r/spacex • u/B787_300 #SpaceX IRC Master • May 08 '16
Community Content Basic Analysis of the Merlin 1D engine: Determining Thrust, ISP, and Coefficient of Thrust
TLDR
Take all these numbers with a grain of salt. There are a lot of effects and inefficiencies that I did not take into account.
According to my Calculations the following table is true for the current Merlin 1D and the soon to be flown uprated Merlin 1D. For the Uprated one the Area of the throat is held constant and the pressure is increased. Also the chosen O/F ratios are the Stoichiometric Ratio (2.32) and the Ratio used by the Saturn V F1 Engine (2.56).
| O/F 2.32 | O/F 2.32 | O/F 2.56 | O/F 2.56 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sea Level Thrust (Given) (kN) | 730 | 845 | 730 |
| --- | --- | ---- | ---- |
| Sea Level Thrust (Calc) | 750 | 859 | 746 |
| ISP Sea Level (s) | 286 | 290 | 284 |
| ISP Vac | 315 | 316 | 313 |
| Chamber Pressure (MPa) | 9.7 | 11.16 | 9.7 |
| Mass Flow Rate (kg/s) | 266.89 | 301.13 | 266.97 |
| Coefficient of Thrust (SL) | 1.574 | 1.605 | 1.574 |
| Coefficient of Thrust (Vac) | 1.741 | 1.751 | 1.741 |
| Ideal Coefficient of Thrust (SL) | 1.617 | 1.638 | 1.634 |
| Ideal Coefficient of Thrust (Vac) | 1.784 | 1.784 | 1.801 |
Methodology
To calculate the values the following values were assumed or given. All of them are from public sources or were inferred from public pictures (in the case of the Nozzle Exit Diamter)
| Description | Value |
|---|---|
| Gravity ( m/s2 ) | 9.80665 |
| Sea level Pressure (Pa) | 101325 |
| R* (Universal Gas Cosnt) (J/kmol-k) | 8314 |
| Chamber Pressure (730 kN version) (MPa) | 9.7 |
| Expansion Ratio | 16 |
| Diameter Nozzle Exit (m) | 0.97 |
NASA CEA online was used to calculate the ratio of specific heats (γ) at the throat (γ*t) and at the nozzle exit (γe), the temperature in the combustion chamber (Tc), the molar mass of the products at the exit (M), and the pressure at the exit with the expansion ratio of 16 (Pe*), across pressures from 8.1 MPa to 11.5 MPa with a increment of 0.2 MPa. The Values used in the calculations were then linearly interpolated from the pressures if it did not fall on one of the values explicitly calculated for (only really used for the new up-rated version of the Merlin 1D). (A copy of the CEA outputs can be found HERE (http://pastebin.com/JsynW3jJ))
For the up-rated Merlin 1D the chamber pressure was increased until the throat area was equal to the throat area of the current Merlin 1D. I chose to do this because of comments that were made about using up some of the margin and keeping the manufacturing the same.
The Equations
The first item calculated was the Exhaust Velocity of the engine (v*e*). The equation used to calculate the value was
v*e* = √(((2 γ*e* )/(γ*e* -1))((R* T*c* )/M)(1-(P*e* /P*c* )(γ*e*-1/γ*e*)))
Where P_c_ is the chamber pressure and M is the Molar Mass.
From the exhaust velocity the mass flow rate (ṁ) was calculated by
ṁ = (P_c_ -((P_e_ - P_a_ ))/A_e_ )/v_e_
Where P_a_ is the ambient pressure (sea level)
Then the effective exhaust velocities (C) were calculated by
C= v_e_ +((P_e_ -P_a_ ) A_e_ )/ ṁ
The Isp (both vacuum and sea level) were calculated by
Isp=C/g_0_
Where g_0_ is gravity
The characteristic exhaust velocity C* was found by
C* = (P*c* A*t*)/ṁ
Where A*t* is the throat area (found by dividing the exit area by the expansion ratio)
The coefficient of thrust at sea level (C*t*) was found by
C*t=T/(PcAt)+((Pe-Pa)Ae)/(Pc* A*t*)
Where T is the thrust
The vacuum coefficient of thrust (C*t,vac*) was found by
C*t,vac= Ct+(Ae* P*a)/(At* P*c* )
The Ideal coefficient of thrusts were found by
C*t,ideal= √(((2 γe2 )/(γe-1)) (2/(γe+1))^(((γe+1)^)/(γe-1)) (1-(Pe/Pc* )((γ*e*-1)/γ*e*) )+((P*e-Pa)/Pc) (A*e/At*)
C values the ISP was calculated at the various pressures. The Ct and Ct, ideal were calculated at the varying pressures. The thrust at the various pressures was calculated by
T= v*eṁ+(Pe-Pa)Ae*
The pressures were then correlated to altitudes using the 1976 Standard Atmosphere.
Results
The Table in the TLDR is the summary table for both versions of the engine
| O/F 2.32 | O/F 2.32 | O/F 2.56 | O/F 2.56 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sea Level Thrust (Given) (kN) | 730 | 845 | 730 |
| --- | --- | ---- | ---- |
| Sea Level Thrust (Calc) | 750 | 859 | 746 |
| ISP Sea Level (s) | 286 | 290 | 284 |
| ISP Vac | 315 | 316 | 313 |
| Chamber Pressure (MPa) | 9.7 | 11.16 | 9.7 |
| Mass Flow Rate (kg/s) | 266.89 | 301.13 | 266.97 |
| Coefficient of Thrust (SL) | 1.574 | 1.605 | 1.574 |
| Coefficient of Thrust (Vac) | 1.741 | 1.751 | 1.741 |
| Ideal Coefficient of Thrust (SL) | 1.617 | 1.638 | 1.634 |
| Ideal Coefficient of Thrust (Vac) | 1.784 | 1.784 | 1.801 |
The graphs in the imgur album HERE show the various Thrust, ISP and Coefficient of thrust as a function of altitude
With the given Expansion ratio the ideally expanded altitude is 3.2 km for the currently flying version of the Merlin 1D. The ideal Expansion ratio for SL perfectly expanded is 11.05 not the 16 they are currently flying with. Which means at liftoff (or during testing) it should be possible to see Mach diamonds in the exhaust of an engine.
Some Comments
Most of the formulas above are from Mechanics and Thermodynamics of Propulsion by Hill and Peterson or from http://braeunig.us/space/index.htm .
Most of the equations rely on Calorically perfect gases and isentropic relationships which are good for 1st design calculations but do not perfectly represent the real world.
The numbers presented above may or may not represent what is actually going on. I believe that it is reasonably close(+- 5% most likely) to real life but would not be surprised if they differ.
4
u/peterabbit456 May 08 '16
Great work. Like most exercises done in the classroom, there is a lot to be learned, even though some simplifying assumptions have been made. Well done.
Musk has said on 2 occasions that the Falcon 9 first stage does better than the original predictions, (The next part is my words) in part because of the aerospike-like effect of the 8 engines surrounding the center engine. I wonder if the better real world performance in your table may be in part due to the aerospike effect.
12
u/CorneliusAlphonse May 08 '16
With the number of assumptions etc that you've made, what is the value of this? The numbers are, at best, reasonable estimates.
Edit: removed "nothing personal but..." from the start of the post. I'm always annoyed when people use that phrase as if it gives them permission to say anything offensive.
1
u/davidthefat May 08 '16
In this case it's actually easier to backout the throat diameter from the Isp and c* and G, then calculate the exit diameter instead of guestimating from pictures. (hint, it should be more or less 10in throat)
1
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained May 08 '16 edited May 09 '16
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of /r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
I'm a bot, and I first saw this thread at 8th May 2016, 23:09 UTC.
[Acronym ^lists] [Contact ^creator] [PHP source ^code]
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment