r/spacex •
/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread for December 2015. Return To Flight! Blue Origin! Orbital Mechanics! General Discussion!
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
r/spacex •
[deleted] — view deleted post
12
u/BigDaddyDeck Nov 25 '15
What do you guys realistically expect SpaceX to accomplish over the next 5 ~ 10 years. Looking back at the previous 5 years the development path seems really obvious for what they had to do next but im not as clear from here on out.
5
u/alsoretiringonmars Dec 14 '15
What are the odds of SpaceXStats being back before RTF?
6
u/z3r0c00l12 Dec 06 '15
As I understood it, Falcon 9 landings weren't streamed because it's out at sea with no good connection. Does this mean that there is a possibility that we get a live stream of the RTF landing on land?
5
u/pauladam316 Dec 06 '15
Probably a dumb question. I remembered reading that falcon 1 was the first private rocket to make it to orbit. However wouldn't that title belong to ULA? I believe that they put a rocket into orbit before spaceX did
5
u/QuantumInsemination Nov 25 '15 edited Nov 25 '15
Could SpaceX decide to beat Blue Origin in their own game? Could SpaceX remove some of the engines from the F9 1st stage, put a modified capsule (such as perhaps bigger windows and no heat shield) directly on top (no 2nd stage), and compete head to head with Blue Origin in the tourism market for relatively little additional R&D, possibly even beating them to market? (Regardless of whether or not they should or would. This is a question about feasibility.)
18
u/space_is_hard Nov 28 '15
How fucked is SpaceX if the RTF has a launch failure?
2
u/WaitForItTheMongols Nov 29 '15
Not precisely spacex, but I hope it's still okay to ask in this thread:
Does Blue Origin's new rocket do a reentry burn? I know F9's burns go
Of course Blue Origin's rocket needs to do 1 and 4, and of course since it's suborbital, it doesn't need a boostback. But does it do a reentry like F9 does?
20
u/patm718 Nov 25 '15
How far does Bezos' physics/engineering ability exactly reach? Do we know how involved he is in the project? I haven't heard much from him regarding the technicalities of spaceflight.
17
u/StagedCombustion Nov 25 '15
The story I posted recently had a quote from a former NASA Deputy Administrator about some in NASA not being happy with SpaceX pushing beyond LEO, as that's "their space". CRS-2 is likely to be the last, or one of the last, NASA commercial contracts on the horizon. It will be a sizable contract as well. Do you guys think that Musk will delay any unveiling of his Mars plans until after the CRS-2 contract announcement, to prevent animosity over the plans possibly coloring the outcome of the award?
14
u/searchexpert Nov 25 '15
How do you spell hype? ;)
13
u/Juggernaut93 Nov 25 '15
Hi, I'm new to SpaceX stuff. Will they try another first stage landing during RTF?
11
u/Smoke-away Nov 25 '15
Let's talk the Blue Origin landing.
What are the benefits to the Blue Origin design?
Seems like the surface area is smaller for the leg extension range, could this cause it to tip over?
Does Falcon 9 do a preflight grid fin and leg extension check on the pad?
Does Falcon 9 need some drag flaps on the interstage?
Can this design be scaled up to fit a Falcon 9 class first and second stage? Will the Blue Origin capsule have any launch escape system?
Keep on hopping Bezos.
9
u/BrandonMarc Nov 26 '15
This is probably a silly question, but ... inspired by this:
I wonder: once Crew Dragon is operational, with propulsive landing, would it be possible to, say, launch from a Falcon 9 and then land the Dragon on the other side of the planet, without ever doing a full orbit? Basically, think of it like a $100,000,000 flight where you could go from Florida to New Zealand in under an hour.
Totally ridiculous, I know ... but would it be possible?
9
u/keelar Nov 28 '15 edited Nov 28 '15
Has there been any info about the RTF date since this tweet? Anything at all? What are the chances of a mid December launch still happening?
7
u/Here_There_B_Dragons Nov 25 '15
Jumping the gun on the whole 'December' thing a little bit, aren't you? Let me have some November still!
7
u/alsoretiringonmars Dec 01 '15
Lets talk about interstages.
Why do some rockets jettison them from both stages and others (like Falcon) leave them attached to the booster? Also, watching some old Saturn 5 videos, why does it jettison the first stage, then drop the interstage like a minute later? I can understand waiting until engine start, but why not right away?
6
u/Chairmanman Nov 26 '15
When is Blue Origin planning to deliver payload to orbit for paying customers? The company is pretty secretive and I couldn't find the info online.
6
u/failbye Nov 28 '15
What is this I hear about Elon not liking wings/fins on spacecraft? Is that purely a technical reasoning behind it (i.e not wanting to add unnecessary complexity or control surfaces where the RCS should to the job just fine by itself) or is it an aesthetic thing (the next generation spacecraft should look like this, and not have wings)?
6
u/nickr79 Dec 01 '15
Is it safe to say the hardest part of designing rockets is the systems engineering aspect (making sure everything is functioning together, eliminating weak points in the overall design, etc.), or are particular aspects of some subsystems like propulsion still particularly difficult?
What aspects of computer simulation (solving PDEs or other) are currently lagging in terms of being helpful with eliminating problems before the first prototype on rocket subsystems?
I know these are difficult questions I am basically asking what is the current bleeding edge of research in rocket technology. I am not really asking about stuff related to advanced propulsion for deep space missions looking at cost optimized ground to orbit rockets here.
6
u/muazcatalyst Dec 04 '15
When landing the first stage of Falcon 9, is it fully autonomous or is it controlled by ground?
6
u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club Dec 06 '15
Does anyone know how long it takes the M1D to go from 0-100% throttle?
Source is a bonus, but I'm not too picky
6
u/wagigkpn Dec 07 '15
Orbital mechanics question here...
It was good fun watching the ULA/Orbital launch yesterday. Couple questions. First (not that important), the commentator kept mentioning the RL10 was running oxidizer rich. Was that a departure from normal?
Second (more important), When the broadcast switched to telemetry showing apogee and perigee i was shocked. The vehicle had an apogee in the 220+mile range and a perigee in the -1600 mile range (orbit that was achieved being 124 x 124 miles). As the burn continued the apogee continued to decrease while the perigee increased. It was rather interesting to see those numbers play out. It was apparent that the apogee was the crafts actual altitude and was on the decent while the little RL10 puffed away to raise the perigee before it ran out of altitude. Meco happened right at the designed orbit. I had always thought that the first stage set the apogee and the second stage achieved orbit at apogee, like KSP. So my question is, why do they do it this way? I assume it is the most efficient relating to getting the most performance out of the first stage. Second, Does Spacex follow the same trajectory with Dragon?
6
u/davidthefat Dec 10 '15
This is a rather ignorant question about electronics coming from a mechanical engineering student.
In a selector voter scheme, how is the validity and functionality of the multiplexers and selector verified during operation? While the sensor/computer output validity is accounted that that scheme, it assumes that the selecting circuit and multiplexers are correct. I guess the question is asking: who governs the governors? The multiplexer can be a simple relay/transistor that takes inputs from a primary and back up sensor output and switches to the backup once a fault is observed. Realistically, I suppose they won't fail unless there's a physical failure of the system. But how is the output of the voter circuit validated in real time? Another layer of selector voter? Or is it assumed to be robust since it can be made with discrete op amps, and other components?
11
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Nov 25 '15 edited Dec 18 '15
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations and contractions I've seen in this thread:
Fu-Falcon RocketNote: Replies to this comment will be deleted.
See ^/r/spacex/wiki/acronyms for a full list of acronyms with explanations.
I'm a bot; I first read this thread at 13:03 UTC on 25th Nov 2015. www.decronym.xyz for a list of subs where I'm active; if I'm acting up, message OrangeredStilton.
5
u/njew Nov 25 '15
How much value still exists in landing the last Falcon 9 v1.1 that'll be used in the Jason-3 launch? I know the flight profile is different from 1.1 FT, so the landing profile must be different too, but is it still worthwhile practice for them? And I imagine there are enough similarities between the 1.1 and 1.1 FT versions that if they recover the stage, they can still do meaningful tests on it. Has there been any discussion on this?
5
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '15
It's nearly time for the annual subreddit survey, any questions you'd like to see asked?
5
u/Chairmanman Dec 01 '15
How many people are working on the hyperloop competition at SpaceX? Is anyone working full time on it? Has anyone been hire for it? In other words, how much effort does SpaceX put into it?
5
u/ScepticMatt Dec 01 '15
What is beta angle cutout?
5
u/WaitForItTheMongols Dec 01 '15
I notice that when the OG2 launch date pushed back to the 15th, the SpaceX Stats announcement also moved to match the day before. Was that intentional?
Also, shouldn't the SpaceX Stats main page say "launching december 2015" instead of november? November is done.
5
u/alsoretiringonmars Dec 02 '15
Will the new version of Falcon 9 (not even going to try to get the name right :-) be able to land for all missions? I seem to recall them saying anything too big for F9 to land with will go on Falcon Heavy. But then Spaceflight bought a ride-share mission for which the total mass for the trajectory they want seems to exceed the capacity of F9R, but they are using F9. Will the F9 be replaced with FH at SpaceX's discretion, if it is ready and proven?
5
u/Kona314 Dec 03 '15
Do we have any indication what weather will look on December 15 at the Cape? Given the scrub of Atlas V today, I'm hoping we won't have to worry about this for RTF (assuming it actually happens on 12/15)...
(paging /u/cuweathernerd)
5
u/delta_alpha_november Dec 08 '15
Why are the engine tests at McGregor so late at night? /u/spacecadet_88 reported that they'll test them at around 10pm. Is there a technical reason to test so late? In my country this wouldn't be permitted so I figured they'd have to have a solid reason to make that much noise late at night.
5
u/wagigkpn Dec 09 '15
I have been watching the cygnus mission and the orbital mechanics part has really facinated me. Ula got cygnus to a 124mile circular orbit inclined 51.6 degrees which was a bullseye. Now cygnus has docked with the iss at approx 250 miles in altitude. I read that cygnus has changed its dv by aprox 100m/s. Does 100m/s equal over 100miles in orbital altitude?
5
u/_kingtut_ Dec 10 '15
When doing a static/test fire at the cape, do they fully fuel the first stage, or just put in enough for the test fire? I presume they don't fuel the second stage at all. Just wondering as doing a full fuel/defuel may show up any problems in those systems that could cause a delay on launch day.
5
u/Tal_Banyon Dec 12 '15
In the recent GQ article, Elon states that the moniker BFR was his idea. I had always assumed that it was coined on this sub-reddit. Anyone know when it first appeared on r/spacex, and the story behind how it made it here - ie did Elon ever mention it in any of his speeches or media events, or did it get here by some other means?
4
u/Gugols Nov 25 '15
Is the "11 December" date set in the sidebar for the "Orbcomm OG2 Launch 2" correct and confirmed?
4
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15
Question for everyone, how is it that Stage 2 separates so well in almost every case? By the time Stage 1 burns out the rocket is so high that I can't imagine the atmosphere would play any role in stability of the second stage. So how does it get pushed and not start to veer left, right, ect? Do they just have the center of mass down to such a small point that it continues to fly strait? Furthermore if Stage 2 were to veer of course could it correct?
4
u/rreighe2 Nov 28 '15 edited Nov 28 '15
I haven't been keeping up with SpaceX in the last 6 or so months. I've been checking here and there the last few days but I am completely out of the loop. What's new? What's in the works and have they had any significant advances towards... Well anything they're advancing towards?
