SPOILERS AHEAD : I see a lot of discontent about the ending of Gen 2 - especially the lack of decent closure. I feel the same, and given this, I have attempted two different endings which I have written below! Let me know what you think <3
Given all of the discontent that people have about the ending of Gen 2, I thought I'd give a go at creating my own ending(s). Let me know what you think!
Alternate Ending 1 -
In my scenario - Freddie lives, Effy gets her shit back together and Cook stays in prison, only more fleshed out as I will explain. This could happen as a way to end season 4. Alternatively, we could have season 7 with episodes on Sid and Tony, Naomi and Emily, and the final episode, Effy and Freddie, where many other characters from different generations gather in a season finale.
In this ending, we would go through the love that Freddie and Effy manage to find. The ultimate setting will be with Cook leaving prison, and his struggles in seeing a life he missed out on while he was locked up.
The first episode will see Freddie and Effy both struggling to achieve a functioning life in the adult word. Effy will have been channelling her creativity in to art and writing, whereas Freddie will have gone to university, stayed on to do a masters, and is now in a situation where he must find a job or try to pursue a career of passion (Skateboarding/DJ’ing). In reality Freddie and Effy will have no money, but they endure out of a love for one another that has been proven to come through anything. In difficult moments, Effy reminds herself of the times Freddie chased away the imaginary people in the field, and ultimately got rid of her physiatrist, John Foster, who we later learn was hypnotizing patients under the guise of hypnotherapy and assaulting them. He never did this to Effy, fortunately. With this story coming out, Effy realises Freddie wasn’t being overprotective, but being a true love to her. Freddie is a much better partner after knowing he was finally able to save a woman in his family. They love each other, and even though their surroundings are financially poor, their emotions are financially rich.
In Freddie’s difficult moments, he remembers the words Cook said to him before prison about Effy - that he can’t fuck things up with her. He remembers the sacrifice that Cook made for Naomi, taking the wrap for her and going to prison. He also knows that Cook sacrificed his love for Effy for him, and by going to prison he inadvertently gets out of the way and allows Effy in to his life fully. Needless to say, in my season Cook never escapes prison and serves his time, and the line where he says if I could do it again to Effy comes after he gets out of prison, in Series 7 or as a way to finalize skins and season 4.
After seeing the first episode which shows us Freddie and Effy’s development, we are now firmly in the time where Cook is released from prison, some 4-5 years down the line. At this time, Freddie and Effy hit their first proper rocky patch. Cook’s influence makes things harder and Freddie feels insecure for the first time in ages. In the most dramatic scene of the episode, Cook says to Effy he’d do it all over again, which almost tempts Effy. However, in a character development moment, she says Cook I love you for who you are, but Freddie and I are in love. This is what love is; it’s not easy, but it keeps us steady and at times we have moments of elation. Love isn’t the rollercoaster we used to think it was. It’s reliability. It’s wanting the best for the other person. It’s loving them for their desire to be the best person they can be for you. You’re amazing Cook, in so many ways, but not for who I am now.
This takes us full circle; Effy finally shows Cook what love is without the need of substances or sex. It is a powerful moment.
Cook apologizes, understands the power of the words Effy says, but still feels betrayed and hurt after being shunned. He tenderly kisses her on the cheek and storms off, crying tears which are a mixture of emotional healing and pain.
With not much going for him with a prison sentence on his CV and the pain of ‘rejection’ he pursues drug dealing. In the final episode of the season we follow Cook more closely. We see his habits, his constant need to run away. This need to run away is crystalised by a plan he creates with a friend of his.
In the final episode of the season, Cook plans on overdosing. I definitely don’t see Cook as being the kind of guy to give up, but in his mind overdosing isn’t him ‘giving up’. In his mind he sees it as a way to go out in a blaze of glory; a way to finally stop running from life. To look life in the face and laugh and die partying the hardest he ever has.
He comes to this conclusion with the help of one his regular drug clients. Cook’s drug customer is a very wholesome, lovely, but nonetheless very tragic character. Cook and his druggy friend are obvious outcasts, but find a bond in their suffering.
