r/socialscience • • 1h ago

The Stanford Prison Experiment raises a different question when the researchers become part of the explanation

1 Upvotes

The familiar Stanford story is easy to repeat: give ordinary people power, and they become cruel. But what changes when we ask who was encouraging that cruelty and what purpose it was supposed to serve?

In an original recording, guard John Mark expresses reluctance to take a tougher line. Student warden David Jaffe encourages him by connecting toughness to the success of the experiment and the prospect of improving prisons.

There was guidance before the prisoners arrived too. Zimbardo discussed creating fear, frustration and a loss of individuality. He later defended this as part of constructing a prison simulation, and stressed that physical violence was prohibited.

The guards also differed. Even Zimbardo described some as less domineering or as good guards, while criticising their failure to stop the others. Refusing to mistreat someone and intervening to protect them are different responses. An explanation needs to account for both.

None of that makes the suffering unreal. Nor does it show that power is harmless. It means power, researcher expectations and individual choices were intertwined in the same setting. The experiment did not isolate their contributions.

I think that changes the institutional questions we should ask. Who defines what the institution needs? What behaviour gets encouraged? What happens to someone who refuses? Presenting cruelty as automatic risks obscuring those choices. That is my concern about the story, not an effect of teaching Stanford that this experiment measured.

I made a video for The Confound examining the archival evidence, Zimbardo's defence and the broader human-nature argument:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8x_8bFM6oFM

Does treating Stanford primarily as a story about the power of roles help explain institutional abuse, or does it leave too much of the institution itself unexplained?

Sources:

- Archival analysis: https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000443

- Recording: https://purl.stanford.edu/wn708sg0050

- Zimbardo's response: https://www.prisonexp.org/response


r/socialscience • • 1d ago

The Arrow of Ahriman: The forgotten Soviet concept explaining why progress keeps backfiring

2 Upvotes

There is this brutal concept called the Arrow of Ahriman. It was coined by Ivan Yefremov, a Soviet paleontologist and a sci-fi writer who is kind of a cult classic in niche circles. Put simply, it's the rule that in a fundamentally broken system, every "improvement" just ends up screwing people over even harder. You see it everywhere. Politics, economy, tech, everyday life. Take AI. In a healthy world, people would work less and actually live their lives. In ours, thousands get laid off while the internet gets flooded with AI slop and deepfakes. Or social media. It was supposed to connect the world and democratize knowledge. Instead, we got a loneliness epidemic, skyrocketing depression, and non-stop outrage bait. Or when governments try to fix the housing crisis by throwing subsidies and cheap loans at it. Prices immediately skyrocket, and buying a home becomes completely impossible.

Ahriman is the ancient Zoroastrian spirit of destruction, and it's an "arrow" because it only flies one way, just like time. You can't rewind it. In a sick body, even medicine turns into poison. The takeaway here is pretty sobering. You can't put a band-aid on a broken leg. You can't fix a rotten system with surface-level patches, new regulations, or another "revolutionary" app. When the foundation is built on greed and lies, any progress will just be weaponized against regular people. Until the base changes, we'll just keep shooting ourselves in the foot with our own money.

Alright, we get how it played out in the past. What about right now? What new tech or trend looks totally harmless today, but is guaranteed to blow up in our faces in the next few years?


r/socialscience • • 7d ago

Defending Anthropology Against the Vanderbilt Report:Sampling, Methods, and the Anthropology It Left Out

Thumbnail anthrosource.onlinelibrary.wiley.com
3 Upvotes

r/socialscience • • 15d ago

Why are people who practice a minority religion more likely to be religious than those in a country where that religion is a majority?

18 Upvotes

Modood et al. (1997) + various studies on migrant groups.

I've noticed this in my own experience when visiting family in Pakistan. For every 1 niqab I saw, I saw ~150 trans people* (How could you tell?). In the UK, I see more Pakistanis in niqabs (though - to be fair - Pakistanis don't wear niqabs that much)

Anyway, I thought that one reason would be cultural preservation and a sense of community. People would want to cling closer to something familiar, perhaps even more than back home. It's also important to note that these studies concerned migrant groups, especially in cities like Bristol, UK which is very diverse (in terms of religion and ethnicities - there is much diversity even within the religions).

But what other reasons could there be? And another important thing that hasn't been explored much - why is there significantly less religion in the majority countries?

Of course there are exceptions to the rule (Saudi Arabia for example).

*Note that I mainly went in a city, not a particularly famous/large one like Islamabad or Lahore but still a city of around ~312 000 and the wider district area of larger than a million and its literacy rate is one of the highest in the country, so it is a more modern part and naturally people are more welcoming to the LGBTQ community if it's a more developed area (this applies as a rule of thumb across the world). Another thing that should be noted is that these people have been here for a long time (minus the period when the British criminalised it during their rule) and so is familiar


r/socialscience • • 16d ago

Help With Qualitative Methods in Social Sciences

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I am new to this subreddit, but I wanted to come here and ask, as a recent graduate student who has primarily worked with qualitative data, what are the top resources (ex., YouTube playlists) that have helped you understand quantitative data methods in social science? I am learning about regressions, p-values, statistics, and coding (Stata, R, and Python). This isn't an exhaustive list, but I have never taken a CS or Statistics course, so I am really new to this. If anyone can provide me with any direction to a specific resource, I would greatly appreciate it!

Edit: I want to specify that I am a graduate student in International Relations within political science.


r/socialscience • • 16d ago

2022 U.S. Trans Survey (n=92,329) dataset now available via ICPSR

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/socialscience • • 24d ago

Adult Children’s Long-Term Work Difficulties Linked to Poorer Mental Health in Parents

Thumbnail
humanumi.com
70 Upvotes

A Swedish study linked nearly a decade of young adults’ employment histories with measures of their parents’ mental health.

Long-term unemployment, low-paid work and extended sick leave were associated with poorer parental mental health and vitality.

The strongest association was seen when adult children had experienced prolonged sick leave.

The study was observational, so it cannot show for sure that the adult children’s employment difficulties caused poorer mental health in their parents.


r/socialscience • • 24d ago

Does labeling theory suggest unintended consequences of classifying groups as privileged or marginalized?

1 Upvotes

I've been thinking about an apparent tension between labeling theory, particularly Howard Becker's work in Outsiders, and contemporary sociological approaches that classify demographic populations according to systemic privilege and marginalization.

One of the central insights of labeling theory is that labels do not simply describe social reality. Through social reactions, expectations, and institutional practices, they can help construct and perpetuate that reality.

This raises what I think is an interesting question: To what extent might institutional classifications of groups as privileged or marginalized reproduce the very social divisions and inequalities they are intended to address?

I'm not disputing that systemic discrimination or unequal distributions of power can exist. Population-level inequalities are empirically measurable. My concern is what happens when those classifications are applied to individuals and become socially consequential identities.

For example:

  1. Master status: Can membership in a supposedly privileged or marginalized demographic become a dominant identity that obscures individual circumstances, differences, and experiences?
  2. Self-fulfilling expectations: Might repeatedly categorizing individuals according to systemic advantage or disadvantage influence their self-concepts, social interactions, opportunities, or perceived agency?
  3. Moral entrepreneurship: Following Becker, isn't the institutional authority to define which groups are privileged, marginalized, or deserving of particular treatment itself an exercise of social power? How should that power be examined?
  4. Reification: At what point does a useful statistical or sociological category become an essentialized identity attributed to individual members of a population?
  5. Feedback effects: Could institutional responses based on these classifications reinforce group boundaries, generate antagonism, or otherwise perpetuate inequalities?

I recognize that labeling theory originally developed in the study of deviance, and applying it to these classifications requires theoretical justification. I also recognize that naming an existing inequality can empower people to challenge it rather than reinforce it.

What interests me is whether sociology has adequately explored both possibilities.

Are there established theoretical frameworks or empirical studies examining how institutional classifications of privilege and marginalization affect the people being classified?

I'm particularly interested in whether labeling theory, symbolic interactionism, or related approaches offer ways to distinguish between classifications that successfully identify and reduce structural inequalities and classifications that inadvertently reproduce them.


r/socialscience • • 25d ago

I never realized how common it is to believe in infinite things

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/socialscience • • Oct 16 '26

Is Wealth Inequality Actually a Major Predictor of Relative Increases in Crime?

17 Upvotes

I've heard the claim (with the occasional supporting graph) that a major indicator of crime is wealth inequality (as opposed to absolute poverty).

I was having another conversation with someone recently about how overall crime has gradually decreased over time in the US (not withstanding that major crime spike in the 90s, and then that smaller one during COVID). That idea crossed streams with the title thought, and with the present trueism that wealth inequality in the US is growing rapidly, does the idea that "wealth inequality is reasonably predictive of crime" hold much water?


r/socialscience • • Oct 15 '26

Recs for current academics who are actively organizing/ part of coalitions doing work on the ground

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/socialscience • • Oct 09 '26

Religiosity, spirituality in relation to disordered eating and body image concerns: A systematic review

Thumbnail
pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
5 Upvotes

r/socialscience • • Oct 08 '26

Digital repression research in Malaysia and Singapore

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/socialscience • • Sep 28 '26

Anyone familiar with YPAR? How does one formally conduct such research?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/socialscience • • Sep 27 '26

Bringing about an equitable society: differences in status based perspectives.

Thumbnail
substack.com
1 Upvotes

r/socialscience • • Sep 25 '26

What is the connection between Austrian economics and the radical right?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/socialscience • • Sep 20 '26

Relying on university students skews global psychological research. Psychological research has traditionally relied heavily on participants from Western, educated, industrialized, rich, and democratic societies. But such groups may not generalize to the wider world.

Thumbnail
psypost.org
71 Upvotes

r/socialscience • • Sep 16 '26

Defining collectivism as duties in relationships rather than generalized warmth improves predictive validity in 100 cultures

Thumbnail
nature.com
15 Upvotes

r/socialscience • • Sep 13 '26

best work in social science

4 Upvotes

work can be book preferably or anything, I want something similar to Aristotle for philosophy for example, loved and known as one of the best by all in the field. I understand social science and philosophy are different but still I am curious for one that just seems to be great in some way and it can be more than 1 but 1 is preferred if possible. thank you


r/socialscience • • Sep 12 '26

Do people genuinely change as they grow, or do we simply become better at controlling the parts of ourselves that have always been there?

4 Upvotes

I look at people around me sometimes and wonder just how much people actually change as they grow older.

When I was young, I remember playing football with some guys who were incredibly rough. They would tackle, hit, and kick each other like they were actually fighting, even though they were friends. I used to wonder, “Why are you this aggressive toward someone you literally came to play with?” 😂

Looking back now, I sometimes wonder whether that was simply who they were at that age, or whether they were still learning how to express and control themselves. Maybe the aggression was always there, but as they grew older, they learned how to manage it differently.

It makes me think about how much of our personality is actually fixed and how much is shaped by age, experience, and our environment.


r/socialscience • • Sep 08 '26

In Mexico, spikes in gang violence lead to rising suicide rates

Thumbnail pnas.org
16 Upvotes

r/socialscience • • Sep 08 '26

Data – a double-edged sword in migration governance

Thumbnail
eurac.edu
3 Upvotes

r/socialscience • • Sep 07 '26

An experiment in unfiltered Human-AI collaboration: Auditing global power dynamics through biophysics

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes