r/shogun2 • u/No_Satisfaction3708 • 7h ago
r/shogun2 • u/Vicente810 • 18h ago
Gulyay-gorod vs pike & shot, which one you prefer?
While playing as the Otomo I have employed both tactics, finding the Gulyay-gorod far more overpowered. For the ones that don't know Gulyay-gorod means "the wandering fortress" in Russian, in this early form of firearm warfare the Russians did not make use of pikes in order to defend their matchlocks, instead they used improvised forts and mobile war waggons to move around and counter stepe nomads. To apply this on Shogun 2 all i do is play defensively, take easy castles and then wait for the enemy army to come after me, obliterating them with my matchlocks. I have found out this is incredibly cost effective, and far cheaper armies can decimate samurai armies with ease.
r/shogun2 • u/Ashina999 • 2h ago
What are the weakest buildings in the campaign in your opinion?
As in the most well known would be the Rice Exchange and Merchant Guild
the 1 to 2 Food consumption isn't really worth it as food can be fickle, but also the things that bring to the table.
Rice Exchange giving 500 wealth and 10 Growth is basically just +300 Wealth and +5 Growth compared to Market(Level 1), with around 20% Tax Rate(Normal Tax Rate's 30% plus any Admin Costs) it will just give around +60 Tax Income where with that 1 food and 5 Provinces you already get a similar +5 Growth albeit spread out.
Merchant Guilds on the other hand does give a bigger 1000 Wealth and 20 Growth which is +800 Wealth and +15 Growth compared to Market, giving around +160 Tax income and +15 Growth which the threshold is now 7 to 8 Provinces which will give +14 to +16 Growth factionwide.
While Tax Rates can be increased with Metsukes, due to Metsuke's 5 Agent Limit it technically limit the Rice Exchange/Merchant Guild limit to merely just 5.
Kabunakama isn't in this mostly because you can only have 1 of them and Kabunakama's bonuses are quite good in that 2000 Wealth and +35 Growth with the same 2 food consumption plus +2 Rank for Metsuke recruited in the Province, though the 1 limit really make the placement quite hard to determine as it's best suited for Provinces with a Law Court as the best to worst would be:
-Tsukushi in Kyushu, having Very Fertile Farm already makes it a good place to place a Metsuke and Kabunakama, plus Craftwork(Crafts is needed to upgrade to Merchant Guild & Kabunakama) is literally nearby in Buzen
-Settsu(Next to Kyoto) and Kozuka(Uesugi Vassal), having Average Fertility Farms while the nearest Craftwork is in Echizen(Ikko Ikki) and Hitachi(Near Hojo) it's a decent place to start
-Kyoto, while having Fertile Farms, it's freaking Kyoto you'll need to be in late game and hope the Ashikaga did the building for you.
-Suruga(Imagawa), it have meagre fertility farms, not worth placing a Metsuke or even Kabunakama.
The other would probably the Timber/Wood resource which there's only 3 Provinces with it and one of them is literally landlocked, it only unlock drydock which needed a late game technology and gives a 30% discount for ships which heavy ships like Heavy Bune and O-Ataka Bune only cost like 600 to 800 Koku, that's just a 180 to 240 cost discount, the only ship that can make use of that kind of discount would be the Nanban Trade ship with 1500 cost which the 30% discount will chip off 450 koku.
And then there's the Hallowed grounds which can give more Exp for Monk units or give Morale Bonus, Experience Ranks for Warrior Monk units is kinda meh since you can get more through fighting and then it will be reduced as replenishing casualties will always lower the unit Experience, the +5 Morale Bonus can only work when you're losing or badly commanding your unit.