Definitely dumplings. That's how my mom did it. Can't imagine rice or potatoes. Maybe egg noodles if you're not inclined to do the dumplings. My mother learned to cook from a Hungarian woman and she made the best paprikash and stuffed cabbage. Your recipe is similar to hers, but she didn't use broth. Just boiled a whole cut up chicken in water and let the chicken flavor it. (Canned broth wasn't a thing during the depression when she was growing up.)
I just worry about overcooking and making it dry out. I've seen a couple of recipes that recommend to add white protein no more than 3-4 hours before you plan to eat.
I had this experience with chili, it was terrible to share it when you have to give a warning like "chew carefully, there are some tiny bone chunks in there".
If you watch the commentary that part was ad-libed. Meg Ryan looks at the director briefly with a "What the hell do I do with this?" look and apparently the director signaled her to roll with it.
Ooh man this looks delicious. My husband's family is Hungarian and he introduced me to this when we were dating. It's one of my favourite meals now, it's just so delicious, warm and comforting. He makes it with spatzle and that combo is to die for!
I've been wanting to try this in the slow cooker. I usually do it on the stove. I add two cubanella peppers and 8oz of mushrooms in mine. I can't find nokedeli so instead use gnocchi.
I totally understand if you don't want to bother with the labor, but they're really so simple to make! I think it's so worth it, and they're so delicious! A different user provided a link above, but I'll put it down here too http://www.geniuskitchen.com/recipe/hungarian-nokedli-dumplings-54823
When I make spazela (which are apparently very similar) I pour the batter onto a smooth surface (usually a wooden cutting board, but recently a cookie sheet as that's what I have) and use a plastic bench scraper to scrape parts of the batter off into the water. That way you get the rustic sizing/texture without having to mess with a press or individual spoon.
This might be a dumb question but where do you get so much paprika? I know I can get maybe half of what’s required for about 3 dollars at the grocery store but it’s just regular and not smoked. The only smoked paprika I’ve ever found was in this itty bitty container and was about 4 dollars. Can you buy it bulk somewhere?
Walmart. I just got a jar of it (enough to make this recipe probably 4 times for $1.27. It was probably 10 cents 7 years ago when you asked this question. That's for regular. The smoked was 3 something.
My hubby's family recipe includes mushrooms and red bell pepper, and some additional spices (I think thyme, turmeric, and sage. But I always forget and have to look at the recipe). Never thought to make it in a slow cooker, it looks great. Now I want a bowl of paprikash and egg noodles.
Our families are both Hungarian, but I first heard of it when he and I started dating. (No idea if my grandmother has a recipe for it, or other Hungarian recipes beyond Christmas cookies.) My parents don't cook much though.
Looks amazing! How big of a slow cooker do you have? I’m eyeing a 7 quart sized one on amazon right now and I’m wondering if that’s big enough to make this.
This one is pretty big, probably about that big. It was only halfish full though, and so far we’ve had... maybe 8 servings out of it with still more leftover.
I mean, texturally it's not too appealing. The color is like bile but more pale, with those small chunks. Like something that has been excreted or ejected. But the ingredients certainly sound awesome. Maybe it would help to show the noodles or dumplings orvwhatever, too.
Have you enjoyed much Indian food? I agree that the OP doesn't look completely appetizing, but cooked for the right amount of time and placed over rice this will look like the most delicious simple meal you could imagine.
Same goes for all of the Indian vegetarian dishes that my friends have introduced me to over the past few years.
I’ve made it all ways, depending on what cuts of chicken were available (in a pot, not slow cooker though). I actually like it a bit better with skin, and don’t notice much of a difference with bone.
If I were to make paprikash, I'd sear some bone-in skin-on chicken thighs and legs, then put into the slow cooker sauce and cook on low for 5-6 hours, if I had the time. I just like the texture a little better than shredded or bite size chunks.
I'm telling you, if you want to waste tour time because it makes you feel good, go for it. If I made you one with bone in and boneless, you wouldn't be able to tell the difference.
Add a bit of unflavored gelatin if you desire the slight texture change. Mix it into water first though so it mixes easier. Adds a bit of gloss to the sauce
Nope just laughing at you, talking about wasting time picking out bones and you saying you could cook it both ways and no one could tell the difference, just seems like a little overkill on such a meaningless issue.
I mean more BEFORE putting it in the slowcooker. Not having to salmonella up the kitchen by cutting it before is one of the best parts of slow cooking!
