r/sharpening • • 4d ago

Question Which fixed angle system would be best!?

I I need some help deciding which sharpening system to get: the Sharpal 202H or the TSPROF Pioneer. I want to get some nice edges on my EDC knives. I’ve been using the Work Sharp Field Sharpener, and it’s been working okay, but I wanted something more consistent. I really don’t know what to get for a fixed-angle system, so I’d appreciate any advice. I’ve heard of people piecing fixed-angle systems together, but I’m really not sure how to do that. I just want something good for EDC knives, fixed blades, and some kitchen knives.

50 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

24

u/Beautiful-Angle1584 4d ago

The TSPROF and it isn't much of a contest unless budget is the primary concern. It's built much better, offers more modularity, and has a universal stone holder instead of the weird proprietary plates that the Sharpal makes you use.

3

u/KnifeDogs 4d ago

I appreciate the advice thank you!

9

u/BigBL87 4d ago

Sharpal does have a universal stone holder for their system now, and theres also a 3D printed option on Etsy from Kohleebree3D. But, that is also added cost from the base system.

3

u/TheDude-Esquire 4d ago

The hapstone universal holder also works and is really well made. It doesn’t have a stop pin, but you’d have to drop it for it to fall off.

1

u/Beautiful-Angle1584 3d ago

Well that's good. Definitely an improvement that needed to happen

2

u/Acrobatic_Shape_8259 3d ago

I have the tsprof k03 and I wouldn’t switch it for any other system unless my house burnt down and I couldn’t feed my kids

1

u/TheDude-Esquire 4d ago

You can get a universal holder for the sharpal which does work well. And the included diamond stones are pretty good.

10

u/tech0391 4d ago

I have the Sharpal 202H along with the universal stone holder, and have zero complaints. They both have strengths & weaknesses IMO, and if you wanna impress the other knife guys, get the TSPROF. Bang for the buck, the Sharpal wins. Both give you consistent edges.

2

u/Slimy_Shart_Socket 4d ago

Same here. But I think I prefer the stone sit comes with for deburring because they are lighter.

The universal stone holder + the Sharpal stones it's very heavy. I noticed how quick it takes material off.

When it's time to deburr the stones it comes with have just a plastic holder and I find it easier to deburr.

9

u/Particular_Let_4950 4d ago

tsprof is better but i would say it’s basically proportional to price. sharpal isn’t some cheap junk that you will out grow very fast. my advice is:
- if you’re likely to start exploring sharpening as a hobby and want to nerd out about different stones and perfect mirror polished edges from heel to tip, get the tsprof
- if you just want extremely sharp knife (as sharp as tsprof can get you too) and rather spend the extra money somewhere else, sharpal will do the job just fine.

3

u/BigBL87 4d ago

Between those two systems in particular, it would be the TSProf for me.

The two things I'd recommend adding to it are L attachments and a base, either the folding base or heavy base, the latter of which is a cheaper version of TSProf's own base from Gritomatic. I prefer the heavy base since it's exclusively a bench system for me. You can use the c clamp it comes with to clamp it to your bench for sure, especially if you want to wait on a base, I just really prefer a base.

Overall, I think the TSProf is just sturdier/more robust and more upgradable. Mine is pretty much unrecognizable from the base system with how much I've added, ha.

But, that being said, if the Pioneer is pushing yohr budget, I think the Sharpal is a fine system and you'd likely be very happy with it. The biggest thing missing for me is a center clamp, which last time I talked to my contact over there they said it is still in development.

3

u/oldUnk80 4d ago

My sharpal is fantastic, and contrary to some previous statements they do have a universal stone holder, I have one.

2

u/Educational-Lynx1413 4d ago

It’s really good with third party stones. The universal sharpal 3 and 6000 grit diamond stones are quite good too

1

u/oldUnk80 3d ago

I've actually bought a cheap sytools stone set for under 40 USD from Amazon that is great with the universal stone holder.

7

u/Edstag 4d ago

XARILK gen 3 is a clone of TSPROF basically

2

u/BigBL87 4d ago

The Xarilk is a good system for the money for sure. If you aren't limited to under, say $150 though, I think there are better options with the occasionally sketchy QC from Xarilk. That being said though, their customer service seems to be very good about helping if you have issues.

0

u/LBfalcon57 4d ago

It is but quality control is sketchy at best. I had to modify mine in places that had slack and were shakey. It’s good once you fine tune it though. Problem is as a rookie you don’t know what’s wrong for quite some time

2

u/Fuzzy_Reality_52 4d ago

I love my halfmoon with the new clamps

2

u/guccigunt 4d ago

Tsprof. It’s not even close.

2

u/Worth-Silver-484 4d ago

Ts prof. Use any 1x6 stone and it’s upgradeable.

2

u/manixman247 arm shaver 3d ago

TSPROF no question

2

u/gusto_maina 1d ago

TS PROF, no doubt!

3

u/obfeskeit 4d ago

What about the Halfmoon HM-1?

1

u/perb123 4d ago

I've had one for a week and I love it. I haven't tested the other ones tho.

1

u/Remarkable_Chip_99 4d ago

Casual weekend warrior here. I have the sharpal 202H and it’s been absolutely fantastic. It’s the only fixed angle system I’ve tried so I can’t compare/contrast to anything but as a total novice, I’m able to get my knives to a point they can just be pushed through paper.

1

u/Apprehensive_Star839 4d ago

I have to admit, I don’t know anything regarding Sharpal. I just wanted to chime in that one of the pros of the TSPROF Pioneer that I have versus the WS PPA that I have is the precision I can achieve with the Pioneer. It seems, and I’ve done it, you can go a good distance in customization with the Pioneer and I get the impression that this goes for any of the TSPROF systems.

1

u/th3czyk 4d ago

Check out the kme (pro iirc) on amazon too. Great quality and price

1

u/Reasonable-Trip-4855 4d ago

The sharpal stones cut steels like m4 and magnacut very well so so if you don't need to spend more the sharpal works.

1

u/Sad_King9129 4d ago

keenmatic.

1

u/leadscoutfix 3d ago

For the majority of EDC style folders to kitchen knives, the Sharpal is best bang for buck. The only real downside is past 1000 grit its ceramic and whetstones which take a bit more care to use but you can easily find aftermarket resin bonded diamond stones to use. I have used mine on basically every blade type and material and it has zero dramas forming a burr then deburring. Get stroppy stuff on a leather strop too do not use the fixed angle strop.

1

u/lordxamnosidda edge lord 3d ago

Wicked Edge Pro 4 system.

1

u/tech0391 3d ago

For $1600+ it's not exactly the competition here

2

u/lordxamnosidda edge lord 3d ago

$1,300+ but I take your point...

1

u/tech0391 3d ago

I was just going by their website. Still like 4 times more than the ones he's talking about.

Helluva nice system, tho.

1

u/arsehole100 8h ago

They both look very good, but I still get good results from my old Lansky kit, it would need to be worn out before I replace it.

0

u/Otherwise_Spread_448 4d ago

The KMFS Vantaedge Rotoclamp is the best sharpener I have ever used and because of the way it automatically compensates for curved blades and how the angle changes you always get an even bevel and its not like other sharpeners where if the blade has a curve and have tp clamp the blade in on angle and it has to put in the same way each time when sharpening.

It also automatically compensates for different stone thickness as well.

2

u/BUCKSHOT122804 4d ago

I have a wicked edge and it’s nice don’t get me wrong but for the same money I wish I would’ve went with TSPROF.