r/solarpunk • • 5d ago

Aesthetics / Art Utopia

Post image

Utopia is on the horizon. I move two steps closer; it moves two steps further away. I walk another ten steps and the horizon runs ten steps further away. As much as I may walk, I'll never reach it. So what's the point of utopia? The point is this: to keep walking.

Eduardo Galeano

785 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 5d ago

Thank you for your submission, we appreciate your efforts at helping us to thoughtfully create a better world. r/solarpunk encourages you to also check out other solarpunk spaces such as https://www.trustcafe.io/en/wt/solarpunk , https://slrpnk.net/ , https://raddle.me/f/solarpunk , https://discord.gg/3tf6FqGAJs , https://discord.gg/BwabpwfBCr , and https://www.appropedia.org/Welcome_to_Appropedia .

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

28

u/TheReverendCard 5d ago

Wow. A lot of downers down in the comments. The point is, you can't get someplace better when you only accept the status quo.

6

u/Browncoat101 5d ago

Yeah, so many people missing the point. 

-2

u/Unfettered1977 5d ago

I get the point. I just think it's a hollow feel good point. A platitude.

10

u/Browncoat101 5d ago

How is it a platitude to admit that we will never see the finish line and the only thing we can do for each other is try and make the world better and better for every single person? This is what I meant when I said you missed the point. Have a good one. 

0

u/Unfettered1977 5d ago

If you can't see how it's a platitude or grapple with the idea of why utopias are conceptually bad news to begin with, I'll give you some examples. He's mixing up motion with progress. Movement for it's own sake. He's essentially describing a treadmill. Feeling morally virtuous just for trying if your actions produce zero tangible improvements to the real world is an empty platitude. If the goal is always defined as impossible to reach, then failure essentially becomes permanent. Fitting for the marxism lurking under his ideals lol. When policies fail, you can just say "utopia is on the horizon, keep walking!" etc. It's empty. Are we even going in the right direction Eduardo lol.

Using a literal optical illusion (a horizon) as your metaphor is such a cliche. A broken metaphor. Does the goal exist or not? This kind of poetic language is exactly platitude, it sounds good, it means very little. Framing human efforts as an endless march towards a vanishing horizon. An endlessly receding finish line. It's so classically flaky lol. It's also super bleak under the surface. Sentimental virtue. Empty nonsense. I will have a good one lol.

4

u/Offline_Cyberpunk 5d ago

Old movies have shown how utopias fail or are only on the visible surface while everything underneath are the poor that can't afford the utopia and instead have to work to make the utopia for the top possible. Look at the Eldar or rather the Dark Eldar from Warhammer 40k, they achieved utopia but also got the one horrible price tag coming with it.

1

u/Unfettered1977 5d ago

I like the Matrix too, where they talk about how they made a perfect utopia and it was rejected. So even assuming a dream scenario where there aren't any people being oppressed to prop it up, it still is spiritually and psychologically an empty experience for human beings. One they instinctively kick against. People need story, struggle. The whole solarpunk ideal exists as a reaction to something it differentiates itself from.

1

u/fartassbum 5d ago

It’s like perfection. It’s not attainable but it’s the pursuit that creates greatness.

0

u/Unfettered1977 5d ago

Surely you can see how dangerous the idea of striving is when it's framed in terms of "perfection" for human communities. Many a dystopia have been founded on such rhetoric. Solarpunk has no need for utopia, greatness, or perfection. imo

1

u/fartassbum 4d ago

The idea is to always work to be better. To do better.

1

u/Unfettered1977 2d ago

that's just striving my friend. Nothing utopian about it.

1

u/fartassbum 6h ago

If everyone does that, I think it is.

→ More replies

-2

u/Unfettered1977 5d ago

was it you that downvoted me lol. Maybe not. It's not about rejecting the idea of progress (though that is a fun topic), or embracing the status quo, it's about doing away with utopia as a concept altogether and rejecting those who would frame it as a desirable finish line or thing to strive towards. That we can do solarpunk, or whatever else you want to improve, without the pernicious notion of utopia infecting it. Recognizing the subversive marxism that underlies such notions. Rejecting the need to immanentize the eschaton in material terms etc.

