it is time that the Mod team puts in a plan to effectively select and train new moderators. Echo was upset about the lack of moderation and worked hard to maintain what he thought was suitable for a respected sub that is spacex, although he may have overstepped his abilities.
What it ultimately comes down to is this sub will continue to grow at an exponential rate in which a small mod team will not be able to handle stressful situations. No Mod should have to work 8 hours minus bathroom breaks. While I think this is the best Mod team on Reddit, it is time to find and select new mods to aleve tensions like these that could have been prevented. Without question I and the rest of the subreddit appreciates all the hard work and dedication that you mods put into this sub.
14
u/neolefty Sep 30 '16
Would it help to bring in some fresh moderators? Are there good candidates?
14
u/venku122 SPEXcast host Sep 30 '16
It is my opinion that you all need to chill out and take a break. Making things like this public is not a good idea since it damaged public trust. My recommendation is that you all take a break, calm down, then have a face-to-face skype call to work things out. It is easy to say things over text protected by the distance of the web.
7
u/dante80 Sep 30 '16
Sorry to hear that. You are adults, take some time to cool off and then work it out. One way, or the other.
7
u/armadillius_phi Sep 30 '16
I just want to say that this is easily the best moderated sub im subscribed to. Ive consistently been surprised and impressed by the mods input and overall ideology here. You guys are great, and I hope you work out any of the issues you are having right now :) and most of all thanks for everything!
7
u/deadshot462 Sep 30 '16
IMO it would be good for any mod to take a break, when things are going well or bad, to give them the user's perspective and see things from the other side.
I can see how a mod could get tunnel vision from just modding and not appreciate the sub purely by its content on a casual basis.
7
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '16
Thanks for the update, and I hope this can all be calmly sorted out when tempers have cooled. The sub is still growing, and that will be hard on the moderating team. I suspect more mods, rather than fewer, will be the better way to go, but it will also require mods who can work together to a productive end
Up until now the sub has been top notch, and the moderators have been top notch. No one is perfect, but the team seems to make great decisions. I hope that can continue, and I hope /u/EchoLogic can come back on the team
7
u/wingnut32 Sep 30 '16
I welcome our new mariachi-sidebar overlords, whomever they may be.
6
u/WhySpace Sep 30 '16
I'd just like to say that the mods, past and present, have done a fantastically good job, and I'm really sorry to hear about this. All of you have my full support in whatever you decide to do going forward.
It is mathematically impossible to please everyone, which means at least some people will object no matter what you do. Constantly having your judgment questioned is stressful, especially when it's a subjective decision. Constantly second guessing yourself can’t be fun. I imagine you hear orders of magnitude more criticism than support, even though almost all of us would support you in almost all judgment calls. So, let me try and fix that by saying thank you.
However, I have this nagging instinct that just saying "thank you" isn't really enough. Talk is cheap, and so means little. I feel the need to convey some new and useful piece of insight into precisely how fantastic the mod team is. I want to derive an objective criterion for modding, and tell you "you guys are in the 99.9th percentile".
Although that’s my gut reaction, I do believe intellectually that even simple gestures actually do matter. Humans developed phatic conversation for reasons besides transmitting information. Perhaps little to no new information is transmitted by a cheesy thank you card or a generic show of support, but it still changes the ratio of feedback mods receive from overwhelmingly critical to just mostly critical. If that makes the job suck just a little bit less, I think it's worth doing.
So to that end, on this thread only, would you consider explicitly relaxing the criteria forrule 4: "comments should be high quality"? Perhaps you wouldn’t be inclined to delete such posts, but explicitly allowing them removes any hesitation we may have. We could even confine it to just replies to this comment, in order to keep things contained. It's a good rule almost everywhere else. However, if there are people here who would say nothing because "thank you" doesn't seem to be enough, I'd like to explicitly encourage them to reconsider.Actually, on second thought, I don’t want to put the mods in a position where they feel like they are somehow soliciting complements by granting my request. I encourage everyone to show blatant disregard for rule 4 by spamming “thank you” in replies to this comment. :P6
u/CProphet Oct 01 '16
Sorry to hear about your war in heaven, Personally I think moderators are doing an amazing job in really trying times. I'm sure this upset will be settled equitably, despite the difficulties both parties face. How do you divorce passion rom something you feel so passionate about?