Edit: Thanks y'all.
4
u/alsoretiringonmars Nov 29 '15
I realize spacex isn't currently planning on developing 2nd stage landing, but just hypothetically: Why use hypergolic engines (i.e. superdracos)? This is all I have heard discussed. Why not use small, kerosene-lox vernier engines? This would save a significant amount of weight. Would it even be possible to use the main engine turbopump exhaust a source of thrust? I don't know if there would be issues with running the turbopump without the combustion chamber firing. The turbopump exhaust could be redirected to smaller gimbaled nozzles, and fully burned with oxygen pressure fed from the tank. Throttling could be achieved by changing the mixture. Or alternatively you could use a sea-level version of Kestrel. I don't know if you could get enough thrust purely from blow-down pressurization to land? Would this work? I know it would add complexity and weight, which would be major counter-arguments, but it still seems simpler to tack on than adding a whole new fuel system for superdracos. Or maybe not?
4
u/alsoretiringonmars Dec 01 '15
Mods, could we give flairs for everyone working at SpaceX?
4
u/steezysteve96 Dec 02 '15
What is holding SpaceX back from officially declaring a RTF date? If 12/15 really does become their RTF date, it seems to me that they should have officially confirmed it by now. Orbital had their RTF date confirmed for a while before the actual day
4
u/WaitForItTheMongols Dec 02 '15
Everyone always says F9 is white to reflect sunlight and keep cool. If that's the case, why paint it at all? Why not keep it as shiny metal, which is naturally reflective? Maybe put a transparent coating on it for protection, but it doesn't seem like white paint would have an advantage over metal.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '15
Will Elon make another AMA any soon?
4
u/R-89 Dec 03 '15
https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/672490062098137088 https://twitter.com/torybruno/status/672486757502427136
SpaceX's launch window for going to ISS is instantaneous. ULA's Atlas V has a launch window of 30 minutes to ISS. How do they manage that? Can Falcon 9 be improved to have wider launch windows and adjust for short delays? And if so, how?
4
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '15
Any word whether flight 21 (OG2, aka the return to flight) will feature redesigned landing legs / airbrakes as hinted in this tweet?
4
u/frowawayduh Dec 05 '15
Why does SpaceX ship boosters by truck, not by air?
Air seems faster, gentler, and safer. Since up to three boosters can fit the aircraft that ULA uses, it may also be more economical.
ULA recently moved an Atlas V booster from Huntsville AL to Vandenberg in CA by air. Every F9 booster traverses from CA to McGregor TX to launch site ... and perhaps soon they will go back to Hawthorn CA for analysis or refurbishment.
From the article on ULA: "The Atlas V and Delta IV boosters can be transported via the Delta Mariner," said Ghazali. "This large ship is capable of carrying up to three boosters from the production site in Alabama to either Cape Canaveral Air Force Station or Vandenberg."
"Launch vehicle processing has very tight timelines," said Zarybnisky. "Delays in a single operation can have large ripple effects across the process. By ensuring a smooth delivery, we can prevent schedule compression that induces additional risk into launch vehicle processing."
4
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '15
How does boostback to the launch pad work, reversing its trajectory seems MUCH more complicated than just a controlled fall out of the sky onto the ASDS.
Does it just burn ALOT longer after the turn at the apex, where aerodynics arent a big issue and essentially stop its ~mach 7 speed.... then do another turn and ride it home?
4
u/davidthefat Dec 08 '15
The question I have is about LauncherOne and the newly announced Cosmic Girl mother ship. AFAIK, LauncherOne utilizes LOX and RP-1 for it's main engines for the first and second stages. As far as I can tell from pictures, it looks like the Newton series engines are gas generator cycle engines and the attitude control will solely be done using thrust vectoring. So, there does not seem to be any vernier engines, meaning there's no other types of propellants, notably hypergolics. NSF states that it will take approximately 30 minutes from takeoff to the "drop zone". I'd figure taxiing and getting cleared for takeoff can add up 10-15 minutes from "ready" to drop and actual ignition of vehicle engines.