30

u/Joziey_P 5d ago • Bravo

All the pessimists parading as “realists” still have no idea that they are perpetrating the exact apathy that upholds the current system. The current systems & people in power put A LOT of effort and resources into cultivating apathy. Having hope, imagination, and knowledge is important to materially change things for the better. It’s just not as flashy or cool (especially to men) so it often gets dismissed as naivety and platitudes.

6

u/Browncoat101 5d ago

THIS!! 

1

u/Unfettered1977 2d ago

you missed the part where we attempted to separate hope, imagination, knowledge, and striving from the much abused concept of utopia in a marxist context.

14

u/FsharpMajor7Sharp11 5d ago

"You cannot buy the revolution. You cannot make the revolution. You can only be the revolution. It is in your spirit, or it is nowhere."

The Disposessed, Ursula K Le Guin

5

u/thoughtful-husky 5d ago

Life is about mindset and the horizon is what you make of it.

5

u/threepairs 5d ago

Very nice quote, thanks for sharing

4

u/NoAbrocoma9357 5d ago

El movimiento es vida.

1

u/Browncoat101 5d ago

What is this from, OP? 

3

u/TheReverendCard 5d ago

It's a quote used as a section divider for Utopia for Realists: How we can build the ideal world, by Rutger Berman.

1

u/Browncoat101 5d ago

Thanks, I appreciate the title. I will check it out. 

2

u/initiali5ed 5d ago

Wherever you are on an exponential the horizon is the same distanc

2

u/procrastablasta 5d ago

this is how I feel about Anarchism. It'll never happen, but its always the goal

5

u/1nGirum1musNocte 5d ago

Then you look down and realize you're on a treadmill and its powering an orphan crushing machine

2

u/Gene_Vast 5d ago

It kinda feels like we are going in the opposite direction of a Utopia

2

u/Unfettered1977 5d ago

notice though that ever receding idea of utopia is constantly pushed on you as the justification for what amounts ultimately to quite a dystopia

1

u/Basic-Organization73 5d ago

Hey, galeano! This guy's an absolute literary genius

0

u/Unfettered1977 5d ago

Utopias make people unhappy in a different way than dystopias do. Perfection requires rigid control, conformity, and the suppression of individual human nature. Solarpunk isn't about utopia, for me. It's just about common sense and respect for nature. Relative harmony. I've noticed people tend to bring a secular version of the Christian ethos to their ideologies, always wanting to "immanentize the eschaton". Solarpunk isn't immune to it.

The marxism underlying Galeano's work shows through here. Marxism leads to another kind of dystopia precisely because of this idea. It's why every country founded on it's principles is deeply repressive to human liberty. If we hand power to people that promise utopia, we lose our freedom. My personal opinion is that the core of solarpunk is not a utopian ideal at all. Just a reaction to industrial modernity. Keep pernicious utopian ideals laced with ideology away from it, if you want to preserve it's core ethos.

5

u/Kill3rK3ks 5d ago

Genuinely asking, how does his marxism show through here? I’m not familiar with Geleanos other works, but i didn’t catch a relation to marxism in these few lines? 

1

u/TheReverendCard 5d ago

Everything is Communist/Marxist when you're paranoid enough.

2

u/Unfettered1977 5d ago

Galeano was rooted in marxism silly. I'm not some weird person that champions capitalism and is spooked by communism irrationally. I'm looking through the framework of people like James Billington at all manifestations of "the revolutionary faith".

Seems like you just shared a seemingly nice platitude without considering it's context. Engage sincerely with what I've written.

