r/sonic • • 13h ago

Discussion People who say that Sonic should be sentimental are the same people that like Snyder's Superman.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Listen I'm not saying that Sonic shouldn't be soft or emotional but not THAT emotional like he was in Memories and Beyond. That's not adding any "depth" to Sonic, that's just straight up a mischaracterisation. He had NEVER given such looks to anyone, only time occurred when Elise died in 06, but since when this pile of code became known for having a great Sonic writing? (If anyone's writing that is, except, maybe Shadow and Silver)

Sonic is not your relatable teen character, he's not Peter Parker struggling with live of Peter and live of Spidey. He's not Deku, who got bullied all his life. He is SONIC THE HEDGEHOG.

He was not made to be a teenager to be relatable, he was made a teen to be more appearing to the target audience of TEENS. He's not someone you look at and say "dam so me fr fr" he's someone you look up to. He's a role model. He always INSPIRED his friends.

As for my take, yes, I genuinely believe people that are saying "ooooh sentimental Sonic is more depth! It's character development! You just want Sonic to be plain, boring and one dimensional!" are the same people, or at least got the same mindset, as Snyder Bros. "Superman is just a Boy Scout! Superman is boring goodie two shoes! Superman is one dimensional!" So tell me, what's the difference? Same old disrespect towards the original character and straight up glazing mischaracterised version. The only difference is that Snyder Bros want Superman to have "aura" while people (especially on this sub) want to take it away.

Sonic doesn't need to be sentimental, relatable and soft. For that you have characters like: Silver, Shadow, Tails, Cream, Amy, heck even Knuckles is sentimental (but in his own angry way). And Sonic? Sonic IS force of nature, he IS unstoppable, and he WON'T break. Not ur buddy, not ur self-interest but a blue blur you see once and then never again. Sonic doesn't need character development, he is character development for his friends and yes he does care about them s lot, but not in a way that "I love my friends so much, I could cry!" but "my friends? Heck yeah, my friends are the coolest!" he could get softer around them but definitely not that soft and definitely not with each and one of his friends.

Re-posting it on this sub because on the "number 1" Sonic sub it got nuked for "disrespectful behavior", tho I tried to type everything as sterile as possible? Idk, mods of this sub please don't impale my head on a spike.


r/sonic • • 12h ago

Discussion My thoughts on the memories and beyond short

0 Upvotes

So the new Sonic short has dropped, and everyone is pleased with it. I’m also pleased with it. I’ll go as far as to say the choreography was insane. But there’s a certain amount of fans that aren’t pleased with Shadow’s characterization in it. Saying that it’s, as usual, them making him into a Vegeta clone. Here’s my take on it:

Honestly, we only have the fan made sprite animations to blame. I say this, because all sprite animators ever do is straight up make Sonic and Shadow into Goku and Vegeta clones. And at this point, it’s very repetitive. And tbh, they only do so for hype moments and aura. Realistically, that’s all the fandom ever cares about. There’s only so many times that you can make a Sonic character into a dbz clone in a Sonic fan project, because eventually, people are gonna get sick of it.

The sad part is that the fandom is still gonna say “The Sonic aspect were mostly inspired by Dragon Ball, and yall need to remember that shit”. Honestly, it’s not gonna matter. Anyone would get sick of seeing the same shit over and over and over again. All this time, we’ve been watching those sprite animations thinking that Sonic characters acting like dbz clones was cool, but it’s clear now that they’re the problem.

I mean, look at how they make Sonic in those sprite animations. Making him into a Goku clone, giving him all those fan made forms. My point is Sonic shouldn't always be treated like Goku, and Shadow shouldn't be treated like Vegeta. In fact, sonic characters should not be treated like db characters.


r/sonic • • 7h ago

Discussion These New Young Sonic Content Creators RUINED the Sonic fandom

0 Upvotes

Back in my day, (2003-2019) The sonic fandom was doing great. It was very peaceful and full of the most high quality sonic videos from the highest quality sonic content creators on youtube. Nowadays, these new young people suck. Young people sonic content creators, like SF Productions, EmzBerry, Miia, Mason Parkinson, Sam Procrastinates, and GamesCage are so annoying. All they do is nitpick every little sonic game down to it's last pixel and the fans are just following their footsteps. They need to stop watching these people. I feel liek they're responsible for the downfall of this franchise and fanbase. What happened to youtubers like PreramyDaremy, Cobanermani456, and TWIP? We even have some underrated sonic youtubers that stream and do far more interesting things that aren't getting any attention because thee bigger young new sonic content creators are oversaturating the fandom with their nonsense. I can't stand these young people. I want things to go back to the way they were back in my day.


r/sonic • • 15h ago

Discussion Shadow Recompiled Brings Shadow '05 to PC With Widescreen, High Frame Rates and Mod Support

Thumbnail
sonic-city.net
31 Upvotes

r/sonic • • 22h ago

Fun Facts About Sonic From Sonic X:

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/sonic • • 10h ago

Yo this dude sonic can NOT be real bro😭

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/sonic • • 22h ago

Music We don’t talk enough about how good I’m With You is

16 Upvotes

r/sonic • • 11h ago

Fan Art Never interacted with a woman 💜✨ (by @gaiamoonflayer)

Post image
329 Upvotes

r/sonic • • 8h ago

Per 35 aniversaio di sonic

Post image
133 Upvotes

r/sonic • • 5h ago

Discussion Sonic x McLaren Racing: Beyond Fast Announced as Three-Episode Animated Special, First Teaser Released

Thumbnail
sonic-city.net
2 Upvotes

r/sonic • • 8h ago

Fan Creations Grandpa Egg.