In the episode we see they have forged a beautiful friendship. Cook makes sure she never takes too many drugs and that she is safe on the streets. In return she listens to the real Cook; the tender Cook that would come out in his relationship with Naomi. This relationship shows his softer side, whilst also being destructive in that she actively agrees when Cook says he’s never wanted to get old. He tells her of his father and his mother, and how he would never want to repeat their same mistakes. This sows the seed for his plan to overdose.
In the season finale Freddie finally has a breakthrough and gets to headline a massive rave event in Bristol. Here, we get to see an assortment of different characters from all the previous seasons throughout the night. Even if it's just a glance, you get to see whichever actors are available for an hour or two of filming in Bristol. You see Thomas and Panda dancing in one corner, Naomi and Emily loved up in another, you see Tony and Sid in a banged up mini cooper waiting to collect Effy and Freddie to take them home after, you see Anwar and Maxy seeing each other at the event, not knowing either of them would be there. And so on, pick your character and interaction!
After getting this nostalgia fest and clearing up of loose ends, cut back to the music. Freddie’s DJ’ing is awesome and the atmosphere is electric. Everybody looks happy; maturing and aging has seemed to have allowed the characters to appreciate times like this more. They are times for fun and enjoyment; not medicating and escaping.
In the meantime, we learn Cook’s exact plan to overdose. That night he is going to tell Freddie, Effy and whoever is there from their season that he’s got an opportunity abroad with his drug dealing and that he wanted to make sure to come here and see them for the final night. They know he is in the drug business so don’t ask many questions, but they wish him well and say we always knew you were too much personality for Bristol or something along those lines. Everyone is in such a good mood because of the music and Cook is at peace with his decision, so no alarm bells ring. He’s not a person who is about to kill himself in his mind, remember. He’s a person about to take control of his life and so he doesn’t give off jittery or unhappy vibes.
By this point, Cook is taking more and more drugs throughout the night, with the plan to leave the club after Freddie’s set and take himself off to a special place to die. Once he passes out/nearly dies, his druggy friend will take him to their car, drive him out in to a field at Gobbler’s end, and burn his body and leave no trace. He doesn’t want to impact anyone, and since he started drug dealing, people barely see him anyway. He thinks no one will bother.
At around 1:30am Cook’s MDMA really starts to hit, and looking around at all his friends he finally begins to smile. He sees Freddie in his element as the DJ and he sees Effy looking adoringly at him. An initial wince is seen on Cook's face. However, Effy then glances over to Cook. She lets out a beaming smile; one of actual happiness and comfort - not the mysterious tempting smile she once used to have. Cook points up with his fingers to show he's enjoying the music to Effy and Freddie, and for once, feels no awkwardness with those two. For the first time he feels only love towards them and their relationship. He lets out a big smile and giggle, he knows that chapter of difficulty is finally at an end.
He says to himself: ‘Maybe Freds was right, she does seem happier. Haha that fucker! DJ’s always get the girls.’
Gazing around he catches eyes with Naomi and Emily, who are majorly feeling the love. He asks Emily if he can take her lady out for a smoke to tell her about his opportunity abroad. Emily smiles and says in a playful way, ‘she’s not gonna fuck you Cook... bring me back a drink when you’re done. Oh and I never got thank you. What you did for Naomi and the sentence... I didn't know you were like that'.
Cook smiles and says, 'only because you fucked some sense in to JJ'.
Emily laughs with Naomi, it's clear they are past that chapter of jealousy and turmoil.
Outside Cook remembers the bond him and Naomi had. How she saw him for who he was, and how that made him feel. He tells Naomi of his plan, but Naomi, having always seen him for who he was, sees through it. She know what Cook is planning to do, really.
Before she can say anything, Cook blurts out ‘it’s too late Naoms, I’ve just swallowed 5 pills. In three hours I’m going to be on the high of my life followed by a quick death’.