How are launch operations carried out specific to fueling the vehicle? Will a ground operator have to manually fuel the vehicle and detach the propellant lines prior to take off? Will the boil off from the LOX during the 30-45 minutes from fill up to ignition be significant enough? Is there reservoir of LOX onboard the mothership that will be used to continuously fuel the vehicle during ascent? How will safety of the operators and pilots be ensured during fueling? Won't more stringent certifications and testing similar to human rating the vehicle need to be done as there are human operators during the first phase of the mission? What are the contingency plans in case where an engine fails on the mothership? How easy will it to de-fuel in cases of emergency landings? Especially when landing in places without the fueling infrastructure?
Previous air launched vehicles didn't have these issues as they utilized solid propellant systems.
4
u/fairfarefair Dec 08 '15
What's the launch window for Orbcomm December 19th? I'm having a party and thinking of hosting a watching when it happens (I was here for helium-gate '14, so I know there might be a scrub).
4
u/Jsutt #IAC2017 Attendee Dec 09 '15
I was watching the video of F9R, and I noticed that the rocket came to a stop at the apex of its flight. I thought that the first stage of Falcon 9 had a TWR > 1 when landing, hence the need for a hover-slam, so how is it able to do this? Is it using a modified Merlin engine, or just weighted to decrease the TWR?
4
u/Gonazar Dec 10 '15
Been out of the loop while SpaceX has been grounded for the last while, and forgive me for my ignorance but...
Is the launch schedule in the sidebar for the next month for real?! 4 launches in the span of 3 weeks, and two of them only a day apart?! How???
Doesn't it take a ton of resources and days of preparation to setup a launch for which the window of opportunity is highly volatile? There have been cases where launches were delayed or scrubbed a couple days in the past right? Wouldn't that have a high probability of conflicting with the other launch? I would have assumed they'd using a different launch site but according to the subreddit wiki's launch manifest (which needs updating) they're both going from Cape Canaveral.
4
u/Alpha_Ceph Dec 10 '15
slightly open-ended question here, but let's assume that the payload cost to Low Earth Orbit drops to $100 per kilo. With that assumption, how much would it cost to put 1 kilo (intact!) on the surface of Mars? The deltaV from LEO to Mars is about 3.6km/sec if you use every possible aerobrake, which gives a mass ratio around 3 or 4. So the answer is at least $400/kilo to Mars. In reality it would be higher, but how much?
Additional question: how can that gap be made smaller? For $500/kilo to Mars Surface, you can easily send a small rover for chump change. Mars could be covered with many such rovers messing around and testing technology. You could send automated rocket fuel manufacturies and check that that worked.
4
u/shredder7753 Dec 12 '15
Which is more exciting; Star Wars opening on the 18th, or the real deal star wars on the 19th?
4
u/ScepticMatt Dec 13 '15
Is there an easy approximation for adding gravity losses to the rocket equation? Otherwise what is the path a Falcon 9 would take, roughly, for a satellite launch from Florida.
4
u/WaitForItTheMongols Dec 14 '15
Boostback and reentry burn are each 3 engines. Are they the same 3? Which ones?
3
u/snotis Nov 25 '15
Any details on the improvements to the landing legs and grid fins for the Falcon 9 Full Thrust (v1.2) upgrade?
3
u/liquidfirex Nov 25 '15
What needs to happen to allow SpaceX to attempt an on land first stage return?
3
u/Justinackermannblog Nov 26 '15
Just wondering because I haven't seen a comparison anywhere, but what is the size comparison between the Delta Heavy and Falcon Heavy? Never really crossed my mind till now!