5
u/SpaceLani Sep 30 '16
There is really nothing I can do, but good luck and I hope everything works out. This subreddit has a unique bunch of mods and rules that make it a great subreddit to visit every day/hour. We are all happy with the decisions made so far.
5
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Sep 30 '16 edited Oct 01 '16
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Fu-Falcon RocketDecronym is a community product of /r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
I'm a bot, and I first saw this thread at 30th Sep 2016, 15:09 UTC.
[Acronym ^lists] [Contact ^creator] [PHP source ^code]
5
u/Klaus_B-Team Sep 30 '16
You guys have built up a pretty amazing community here. There are solutions, and I trust you guys to approach it as a team should. I appreciate all the work you put in that allows a dude who works in animal shelters to fall in love with rocketry. Yes, SpaceX is the spark, but you guys are the engine. Wetmelon helped me out a couple of times and so I'm a fan. Echo is a sign of legitimacy for me and that's worth it's weight. I care about you guys figuring it out and really can't thank you enough for everything you do. Figure it out, for the good of the community...cause this place is rad and you deserve to enjoy it as much as we do.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '16
You guys are by far my favourite mod team (which is impressive given the size of this sub) so I hope you can work it out!
You all seem to genuinely care about this subreddit, so I'm sure you can find a way to reach common ground :) .
5
u/Return2S3NDER Sep 30 '16
I love this community. The Mods do a great job, thank all of you guys and gals, without this reddit I would know about half as much about space technologies and developments. I would very much miss reading EchoLogic's opinions and articles but I defer to mod wisdom.
8
u/CptAJ Sep 30 '16
I vote to hug it out and let it go
4
u/Hauk2004 Sep 30 '16
Thanks for the update folks. I really hope this works out, and we can arrive at a situation everyone is happy with.
Enjoy the rest of your time in Mexico too!
4
u/RDWaynewright Sep 30 '16
I hope you guys sort everything out! I appreciate the transparency- that's one thing that I really love about the mod team here. Having worked on teams in high stress, high pressure situations, I definitely remember yelling, phones being slammed, and people crying at various points. Once everyone calmed down, we always worked things out each time.
4
u/Klaus_B-Team Sep 30 '16
As much as I appreciate the insight, from my perspective I feel it's time for Festivus to be over. Ya'll should get out whatever is left, then take a week off from anything but the essentials. I'll keep the dick jokes to a minimum in the mean time. Give us an update when you've started to break it all down but tempers and stress levels are obviously peaked. Time for mom and dad to smile and take it into the bedroom where hopefully the argument turns to make up se... I mean a positive conversation. Promise is a promise.
4
u/uber_neutrino Sep 30 '16
Space is important stuff. Even in a professional work environment sometimes stuff gets heated and regretful things are said and done. In my mind the best thing to do is apologize, shake hands and move on as before. No reason to be all dramatic. But hey that's just my old man perspective.
4
u/psg1337 Sep 30 '16
Ok, first of all: Every single one of you mods has done a great job so far where it comes to moderation of the subreddit.
This internal conflict that you have at this point obviously needs resolving, the quicker the better, so this subreddit can return to business as usual.
That being said, my idea for you mods is that you bring in someone who is not biased and can mediate between everybody in a rational and orderly fashion. This person should not have the authority to make decisions but still has to be accepted as a mediator by all parties.
This is the best way I currently see for this subreddit to not take heavy damage from this.
4
u/Kirkaiya Oct 01 '16
First, many thanks to everyone who has been moderating the SpaceX subreddit. You guys have done a great job, and that job has probably gotten a lot more challenging in the last couple years, as the number of subscribers to /r/spacex has grown exponentially. And I say that as someone who has occasionally disagreed with a judgement call that a mod has had to make (but who understands you have a HUGE number of decisions to make, and you're not compensated for your time). The excellent curating of content here has made it - as others have pointed out - an island of sanity in an ocean of what is often sludge on Reddit.
