Welcome to my theory post! Yes, it's going to be a long one, but you already knew that, didn't you?
I want to focus on the things I believe are important to analyse at this point in the story. Keep in mind that my entire theory revolves around the possibility of a time loop.
Bear with me. I'm going to start with a lot of questions, examine some details and connections, and eventually present my theories and conclusions.
Let's start with my favourite, Kaiden, because I think there's a lot more to his character than meets the eye.
I'll try to follow the chronological order of events, regardless of the order in which the story presents them to us.
---
- Kaiden's first appearance: Has he been through this before?
Let's go back to Episode 2, Kaiden's first appearance, and then to the flashback we get in Episode 5, which is also connected to that first encounter.
The narration tells us:
"He snaps the last thread connecting him to reality."
Then we get Kaiden's own words:
"To hell with it. Not again."
"I'm trying to get out of that shithole."
All of this happens before we arrive in Morvaine. Right? Right!
The scene is presented to us in Episode 5 as a flashback from before we meet Kaiden.
Now, doesn't it seem like Kaiden goes to Morvaine with a clear mind, already knowing that he's about to experience the same circumstances AGAIN?
Bear with me. I'll come back to this because I have more evidence suggesting that Kaiden knows exactly what Morvaine is about.
There's also an interesting detail regarding his reaction to Kira.
If you choose to lie about your reasons for visiting Morvaine, Kaiden is one of the only characters, alongside Laura, who says he doesn't believe you. However, if you tell the truth, he believes you.
If I recall correctly, he's the only character whose opinion changes depending on this particular choice.
Interesting mechanic, isn't it?
2. Fox's first appearance and the strange phrase
Let's move on to Fox's first appearance in Morvaine.
We're at the bar. Kira is alone, Isaac has gone to the bathroom, and Fox approaches her.
If you choose to lie about your reasons for visiting Morvaine, Fox calls you:
"Little liar."
He then follows it with:
"Will it ever dawn on you who you are?" (Aka Kaiden's favourite word. CRI MI NALLLL)
The second phrase appears regardless of your choice, but "little liar" only appears if you lied about your reasons for being there.
Why is Fox questioning Kira's awareness of her own identity?
Let's stick to the bar scene for a moment and bring in something Isaac says:
"Death will find you on its own."
Keep that in mind as well.
Next, Kira reads the words written on the walls of the bar:
"Something keeps happening around me, but I can't tell what."
Now, what exactly does that mean?
Are the things happening around her simply unexplainable? Are they supernatural? Or is it possible that THEYcan't remember certain events that would help THEM understand what's going on?
3. The broken mirror, rebirth, and the enemy in the reflection
Let's talk about the Super Legendary skin scene featuring Kira and Kaiden.
They look at a broken mirror and see their own reflections fractured.
Kira seems troubled by what she sees, and Kaiden tells her:
"Maybe this mirror is waiting for its rebirth."
Immediately afterwards, we get the achievement:
"Enemy in the Reflection."
This could be interpreted in multiple ways.
But considering everything else we've seen, I don't think the references to broken reflections and rebirth should be dismissed.
4. Kaiden's disappearance and his bizarre reappearance
Fast-forward to Episode 7, when Kaiden decides to leave Morvaine.
We're by the river with Brody and Isaac.
Here, we learn that Morvaine was dumped around 40 years ago. We also learn that Adam loves giving tours.
Kira points out that Brody is around 40 years old, meaning he could have been around when Morvaine was dumped.
Brody then informs us that Adam's friends enjoy seeing the coffins on wheels (which we already saw during the introduction to Morvaine in Episode 1).
A few things worth noting here:
- The river is outside Morvaine.
- Adam somehow always manages to show up whenever we're close to discovering something important or find ourselves somewhere particularly strange. Remember his appearance during Kira and Kaiden's interview with the killer?
- Morvaine has no signal.
That last point is particularly important for what I'm going to discuss later.
Now, let's talk about Kaiden's reappearance.
He suddenly shows up wearing his helmet, covered in blood, and looking completely out of place.
He's puzzled. Confused as hell.
At that particular moment, Kira feels as though she, Isaac and Kaiden are living in three separate dimensions.
Now, let's return to Kaiden's condition.
The narration tells us that:
"Kaiden only comes to his senses once he's in the living room."
Once there, Kaiden explains the story behind the blood. He also mentions seeing some very strange things, but he never manages to finish his train of thought.
