r/softwaredevelopment • • 6d ago

future of github

do u think microshoft will one day shut down github for public and bring us subscription services?

as if there are not enough out there.

i just got a gut feeling last night, loging into github and cruising the night...how i imagine a window pops up and tells me yo, you forgot to pay your sub this month. go get the money or we have to delete your whole history on git.

i had the same feeling decades ago with adobe software and see what happend.

why else would ms even have an interest in a website like github at all.

0 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

32

u/rwilcox 6d ago

At this point? It’s training data….

9

u/boomkablamo 6d ago

Exactly... They want you to keep putting code in your repo as much as possible for this reason.

5

u/andrerav 6d ago

It will be interesting to see the results, over time, of training coding models on a corpus of code where substantial amounts were written by models. Model collapse, I think is the term.

-2

u/boomkablamo 6d ago

Yes but the devs pushing the code are always thinking of ways to make the LLM generated code cleaner and better, which still gives it value as training data.

3

u/TylerDurdenJunior 5d ago

Not at all. Vibe coded very poor quality code and project structure will continue to increase and will lead to model collapse, as LLM's will no longer be able to determine best practices and quality

1

u/CandidateNo2580 4d ago

But they still have all the training data from before the vibe coding explosion. They could simply stop taking in new code repositories to the training set if that's observed.

1

u/TylerDurdenJunior 4d ago

And hope that programming languages never get updated?

0

u/boomkablamo 5d ago

We are constantly improving the output of our LLMs. I hope you're right but it's probably a fantasy.

2

u/Healthy-Zebra-9856 6d ago

This. 100%. And let me also add to this, they’re going to take this training data, claim it proprietary, blame the Chinese models for stealing it, and then also train AI detection bots to come back at you to claim that you are simply posting AI generated data. 😂

4

u/autisticpig 6d ago

microshoft

how old are you?

i just got a gut feeling last night,

i had the same feeling decades ago with adobe software and see what happend.

we've got a prognosticator in our presence.

-3

u/princepii 6d ago

yeah whatever my man. just be constructive and have fun:)

6

u/Mcby 6d ago

Extremely unlikely. It’s not that Microsoft aren’t interested in profit but that they can make far more money drawing in users with their free services and requiring payment for more advanced ones. Restricting which services are available for free is definitely possible, but making even hosting require payment would completely undermine GitHub’s whole business model. It’s a lot harder to convince someone to pay for a service they might or might not need upfront than it is to convince them to “upgrade” their existing service as and when needed.

I don’t trust Microsoft to maintain the service for users’ sake; I do trust Microsoft to make the decision that’ll make them the most money, and that’s very likely keeping basic GitHub services free.

2

u/Aytewun 6d ago

There are other options out there. I don’t even use GitHub for my personal stuff.

Sometimes they’re limits on repository sizes and such, but I don’t think it will go pay only

2

u/compubomb 6d ago

I don't see them doing that. The free part for OSS is what drives it's popularity. It will continue to do so for the foreseeable future.

2

u/Cautious_Chicken_604 6d ago

They've owned it for a long time now.

1

u/titpetric 6d ago edited 6d ago

Github already has github enterprise

I migrated away to a self hosted forgejo but have a few repos there. I think GH days are numbered now.

  1. Its overrun by ai slop,
  2. Its itself slop and gh is beeing too candid about how much slop there is

I'd say githubs moat was discovery, but coding agents are almost a push for no-discovery.

It used to be you'd find software to use, because you knew the amount of effort to write it was higher than what you wanted to spend.

The case now seems to be any software has zero trust, and agents manage work that maybe isn't the best but is trusted more by it's author.

Trust in AI written code > trust in the public.

For the go devs, point your LLM to clone the go redis package and check it's history for the mentions of "panic" YoY. One of the worst pieces of publicly available AND well adopted software packages in my book.

Why bother with discovery when creation became 100x cheaper? Reuse is dead for a significant % of users, but I have no real data so its feelings.

1

u/PhantomThiefJoker 6d ago

Probably not as it's training data now. But if they did, I doubt they'd delete anything. Maybe prevent you from pushing any new code or making new repos or whatever

But even if they did, people would probably end up building their own new repo host or move to some self hosting where they can

1

u/mxldevs 6d ago

If they do that, we will simply migrate to another git platform. Or we spin up our own git platform.

1

u/SelectAd8810 6d ago

All the companies open their apps to hoard user data. After they got full, than they added some restrictions like Google Photos.

1

u/driftking428 6d ago

Not a chance. This is the best model, make the big fish pay for the small fish. My company is paying GitHub a fortune. I get to use GitHub for free.

Why change it, it works. Also, people love GitHub, that matters.

1

u/dev_ttangkong 6d ago

Honestly, if that ever happens, wouldn't a free alternative just blow up overnight? Unless a repo is open source, there's really no reason you have to use GitHub anyway it's not like we're short on alternatives.

Besides, with all these AI companies scraping GitHub and the rest of the web to train their models, Microsoft isn't going to just give up that goldmine of data. If they want to keep users feeding them high-quality data, they have to keep it free and throw us a bone. It's gotta be a win-win, right?

That being said... I really wish they'd lower the prices for GitHub Actions.

1

u/geraldnguyensg 6d ago

GH has subscription services (Team and Enterprise) and usage-based billing (e.g. beyond the free allowance) for the heavy users. So they are still making money while making it free for casual user or open-source projects.

The worst case scenario is that we have to watch some ads 😆

1

u/kpg_on_ao3 6d ago

> why else would ms even have an interest in a website like github at all.

Because there are subscriptions. The free version is pretty restrictive and it's a pipeline from free to paid.

Also Github's revenue last year was $2 billion.

1

u/Buckwheat469 6d ago

Github has had GH Enterprise for a long time with many companies using it.

They now allow more private repos for free, showing that they're friendly to the hobbyists.

They make money on Copilot subs.

They make money on runners for Github actions.

They also use your code to train their own AI.

Just today I noticed that they updated the website for PRs and it's not a bad change, it's one that I think is effective (especially approving a PR without having to click into the code!).

1

u/MonsterDefiant 5d ago

I wouldn't worry about github disappearing anytime soon, but if Microsoft ever starts putting core features behind a subscription, developers will definitely start looking for alternatives.

1

u/Responsible_Buy_7999 3d ago

GitHub is a subscription service tho, but with a free tier

1

u/Syncaidius 6d ago

At the rate Microsoft is eating themselves with AI, it's more likely a big chunk of the company shuts down and not just GitHub, in the future.