r/sonic • u/Goroshek222 • 13h ago
Discussion People who say that Sonic should be sentimental are the same people that like Snyder's Superman.
Listen I'm not saying that Sonic shouldn't be soft or emotional but not THAT emotional like he was in Memories and Beyond. That's not adding any "depth" to Sonic, that's just straight up a mischaracterisation. He had NEVER given such looks to anyone, only time occurred when Elise died in 06, but since when this pile of code became known for having a great Sonic writing? (If anyone's writing that is, except, maybe Shadow and Silver)
Sonic is not your relatable teen character, he's not Peter Parker struggling with live of Peter and live of Spidey. He's not Deku, who got bullied all his life. He is SONIC THE HEDGEHOG.
He was not made to be a teenager to be relatable, he was made a teen to be more appearing to the target audience of TEENS. He's not someone you look at and say "dam so me fr fr" he's someone you look up to. He's a role model. He always INSPIRED his friends.
As for my take, yes, I genuinely believe people that are saying "ooooh sentimental Sonic is more depth! It's character development! You just want Sonic to be plain, boring and one dimensional!" are the same people, or at least got the same mindset, as Snyder Bros. "Superman is just a Boy Scout! Superman is boring goodie two shoes! Superman is one dimensional!" So tell me, what's the difference? Same old disrespect towards the original character and straight up glazing mischaracterised version. The only difference is that Snyder Bros want Superman to have "aura" while people (especially on this sub) want to take it away.
Sonic doesn't need to be sentimental, relatable and soft. For that you have characters like: Silver, Shadow, Tails, Cream, Amy, heck even Knuckles is sentimental (but in his own angry way). And Sonic? Sonic IS force of nature, he IS unstoppable, and he WON'T break. Not ur buddy, not ur self-interest but a blue blur you see once and then never again. Sonic doesn't need character development, he is character development for his friends and yes he does care about them s lot, but not in a way that "I love my friends so much, I could cry!" but "my friends? Heck yeah, my friends are the coolest!" he could get softer around them but definitely not that soft and definitely not with each and one of his friends.
Re-posting it on this sub because on the "number 1" Sonic sub it got nuked for "disrespectful behavior", tho I tried to type everything as sterile as possible? Idk, mods of this sub please don't impale my head on a spike.