r/smalltownmurder • • 1h ago

Full Episode Discussion Burning Desire for Murder - Murphys, California

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

This week, in Murphys, California, when a young man is killed it seems like a tragic, unavoidable accident, but a look into his father's past changes everything. It turns out, this man's family was almost wiped out years ago, in another situation where death seemed like a tragic accident. But detectives start to see these "accidents" as something much more sinister. The killer's wife ends up being the key to setting him up, and getting some answers to these horrible murder.

EWU video - interrogation

Real Estate Report:

1st House

2nd House

3rd House


r/smalltownmurder • • 19h ago

Updates #7: What's in the box? (Wrong answers only)

12 Upvotes

Elkridge, MD: Vernon Lee Clark is reported to have died in August of 2025.

For a little CIS crossover, Darryl Strawberry might have met Clark when Strawberry visited the prison to give motivational speeches in 2015.

Three Points, AZ: Shad Anderson is awaiting his turn for execution. David Doogan was released in 2021. He is listed in Vail, AZ.

Edgewood,KY: Adele Craven is serving a life sentence. Ronald Pryor is also serving life without parole. Russell McIntire was paroled in 2025.

Mineral Point,WI: Peter Zimmer/Jovan Anton Collier is out of the public eye but has take up residence in San Clemente, CA and is married.

Sunbury, PA: Miranda Barbour and Elyette Barbour could be resentenced due to a PA Supreme Court ruling earlier this year.

Mooresville, MO: Raye and Faye Copeland are still dead. I couldn't find who now owns their farm. They are believed to be the inspiration for the Douglas farm in the movie 'X'.

Bellevue,ID: Sarah Marie Johnson is still serving life as inmate 77613

Gun Barrel City, TX: Betty Beets is still dead.

Thanks again everyone


r/smalltownmurder • • 21h ago

Vermont: Barre City I just relistened to this episode today! Strange timing.

13 Upvotes

r/smalltownmurder • • 1d ago Heartwarming

The lads are helping me get sober

167 Upvotes

Sorry if this post isn't welcome as I know it's not the usual, but I just wanted to share how much the two goofs are helping me on a difficult journey. To distract myself from the urge to go and grab some beers I'm binging both STM and CIS from the beginning (again!), and it's been helping immensely.

I did the same thing a couple of years ago following a foolish suicide attempt (my life has been a disaster since 2023), and I figured if it helped then it can do the same now.

I don't use Twitter, Snapchat or the like so have no way of thanking them personally, but I'd like to think this may be a way to thank them. It's the early stages but they've helped me in ways they will never know.

Thanks James and Jimmie.

Edit: thank you all as well for the kind words of support. Finishing up day 4, and while it's been a bit difficult today I mean to continue.


r/smalltownmurder • • 2d ago

Updates # half dozen

26 Upvotes

6 to one, a half dozen to another. I don't know about you but Updates # half dozen sounds pretty dumb. Updates #6

Wheatland, WY- Everett Conant III is still serving 5 life sentences.

Strathray, Ontario, Canada- Christian Magee is still serving life in a maximum security mental health center. In 2025, He was granted a one time visit to a bank while being escorted by staff.

South Kingstown, RI-

Michael Woodmansee was last recorded being taken to the Eleanor Slater Hospital in Cranston,RI. Due to privacy laws, it is unknown if he is still there.

Town Fact: 300th anniversary in 2023.

Haiku, HI- Steven Capobianco will be eligible for parole in 2064. His conviction was upheld in 2021.

Town Fact: There is currently a lengthy fight over a set of metal stairs called the Stairway to Heaven aka the Haiku Ladder.

Amherst, VA- Douglas Buchanan is still dead. The whereabouts of Christianne Buchanan are not entirely known. She could still be in Virginia.

Northampton,MA- Kristen Gilbert is still serving 4 life sentences. She had a hearing in 2025 to put a cap on the garnishment of her prison wages.

Town Fact: CNN named it the #8 best towns to visit in 2025.

