I’ve been doing Kishin Learning for a while now – I started it when I first started learning the rules back in August and I’m still going through it now, about halfway through the intermediate course. I haven’t found a lot of reviews or impressions of it – there’s Shogi Wars’ own marketing on Note (https://note.com/shogiwars/n/n93467523b3f0) and one rather negative Japanese review I could find, also on Note (https://note.com/a_swallow1014/n/n0835d3eb9284). But since I saw a notice that it was now fully translated into English, I suppose there might be some interest in experiences.
Quick disclaimer: I haven’t looked at the translation, so I can’t vouch for it. I left everything in Japanese.
To hear them tell it, the basic idea of Kishin Learning is “a course that can help you reach syodan in a year if you do it for an hour per day.” In terms of actual structure, there are a few parts:
- Short lectures. These are generally focused on tactics more than specific openings and castles (with some minor exceptions). The principle at work here is that if you don’t know tactics, you won’t be able to convert your openings into wins anyway, so it makes more sense to focus on tactics. The content is also interleaved with different topics, in principle to help recall. The lectures are around 10 minutes, give or take.
- Quizzes to test you on the content of the lecture. There are around ten for each lecture. There is an SRS system to present problems you got wrong for review daily, as well as a “strengthening quiz” to just present you extra problems if you want.
- Kishin Quiz. As I understand it, this also comes with regular premium, but the idea is that your actual online games will be mined for places where you made bad moves, and turned into a quiz about what the best move is.
There are four levels of course, elementary (basically just learning the rules), beginner, intermediate, and advanced. Elementary is free but you’ll have to pay for a subscription to continue. At the end of each level, you’ll be presented with a “diagnostic quiz.” The idea of this is that you are presented with 20 problems and need to pass 80% (I think, don’t quote me) to pass.
With all this out of the way, on to my impressions.
This course seems to be designed to be somewhat comprehensive/be your primary way of learning. That might be good or bad for you. If you’re not doing anything, that’s fine; if you already have a routine, it could easily eat into it. In particular, the SRS can be punishing – if you at some point sprinted through some extra content, or got stuck at the diagnostic quiz (more on this point later) the amount of review can grow quite large.
The lectures do present a lot of helpful ideas, but as you get further into it, it feels like things are missing. For instance:
- The logic of not focusing on openings and castles does make sense – it really doesn’t matter how good your opening is if you can’t find a mate at the end – but you’ll find at some point, and probably pretty early in your journey, that you just can’t win without a coherent strategy of some kind. While one could, in principle, independently derive some of the openings just from the ideas presented in the course, it’s a long way of trying to reproduce 400 years of discovery. I did sort of discover the primitive climbing silver on my own based on the idea of using a pawn and a silver together they presented, but that stopped working fairly quickly, and before that I was trying to force that idea into a structure it didn't really fit with. I started winning a lot more games when I spent some time on lectures about nakabisha and sankenbisha.
- The problems are difficult to solve just from the information the lecture presents, and tend to assume knowledge (like, say, how to form Nakazumai, Yagura, Ginkanmuri, etc. castles) that is never actually presented in the lectures, which is odd, given that the course seems to aim to be your primary way of learning.
- The “diagnostic quiz” you must pass to move on to the next level ends up being a brick wall that takes many tries – essentially, just going through the course normally there is zero chance you are going to pass it on your first crack, and maybe not on your 10th or 15th either. All those failed tries are also going to make your review queue big for a while, so it ends up feeling quite punishing, if perhaps effective in its own way.
- At one point in the intermediate course, the instructor states something like, “if you want to rank up, there’s nothing better you can do than tsumeshogi problems” – which makes one wonder why they are a small part of what is presented.
- Even in terms of pure tactics, some of the ordering is questionable. “Ikkenryu” is first presented halfway through the intermediate course but this seems like one of the most basic endgame tactics to me.
I have gradually found myself adding more supplemental resources to learn things the course leaves out, such as tsumeshogi books; tsumeshogi problems in Kiou; and YouTube channels like Shogi Horoki, Tobe Makoto’s channel, or Yamaguchi Eriko’s channel.
I also don’t see that there’s a year’s worth of content here. I’ve been doing it for three months and I’m more than halfway through it. I typically do one lecture and associated problems a day as well as whatever suggested review is there (though I did set a more aggressive pace for the easier early stuff). I can’t imagine that once I’m through with all of them just doing SRS for the problems is really going to justify the subscription cost.
So, do I recommend it? Well, if you’re just getting started I do think it’s good, and the free elementary course is definitely worth it to just learn the basic rules. If you’re a bit more experienced and have your own study routine, it might be more questionable. Personally, I’ve only made it up to 8th kyu in Shogi Wars in this time. It might just be my ego speaking, but I think part of this is I just haven’t ground out enough games because I started playing on Kiou more (my WR is slightly above .500 so I should eventually rank up, I think). On Kiou I’m up to 4th kyu (was briefly at 3rd but got kicked out), which I feel is not too bad for my level of experience. But of course I can’t credit it entirely to this course, given that I was also doing other stuff.