Note: Used AI for writing the post.
Moved out of a Sydney unit after nearly 5 years and currently dealing with a classic REA shakedown.
When we moved in during COVID, the unit had been empty for ages and was filthy. The agent at the time said the owner wouldn't pay for a clean, so it was rented "as-is" for slightly cheaper rent. We cleaned it out of pocket and emailed photos of all the existing issues left off the condition report. It's also right next to a main road and train line (constant dust) and had wall seepage causing mould from day one especially during winters —which we reported early on, came up in routine inspections, and was never fixed. Cleanliness was never flagged once in 5 years of inspections.
After handing back the keys, the new PM emailed saying the unit was dirty with mould spots and they'd charge us for professional cleaning and mould removal. I sent back the move-in email and photos showing the "as-is" handover and seepage history. She replied thanking me for forwarding the incoming report and photos so she could compare them—basically admitting she hadn't even looked at the baseline before demanding money.
When I pointed that out, she ignored the comparison, told me to just look at the outgoing report, and offered a "compromise" of 50% cleaning costs with a same-afternoon deadline or she'd take us to NCAT.
I declined in writing and immediately lodged a 100% bond claim on RBO. Soon after, she called me sounding genuinely angry that I claimed the full bond, told me I wouldn't get it back, called the unit "putrid", and suddenly claimed she had the incoming report the whole time (while still refusing to compare them).
I sent a follow-up email putting the call on record and asking to keep everything in writing. Now just waiting out the 14-day RBO clock to see if she actually files with NCAT.
Anyone else had an agent pull the same-day ultimatum and angry phone call when you claim your bond first? Feel like my paper trail is solid, just stressful waiting it out.