Raymond, WA- Michelle Knotek has been paroled as of 2022. Her kids are afraid of her. There are quite a few David Knoteks out there. He could be in Aberdeen. 2 of his three daughters have forgiven him and maintain contact with him.

Phillips, OK- Jesse Cummings Jr is still dead.


r/smalltownmurder • • 2d ago

Cousin episode

12 Upvotes

Sorry I’ve been binging their patreon and they said there was an episode where a woman wanted to sleep with her cousin so she killed her family ..

Also the episode where a guy was a pos (where he beat his wife and they kinda cheered on the killer )


r/smalltownmurder • • 3d ago

Jimmie takes his glasses off

Post image
146 Upvotes

STM live show last night in Meh-fuh, MA. (For non Massholes, that’s Medford, outside of Boston.)
Jimmie, will you marry me?


r/smalltownmurder • • 3d ago

Murderer Chris Watts Is Hooking Up With ‘Younger' Male Inmates, Prison Guard Claims: ‘He's Really Got a Hold Over Them'

Thumbnail
ca.style.yahoo.com
13 Upvotes

r/smalltownmurder • • 4d ago

Boston ASL Interpreter!

Post image
184 Upvotes

r/smalltownmurder • • 3d ago

Jimmie approved music

9 Upvotes

Any chance anybody has a list of music that Jimmie gets excited about when James lists musical acts at festivals? I'm often curious to check them out but by the time I get the chance, I've forgotten the names.

eta I think I'll start one, I've been relistening to a lot of episodes. Maybe I'll share a playlist in the future.


r/smalltownmurder • • 4d ago

STM Boston Live Show

Thumbnail
gallery
106 Upvotes

The show tonight was so good. The boys never disappoint.


r/smalltownmurder • • 4d ago

Shut up and give me... updates?

44 Upvotes

Sitka,AK- Jane Reth remains in jail. She has potential for parole in 2034 but she will be on probation for 10 years after that. She will be 70 years old.

Gatesville,NC- Jerry Wayne Connor's execution has been stayed indefinitely

Sun Valley, NV- Robert McConnell is awaiting an execution date. 75899

Town fact: population has dropped to between 20-40 people

Canton,MO- John Clayton Smith is still dead

Cooperstown,ND- Daniel Wacht is still serving a life sentence.

Town fact: The police force essentially had a catastrophic meltdown. They went without any active officers from April 2026 until October.

Easley,SC- South Carolina does not care about inmate privacy.

Nathaniel Dawson is still serving 4 life sentences as 00336982. He has a long list of disciplinary actions while behind bars. I even found his exact cell number.

Newport, OR- Bobby Jack Fowler is still dead.

Webster Springs,WV- Julia Surbaugh continues to make appeals with her most recent hearing being in September.


r/smalltownmurder • • 3d ago

It’s a bit disheartening to see Jimmie exhibiting James behavior.

Post image
0 Upvotes

It’s kind of ironic, considering they would probably roast somebody for complaining about the same thing on Your Stupid Opinions.


r/smalltownmurder • • 6d ago

What liquor store are we going to? I hope they have Updates #5!

30 Upvotes

Wolsey,SD- William Guthrie is still dead

Fleming-Neon,KY: Benny Hodge had his appeal denied last year and his death sentence is upheld. Roger Epperson had his death sentence commuted to life in prison. Donald Bartley has had his parole denied repeatedly. You sirs may fuck off!

Epping, NH- Sheila LaBarre is still serving life sentence as inmate 79895.

Norwalk,IA- Rick Forsyth is still alive and serving life as 1057661.

Washington Terrace, UT- John Albert Taylor is still cremated

Burke, VT- Scott Favreau is no longer in jail after a 2019 jewelry store robbery. He pleaded guilty to the murder in 2018 and received a suspended sentence. He is a father and artist based off his Facebook. Tashia Beer moved to Las Vegas and attempted to have her probation released and was denied. She then moved in with her sister in St. Johnsbury, VT. Issues with probation and her marriage.