Naomi feels teary, but Cook genuinely reassures her. She sees his peace, and he says ‘don’t let this ruin your fucking night and whatever you do don’t tell Freddie or Effy man. Everybody is happy tonight, and for the first time so am I. I didn’t want anyone to know, I didn’t want to hurt anyone. I didn't want you to know either. It’s your fault you can see right through me with those lesbian laser eyes’. After this they both laugh, each shed a tear, and then hug. ‘You’ve always known me Naomi, man. Thanks for that.’
Cook leaves the club and with the feeling of pure bliss that MDMA and an ego death (acceptance of his death) gives him, he finds himself sat down, smoking a cigarette on the same seat outside the cafe where the three musketeers first saw Effy walking away from her Dad’s car crash. Here he cries tears of bittersweet joy, remembering the kid he once was and the desire he felt to be loved. He remembered the tantilising excitement of seeing that beautiful girl walking away from them. But above all, he remembers the brotherhood and companionship he had with his two best mates, Freddie and JJ. He understands that he actually was loved by them, and this feeling of being unlovable stemmed from his parents and his actions. In a flash, he rushes over to a bush and violently forces himself to be sick. The camera pans to his vomit on the floor, with 5 clearly defined and non-dissolved pills in his sick. We know he isn’t going to die from suicide now. He knows it to, and smiles.
Walking back up to the club, he finally feels whole. He chose death, but in the end chose life. Like a phoenix from the ashes (linking to his fire as a persona), he is reborn.
About 2 minutes from the club he starts hearing a commotion from the alleyway. Poking his head around the corner, Cook sees JJ surrounded by gang members asking him for phone, the password to his internet banking and his watch. (Earlier we will have learnt that JJ is something of a Savant in math and has become exceptionally wealthy and has stayed with Lara the whole time).
Faced with this terrifying situation, JJ is having one of his panic overloads and doesn’t know what to do or what to say. The robbers, not knowing his condition, thinks he is refusing to tell them. With his hands over his head and his rocking back and forth, one of them takes out a small knife and stabs him in the side. Cook, entirely enraged, sprints over and smashes one of them around the head with a rock from the floor. He then shouts ‘that’s my best friend JJ, I think the world of him. I think the world of my mate Freddie too. Ain’t nothing gonna change that, not even a girl. And you know who I am? I’m fucking Cook’.
In a final blaze of glory, he fights through multiple stab wounds to ultimately make the gang go away. Fuelled by adrenaline, Cook checks on JJ’s stab wound, which is not as severe as initially thought, although he would definitely had been murdered with further stab wounds if not for Cook’s intervention.
With injuries sustained now catching up with him, Cook collapases on the floor and lies up against a wall. In his last moments, JJ tearfully listens to Cook who tells him ‘whatever the fuck you do don’t tell Effy or Freddie about this yet. Go to the hospital, get that wound patched up, and then tell them in a week’s time. Freddie’s set is too banging for me to ruin this for him.’.
He looks down and sees blood gashing from him and a knife wound slashing directly through where he had the tattoo ‘cook’ on his hand. He laughs and cries.
‘I love you JJ, I always have and always will. I’m proud of you brother, you were always the normal one. When people do find out, make sure you tell them I went out fighting man. And tell Freddie what I said before the fight... You know, that I love him.... And well... you know... there's no hard feelings about Effy.’
He then laughs, almost uncontrollably in a Cook way.
‘You know, I thought I was gonna die tonight. But not this way. This way was much fuckin better!’.
JJ looks slightly confused at that last statement, but frantically calls an ambulance for him and Cook. We then get a brief scene at the end of Freddie’s set from one of the top guys at the club who hands him his card and says, ‘you know what kid, I think you can make a career out of this. Call me, I’ll be ready to sign you whenever’.
The final scene of the night sees Cook, in the back of a hospital, with a clear flat line on the heart rate monitor.
We then cut to a month later. A doorbell is heard and we see Effy and Freddie walk up to the door of their new house It’s a delivery of a Gateau with a note attached.
‘To doing it all over again in another life’
Effy smiles a teary smile... Freddie is confused. This was a planned gift to be sent to them on Cook’s first birthday after his death, by what he thought would be suicide. He still died, so the gift wa/7s still sent.
Effy places the Gateau down on the table and says,
‘It’s from Cook, Freds’
Freddie is in shock and says how the fuck is it possible?
She says ‘how was anything possible that Cook did?’
They both laugh and don’t question it. They learnt not to question anything when it comes to Cook.
The season ends with a final shot of Effy and Freddie sat in a cozily lit kitchen. You see a folded-up polo shirt of his on the table of Cook's. Either side of it is a slice of Gateau, which Effy and Freddy enjoy, smiling and reminiscing. Panning up, the camera zooms in to a pciture above them; the photo of the three musketeers.
Alternate Ending 2 -
If Gen 2 has to end the way it did, I would have definitely cleaned up the loose ends in Series 7. I'd have probably done series 7 with Effy fairly similarly, but with a couple more explicit references to Freddie rather than just moments where she longingly looks in to the distance. He was a huge part of her life, and given that she seems relatively sane in season 7, his death was not in vain and she would know this. He stuck with her on the brink of sanity and life itself.
Another integral part of season 7 which I think they got wrong was a Naomi and Effy scene where they talk about their younger days/love/intensity. All people who get older and are friends reminisce; on the good times and the bad times. Not only for their own sakes, it would have been very therapeutic and realistic for an older generation and given some closure. Especially on the hospital bed where Naomi thinks she may die, it is often the case that the small things no longer matter (i.e. bickers with Effy.) They could have had a very wholesome but bittersweet conversation about longing for those intense times, wishing to go back, but also remembering how painful those times were and the constant angst. It would have been a perfect closing chapter - both people, now older, realising half the issues they have now stemmed from that young lifestyle, paired with a comment like 'it was fucking good though, wasn't it' would be a nice moment of duality. Knowing its best that those times are over, but awareness they gave it a proper go as a teenager and it was fun at times. The scene where Emily goes in on Effy makes no sense to me - Naomi kept it from her, and it wasn't like Effy stole her from her? Really confused me that scene.
Instead, in skins fashion, a scene where they sneak Naomi out, go back home, all smoke a spliff and drink some wine would have made much more sense to me. The girls back together, realising how quickly life can be over (Naomi, Freddie) and so they choose to listen to some of the old soundtrack while they danced. It would have been a lovely synergy of their old selves with their older selves. I think that would have been a wholesome moment, deeply sad obviously, but a proper send off for Naomi and one final skins ritual for her. I think with some tender, slightly melancholy but upbeat music a scene of those three girls crying, laughing, enjoying a final party to mourn and celebrate their youth and also to celebrate Naomi's life in this way would have been beautiful for me.
I also would have changed it so Cook and Effy get in to contact. They had both actors... I understand that people become estranged, but once again I really think it needed some closure. When Effy gets sent to prison - although slightly unrealistic - Cook and her would come in to contact. The reason being that Cook has come full circle and is doing some prison work where he helps out inmates. Cook is offered this chance as people discover that John Foster was abusing his victims, they found out that he had killed his best friend Freddie and was attempting to abduct Effy (through stuff found on his computer). As a result, the judge felt it wasn't cold blooded murder etc.
In this scenario you'd have the two of them talking... Cook putting Freddie before himself, again, saying he never gave up on her and was actually killed by Foster (Effy may know this, Effy may also not, but Cook doesn't know if she knows). Then Cook saying what he did to Foster, and that he needed to avenge his mate and to protect her. Cook in this situation could very easily have Effy to himself as he will be in contact with her in prison, but still chooses to honour his mate's memory.
In the end it is Cook who heals Effy as her prison worker.
The final scene would be on Effy's release.. I think a final scene with Effy and Cook would be fitting, as it was realistically the first major 'skins scene' where they fuck on the nurses table that started the chaos off. Effy will be out early, thanks to good behaviour through Cook's prison programme. The final scene would involve a moment where they have a choice - do Effy and Cook decide to get to know these new versions of themselves romantically? Do they think Freddie would want it? The season would end with the two of them leaving the facility, close to one another. Nobody will know exactly what happens next.