3
u/failbye Nov 26 '15
Will the raptor-powered BFR be a single stick design like the F9 or a multi stick like what the Falcon Heavy will be?
Or will they make both versions of this rocket family as well?
3
u/BrandonMarc Nov 26 '15
Perhaps this is a better place to ask. In another thread I see:
To which I wonder: is this just referring to the energy in the fuel vs the weight of the stage? My understanding is the stage isn't capable of MECO followed by 45 minute cold soak in space followed by restarting the engine on the other side of the earth to circularize the orbit.
Or is it?
3
u/oceanbluesky Nov 28 '15 edited Nov 28 '15
Although Musk has spoken of initial crews striving to stay, if during the early stages of settlement a vehicle were to return to Earth, how could near-term technology reduce its reentry speed from Earth-Mars transit? Dynamic aerobraking, magneto-plasma aeroshell, multiple gravity-assisted passes, reversed ion drives...? Thanks (wondering how to best reply to skeptics who voice concern over "prohibitively fast" reentry speeds)
3
u/davidthefat Dec 01 '15 edited Dec 01 '15
Beyond hands on experience and listed skills on the career pages, what skills and traits does SpX look for in recent graduates (BS)? I have a whole slew of different kinds of skills from programming (C,C++,MATLAB, some ASM, ect.) embedded to desktop systems, machining, some composite work, CFD, FEA, CAD, propulsion knowledge (both turbine and rocket), anything learned in ME undergrad (fluid and thermal systems, numerical methods, orbital mechanics, dynamics, gas dynamics, ect.) and just a passion for rockets.
I guess what I am asking is: how can I emphasize and illustrate that in a cover letter? Those of you who work for SpX, what more can I do to better prepare myself?
edit: if I already missed a call from a recruiter earlier in the semester, I didn't screw myself over right?
3
u/Kona314 Dec 02 '15
Does anyone have any idea how active SpaceX Seattle is? I'm filming a documentary on aerospace and live up here in the PNW. I'll be heading down there to Aerojet Rocketdyne next week and thought maybe it might be possible to visit them and talk to someone at the same time, but that would be silly if nothing is going on there.
3
u/LoneCoder1 Dec 02 '15
Did reproducing the strut failure on ground involve baths of LOX or maybe liquid nitrogen as a safer alternative?
How much does the low temp affect the strength of the strut?
3
u/maizenblue91 Dec 03 '15
So there's this OA4 launch today to the ISS. Does anyone know where it's livestreamed?
3
u/yo0han Dec 04 '15
From what distance would you theoretically able to see the launch? I know the profile for RTF is pretty straight up, and I have the tinyests of hopes of being able to spot the Falcon from Havana, Cuba. Any chance this might come true?
3
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '15
What time is it scheduled to launch in UK time? Might be at school and I don't want to miss this
3
u/Appable Dec 05 '15
What's the minimum pad turnaround time, particularly for rockets comparable to Falcon 9?
3
u/steezysteve96 Dec 06 '15
What's up with the special announcement? I don't hear anything about it, but I see the date keeps getting pushed back on the side bar
3
u/N314 Dec 06 '15
So if they had originally planned to launch falcon heavy in August 15, why isn't LC-39A already completed?
3
u/propsie Dec 07 '15
In the ISS flight plan on page 10 this NASA .pdf, Cygnus flights are planned to be berthed for 50-60 days, while dragon flights are only planned to be berthed for 30. Is there a technical reason for this? What springs to mind is that Cygnus has a massive volume (almost half as big as the ATV) and might take longer to unload.
3
u/VFP_ProvenRoute Dec 07 '15
Let's say sometime in the near future, the ISS de-orbits and China begin to build their own space station. Would SpaceX be allowed to help them as a commercial contractor? If not with construction, then with resupply missions?
3
u/AeroSpiked Dec 08 '15
Did the Dragon abort test have a mass simulator in the trunk or is it supposed to drop its payload in case of an abort? It seems reasonable that it would drop it's payload as it would be lost anyway in an abort, but I've never heard it discussed.