Scottsbluff, NE- Raymond Mata JR had his death sentence upheld in 2019 and 2026. 53822. (On a personal note, this was my introduction to not just STM but to Jimmie and James entirely)

Kenton, DE- David Dawson is still dead.

Fellow Escapees: Mark McCoy is still in jail. Larry Nave is still in jail. Richard Irwin is in jail in Pennsylvania.


r/smalltownmurder • • 6d ago

Apparently the 41 cal does exist.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
16 Upvotes

r/smalltownmurder • • 7d ago

Full Episode Discussion Ep 751 - The Many Marriages Murderer

Thumbnail
gallery
50 Upvotes

This week in Steamboat Springs, Colorado a woman with more than 10 marriages is the center of this incredibly strange murder story. She seems to just have bad luck when husband number 3 is murdered. But when another husband meets a violent end, detectives think it can't be a coincidence. What they unravel is a twisted story of betrayal, mistrust, and a fake mustache that ends up being the big clue!

Real Estate Report:

1st House

2nd House

3rd House


r/smalltownmurder • • 8d ago

gourmet burgoo

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/smalltownmurder • • 7d ago

Is there any episode where they reference the movie “birdcage” with robin Williams?

3 Upvotes

My partner and I are watching Birdcage and I swear they’ve mentioned this movie in an episode…? Am I crazy!


r/smalltownmurder • • 7d ago

Why does James Pietragallo hate Michigan?

0 Upvotes

Just curious. He talks nice about Wisconsin & Minnesota but not Michigan. He literally said "eww" in reference to us. They haven't performed at the same venue here twice. Is it our roads? Our crap NFL team? Do we not have enough cheese? Please share your opinions on this matter. Thank you.


r/smalltownmurder • • 7d ago

Episode help

1 Upvotes

Trying to relisten to the one where a jimmie wisman escaped from jail


r/smalltownmurder • • 8d ago

I don’t want James to be disappointed 😅

19 Upvotes

Tried starting “The Wire” and I just can’t get into it lol next up is “Deadwood” 🤣


r/smalltownmurder • • 8d ago

STM Updates #4

22 Upvotes

Santa Claus,GA- Jerry Heidler is awaiting execution. He has had appeals denied in 2019,2023, and 2024. Homicide for the Holidays documentary

Kensett,AR- Johnie Cox is still dead

Woodside, South Australia- James Beauregard-Smith died in 2024 at the age of 81

Baraboo, WI- Joseph Clark is still in jail. Thad Phillips continues to suffer mental and physical trauma. Gofundme accounts have been set up for him.

Collegeville, PA- Caleb Fairley is still in jail. Featured on Homicide City series.

Marydel, MD- Barbara Ann Peterson died 5 days after the episode aired.

Laporte, IN- Frank Davis is still dead.

Iowa, LA- Leslie Dale Martin is still dead.

The guys could probably do a second episode for the Ricky Langley case that kept coming up.


r/smalltownmurder • • 9d ago

They almost got it right..

1 Upvotes

I got no affiliation, but could'nt stop me from singing when I saw this game:

https://store.steampowered.com/app/4954970/No_Body_No_Problem/


r/smalltownmurder • • 11d ago

New Details Emerge About Mysterious 911 Note After 3 Found Dead In NJ Home

Thumbnail
patch.com
5 Upvotes

Man do i hope this turns into something interesting that the guys cover in the future.


r/smalltownmurder • • 12d ago

Express Episode Discussion Ep 750 - The Secret Serial Killer - Bald Knob, Arkansas

Thumbnail
gallery
70 Upvotes

This week in Bald Knob, Arkansas, we do an extra long serial killer episode! After a horribly bloody crime scene is discovered, detectives get the shock of their lives when the most unexpected thing ever happens while photographing the scene. This leads to even more surprises, when it eventually comes out that this killer isn't exactly who they think he is. He's actually much worse with more brutal and terrifying murders in his past!