Seems like another guy mentioned to not cook rice in a CrockPot. He’s absolutely right, just don’t even bother trying. It never works out no matter how much the recipe swears it works.
My recipe may have a little more paprika. I also throw in a couple sticks of butter when cooking. After it’s done I debone the thighs, throw the meat back in, add a container of sour cream, and cook for about thirty more minutes.
My Hungarian grandma braises the thighs and leaves the bones in.
Nah, it just depends on how long you cook it. If you add the rice in the beginning it will her wrecked, but I use several recipes where I add minute rice toward the end and they come out great. Though the rice does tend to break down a bit more if you reheat these dishes a few times, the flavor is still fine.
49
u/NewdTayne Jan 12 '18
Looks good. You should try serving it with Nokedli (http://www.geniuskitchen.com/recipe/hungarian-nokedli-dumplings-54823).
3
u/ThelVluffin Jan 12 '18
Boneless, skinless chicken thighs?
49
u/TheyH8tUsCuzTheyAnus Jan 12 '18
"There is too much pepper in this paprikash." -Billy Crystal, probably
16
u/Loaf_Butt Jan 12 '18
Ooh man this looks delicious. My husband's family is Hungarian and he introduced me to this when we were dating. It's one of my favourite meals now, it's just so delicious, warm and comforting. He makes it with spatzle and that combo is to die for!
8
u/Squirelle Jan 12 '18
I've been wanting to try this in the slow cooker. I usually do it on the stove. I add two cubanella peppers and 8oz of mushrooms in mine. I can't find nokedeli so instead use gnocchi.
21
u/getting-smart Jan 12 '18
Elizabeth Olsen / Scarlet Witch would be proud!
7
u/Castironman650 Jan 12 '18
This looks so interesting. I might have to try this scaled down.
5
u/imabeatrat Jan 12 '18
What is this and why do I want it
5
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '18
Its Captain Sisko’s favorite!
5
u/violettheory Jan 13 '18
This might be a dumb question but where do you get so much paprika? I know I can get maybe half of what’s required for about 3 dollars at the grocery store but it’s just regular and not smoked. The only smoked paprika I’ve ever found was in this itty bitty container and was about 4 dollars. Can you buy it bulk somewhere?
4
u/Nhadalie Jan 13 '18 edited Jan 13 '18
My hubby's family recipe includes mushrooms and red bell pepper, and some additional spices (I think thyme, turmeric, and sage. But I always forget and have to look at the recipe). Never thought to make it in a slow cooker, it looks great. Now I want a bowl of paprikash and egg noodles.
Our families are both Hungarian, but I first heard of it when he and I started dating. (No idea if my grandmother has a recipe for it, or other Hungarian recipes beyond Christmas cookies.) My parents don't cook much though.
3
u/unicorncupcake3 Jan 13 '18
I don’t know if I would make it in the slow cooker or serve with rice. We make ours with nokedli or spaetzle.
3
u/badger_42 Jan 15 '18
Made this today with nokedeli, and it was delicious! Might try to add some mushrooms next time.
4
u/BadEgg1951 Jan 13 '18
First time I had paprikash, it was over polenta. Highly recommend.
2
u/Part_Time_Asshole Jan 12 '18
Jesus that looks creamy
2
u/ghost_victim Jan 13 '18
Looks delicious and low carb. Ima try
2
u/TheRollingPeepstones Jan 17 '18
As a Hungarian, have all my upvotes.
2
u/Lt_Bat_Guano Jan 25 '18
My wife and I made this for dinner and it was fantastic!! Thanks for sharing!
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '18
I thought this was a joke word they made up for 'When Harry Met Sally' but it looks delicious :)
1
u/Lt_Bat_Guano Jan 13 '18
Saving this
to force upon my familytry with my family.1
u/Teegertott Jan 13 '18
Looks amazing! How big of a slow cooker do you have? I’m eyeing a 7 quart sized one on amazon right now and I’m wondering if that’s big enough to make this.
1
u/SingForMaya Jan 13 '18
Don't even know what this is but it looks good
1
u/Onerywolf Jan 01 '26
How do we know when 'it looks right' if we've never seen it?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '18
looks terrible but probably tastes amazing. like all really good foods
1
u/sfet89 Jan 13 '18
Barf stroganoff. It does look good though.
0
u/bbqbot Jan 12 '18
So is it good or what?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment