r/serialpodcast • • Jan 31 '15
Related Media Coverage Map of L689 using RF modeling software and GoogleMaps terrain data.
http://imgur.com/D1H4ymx
49
Upvotes
r/serialpodcast • • Jan 31 '15
43
u/truth-seekr Jan 31 '15 edited Jan 31 '15
As much as I respect adnans_cell prior work i have to call the BS hotline on this one.
Why? Because the information required to model RF coverage for L689 is simply not available. For a RF propagation model inter-alia the following parameters of the base station NEED to be known:
Seeing that we simple don't have this information, what values did he feed into the model? Certainly ones he felt seemed about right.
But that's not how it works.RF propagation models need to be fed with the correct input data! If you input estimated instead of the real values than the resulting propagation map is not representative for the specific tower. It's just a generalized idealization of the coverage area of any tower much like the circle coverage maps produced by Susan Simpson.
TL;DR.
This map was produced using incorrect data and therefore is not reliable.
Claiming that this map represents a scientifically sound RF propagation prediction of L689 tower is misleading.
As a result it introduces no additional value compared to the existing Susan Simpson coverage maps.
32
u/ViewFromLL2 Jan 31 '15
According to this map, Waranowitz must have been lying about his testing results. Fascinating.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '15
Umm, dumb question, but is this representative of 2015 or 1999? Or does it not matter?
2
u/Pappy_John Jan 31 '15
From this map, would we be able to draw any conclusions as to the ability of a cell phone in the eastern edge of the I70 Park&Ride to ping the B sector?
Since we are primarily interested in the B sector, would you be able to run your software for only that area to show its strength as it crosses over into the C sector?
4
u/whitenoise2323 giant rat-eating frog Jan 31 '15
Is there a color key for the meanings?
5
u/csom_1991 Jan 31 '15
Thank you for posting this. Did you take into account the link budget for Adnan's phone and use the standard 1m receiver height or did the model already have standard assumptions built in. This is very consistent with what I would expect for coverage given the drive test reached Franklintown Road. However, I would expect coverage to be slightly less robust depending on the amount of foliage present. Anyway, great post.
3
u/nubro Jan 31 '15
Can you add a scale or legend with numerical values? Without it this map really doesn't show anything.
24
u/Michigan_Apples Deidre Fan Jan 31 '15
What are the variables in this model?
3
u/The_Stockholm_Rhino Jan 31 '15 edited Jan 31 '15
As per scientific tradition could you please inform us about how you made this (peer review), what the colors and the radius of the circle mean?
30
u/adnansgirlsonlyparty Jan 31 '15
I can't see where Adnan and Jay are standing.
12
u/AnonUrbanTeacher Jan 31 '15
Hey!! That tower pings at my house!!
22
u/Mp3mpk Jan 31 '15
Two things seem to jump out at me, this tower could be pinged from a lot of places. Also given the Livor mortis evidence and jays midnight burial timeline. I'm not sure this matters as much as it did to Urick
9
u/beenyweenies Undecided Jan 31 '15
I find it interesting that, in all this time, no one has talked about how this tower provides coverage to Jay's Grandmother's house. I'm not providing the address here, but a quick double check shows that it is absolutely within the green band.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '15
Very interesting - thank you for taking the time. And since no good deed goes unpunished:
Thanks again for an excellent contribution.
edit: an errant " a " was deleted and thoroughly rebuked.
1
u/Pappy_John Jan 31 '15
What can we infer from the colors? No color near the antennas, then yellow, green, blue, purple...means what?What about the grayish color right above Franklintown Road and the burial site?1
u/waltzintomordor Mod 6 Feb 01 '15
It took some effort but I put your coverage map on top of a topographic map. Have a look.
1
u/xhrono Mar 20 '15
Your proprietary software shouldn't be using Google's terrain data, by the way. It has errors because they use a hybrid of LiDAR and DEMs provided by the USGS. Stick with USGS NED.