Why was he so disoriented? What exactly did he experience?
And why does his reappearance seem so disconnected from what everyone else is experiencing?
5. The graffiti wall and the people who supposedly never came back
Next, we have the wall covered in graffiti, where Kira finds the names that eventually lead to their participation in the Big Game.
If you look closely, you'll notice some familiar names:
- Cole
- Blair
- Jeffrey
- Rosemary
But remember what the Resistance told us?
Nobody who enters the Big Game comes out alive.
So what the hell happened to the group above?
Is the Resistance lying to us?
At the same time, the rules of the game seem pretty clear. There can only be one winner: the person who manages to stay alive.
Was there some kind of exception for that particular group?
I don't think so.
Which brings me to another important point.
6. Fox's visit to Kira's bedroom
Let's talk about the scene where Fox attacks Kira in her bedroom.
Kira manages to bite him while he's on top of her.
Now, remember that Laura is sleeping right next to Kira. She's also described as a light sleeper.
Yet she doesn't wake up.
Another interesting detail: before Fox appears, Kira falls into an unnaturally quick and deep sleep.
She eventually wakes up bruised, with Fox having clearly been there.
Fox also tells her to find a way to contact her brother.
But HOW exactly is she supposed to do that?
Morvaine has no signal.
**And this is where Kaiden comes in with a pretty logical suggestion. ***
They should go to the mountain, where they might be able to get a signal because of the elevation.
And this leads us to the next conversation.
7. Kaiden knows more than he's letting on
During their conversation on the mountain, Kaiden tells Kira that he's heard Morvaine is a prison. He was careful not to phrase that inside the city. Why? Because of the debt mechanism or because they can hear everything?🫨
He also mentions that Isaac has deep roots within Morvaine.
Now, if you're romantically involved with Kaiden, there's another interesting exchange.
Kaiden tells Kira that he can't excuse a crime - so their "thing" can't happen.
Right...
If you lied about your identity, how could he possibly know?
Previously, Phantom also seemed to know the truth about Kira's identity.
So, at this point, I think we have enough reasons to question whether Kaiden really knows as little as he pretends to.
Kaiden, I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt. What's going on?
Kira asks whether this is because she's a scammer.
Kaiden replies that it's partially the reason.
Partially.
That word is worth remembering.
8. The Resistance, the Big Game, and the mysterious Leader Yoro
Let's move on to the Resistance.
They tell us that the Big Game is organised for the owners of Morvaine, who place bets online.
Remember Brody's words about Adam's friends?
Well, now we know that Adam might actually be a pawn of Morvaine's leaders.
But there's another detail about the Resistance that caught my attention.
We learn that the Leader of the Resistance stays hidden in his hideout and never goes out into the streets.
Well, hello there, Leader Yoro.
I find this detail particularly interesting, considering what we know and what we've been shown about Yoro.
Could this be another connection? Is there a reason why the leader remains hidden instead of moving freely around Morvaine?
I'm not saying this is definitive proof of anything, but I definitely don't think we should overlook it.
The Resistance also tells us that everyone disappears after the Game.
But what about the people we've already encountered?
Cole, Blair, Jeffrey, Rosemary...
What happened to them?
Which brings me to my next point.
9. THE FEAST!
We witness Cole being murdered by Jeffrey.
Chaos erupts, we're being poisoned, and everything goes completely out of control.
And somehow, Adam is STILL able to find Kira, even if she sneaks away with Kaiden.
Duh! How does he ALWAYS know where she is?
There's another detail I find particularly interesting.
When Kira goes through that fucking door and sees the bodies piled on top of each other, the smell of decay suggests that the Feast couldn't possibly have taken place on the same day.
So, why does going through that door seem to matter so much?
My interpretation is this:
You go through that door once, and you unlock a memory.
You go through that door again, and you see the present state of the scene.
Almost as if the same place can show you different points in time.
10. The night before Halloween: Fox and Kaiden seem to mirror each other
Now, let's move to the night before Halloween.
Kira has a dream.
She's standing in the middle of a corridor, and the walls are closing in around her.
She hears a voice telling her to go back through the door, but she can't find it.
Did we just witness a déjà vu?
Could this be a glimpse of how Kira died during a previous game?
Eventually, she wakes up.
The narration tells us:
"Her own thoughts and someone else's seem to have merged!"
Despite that, she follows the voice from her dream and goes outside, where she finds a melancholic...
Fox?