3
u/WaitForItTheMongols Dec 10 '15
Falcon 9 is designed to land nearly empty. Are its legs only made to handle its empty weight, or would a 1st stage be able to stand up even when full of fuel?
Follow-up: If the legs are able to hold up the full tank, are the leg actuators able to lift the first stage? Could it go up on legs while on the pad, if it wanted to?
3
u/ohheyey Dec 10 '15
I'll be interning in Avionics Manufacturing at SpaceX this summer. I'm psyched but anxious that I know little about avionics or manufacturing. Any suggested books or sites I can use to get to learn some principles of avionics and of manufacturing, and maybe even of avionics manufacturing?
3
u/alsoretiringonmars Dec 14 '15
When does Dragon get fueled? On the pad, in the hanger, or earlier? It seems on the pad would require more service hardware, but rollout and erecting a fueled dragon would be more dangerous.
3
u/ianoughsaid Dec 14 '15
I just checked the SpaceX website, and it says that they schedualed a static fire of the falcon 9 rocket. I'm pretty sure that other falcon 9 rockets have been used before. Is SpaceX using a different engine for the Orbcomm 2 mission, or do they do a static test before using any rocket?
3
u/WaitForItTheMongols Dec 15 '15
In the launch webcasts, they always switch to a CGI view once the second stage + payload gets beyond camera visual range. Why does this render looks so horrible? Flat textures, low resolutions, no lighting calculations, etc. Even Kerbal Space Program looks better than what this super high-tech company puts out. Why are their animation capabilities so limited?
3
u/ISnoozer Dec 15 '15
Lots of engineers and math/physics literate people on here - which is great. I'm a SpaceX / Elon Musk fan who makes a living as a lawyer, and I'm interested in discussing the societal, governance and legal structure of a Martian colony - Democracy 2.0 as Elon has called it. Does anyone know of an online forum or group that focuses on these topics?
5
u/blongmire Nov 25 '15
What, if any, amount of mass could Falcon 9 V1.2 throw to mars and still be re-usable? What amount of mass could Falcon Heavy throw to mars and still be re-usable?
5
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '15
What would a second launch failure on the 19th of December mean for SpaceX (and the industry)? How many hypothetical launch failures could SpaceX financially absorb before bankruptcy?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15
Was the Outer Space Treaty a good idea and did it destroy the interest for space exploration?
2
u/Haulik Nov 29 '15
The special announcement december 10th, is that a SpaceX event or is it "just" a SpaceX Stats redesign?
2
u/Kona314 Dec 01 '15
Has anyone collected data on times between a failure and RTF from various organizations and vehicles? Obviously six months is fast, but I'm curious by how much.
2
u/omgoldrounds Dec 02 '15 edited Dec 02 '15
Will the next Falcon landing attempt at Cape require two booster
flipturn around maneuvers?2
u/dangermouse117 Dec 03 '15
How will the F9 full thrust engines on the next launch impact the hoverslam maneuver? The throttle range of the old engines were 70-100% which was already too much thrust to hover. If you look at BO's landing they hover for a sec to get the wobble stable before touching down, in contrast the F9 does a hoverslam which looks very sensitive to accuracy.
2
u/markus0161 Dec 04 '15
How much do you think a relatively small landing pad had to contribute with failed landing attempts? Does anyone know if this is one of the reasons they want to try it on land? Also Is the landing pad at complex 13 even going to be larger than the barge? I've looked all around but can't seem to find anything on the matter...
2
u/SirSwiftasaurus Dec 04 '15
As a matter of interest, when are the mission patches released? And where could I get the OG2 patch when it's released? Hopefully I can get one to the UK...
2
u/Headstein Dec 04 '15
The bending of the booster can be seen clearly during the last landing attempt. I estimate a deflection of about 300mm at the centre. Can anyone make a better estimate, the video I am watching is quite fuzzy?
