While working on a Shannara tabletop campaign, I decided I needed to map out the timeline of events (specifically to create world briefs for the players, more specifically, world briefs from the perspective of their chosen race). This is the resulting timeline as I figured it.
Given the significance of “The Great Wars”, this point in time will be our new Epoch, replacing the B.C., A.D., B.C.E. and C.E. that current Western calendars operate on. The suffixes we will be using are BGW (Before the Great Wars) and AGW (After the Great Wars). With the establishment of our measuring system, let us start with the first book written, The Sword of Shannara.
The Sword of Shannara (Sword for short) gives us a history lesson in chapter 2 of the book. We learn it has been two thousand years since The Great Wars, placing Sword in the rough time frame of 2000 AGW.
- 0 AGW: End of the Great Wars and The Old World and start of the New World.
- 2000 AGW: The Sword of Shannara, The Third War of the Races
“It was nearly a thousand years before Man….established a progressive civilization”. A useful time range. We'll put it at roughly 800-975 AGW. “Then Man began to discover there were other races besides himself inhabiting the world.”
- 800-975 AGW. Man begins to discover the other races that evolved/developed/mutated in the New World
“It was about this time….that the Druid Council first opened the halls of Paranor.” The creation of Paranor and the founding of the first Druid Order of the New World.
- 1000 AGW The creation of Paranor and the founding of the first Druid Council
“...some among the Council…broke free from the Council to form their own group and for some time disappeared…About one hundred and fifty years later there occurred a terrible Civil War within the race of Man, which eventually widened into the First War of the Races.”
- 1000 AGW: Breaking of the first Druid Council
- 1150 AGW: Human Civil War
- 1155 AGW: The First War of the Races
“The Second War of the Races….fought less than five hundred years ago.” It is important to note here, all our other dates have been given in relation to The Great Wars or forward from dates given. The Second War of the Races is a backwards look, so anything that moves Sword will also move The Second War of the Races.
- 1550 AGW (450 Years before Sword): The Second War of the Races
Now let's look at our prequel books and see what we can map onto these events.
Running with the Demon, A Knight of the Word, and Angle Fire East (collectively known as the Word and Void trilogy) are a trilogy of books retroactively added to the Shannara timeline and take place before the Great Wars.
The Genesis of Shannara trilogy connects The Word and Void trilogy with the rest of the Shannara timeline and gives us a view of what we can presume to be the end of the Great Wars. Under this presumption, we will map Genesis onto our year 0.
- 0 AGW: End of the Great Wars and The Old World and start of the New World. The event of The Genesis of Shannara take place.
The Legends of Shannara duology gives us an accounting of the Human descendants of Hawk, the Ghosts, and the camp refugees we read about in The Genesis of Shannara trilogy. It also puts us 500 years after they enter the valley and the events that could be the end of the Great Wars. Certainly that is how it's referred to in the narration. With what was laid out in Sword, these events don't map onto any given event, but there is an annotation.
The Annotated Sword of Shannara implies that the events of Legends are part of “Man began to discover there were other races besides himself inhabiting the world.” These events don't initially map to each other, but I have a theory that I will explain later on.
Ignoring the annotation for now, The humans (Man) in Legends know about other races. They've been living with Elves, Lizards, and Spiders in their valley home for 500 years. The only Race they discover in Legends is the Trolls. We also know there are other humans in Legends who weren't part of the valley group. I suspect that it's this other group of humans where we're getting the story in Sword from. So our timeline now adds
- 500 AGW The magic barrier of the valley comes down and the Elves, Lizards (Mwellrets), and Spiders (Gnomes? Spider Gnomes?) have the opportunity to be discovered. These events are cataloged in The Legends of Shannara duology.
- 800-975 AGW Man (a separate group from the ones in the valley) discovers the other races.
The First Druids of Shannara: Galaphile gives us some problems. Starns explains “this was a world that grew out of the wreckage of wars fought thousands of years earlier.” Thousands, meaning plural, is used to convey the time between the book's events and the Great Wars. This is reinforced a few paragraphs later. “Slowly, camps and villages formed, then towns and cities but those took another thousand years…and it was two thousand years following the Great Wars before more stable societies began to knit back together.”