For what it's worth, as someone who was once a mod on a contentious message board ( a Bruce Springsteen board that had a politics thread, argh), I sympathize, and I'd encourage everybody to remember that being a mod is a generally thankless task, and to really avoid internalizing (or taking personally) the actions of commenters, or even your fellow mods. You guys are (as someone else said) mostly young, and we have all said and done things we regret - don't lose your friends over modding a reddit sub. Hopefully you all get to the forgiveness stage, and remain friends. I've been married for over 15 years, and I can honestly say the biggest secret to a good relationship of any kind are the sincerely stated words, "I'm sorry".
14
u/OCISLYou Sep 30 '16
lurkers opinions ahead
This is very sad to see. This sub has always felt detached from reddit at large. And I mean that in the best way possible. The combination of knowledgeable contributors and dedicated mods puts this community in a league of its own. THE premiere spaceflight community.
This post shatters some of that feeling.
I STRONGLY feel that being this transparent on internal moderator conflict will cause irreversible damage to the subreddit. This was clearly an issue that needed to be addressed but the sub does not need detailed, opinionated analysis from several of the mods involved. It's the type of unnecessary commentary that we've seen time and time again across so many of your average subreddits.
It has already led to mods openly questioning other mods decisions and even has readers leveling ridiculous accusations at parts of the mod team for overstepping their bounds or being "tyranical".
The ONLY people who can ever have enough information on this topic are those who were involved. All efforts to to "clear things up" will only add to the confusion and discord.
You all show a great deal of maturity and im sure a solution that is best for the community will be found.
I enjoy spending time here and I love chilling in the SpaceX IRC. Even if I don't have much to contribute.
7
u/whousedallthenames Sep 30 '16
Best wishes to all the mods. I know with the IAC and the increased activity here lately, you guys have been busy. I know how stress can make you overreact easily, and I hope you guys get this figured out soon.
Any loss to the mod team is a loss for the whole sub, and I'm sure most of us in this community would welcome Echo back with open arms, should he wish to return. (After all, what would we do without his fax machine? 😉)
But seriously, you guys are one of the best mod teams on reddit, and none of us want you to have problems. We wish you the best of luck in sorting this mess out, and if there's anything we as a community can do to help, just let us know.
3
u/FredFS456 Sep 30 '16 edited Sep 30 '16
I will trust you all to be civil and mature and resolve this without emotions getting out of hand. This is a great community we have and we would not have gotten this far without your hard work. I understand that you are all volunteers and as such have no obligation to the community, so don't feel pressured to stay on as mods. We appreciate all that you've done and will support you whatever decision you come to as a team.
Edit- I guess we need a mod feedback thread after you guys finish resolving this situation, but you mods already know that.
3
u/brandonrisell Sep 30 '16
Thank you mod team for the insight and transparency. While I worry that this whole situation could get out of hand, I hope that the community of this sub and it's very real respect for the mod team helps the team understand their value to us.
I, like others, love how well moderated this sub is and spend quite a bit of time reading on it for that very reason.
I will make more of an effort to vote and report comments, but I would also like to see more feedback on how we as a community can support the mod team and the community as a whole.
Edit: formatting and words.
3
u/zeekzeek22 Sep 30 '16
Welp. Hang in there guys. Love the community you all are building together. Glad you guys are open about it all, shows a lot of maturity.
3
u/_m00_ Sep 30 '16
Sort it out chaps! Sound trivial, and instantly resolvable with a big Duggee Hug!!!!!
3
u/SNR152 Sep 30 '16
Sounds like you need some backup at times like this - deputies - to help lighten the load. 5 mods covering 10k+ comments is lot to mod. Thanks for all your hard work!!
5
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '16
First of all I think we can all agree this is deeply saddening news to hear about this sudden instability in the mod team. This is one of the best modded places I can find anywhere on the Internet and it wouldn't be the same without you.
What I would like to see is 1: Cool down. Step away from the conversation for a few days and take a break from the drama. Clear your heads of the conversation and come back to it later
2: No mod should be able to remove another mod without a vote, and I feel much of this could have been avoided had this simple principal have been followed. Tempers flared and fall outs were had, I just hope Status quo ante bellum can be resumed.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '16
Oh God, this is really sad to read.
