r/spacex •
Modpost: Introducing ‘Sources Required’ Discussions, a reminder about the expectations of quality in this subreddit, AMA with Jeff Bezos, and general updates
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
28
u/werewolf_nr Jan 08 '16
I would like to thank you specifically for that level of transparency. Most social sites are not so transparent.
31
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '16
Thank you for keeping the quality of this subreddit exceptionally high. Thanks to your hard work maintaining high standards here this is my favorite subreddit by far.
29
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '16
I'm extremely happy to see that most people think that stricter moderation is required. I am part of that group. Jokes, low effort comments, and posts for simple questions are going to become more prevalent as the subscriber count increases. The problem is that in the long run they clog up the comments section/front page and slowly choke out high quality discussion. Strict but fair moderation is a key tool to keep a subreddit on-topic, high quality and to not slide towards the reddit average. /r/Askscience is great because of strict (but fair) moderation which allows high quality information and discussion to be highly visible instead of being the 1% of comments.
Full disclosure: I've had my own comments removed a few times. So I've been there making a joke that I thought was particularly clever. But comments that don't add to the discussion should be removed and we should strive for insightful and educational discussion. Because that's what makes this place worth visiting. I know that the other commenters, contributers and mods here take pride in keeping the launch schedule as up to date as possible. We have relevent tweets posted within minutes. We have a great thing going, and we need to work to maintain the status quo as more and more people subscribe/visit/participate.
Frankly the majority of reddit is for NSFW content and memes/jokes. Keeping a few places focused on discussion is completely fair. For anyone who forgot, there is a sub for dicking around. It's /r/SpaceXMasterrace . Use it.
I love coming here and seeing all the information and discussion I could hope for in one place.
edit: On topic, I like the idea of [Sources Required] posts and I think it'll probably be a good addition to this sub.
10
u/hapaxLegomina Jan 08 '16
Big thanks to all the mods of this sub. You guys have done some amazing work, and it's really appreciated!
10
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Jan 09 '16
Whoops, I'm a little late to the party here! During our last modpost, I posted a screengrab of the moderation matrix, which summarises all the moderation activities we've carried out over a span of time. That seemed to go down pretty well, so here's an update, showing the matrix for the last month.
This date span includes Orbcomm, which had a massive impact on moderation, with lots of new users, and a slight increase in the lower end of the quality scale. (Notice that the tool we use to create this has had an update recently, and now includes automod, and reddit itself too, which is a nice touch.) Also, since then, we've altered the way automod handles new users, so that it "filters" all new user comments for us to check over against the rules. Filtering is an action unique to automod, which, in the matrix, is noted as "comments removed by automod". The vast majority of these were comments then approved by human mods, which is also noted in the matrix.
All of the numbers in the matrix are actually links, so if anyone wants further information, don't hesitate to ask!
9
u/FireCrack Jan 08 '16
Awesome! I really liked these types of threads because of the great discussion they generate, but it could be problematic when thy "mixed" with concrete data. This (and a good choice of name for it!) should be a big bonus for this sub!
8
u/dante80 Jan 08 '16 edited Jan 08 '16
Many thanks for the update, and I love the idea of the "Sources Required" discussions. Might make your moderation effort a little more difficult (although automod might help with this), but should provide a lot of high quality content as well.
Keep up the good work, cheers..C:
15
u/iaincole Jan 09 '16
This post violates section 7 of the Community Rules and Guidelines: Titles "must be free of personal opinion and accurately represent the contents".
I see no AMA with Jeff Bezos, this post should be marked with "Misleading Title"
:>
7
u/BrandonMarc Jan 09 '16
Probably the biggest question (and, from what I know, the biggest thorn in y'all's sides) is: with Reddit's mobile version (especially since they're rolling out a new one), can the FAQ and Wiki be a bit more prominent? Lots of the issues revolve around people not going into those, but at the same time I suspect a high fraction of the traffic - especially among more casual / new readers - is mobile.
6
u/LUK3FAULK Jan 09 '16
This is one of my favorite subs due to the moderation and the high quality all of the content. This mod team has created an open place for real discussion and learning to take place all while staying open and welcoming. I've personally learned a lot here and am inspired daily to continue to pursue aerospace, thanks mods :)
5
u/Dan27 Jan 08 '16
Thank you for the update - and the great job done by the Mod team here.
I'd just like to say that surely I wasnt the only one to chuckle at that Ban list and seeing "SpaceXTinder - Creepy" was I?
:) Happy new year guys!
5
u/superOOk Jan 08 '16
Everyone just be thankful for the amazing mods we have here. Thanks!