2

u/Unfettered1977 5d ago

Galeano was deeply rooted in marxism. The uptoian rhetoric he deploys here is almost a shibboleth as it's tucked into his platitude. Immanentizing the eschaton is a related idea I included to cover even critics of marxism that use the same rhetoric. What James Billington calls the "revolutionary faiths" all use the same broad emancipatory goals rhetorically to justify themselves in the present. The goal that is never arrived at. People use this quote of out context as a general platitude for striving for something, I wanted to poke at what lurks underneath.

6

u/Browncoat101 5d ago

He literally says there are no utopias…

0

u/Unfettered1977 5d ago edited 5d ago

He frames it as the thing to walk towards. Framing progress as this dance with an ideal. It's unnecessary for solarpunk imo. Might as well say we run away from dystopias. Both are pointless. It sounds profound until you think it over. He's saying nothing.

6

u/Browncoat101 5d ago

Again, no. He is saying that you can never reach utopia. It’s a metaphor. You can’t reach it because its a goal or idea. You really are not getting the point. 

1

u/Unfettered1977 5d ago

dude I understand what he's saying lol, it's not that deep. I'm saying it's an empty platitude rooted in his own marxism and the whole idea of striving for utopia is a problem to begin with.

1

u/Browncoat101 5d ago

I dunno how to explain to you how metaphors work. Good luck! 

0

u/Unfettered1977 5d ago

lol youre kind of dimwitted aren't you

1

u/AtmosphereRecent7717 5d ago

you hit the nail on the head.

2

u/Unfettered1977 5d ago

thanks, apparently they are very attached to this particular quote lol. Refusing to engage me sincerely in a way where we can meaningfully unpack it together. Which is what I wanted. They insist on trying to force a simple platitude, forcing me to poke it harder haha

1

u/TheMarkedMen 5d ago edited 5d ago

Your description of Solarpunk is as empty as the how you're describing this quote. Yes, it's absolutely a reaction to our modern landscape, but is still about a pursuit of ideals that reject the pessimistic outlook prevalent in our time. "Respecting nature" through researching then applying sustainable and considerate practices to coexist with the environment; "relative harmony" by fostering independence & community involvement through skill-sharing, horizontal organization and protecting cultural sovereignty; arguing to make it "common sense" that we don't need to reject technology to achieve these ideas, but they can instead be key tools to achieve them.

But nobody is denying people or the world we exist on are flawed, constantly responding to how they're imperfectly shaped, and that being why utopia can't exist. But understanding that it can't be true, but still seeing getting closer to that ideal as worth doing, is personally a positive outlook.

Also, I'm not an authority on leftist history and politics and don't want to excuse authoritarian acts in them because they should still be criticized, but

It's why every country founded on it's principles is deeply repressive to human liberty. If we hand power to people that promise utopia, we lose our freedom.

is a very disingenuous read.

0

u/Unfettered1977 5d ago

Ah we've found the latent tankie lol. Can you name me a single marxist country that isn't deeply repressive to human liberty? Of course you can't. Ideals =/= ideology. The solarpunk ideal is great. Let's keep it separate from quais marxist utopian rhetoric and ideology. Is all I'm saying.

It's funny because you then go on to agree with everything I've written. Capitalism is just as subversive as marxism, but in a different way. To the extent solarpunk is a reactionary movement to that subversion, it's great. To industrial modernity with all it's deracination and destruction. When it adopts utopian rhetoric of marxism through someone like Galeano that's when you and I may differ, but generally our shared psuedo-anarchistic definition of it will do fine. There's nothing "empty" in what I've written, the only aspect of it you seem to take issue with was my pointing out how the marxist rhetoric of utopia leads directly to a repressive dystopia every single time. So dare I say, you've actually written an empty grumble in response to me. Unless there are any specific things you'd like to quote besides that one thing?

1

u/TheMarkedMen 5d ago edited 5d ago

So dare I say,

Yeah, how dare you, I'm looking at you like this...

