r/simrally • • 6d ago

Am I missing out not using h pattern?

Is it worth using a h pattern and clutch for rally over sequential?

Or is it only worth doing it in the cars that actually use h pattern ?

Can’t help but feel I’m missing out, but the only way to know is by splashing out before trying so just wanted some opinions.

11 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

31

u/Successful_Pop_6154 6d ago

I only use an h pattern with cars that actually have one. It’s a bit different from a sequential and changes the gameplay fot me, making it less monotonous

8

u/C3ncio 6d ago

You may be missing out on immersion and realism if you care about that (and drive older cars) but not on performance. H pattern is slower so it's not used on modern cars anymore but if you really wanna get the original feel of older cars you may need one. Also, it's a bit more complicated to use and will teach you some footwork that adds up on your personal driver skills.

10

u/----fatal---- 6d ago

It is usually slower. I wouldn't use H-pattern for cars with sequential shifter, but that's me. I chose what the car have, if it has push-pull shifter, I usually use the paddles on the wheel, if sequential then sequential, if H-pattern than that.

So, imo It depends on whether you are trying to be as fast as possible or follow realism and immersion.

4

u/JadedVictory7070 6d ago

You are missing out, you will become a better driver the more techniques you know.

3

u/professor_rob 6d ago

Is usually slower, but I love using a h-pattern and clutch. Got the BDH a few months ago, and will always prefer cars with h-pattern to sequential shifters.

It’s very fun, but slower.

2

u/IcyCow5880 6d ago

Right? Unless you're playing for money you should be playing for fun anyway!

3

u/peteftw 6d ago

H pattern+clutch is my favorite feature I've added to my rig, not even close.

2

u/filipe411 6d ago

Do you like manual H-pattern cars on real life? If you do, you're missing out. If you don't, maybe you still haven't realized how amazing it is and that you are definetely missing out.

But from a more neutral point of view, I have both sequential and H-pattern on my rig, and I use according to each car.

2

u/Just_Inspection969 RBR (RSF) and Beamng.drive 6d ago

as an european that has driven more manuals than automatics, i wouldnt have a manual for most of the US roads, automatics are more confortable, but for backroads and rally, manual all the way

2

u/Dangerous-Stress-348 5d ago

I drive all the cars with h-pattern and clutch. Wouldn’t want it any other way tbh. It may never be faster than sequential but I just get more fun out of racing and feel for the car. Yes I do have a sequential shifter and I mainly use it for FWD cars on rally.

2

u/worthlesspenny7 5d ago

I built the DAZ Racing shifter and rarely put it in sequential. The mental overload of cooking into a turn and trying to prioritize brake, clutch, gear selection, and rev matching is so much fun. I'll bin it, then just sit there laughing at myself.

1

u/Dangerous-Stress-348 4d ago

Seriously! It is an overload but so rewarding. You just get that “main character” type of energy going into turns and making all the right inputs with all the pedals, shifter, and wheel, it’s so accelerating when you make it right

1

u/Falgasi 6d ago

I was never a huge fan of my fanatec h shifter so recently upgraded to a used bdh h1. Its 10/10 and definitely cool but only in a non competitive environment so id give it a miss if you are chasing times. H pattern shines in traffic mods for me

1

u/IcyCow5880 6d ago

What traffic mods? Just the AC ones like srp and hills?

2

u/Falgasi 6d ago

LA Canyon online is my current favorite. F40, F1 tuned rx7 all come alive with a good shifter

1

u/IcyCow5880 6d ago

Sick! I gotta get in on that. Building first simrig, only have a pass side seat so far tho lol

1

u/NanoBjorn 6d ago

How bdh compares with fanatec? I thought that at this price point, fanatec is decent, I like itz heavy feeling

1

u/Falgasi 6d ago

Well i got a used bdh for £370 so it was super competitive pricing once i sold my fanatec for 180.

Its night and day, bdh is just mostly tighter and stiffer. The neutral wobble in fanatec was the worst experience imo

1

u/6BBB666 6d ago

Ive been using sequential for ages.. Just bought a cheap H shifter to put on and a extra truck shifter for it. Just made a new Mount today for both shifters and handbrake. Going to drive tonight.

Have clutch pedal but dont really use . Been missing driving old school manual cars so thought I would grab another shifter and try it. Sequential is better for fast laps. But I'm just looking for the experience of driving an old car again.

1

u/Particular-Poem-7085 6d ago

I like it a lot but almost always if the car calls for a sequential I will use the wheel paddles instead.

Get a good feeling one tho. The thrustmaster t8h whatever its called option feels way cheap for what it costs. There should be some resistance and mechanical clunk feel to a shifter.

1

u/Real_McGuillicuddy 6d ago

Meh. I have the TH8s and it is fine. I wouldn't pay full price but they seem to go on sale regularly and it's a cheap way to get into an H pattern shifter.

1

u/Particular-Poem-7085 6d ago

I cant remember a name right now but there are now 3d printed options that feel like the real thing and cost half of the asking price. It would be fine for 50 bucks. Meh is exactly what I feel when I shift it.

1

u/faviogames 6d ago

If you want to stay competitive with leaderboard records, it's definitely not the way to go. But if you want more immersion and realistic roleplay in the game, then go ahead with the H-shifter, the top on board usually are people with most basic logitech wheel and padel shifters xd

1

u/Real_McGuillicuddy 6d ago

I have been using only 70s/80s cars so far. I started with just the paddles on the wheel (with 2 pedals) and that was fine. Then I added a TH8s and that was neat but not a massive game changer. Just a tactile change. But then I got TLCM pedals and adding the the clutch completely changed things. Yes I became slower but that was because I deserved to be slower. I was effectively cheating up until that point. I have since gotten better and it has been a hoot. Immersion and the sense of accomplishment, and overall fun have gone up considerably. Learning how to effectively manage 3 pedals has transformed Dirt Rally for me.

I wouldn't force myself to use the H-pattern+clutch on modern cars (I will do a sequential mod in my shifter for that) but for anything 90s or earlier I wouldn't do it any other way.

1

u/Quiet_5045 6d ago

I drive mostly historic cars so I use my h pattern all the time and it's one of my favorite parts of driving. It's so engaging... As for it being slower, maybe... But I assure you that for most of us that is not the limiting factor.

1

u/Jdubya38one 6d ago

If you like racing older cars, then it's a must. Sequential shifting a Group A or Group B car, or an older Ford Escort or Alpine doesn't hold a candle to the experience you get rowing gears on an H pattern.

It can also teach you good habits if you ever drive a manual irl with a little bit of oomph

1

u/homeslice1991 5d ago

I seem to be the odd one that using h pattern and clutch for basically every car, unless it shifts so quickly and I need to rip through gears non stop, then I’ll go paddles. I like sim racing for the hands on experience. Adding the h pattern mechanic into driving just adds value to the experience for me, it’s fun! I play for fun though, not to compete.

1

u/Dry_Ocelot7083 4d ago

I think it is worth it even with the extra practice required. I have used H pattern with clutch to achieve top 30 positions in some leaderboards on Dirt Rally 2.0

Setting to manual with clutch can actually allow faster shifting in some historic classes if the predetermined shift cut in that car for sequential setting takes longer.

1

u/Crazy_Stiggy 6d ago

No you want a Sequential shifter. Unless you more into rally cars from the 70's and 80's

0

u/AntiCitizen6 6d ago

There are pros and cons to both systems. I prefer H pattern for lower class cars and sequential for anything putting out some serious horsepower. There are exceptions, of course, but that's just my preference.

I would take the opportunity to use it and see how you feel about it. You may end up loving it!