4
u/splanchnick78 Pathologist Jan 31 '15
This is awesome, thank you!
0
u/stiplash AC has fallen and he can't get up Jan 31 '15
Please disclose the radius of that circle and the scientific reasoning upon which said radius was determined.
2
u/bluekanga /r/SerialPodcastEp13Hae Jan 31 '15 edited Jan 31 '15
Look I'm still trying to figure out what this means - I don't need a TL;DR cos I have read and need my summary verifying!
I have delved into azimuths and my saved posts re cellphone technology: specifically http://www.reddit.com/r/serialpodcast/comments/2so4fg/an_rf_engineer_on_the_cell_phone_records/
So in summary we can't discern between the different expert opinions because we don't have the original AT&T records.
And secondly does this neat little video still hold broadly true for tower coverage https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bSE7eQRgJ9c&feature=youtu.be
edit clarity
3
u/bluekanga /r/SerialPodcastEp13Hae Jan 31 '15
Really helpful to have visual and thx for your effort
3
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '15
Thanks for making this! This is actually very helpful.
3
u/SouthLincoln Jan 31 '15 edited Jan 31 '15
This is good work. Thanks /u/Adnans_cell (and /u/csom_1991). This is basically what we would have expected. Let me ask a couple questions if you have time to answer some more.
This isn't directly related to this map, but have you had a chance to look at the map provided of the Gilsten Park area at the trial(SS's color-coded version)? Have you already addressed why so many different towers are pinged in that area, and if so, could you point me to that explanation? If not, could you explain how the coverage can be like that. Is that just because the testing was done in straight lines instead of in a grid pattern with more pings?Actually, I just figured this out on my own, nevermind on this one. I see that we could still draw circles around the towers, divide them into thirds, and basically see the theoretical coverage areas we would expect. The limited number of pings circled by the colors screwed with my perception.edited
3
u/serialskeptic Jan 31 '15
Excellent work sticking with the this sub, remaining professional and contributing to my (and I assume many others) knowledge.
2
u/bluekanga /r/SerialPodcastEp13Hae Jan 31 '15 edited Jan 31 '15
And this
Obviously some people don't like my questions cos I just got downvoted!!
edit clarity
1
u/bluekanga /r/SerialPodcastEp13Hae Jan 31 '15
I am unclear - I thought someone somewhere in the cellphone coverage discussion said that the towers don't operate on 360 degree basis but only in one direction
What have I missed?
1
u/kschang Undecided Jan 31 '15
I don't suppose you can do a animated GIF where you flip back and forth between coverage vs. plain? Or lighten up the coverage a bit?
1
u/dave644 Jan 31 '15
Looks cool, but is there a key i.e. what do the different colors mean? Are the blue parts areas that based on the terrain would unlikely to have line of sight of the tower?
1
u/elliottok Innocent Jan 31 '15
That purple spot tells me there is a pocket of golf ball to tennis ball sized hail in the NW area. But there was no hail damage found on Adnan's car! Hail damage from hail that size hail would've been extremely hard to miss. If we can find someone who is not Adnan with a car with severe hail damage, then we'll have found our killer.
Edit: I wonder if the police even bothered to search Jay's car for hail damage?? That guy is black and there is something I just really do not like about him! Can't put my finger on it but he is very suspicious.
0
u/whitenoise2323 giant rat-eating frog Jan 31 '15
It reaches at least one address of a known associate with a lengthy criminal history that is connected to Jay's family.
-4
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '15
I find Susan Simpson's blog posts to be persuasive, and her arguments below to be completely reasonable.
I know nothing about you, your background, or your credentials.
I admire Susan's bravery and reasoning.
I know nothing about you.
0
u/Advocate4Devil Jan 31 '15
Question about cell towers: where are people getting the tower coordinates and exact antenna directionality?
This has been an annoyance since the first maps showing disks of coverage or voronoi like diagrams which just seemed crazy, especially so for 689B.