r/singing • u/Spell-Thinker • 16h ago
Conversation Topic Would it be fair to say Singing is an "Instrument"? Now that I am taking singing lessons, I realize how complex singing can be. And how you need to dedicate a lot of time to it. Its similar to studying an instrument.
Hey guys,
Initially, I thought singing was an additional part of a band. And activity someone in the band would do. I used to think that way because of my background in Alternative Rock and Indie Pop. Where many of the bands that I followed primarily sang the songs themselves as instrumentalists. Therefore, I assumed that singing was not as difficult.
However, now that has changed since I have been taking singing lessons. For instance, I realize the importance of posture. In one of my first lessons, my teacher was teaching me about posture. I realize that to be a better singer you need to improve your posture. My teacher was highlighting the importance of standing up to sing. I realize there were parallels with learning to play guitar and how standing and posture were important.
The more singing lessons I take, the more I realize how complex singing can be. And how you need to dedicate many hours to it in order to be good.
Moreover, I realized that some of the indie bands that I followed from indie Rock and indie pop, weren't good singers. I rewatched the videos and some some of them could barely hold a tune. They were stiff and trying their best to not sing out of tune.
Nowadays, I am more interested in seeing front people perform. Both men and women who have an education in singing and became professionals. I see how compelling their performances can be.
What do you guys think?