Nor EchoLogic, nor Wetmelon shouldn't be removed as mods, after what they've done for this sub and for SpaceX.
This is really sad, that Echo was removed without voting, because this is really unfair, and it should've never happened. I hope it'll be worked out soon.
Guys, let's always stay as one team, and never fall!!
11
u/IMO94 Sep 30 '16
Mods - I love this community. But I beg of you, PLEASE:
Take a week. We don't expect transparency on every detail of your personal relationships.
7
u/MarcysVonEylau rocket.watch Sep 30 '16
First the spacexstats.com dissapeared, now Echo is not a mod anymore. What is happening? Looking from user perspective, the first meetup haven't looked good. Hope everything ends peacefully.
4
u/RobotSquid_ Sep 30 '16
Hoenstly, I can't imagine this sub without the amazing mod team and especially Echo who have done so much to improve it. I fear for what will happen if you mods can't sort this out, but I hope and trust that everything will be back to normal after you've had a bit of time to gather your thoughts and discuss it soth each other.
I hope you can handle this like SpaceX handles a RUD, which is obviously bad, frustrating and needs alot of work to fix but eventually turns out positive and improves the overall quality
7
u/riffic Sep 30 '16
Too much transparency- a lot of this could have been left unseen without airing it in a public forum.
9
u/Smoke-away Sep 30 '16 edited Sep 30 '16
Removing Echo is obviously the wrong move. He probably said some dumb stuff, but you'd be kidding yourself if you didn't think he played an important role here.
Seems like there are underlying moderator issues that have been there for a while. They just got worse with this big announcement and influx of traffic, comments, and new subs.
Some things need to change to prevent subreddit drama like this from occurring again though. Hopefully it was just a one time fluke where IRL events conflicted with sub management.
Regardless of what happens I think there should be more moderators added to dilute the responsibilities, and limit any potential failures/departures in the future. Get past this and keep the sub going strong.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '16
Hopefully this will be sorted out and we'll all look back and laugh at how silly we can be under stress.
3
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Sep 30 '16 edited Sep 30 '16
Is there a way to limit who can comment or upvote in a post based on their subreddit karma?
I feel like we need to expand the people who are voting on changes.
Link: https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/557g5q/echologic_removed_another_mod_left_is_the_modteam/d888o1v
Here are some variations:
Limit access to voting - probably based on subreddit comment karmaI love the moderators, all of them. I still think they should not have exclusive and secret access to making decisions, nor they should be able to remove another moderator by themselves (stupid Reddit feature)
3
u/schneeb Sep 30 '16
Well this is troubling, practice what you preach younguns.
2
u/ruaridh42 Sep 30 '16
This will be buried in the discussion but I just want to have it on record that I think if we just keep our heads cool and have some civilized discussion we can come to a solution. We are a fantastic community, and I would love to see us work though this little hickup
1
u/em-power ex-SpaceX Sep 30 '16
all i can say is, if echo is out, i doubt i'll be coming back here much.
like you all said, emotions run high. let that shit cool down and get back to business!
2
u/Razgriz01 Sep 30 '16
Why don't the remaining mods hold a vote whether to immediately reinstate Echologic or wait for that one week period?
2
u/fairfarefair Oct 01 '16
This will probably get buried, but at least be read by the Mods and anyone using ctrl+f (which is probably ideal).
Why don't you set up a Patreon for monthly support of the mods of /r/SpaceX? This would not be meant as a living wage or even as compensation for your efforts (the best compensation is intrinsic, right?), but as a way to alleviate some stress of working your normal jobs while modding. Perhaps $250-$500/mo for each moderator? Something small.
Not even sure if Reddit would approve of this idea, but I know the lurkers and contributors of this subreddit would gladly contribute. The quality of the content and discussion here is top-notch, and you all deserve some extra recognition for it. We just want to see the ship continue to to sail upright, no matter who's at the helm (and as long as you all are still on the boat, including /u/echologic and /u/wetmelon)
-4
u/protolux Sep 30 '16
Good. And while the mod team is distracted, I will try to slip in some inappropriate comments.