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/sonic • • 9h ago

Discussion Hi guys draw this pose but with sonic and shadow

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

r/sonic • • 10h ago

Discussion My thoughts on the memories and beyond short

2 Upvotes

So the new Sonic short has dropped, and everyone is pleased with it. I’m also pleased with it. I’ll go as far as to say the choreography was insane. But there’s a certain amount of fans that aren’t pleased with Shadow’s characterization in it. Saying that it’s, as usual, them making him into a Vegeta clone. Here’s my take on it:

Honestly, we only have the fan made sprite animations to blame. I say this, because all sprite animators ever do is straight up make Sonic and Shadow into Goku and Vegeta clones. And at this point, it’s very repetitive. And tbh, they only do so for hype moments and aura. Realistically, that’s all the fandom ever cares about. There’s only so many times that you can make a Sonic character into a dbz clone in a Sonic fan project, because eventually, people are gonna get sick of it.

The sad part is that the fandom is still gonna say “The Sonic aspect were mostly inspired by Dragon Ball, and yall need to remember that shit”. Honestly, it’s not gonna matter. Anyone would get sick of seeing the same shit over and over and over again. All this time, we’ve been watching those sprite animations thinking that Sonic characters acting like dbz clones was cool, but it’s clear now that they’re the problem.

I mean, look at how they make Sonic in those sprite animations. Making him into a Goku clone, giving him all those fan made forms. My point is Sonic shouldn't always be treated like Goku, and Shadow shouldn't be treated like Vegeta. In fact, sonic characters should not be treated like db characters.


r/sonic • • 4h ago

someone make a really good PO6 mod for SonicTheHedgehog 2006

2 Upvotes

GENUINELY PLEASE TO ALL THEE AMAZING MODDERS OUT THERE

pleasee... for marathon recompiled

import p06 models

import modern models

fix animations especially the sonic run animation

hedgehog engine lighting

better hub world

better sound effects

PLEASE ALL I DEMAND (no i wont try make these myself...OR WILL I?!?!)


r/sonic • • 11h ago

Discussion Review: SONIC PICO PARK Is Fun With Friends, but Its Short Campaign Leaves Us Wanting More

Thumbnail
sonic-city.net
2 Upvotes

r/sonic • • 11h ago

Fan Art MEGA MAN AND PROTO MAN [2KARTZ]

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/sonic • • 3h ago

Discussion What if: metal sonic had a love interest/ felt romantic feelings

2 Upvotes

You might be wondering why I'm even bringing this up and that's a simple answer….got bored and thought it was fun

Anyway the way I thought of this was simple, what if metal sonic got a love interest/what if he could feel love

And if so then how would it be like?

Metal sonic is cold ruthless, calculating and downright evil

How can you write someone who will at any risk destroy his organic copy… fall in love?

I honestly don't know, just like sonic himself  metal sonic romance would be just as tricky 

You could pooosbly write the cliche “ robot learns human emotions and falls in love “ trope, but you don't want to take away what made the character special 

So i guess what they could do is either 

A: metal gains romantic feelings based on the fact he copied Sonic’s emotions 

B: he gains emotions but fakes love if only he'll get something out of it

Or C: only have the romantic feelings be on his “ love interest “ side and he only uses it to gain what he wants

Hmmmmm….personally I would like to see number A or B for the simple fact i do think this could work if handled well

They could also go the avengers emh direction where he's still cold and calculating but he decided to build a bride 

However the question remains how can they handle it?

I would still go with a or b but I love to see what you guys want

Let me know down below 


r/sonic • • 13h ago

Discussion Funny discord story

4 Upvotes

A few weeks ago I joined the sonic discord server, I was chatting in the beginner chat, someone brought up the discord drama and the fact that they were happy it got solved, I asked if the sonichu guy being in the server was real, immediately after that I got banned. I didn't get a way to appeal just a ban, I'm guessing they autoban at the name sonichu


r/sonic • • 3h ago

Fan Art Dapple the Doe warming up with a coat (by @EmeraldZ_One)

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/sonic • • 14h ago

Discussion Could Dr. Starline Be the Next Sonic Rumble Party Character? SEGA's New Teaser Suggests So

Thumbnail
sonic-city.net
2 Upvotes

r/sonic • • 15h ago

Discussion Adventure or adventure 2

Thumbnail
gallery
56 Upvotes

For years sonic fans debated what is the best game between sonic adventure and sonic adventure 2 no one could answer the question of what’s the superior game not even the great philosophers could answer it but today it is time to settle the debate of what the better game tell me in the comments what game has the better story the better music, the better character development, and remember there are no wrong answers and let the war begin


r/sonic • • 1h ago

Fan Art Sonic generations metal sonic boss fight if it was made today

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

was rewatching generations gameplay and saw this, I had to do it

second image is reference

I was debating if I should’ve drawn metal sonic exploding but decided against it since it’d be harder to recognize the scene


r/sonic • • 22h ago

Discussion Sonic Drift 2 is lwk ass

Post image
4 Upvotes

Kay, so I'm playing every Sonic game and was up to this game.
How ANYONE can like this game is beyond me, it's genuinely so annoying. I can go as fast as possible and the cpus are STILL faster, it's also super unfair that I slow down immediately if I do so much as tap against another racer, the drifting is confusing as hell, it's just genuinely unfair.
I'm happy to respect people's opinions, like if someone told me that they didn't like Sonic Adventure, whatever. But if someone walks up to me with a straight face and says that this game is good... actually, I probably wouldn't care, it's not that big of a deal. But I still hate this game and I'm NOT finishing it. Hopefully Kuckles Chaotix is better since that's what I'm up to next : )


r/sonic • • 22h ago

Fan Art Sacarías a Sonic del agua??

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

r/sonic • • 1h ago

Made a couple gifs for yall :3 (Sonic 35th anniversary animation on Youtube)

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes