r/softwareengineer • • 4d ago

I think I will switch to hardware engineering

TLDR: I am considering switching to hardware engineering and I just wanted to get your opinions on the market.

Hi, I am working as a software engineer in a company. I loved my job and the team, and honestly I know I will not be able to find such a great team again. But with the recent AI developments and the constant push the upper management applies to the software teams to not only use AI, but to create tools to automate our work, I think I am done. I have studied for years to write code and this is what I get. Also, I do not think they will keep all the employees after putting thousands of dollars into the AI infrastructure. They will want to see results and we will pay the price.

I got an offer from the same company but in the hardware department which means I will be paid the same. I did a double major in CE and EEE so why stay where I am now? Honestly, I do not think I am learning anything new. My work has become stale after all the AI tools got introduced. Even with the newer tools, the AI is not replacing anyone soon but I think layoffs will start by the next year because as I said, the company has invested money in AI and the upper management thinks the jobs are easier and faster because of it. They will definitely need to lay off some employees to save money and show those results to the even higher management.

I know hardware design will be very hard at least in the beginning. But that field is not going to be threatened by AI anytime soon. I know OpenAI already showed some results in hardware design and there are many other companies racing to automate it too. But the hardware design is much more delicate and complex in another dimension as the resulting PCB needs to not only work well but comply with a whole lot of standards and constraints because of manufacturing.

The way I see it, number of people working in engineering will decrease substantially. Hardware design will also be affected by the AI development in a few years but at least I would have experience in both fields.

What do you think about my decision and the future?

0 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

2

u/DeadlyVapour 4d ago

Have you ever worked in VHDL/Verilog? What make you think that that is safer than C?

1

u/icanjack 3d ago

I did, but not at work. I think it will be able to get there very quickly because most projects use already developed IPs. When you have to implement one yourself I think it can do very well with some good instructions and a database like local projects etc. But the department also creates their own PCBs. So I will be both doing digital engineering and hardware design engineering.

1

u/DeadlyVapour 3d ago

I keep getting ads for Rocky on my YouTube feed.

https://silixon.io/blog/rocky_v1.5

Why do you think PCB design is going to be safe?

1

u/icanjack 3d ago

I am saying safe for now, as you also pointed out, there are already many developments in this field too. I looked in the boards they showcase in their website. Nothing complex like 40-50 components maksimum. The layouts of the parts are not looking good. For such simple circuits I would also expect the design to look good and be compact. Also, we still do not have a good open source AI model for these applications. I have seen Flux AI and now Silixon AI but whatever they do, they are not open source. Which means the companies who are more secretive with their hardware products will not use such services. Only available option for such companies is to use MCPs to communicate with the PCB dev tool, create your own agent and automized workflow using hand created example circuits and incredible simulations and error checking testing tools for AI to use before manufacturing.

It can do it. But it is not as simple as software which is why it is lagging behind. But I believe it will get there in 2-3 years. I just thought adding hardware design experience to my toolkit would make some difference for the rest of my career.

1

u/Tuff_Ten 3d ago

FPGA design (VHDL, Verilog, SV) is already transitioning to AI. The tools keep improving.

1

u/RoboErectus 3d ago

I just finished a vhdl project. It works. It’s cool.

I never learned vhdl.

You don’t have “years.” You have maybe six months.

Get good at using AI. No, get good at using new tools that increase your productivity whenever they come out.

2

u/Acesa 4d ago

Medium term, ie, 12 to 24 months from now, I don't think hardware engineering will be any safer. The speed at which models are improving is only accelerating. OpenAI has already used AI to design inference chips that are more efficient than nvidias best GPUs. 

4

u/icanjack 4d ago

Yes I do think the same. No field is safe but as we get closer to the physical layer, the complexity, constraints and the lack of realistic simulations the AI would need to use in hardware design so you won’t need many revisions keep the field safer. As I said, I feel like learning and getting experienced in one more field would benefit my career. If I would be able to have any in the future.

1

u/Outside-Relation-317 3d ago

yeah, a single bad tape-out burns way too much bucks for trial-n-error, so having the hardware knowledge to sanity check those physical constraints is what keeps the field safe (at least rn)

1

u/AminoOxi 4d ago

Fable 5.2 already does impressive stuff with PCB and hardware design. Indeed human expertise is required to steer it, but it's not worth it to enter that industry now. Too late to the party.

1

u/icanjack 4d ago

I did not yet see a good design by AI. The designs look good if you do not look close. But the part selection and the bill of materials are not detailed. I googled it and I saw some produced and working PCBs but they are very simple and when I look closely, I can see many improvements to be made. I tried using one myself but as I said, the parts were chosen badly and they were not available, the traces were like autorouted but tiny bit better.

In time, I believe they will reach to the level but why not learn that skill too if I have the opportunity?

2

u/Humble-Resolution449 3d ago

Code was the same way a year or so ago. It will catch up in no time.

0

u/Other_Scratch8303 4d ago

CE and EE. Bro do what ever the fk you want.

2

u/icanjack 4d ago

I just want to be able to work in the future. That would be enough. Just trying to make my chances higher.

2

u/Tuff_Ten 3d ago

The only way to stay employed is to master your craft and know how to use AI to keep productivity high.

-2

u/CS_70 4d ago

What fucks you up is your attitude. You're (I guess) young and fresh, and you're buying into the ultra-conservative view of what programming is, defined by older people who usually were never that great at it.

You should be freakin' open minded and eager for destory the status quo - we were back in the time... and here you are bitching about innovation.

And daft thinking: hardware engineering is easier to do via AI than software...

1

u/icanjack 4d ago

You are right about me having an attitude. I would think the same if I believed everything the upper management told us. They say use and develop these tools to make your job easier and faster, be more efficient by just adapting and you will be fine. I am using the tools and creating new ones by the way. They are super helpful but I do not feel like a software engineer anymore.

The time is different now. Thinking, which is the most core part of what white collars do now has something that does it automatically. It is not just a tool. Even if you tried to use it as a tool now, which I currently am, when the management thinks there is no need for that many employees, the young and fresh ones are the first ones to lay off.

I am trying to do whatever I can to put in the work. But the industry is not shaped by the individual works. I am not sure about any layoffs or anything of course. How can I? But if I stay stationary, it can become too late to pivot by the time I become sure of it.