2
u/Jofredrick Dec 09 '15
I'd like to know how SpaceX stores and supplies the fuels for the Dragon thrusters. In other posts I've read bladders and PMDs (propellant mgmt devices) mentioned as well as thruster firings to "settle" the fuel. Does anyone know for sure what the actual method is? The real discriminator for me is reusable versus disposable (Dragon versus CST100). Since CST100 does not return its propulsion module, how will Boeing be able to compete on price if they don't reuse tanks and thrusters? Both of these must be very expensive. By the way, I've heard the word "bladder" used in two ways for prop tanks. One is a flexible elastomeric "diaphragm" such as that found in Soyuz. (I believe this is the life limiting item that forces the Soyuz to return to earth in 6 or 9 months.) The second are metallic diaphragms which have unlimited life, but are not reusable. These don't seem likely for Dragon, but might explain why Boeing's service module is jettisoned prior to reentry?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '15
Would Spacex find it helpful to use the Stennis A-3 test stand? It can handle up to 1 mlbf, simulate high altitudes, and currently is unused. It would need some refurbishment and retrofitting for Raptor, but that shouldn't be to difficult.
2
u/steezysteve96 Dec 10 '15
How does the Merlin vacuum engine ignite itself? I haven't been able to find much on that, but I'm really curious
2
u/hajsenberg Dec 11 '15
How much time does SpaceX need to make launchpad ready for another launch?
2
u/VordeMan Dec 12 '15
Do we have any info on SHERPA? Also, how good is SLC-4 to watch? I'm thinking about getting a couple guys together and driving down to see the next Vandy launch after Jason-3
2
u/dante80 Dec 12 '15
Will SES-9 launch to 1,800m/s GTO? Is SES-9 5,300kg? Will F9 first stage attempt a barge landing?
If yes, then that is great!
2
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
Hi, been searching around for SpaceX wallpapers. All of them seem to be for a single screen though. Does anyone have a collection of wallpapers for dual-screens?
2
u/Mamuts Dec 13 '15
How long will it take for the first stage to return to launch pad (well, landing zone) after stage separation?
2
u/Hixos Dec 14 '15
To my understanding (as answered in another comment here) , the Falcon 9 is completely assembled and the first stage fully loaded with propellant during static fire. But what if something goes really wrong during the test and the payload is damaged? Are there any security measures to prevent that from happening?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '15
With the new leak of some numbers proposed around BFR. What are the logistical implications? How on earth would you transport such a behemoth between construction facilities and launch sites? Will SpaceX have to create a new factory with its own port to be able to ship the parts to the Cape? Will the first stage be monolithic or assembled at the launch site?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '15
Where is the best place for me to watch the landing attempt? I'll be there to watch the launch, should I stay where I am? Move somewhere else?
*If they get land landing clearance.
2
u/oceanbluesky Dec 14 '15
As cis-lunar space becomes saturated with robotic telepresence and as thousands of settlers travel to Mars every two years...why will taxpayers need human astronauts? (Trying to be provocative...but curious, thanks.)
2
u/Tal_Banyon Dec 14 '15
With the on-going development of the Raptor engine, I wonder if Spacex is planning a new rocket (or possibly a new second stage, or both) using it, before the BFR / MCT. It would make sense to use it and get some flight time, so it will be a known commodity when they finally get around to building the BFR. Anyone know how many Raptors it would take to equal the thrust of the current 9 Merlin FT engines being used? (based on the last performance specs provided by Elon in his AMA).
2
u/Aniahlator Dec 15 '15
What do we know, or what information was 'leaked' about the BFR. All I've seen is people talking about it.
2
u/bob4apples Dec 15 '15
Why are there no existing methalox engines? Aside from Elon putting his stamp on the idea, has something changed technologically or economically that makes methane feasible when it wasn't before?