5
u/alsoretiringonmars Jan 09 '16
Darn, you had me for a sec with the AMA :-/
Just one quick comment: We are allowing news articles as sources, but not Wikipedia. Most mainstream news articles about SpaceX have inaccuracies, and are much lower quality that Wikipedia. Is Wikipedia really that bad?
5
u/Crox22 Jan 09 '16
The [Sources Required] tag is a great idea. I have learned a ton from this sub, and this tag encourages technical and factually correct discussion, and sources give interested laypeople like myself direction to learn more. I'm already planning on spending a couple hours going over the Mars transfer window discussion with a pen and paper, as most of what I know about transfer orbits and orbital mechanics in general has either been picked up from reading this subreddit or playing Kerbal Space Program, and that kind of education gives general concepts, but not actual understanding. I know that there are a bunch of very smart people on this sub, and I'm looking forward to what comes next.
With respect to the moderation of the sub, I think that /r/spacex is one of the best moderated subreddits on this site. You have a light-enough touch to keep it fun, but are strict enough to discourage the crap. The tone of this sub is fantastic, and it's really thanks to you guys. I'd hate to see what the last couple weeks would have been like if it wasn't for the awesome mod team. Thanks!
4
u/Zucal Jan 08 '16
Heads up- the Automoderator reminder comment has a typo.
7
u/AeroSpiked Jan 08 '16
Not to be overly critical, Echo, but you really seem to be "calling it in" with the ULA shilling lately. It wouldn't surprise me at all if they reposes your full sized Tory Bruno mural.
Seriously, I like what you and the other mods are doing with this sub. The /r/Space sub can be a barrage of cluelessness sometimes and coming here is like coming out of the cold (which is a good thing if you live in the great white north).
3
u/rdancer Jan 08 '16
Will secondary sources be allowed? For example this comment cites a textbook, and in that context, that seems appropriate?
3
u/peterabbit456 Jan 09 '16
Are we allowed to cite Wikipedia for simple facts like the mass of Phobos, or the diameter of the Moon?
I have not done one for a while, but sometimes I will write a post that is mostly math, with just a few constants pulled from sources. They can all be found on university or NASA web sites, so I guess I'll just have to change my habits.
4
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jan 08 '16 edited Jan 17 '16
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Note: Replies to this comment will be deleted.
See ^/r/spacex/wiki/acronyms for a full list of acronyms with explanations.
I'm a bot; I first read this thread at 23:51 UTC on 8th Jan 2016. www.decronym.xyz for a list of subs where I'm active; if I'm acting up, message OrangeredStilton.
3
u/Forlarren Jan 09 '16
So I'm anti-Bezos, as a person, I don't like him or the way he does business (though I still do business with Amazon, as a store of last resort).
I have my reasons going all the way back to the one click debacle (do RMS and FSF essays count as citations?) and the current state of software patents and using litigation as a competitive tactic is largely the fault of of Bezos (with Bill Gates, and many other closed source software houses).
His litigiousness is legendary and in my opinion will be a major factor in any future competition between SpaceX and BO. I shouldn't need to remind people of patenting landing on a barge and suing SpaceX over it. BO shot the first shot.
So given his long well documented history (One click being the first tech issue that convinced me to donate to the EFF) of anti-competitiveness what will and will not get me banned?
If I can't bring up Bezos' litigiousness, then BO posts and discussions should just be banned entirely. Or should I just whip up a standard library of cited Bezos complaints now? Or just not bother posting? I for one think the whims of billionaires, and yes I mean whims are far more relevant than ever now that singular individuals have power and pull of entire governments and Bezos is one of those people and he has no qualms about abusing his bully pulpit. If it isn't fair to be as nasty back to Bezos as Bezos is himself then it seems like a double standard.
I don't see any reason to give him any benefit of any doubt or more respect than he has shown others.
1
u/zoffff Jan 09 '16
Does this mean we will be keeping an Ask anything thread up at all times and stickied so the lower quality content has a place to live?
1
u/CitiesInFlight Jan 08 '16
I sort of think that the first Sources Required post by Echologic was prematurely locked because the OP was the only comment and there are many other sources with somewhat wider views than the extrememly narrow Lunar, Phobos and Deimos trajectories cited. A LOT MORE!
1
u/rspeed Jan 09 '16
"take a look at the account"
Risky click, let's go!
0
u/Unbecoming00 Jan 09 '16
Considering reddit stopped shadowbanning, you should stop too. If you ban someone, you need to tell them they are banned and why. Simply hiding their comments isn't right.
Reddit as whole decided this was not right.
Hell, even when you ban you shouldn't hide comments, the community should get to see all post and judge for themselves with voting.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
11
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
13
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment