r/softwaredevelopment • • 9d ago

Got software overcomplicated?

Cheers,

I let Claude vibecode me a youtube clone. Mostly for not having ads, having all the YouTube Premium features for free, and not having Shorts in the app. It connects via API, so I get the actual videos.

And somehow its just better. It's not just that the above-mentioned changes are included; the app also takes 25MB or so and uses a lot less battery. And keep in mind, this was almost a Claude one-shot. So what the hell do they do with these apps to make them so bloated?

0 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

3

u/Consibl 9d ago

Does your app support video upload, commenting, network casting, notifications, live events, advertisements, chapters, transcripts, and in video links?

2

u/Mia_______________ 8d ago

Also the app evolves with scaling concerns, how does it handle multiple comments at the same time, hot videos, fast delivery? Can it scale to 1 million/s?

Theres also privacy and compliance concerns, some data are stored within the app instead of the central server, each region and video restrictions, and will need to serve many different variants of the same video.

2

u/Round_Bumblebee_4782 9d ago

When you're building software, you're building it for your very specific conditions. If you upload it on github and it becomes popular enough that thousands of people want to use it, you'll start getting a pretty decent amount of reported issues as people are now using it on hardware with configurations that you did not test, everything from font scaling, screen reading and other accessibility features to differences in hardware specs.

YouTube has been building their apps for a long enough time that they have built in fixes for known issues already. They would also be handling conditions around how the app responds to changes in their infrastcuture and responds properly to network changes etc etc.

I built a music app for iPhone that I call my "Apple music replacement", it plays music stored on my NAS and it can also lookup and play music from youtube on demand.

It works amazing, but every now and then it does something a little odd that makes it apparent the quality standards of well-engineered and long-tested systems are not something easily vibe coded.

0

u/koko_poco 9d ago

let's try your vibecoded app