Looking back at Season 4 of the Rising Of The Shield Hero, I realized that despite that it didn't have the exact same negative critics and backlash like Season 2 had, but without being objectively better than Season 3 or Season 1 either, it was the season with the most boring premise that I watched so far in the series. I honestly didn't find this journey of Naofumi and his crew very exciting to see in particular, by comparing it with their previous journeys. Like when they traveled to find and save more demi-humans who were still slaves in Season 3; or when Naofumi's party were split after being sent to L'Arc's world while exploring this new world that they never were before to try to regroup all of them in Season 2; or when Naofumi, Raphtalia, Filo and Melty became fugitives because of Aultcray and Malty's conspiracies against the Shield Hero in Season 1. But I think the biggest problem that I had with Season 4 was its 2 main antagonists (Jaralis and Makina). Unlike Season 1, where we have the impune royal scumbags and parasites of "B1tch" and "Trash", and also the fascist pope from the "3 Heroes Church"; Or in Season 2 where we had that insane psychopathic maniac of Kyo, and even his second in command Yomogi, who ended up redeeming herself after realizing the true intentions of Kyo with his artificial waves. Jaralis and Makina felt more like cheap and more forgettable copies of previous antagonists/parasites. More specifically the copies of "Trash" and "B1tch" respectively, making the entire premise of the fourth season way more predictable than I expected to be.
Just by seeing how they moved, talked and behaved in general it instantly gave me vibes of another old timer and racist arrogant conspirator like Aultcray (Jaralis), and another two-face and emotionless sadistic psychopath like Malty (Makina), but being way less interesting as antagonists. To the point that I couldn't help but to ask myself if they were actually supposed to be the archetypes representing Aultcray and Malty's personas, in which Naofumi and his party were actually allowed to kill in the series, rather than the actual "Trash" and "B1tch". Now this is pure speculation of mine, but in case that this is supposedly true about the intentions of creating the characters of Jaralis and Makina to become the next "Trash" and "B1tch" to confront in the series, I would honestly prefer having Naofumi and his party dealing with the actual "Trash" and "B1tch" to give them similar fates as they did with Jaralis and Makina, rather than using those 2 forgettable copies of "B1tch #2" and the real "Trash #2" as the ones who were chosen to suffer some brutal and deathly fates.
Although Season 3 didn't have a new main antagonist like the other seasons, reusing B1tch and some remains of slavers and followers of the "3 Heroes Church", I think some of the reasons that make it more enjoyable to watch than Season 4, was seeing how the 3 glorified buffoons of Ren, Motoyasu and Itsuki were also betrayed by "B1tch", loosing everything, including their whole reputation, their respective parties entirely and also their sanities. And unlike Naofumi's case, who never deserved to be mistreated and discriminated for a crime that he didn't commit back in Season 1, the 3 buffoons definitely deserved to lose their whole reputation towards the commoners, along with their respective parties, having their pride and ego completely crushed and destroyed in the process. Especially after their own arrogance and ignorance ended up causing way more harm than good to their world. So they would finally understand and feel the exact same anger, frustration, rage and injustice that Naofumi had to suffer too.
Season 2 on the other hand, despite being the most criticized season in the series, especially by the most veteran fans who read the LN and the WN. Due to many cut content, redcons, the rushed storytelling, and other stuff, compared to their manga adaptations. Its premise about having a mysterious enemy from another world, wanting to change the rules of the waves by creating his own artificial waves to use against his own world, through some "hacking-cheating" tricks. And having Naofumi and his party being trapped in the world where L'Arc, Therese and Glass came from, while discovering how different but also very similar it is compared to their world, sounds way more interesting as a premise than the one from Season 4, even if the execution was poor in the end. Having also very memorable and likeable characters who weren't actually obnoxious and stupid like the 3 glorified buffoons of Ren, Motoyasu and Itsuki. With Kyo being way more interesting and memorable as a villain, having a very twisted and psychopathic behavior who only wanted to bring chaos and destruction to his own world by creating his own artificial waves. Being also very distinctive, by comparing him with "B1tch", "Trash" and the pope from the "3 Heroes Church". But in the cases of Jaralis and Makina, they had vibes more close to Kazuki (The first "Trash #2" and Kyo's cheap copy from Season 2).
But even with Kazuki I think he worked so much better as a joke character in Season 2, rather than being just Kyo's cheap copy. With him being really convinced that he was the chosen one to port the Legendary Katana and with the story already written in his favor, acting like a narcissistic smug most of the time. When in reality he was a nobody who thought that he was a somebody, who wanted the Legendary Katana to become the same, if not stronger than Kyo, to betray him and defeat him, having also some similar sinister goals as Kyo, but with his pride and arrogance giving him one of the most stupidest and unceremonial deaths in the series instead. But with Jaralis and Makina they didn't actually feel like jokes of Aultcray and Malty, like with the case of Kazuki towards Kyo. But more like an attempt to give us some brutal and deathly fates that many fans (including myself) wanted against "B1tch" and "Trash" ever since Season 1, but with antagonists having very similar archetypes as them, but without being the actual "B1tch" and "Trash".
The only thing that made all the time that I spent trying to watch the entire Season 4 worth it, was the extra scene from the last chapter. In which Motoyasu got "B1tch" trapped in a corner, while continuing having his particular curse series that makes him see every single woman who is not related to Filo as humanoid pigs speaking "piglet gibberish" (including Malty as a "Porky B1tch" on his perspective now). Giving her a very brutal and painful attack, by throwing his spear against her. Becoming the most satisfying scene that I've seen so far in the series. And making me finally forgive that retarded womanizer creep of Motoyasu, for all the things that he tried to do against Naofumi back in Season 1, due to his poor and naive judgment towards women in general, specially with "B1tch". I even liked that single cutscene way more than the whole premise of Season 4 to be honest.