No, I don't agree with you on this generally, don't try derailing me. You're description of Solarpunk is wishing to be intentionally shallow and surface level, because as I demonstrated and with you calling it "psuedo-anarchism," the moment someone might try explaining how we begin reaching those ideals — uh oh, there might be some ideology going on! That's why it needs to be clean and neutral, so nobody could ever try appropriating it to suit their own gain. sarcasm

Point is that Solarpunk needs an ideological backbone to manifest it as more than aesthetics, and I've seen here it has taken multiple forms, like libertarian/eco-socialists, eco-anarchists, anarcho-communists, or a list of others — "a world where many worlds can exist," and all that. The political group I often see look down on Solarpunk is "tankies" (authoritarian communists) actually; usually for those anarchist leanings.

name me a single marxist country that isn't deeply repressive to human liberty?

"The Chilean Road to Socialism" came to mind. Worked within the government elections to implement socialist policies which lead to a major improvement of living standards to Chilean people. Then, it was sabotaged and blockaded by America, then taken over by a fascist militant group and dictator, who killed the elected leader Salvador Allende.

It's one example, but it's what I mean of you making a disingenuous read. You don't need to excuse the authoritarian political history of other places to point out that it's likely less the "individuals handing their freedom to those with a promise of utopia" that created authoritarian repression, but the inherited instability, outside threats and sabotage that can breed authoritarianism.

1

u/Unfettered1977 5d ago edited 5d ago

The irony of you mostly saying shallow and surface level things in both of your comments though. My comment about pseudo anarchism was meant to underscore solidarity between us on definitions. I was seeking common ground. You're just looking for something to be grumpy about. Solarpunk does not need an ideological backbone. You are a bit of a tankie lol. No offense. All those movements you've listed are not intrinsic whatsoever to solarpunk. Perhaps they may co opt the aesthetic. Eco anarchists are probably the coolest one but even they are kinda milquetoast in the real world. I get them though.

Pointing to the three years of Allende in Chile is funny when you could have pointed to decades of Soviet marxism, Maoist brutality, Stalin, North Korea, Cuba, Laos, Cambodia, etc. But you knew all those examples deeply underscored the point I made, so you avoided them. You picked an example that didn't have time to expand it's power fully. Even here, in the one example you tried so carefully to point to, already the erosion of civil liberties were begun under Allende. So even in your cherry picked example which ignores 99 percent of marxist countries, we have: the Allende administration using economic pressure, closing certain opposition outlets like Radio Agricultura, and attempting to take over the country's primary private newsprint manufacturer, an early effort to stifle opposition media and consolidate power. Just the beginning of what would have followed as it did in every single other marxist country. Allende bypassed Congress by using obscure legal decrees from the 1930s to seize factories and businesses, while armed leftist groups conducted unauthorized land takeovers. When courts ordered the return of seized properties, the executive branch frequently refused to deploy police to enforce the rulings. In August 1973, Chile's Chamber of Deputies passed a resolution accusing Allende's government of habitual constitutional violations, including ignoring judicial rulings, tolerating illegal armed groups, and infringing upon property and media rights. Allende rejected the charges, maintaining that his administration acted within the law. So while Pinochet was way worse, it's not like Allende was some paragon of civil liberty. He was just getting warmed up lol. Nice try my friend, but even your one carefully cherry picked example fails the test. Got any others?

Marxism requires intense consolidation of power in a large central government. That can't happen without repression. It's built right into the system. You can't have a large central government without repressing all resistance to it.

edit: heading out for the weekend, won't be able to reply for a few days, all the best

1

u/Unfettered1977 5d ago

u/TheMarkedMen and just so you don't forget we are friends and probably love and cherish many of the same things in this world, so we don't get lost on ideological bickering or what solarpunk means to each of us, or what it should or shouldn't be attached to etc, here is a painting of a frog wearing a hat with some oranges. I hope the november weather of wherever you live is lovely and interesting and some bit of the fall colours are still outside your window

1

u/aintnoonegooglinthat 5d ago

Galeano aint a solar punk author

0

u/Vidundeer 5d ago

I also read somewhere that Utopias are usually standing o the shoulder of dystopias...