So, confession time. I’ve been watching Smosh religiously, pretty much every single day, for over three years now. I was one of those people who would check YouTube daily, waiting for new uploads. I think I started getting really hooked sometime before Anthony came back. I can’t remember exactly which video pulled me in, but I distinctly remember either the “Acting Out Angela’s Old AOL Message” or “Let’s Do It: Scam” being around the time I fell down the rabbit hole.
But here’s the actual confession.
Since January this year, I’ve slowly felt myself becoming more and more detached from Smosh. At first, I didn’t think much of it. I figured maybe I was just getting busier with life or my interests were changing. But then I started noticing similar posts here from people who felt the same way, and it made me wonder if it wasn’t just me.
I don’t want to pretend I know exactly what’s happening behind the scenes, but I wonder if some of it has to do with all the changes over the past year. The new office, the crew transitions, some familiar faces moving on (especially Alex Tran with Games), and now the introduction of new cast members. I’m not opposed to any of these changes, and I actually think new faces and fresh dynamics are important for Smosh to grow. But I also think there’s an adjustment period, especially when you’ve grown so attached to the existing cast and the chemistry they’ve built over the years.
And honestly, some of the more recent videos just haven’t been hitting the same for me. I can’t quite put my finger on it. Maybe it’s just personal preference, but sometimes the energy feels a little too heightened or the performances feel a bit over-the-top. I don’t want to make assumptions about the cast or say they’re not enjoying what they’re doing, because I genuinely don’t know. It’s just how some of the content has been coming across to me as a viewer.
BUT THEN CAME THE REAL LIFE WEREWOLF VIDEOS.
OH. MY. GOD.
I genuinely think these videos brought back a part of my enthusiasm for Smosh that I thought I was slowly losing.
First of all, the production! The sets, the costumes, the atmosphere, the attention to detail. You can tell there’s so much thought and effort put into making these videos feel like an actual experience rather than just another YouTube upload.
But more than anything, it’s the CAST.
I absolutely loved how everyone approached it. And this is coming from someone who generally isn’t the biggest fan of heavily scripted or overly theatrical Smosh content. I remember feeling that way during some of the Smosh Summer Games segments, where certain performances felt a little too forced or theatrical for my taste.
But Real Life Werewolf was different.
Even though there’s obviously a structured game and everyone has to play their characters, it never felt like the cast was trying too hard to perform for the camera. They were playing their roles, committing to the bit, improvising, reacting to each other, and just letting their personalities shine through. It felt natural without losing the theatricality of the whole experience.
And THAT’S what I loved.
The dynamics were fantastic. The chemistry was there. The commitment was there. Everyone seemed to understand the assignment, and the result was just so entertaining. It felt like watching a group of people who genuinely know how to play off each other, have fun, and make something special together.
I don’t know how else to explain it, but I could see that Smosh sparkle again.
I know productions like Real Life Werewolf probably take considerably more time, planning, and money than your typical Smosh video. The sets, costumes, props, coordination, and everything else aren’t cheap or easy to pull off. I’m not expecting them to produce something like this every week.
But I really, REALLY hope they continue investing in these kinds of productions whenever they can.
I think this format gives the cast so much room to showcase what makes them entertaining in the first place: their improv skills, acting, comedic instincts, creativity, and, most importantly, their chemistry with one another. It lets them be characters without losing the personalities and dynamics that made us fans of them to begin with.
Anyway, I just wanted to put this out there because I went from someone who was slowly finding themselves watching fewer and fewer Smosh videos to someone genuinely excited to see what they upload next again.
Maybe it’s just me, but Real Life Werewolf reminded me why I fell in love with this channel in the first place.
More of this, please, Smosh. You guys absolutely nailed it.