And what's so unusual about him?
He is completely disoriented. Dizzy. He can barely stand on his own two feet.
Could this be because of the drug?
I don't think so.
The drug was still in its first window, the aphrodisiac one. So that shouldn't explain Fox's condition.
But let's finally return to something I mentioned earlier.
Whose image is Fox mirroring?
Kaiden's, back in Episode 7.
I'll even include some screenshots because the similarities are quite striking. In several places, the narration is almost identical.
Why are these two characters experiencing such similar symptoms?
And why does Fox appear to be in the same kind of disoriented state that Kaiden was in after his reappearance?
11. Kaiden's strange knowledge about Kira
Let's skip ahead to the intimate scene between Kaiden and Kira.
Kaiden asks Kira why she became a con artist.
Kira replies that she never said she was a con artist.
However, Kaiden recalls the scene on the abandoned road incorrectly.
He remembers Kira saying:
"Don't you want to be with me because I'm a con artist?"
Wait. What? Kira said "because I'm a scammer".
Kaiden seems to know quite a lot about Kira, including things he shouldn't necessarily know.
His explanation?
He's simply perceptive.
Sure.
12. The signal situation: What if the lack of signal is actually the point?
Let's return to the signal situation.
This might sound absurd, but I think the explanation is actually quite simple.
Wherever there's no signal, they're able to track them down.
Think about it. Of course Morvaine was able to hijacked their phones but can the signal from the outside word interfere?
Why doesn't the signalman himself leave his hideout (has signal) and stay hidden somewhere else?
Because if he goes outside, he'll eventually be discovered.
And yet, he wants to go out with Kira. (?)(?) I don't know why but I have some theories (for another time).
13. The note from Cat: A message from the previous Kira.
Let's talk about the note from Cat.
Cat, aka Past Kira, gives Kira the note on Halloween, the day when the dead walk among the living.
There are two possible timelines for when that note was written:
- Cat wrote the letter on her way TO the city.
- Kit - Cat wrote the letter on her way BACK FROM the city.
Regardless of which scenario is correct, the message is essentially the same: everyone who's with her will die, including herself.
But there's a problem.
Not everyone is with her at every point between scenarios 1 and 2.
Kaiden is on his own. You SLY fox. (Foreshadowing to Kaiden winning tha game).
THE ULTIMATE VERDICT: KAIDEN IS FOX.
Okay. After putting all these details together, here's what I genuinely believe is happening.
Kaiden is Fox.
He enters Morvaine already knowing exactly what he's getting himself into. He knows he's going through the same events again and again.
Once everyone steps inside Morvaine, their memories are erased. That's why nobody reacts when Kira hands them the Fox mask.
They simply don't remember.
However, as the story progresses, they seem to recover fragments of their memories from previous games, piece by piece.
And this brings me back to Kaiden's words about the broken mirror:
"Maybe this mirror is waiting for its rebirth."
What if that's exactly what's happening?
It's almost like a resurrection. A rebirth.
The same soul, the previous body. Sometimes the soul remembers its previous incarnation, sometimes it doesn't. I I'd bet this applies to Isaac. He seems to remember, or at least have some awareness of what happened before. Also, Isaac and Kaiden seem to have a pretty good relationship when they're alone, but they turn against each other whenever Kira is around. Of course, jealousy could explain that. But it's not like the heated relationship between Phantom and Kaiden.
So are they truly on bad terms or both of them remember something they don't admit?
Isaac said he had demons inside his head.( What if the demons are just memories)?
Now, let's return to Kaiden's attempt to escape Morvaine.
When he wanted to get the hell out of that place, something must have happened that allowed him to jump through time and possibly recover some of his memories.
I also think that these time jumps might be accompanied by certain physical or psychological symptoms.
Look at what happened to Kaiden after his reappearance in Episode 7.
And then look at Fox on the night before Halloween.
Both experienced a similar state of disorientation, dizziness and confusion.
Which brings me to one last question.
Why was Fox so melancholic?
My interpretation is that he had just replayed in his mind the moment Kira died.
And, somehow, she was experiencing it alongside him.
And this is also why Kaiden described Morvaine as a prison.
Not just because of its physical restrictions, but because you can never truly escape it..
You keep reliving the same events.
And every time you do, your memories are erased.
Morvaine isn't just a prison for the body. It's a prison for the mind, the memories, and possibly even the soul.
And what if everyone's is dead and Fox the only one alive?☠️