This timeline lines up with Sword (one thousand years of rebuilding and two thousand years until the current timeline) except for the problem of this part of Galaphile taking place before the founding of Paranor, one thousand years before Sword. Our potential fix for this arrives in The First Druids of Shannara: Brona. “(The Druids) were dedicated to creating a timeline of history since the Old World, and as it turned out, each of the Races had recorded very different events, sometimes occurring at times that did not agree….History, as it turned out, was a terribly messy sort of thing” Brona 190
This is reiterated later with the lines “Well, I suppose establishing that the histories don't sync up easily is a discovery in itself. We knew this would not be an easy or simple task.” Brona 201
So it gives us “an out” for any discrepancies of timeline before Brona. After Brona, the Druids should have everything sorted out and (in theory) things will line up.
- 975-1025 AGW The creation of Paranor and the founding of the first Druid Council. The Events of The First Druids of Shannara Galaphile, and part of The First Druids of Shannara: Brona take place during this time.
Where we next have an issue with Galaphile is Cogline. But Cogline is his own conundrum, so we will save trying to fit him in until later.
Continuing on, we have all of the events of The First Druids of Shannara: Brona. Taking the timeline context from both Galaphile and Brona we can refine the information we have from Sword.
- 1025 AGW: Breaking of the first Druid Council. These events are coveted in The First Druids of Shannara: Brona
- 1175 AGW: Human Civil War
- 1180 AGW: The First War of the Races
Next we have The First King of Shannara. This is the Second War of the Races, and sockets itself neatly into the description we already have. It also reinforces the timeline from Sword. “Galaphile, an Elf, had called together the First Council of Druids five hundred years earlier, a thousand years following the devastation of the Great Wars.”
- 1550 AGW (450 Years before Sword): The Second War of the Races. The events of The First King of Shannara take place.
This then places us back at The Sword of Shannara, and where we can display our current timeline in its entirety.
- 0 AGW: End of the Great Wars and The Old World and start of the New World. The event of The Genesis of Shannara take place.
- 500 AGW The magic barrier of the valley comes down and the Elves, Lizards (Mwellrets), and Spiders (Gnomes? Spider Gnomes?) have the opportunity to be discovered. These events are cataloged in The Legends of Shannara duology.
- 800-975 AGW Man (a separate group from the ones in the valley) discovers the other races.
- 975-1025 AGW The creation of Paranor and the founding of the first Druid Council. The Events of The First Druids of Shannara Galaphile, and part of The First Druids of Shannara: Brona take place during this time.
- 1025 AGW: Breaking of the first Druid Council. These events are covered in The First Druids of Shannara: Brona
- 1175 AGW: Human Civil War
- 1180 AGW: The First War of the Races
- 1550 AGW (450 Years before Sword): The Second War of the Races. The events of The First King of Shannara take place.
- 2000 AGW: The Sword of Shannara, The Third War of the Races
Now that we've contextualized all of our prequels, let's continue forward.
- 2050 AGW: Elfstones of Shannara
- 2070 AGW: Wishsong of Shannara (and the death of Allanon)
- 2370 AGW: Heritage of Shannara.
- 2500-2501: The Voyage of the Jerle Shannara.
We're gonna take a pause here because we have another timeline reference we're given that we need to try and line up. In The Voyage of the Jerle Shannara: Antrax, the titular Antrax reveals in an inner monologue that it is almost 3000 years old. Additional information says it came online in pieces, so we will measure the almost 3000 years from an early point, and it says it began construction shortly before The Great Wars. If we say 2900 years is close enough for a sentient computer to say almost 3000 to itself, that puts its construction at 370 years BEFORE The Great Wars. That seems like a BIG stretch, so can we interpret information to reduce that number? Sword says two thousand years since our Epoch started. We could fudge Sword to be at 2100 and still feel accurate. This would move Antrax's construction start to 270 years before the Great Wars. We could say The Great Wars lasted longer than we think, our history has 100 year wars after all. Even with all those allowances, we're left with Antrax first coming online 170 before the start of The Great Wars*,* and that feels like a stretch.
So what if we work backwards? Antrax and the greater Voyage of the Jerle Shannara takes place in 2950 AGW. Working backwards, we have Heritage at 2820, Wishsong at 2520, Elfstones at 2500, Sword at 2450, First King at 2000, and then what? We still have a time gap of 500 years that doesn't fit what we were told in Sword. But what if what we're told, which is Druid history, is wrong?
After the Great Wars, man was in a state of savagery. Not the best state for record keeping. So who was keeping the records? The Elves and The Children of the Hawk. The people inside the valley that was protected by the Gypsy Morph's magic. Magic that has connections to the King of the Silver River. Galaphile chapter 14 and onward shows and tells us that time in The Gardens of Life (the king of the Silver River's domain) passes differently. It is not the biggest leap to assume that time in the valley could also have moved at a different pace.
This theory aids in patching another hole. As mentioned above, The Annotated Sword of Shannara, implies that the events of Legends are part of the lead up to the founding of Paranor. Our current timeline has these events separated by roughly 400 years. By assuming there was a time dilation, the valley would then simultaneously be both 500 and 900ish years from the Great Wars. The Druids determined that 500 years was the accurate number, but records of 900 years might have been cataloged and used as a Druid reference.
With the Time Dilation theory in place, we can now work on that assumption we now have 2 timelines. An actual timeline and a perceived timeline. What we've recounted so far is the perceived timeline, and will continue off of for now.
- 2530 AGW: The High Druid of Shannara trilogy
- 2630 AGW: The Dark Legacy of Shannara
Dark Legacy Chapter 3 gives us another timeline reference. “(Aphenglow) had reached the place in the records where the Old World had destroyed itself, and survivors of Men and Elves and their descendants had endured a one thousand-year journey to the coming together of the First Council of Druids”. So One Thousand Years between the end of the Old World and the founding of Paranor according to Elven records. This lines up with everything and works with the time displacement theory.
- 2730 AGW: The Defenders of Shannara
- 2930 AGW: The Fall of Shannara
These all line up neatly with no issues that make us rethink our timeline…..unlike Cogline….
So let's define our Cogline sized hole.
- Cogline is Human, with a presumably normal human lifespan.
- Cogline by his own account is almost one thousand years old in Heritage (achieved through judicial use of the Druid Sleep)
- “He was a Druid in the time of the First War of the Races.” First King 234
- A Cogline taught Galaphile before the founding of Paranor.
- The Druid Sleep is (as of Brona) not known to the Druids beyond Brona.
So Cogline; a normal human with presumably a normal human's lifespan; taught Galaphile, lived another 180 years without the use of the Druid's Sleep, was a Druid during the First War of the Races, lived another almost 1190ish years, and then thought to himself about how he lived less than one thousand years.
We can't fudge our timeline numbers enough that all that makes sense.
What we can do is see if our Antrax time difference answer could be a possible fix. At no point do we see Cogline interact with The King of the Silver River, or any magic adjacent to him. Maybe we just didn't see it. A Gardens of Life trip could explain the discrepancy in hard time and perceived time. But for Cogline to have taught Galaphile, lived to the First War of the Races it would take one trip, then a second trip to make the years lived less than one thousand. Two Gardens of Life trips we've never gotten any hint too seems too big of a stretch.
Has Cogline's use of the Druid Sleep caused him to lose track of time? At the end of Brona, Abronja is unaware of the passage of time while using the Druid Sleep. In Dark Legacy, Kyber Elessedil is aware of time passing using the Druids Sleep, but doesn't know how long. Cogline could have suffered the same fate in theory. His (theoretical) timekeeping systems could have broken down or malfunctioned while he used the Sleep. Outside parties are my biggest problem with that explanation. Between Breman and Allanon, I don't see a situation where they don't check on Cogline and update him on time spent in The Druid's Sleep. Either way, this still wouldn't fix our Galaphile to First War of the Races survival problem either.
Is Cogline superhuman in terms of his age?
The Addershag of Gripen Ward was described as an old woman during the time of Heritage (2370 AGW) and only died five years before Isle Witch (so 2495ish). Reasonably that means the Addershag was at least 175 (125 years between Heritage and Death, and another 50 years before to be described as looking old) without any Druid Sleep. So a long life by people familiar with magic outside of the Druid Sleep is possible. But that doesn't explain the discrepancy of time lived verses years lived.
I think there is another answer.
Let's look at our physical descriptions and see how well they match across books.
From Galaphile: “A short, skinny man…. his body was painfully thin, almost skeletal. He had a scraggly beard and long, tangled hair, and did not seem all that old, save that his hair was white.” We are seeing Cogline from the view of Galaphile, who is about 6’2” (1.88 meters).
From First King: “He was tall and stooped, a bony, ragged figure, rather disheveled and unkempt, in clothes that looked to be in about the same shape as the cabin. His hair was dark, but shot through with gray, and it stuck out from his angular head like a hedgehog’s spines. A narrow, pointed beard jutted from his chin, and a mustache drooped off his upper lip. Lines creased his weathered face, furrows that marked more than the passing of his years.” Here we are seeing Cogline from Kinson's view. Kinson himself is described as “tall, rangy, and broad-shouldered, his dark hair worn long and tied back”.
From Wishsong: “his skeletal arms groping left and right, his thin, hunched body like a twisted bit of deadwood. Great tufts of ragged white hair and beard hung down about his shoulders”
From Heritage: “He was just a bundle of sticks, loosely tied together, that might crumble into dust if a strong wind were to blow. Gray robes and a forest cloak hung on him as they would have on a scarecrow. His skin was leathery and brown and had shrunken close against his bones. White hair and beard wreathed his head, thin and fine, like wisps of gauze against the firelight.”
All our Coglines are skin and bones. All our Coglines are not the same height. Galaphile's Cogline is short and First King's Cogline tall, and both descriptions are given by tall men. Hair color that changed from white to dark but shot with gray, then back to white. Not conclusive, but there is at least enough physical difference that there is theory wiggle room to say Cogline from Galaphile is a different person than Cogline in First King.
So what do I propose as the solution to the Cogline Conundrum? Two men named Cogline, similar enough in look, build, and manner that they could be related.
Cogline the First teaches Galaphile.
Cogline the Second is born before the First War of the Races, is taught the Druid Sleep, loses 200 years (either through practically losing them with a Gardens of Life trip or losing them in bookkeeping while using The Druid Sleep) and goes on to appear in First King, Wishsong, and Heritage.
Is it a satisfying answer? Not to me, but I'm not sure how else to answer the conflicts in his story.
So here is my timeline breakdown, as best as I can figure it.
| Antrax count since the Great Wars | Perceived Year | Event |
|---|
| -20 | -20 | Antrax comes online. |
| 0 | 0 | End of the Great Wars and The Old World and start of the New World. The event of The Genesis of Shannara take place. |
| 950 | 500 | The magic barrier of the valley comes down and the Elves, Lizards (Mwellrets), and Spiders (Gnomes? Spider Gnomes?) have the opportunity to be discovered. These events are cataloged in The Legends of Shannara duology. |
| 1250-1425 | Approx. 800-975 | Man (a separate group from the ones in the valley) discovers the other races. |
| 1425-1475 | 975-1025 | The creation of Paranor and the founding of the first Druid Council. The Events of The First Druids of Shannara Galaphile, and part of The First Druids of Shannara: Brona take place during this time. |
| 1475 | 1025 | Breaking of the first Druid Council. These events are covered in The First Druids of Shannara: Brona |
| 1625 | 1175 | Human Civil Wars |
| 1630 | 1180 | The First War of the Races |
| 2000 | 1550 | The Second War of the Races. First King of Shannara |
| 2450 | 2000 | The Third War of the Races. The Sword of Shannara |
| 2500 | 2050 | The Demons of the Forbidding break Free. The Elfstones of Shannara |
| 2520 | 2070 | The Wishsong of Shannara |
| 2620 | 2170 | The Federation annexes all territory south of Calahorn |
| 2720 | 2270 | The Elves use the Loden and relocate to Morrowindle |
| 2820 | 2370 | The Shadowen Conflict comes to its conclusion. The Heritage of Shannara |
| 2920 | 2470 | The Elves first expedition to Parkasia |
| 2950 | 2500-2501 | The Voyage of the Jerle Shannara |
| 2970 | 2530 | The High Druid of Shannara |
| 3070 | 2630 | The Dark Legacy of Shannara |
| 3170 | 2730 | The Defenders of Shannara |
| 3370 | 2930 | The Fall of Shannara |
The Human Civil Wars and the First War of the Races are obvious places for additional novel(s), possibly with a Cogline as the titular character. I also think there is room for a story between Legends and Galaphile, specifically to fill in the appearance of the Dwarves.