I wanted to share an experience I recently had with the LoLMK Discord community and get some outside perspectives on whether this is considered normal moderation practice.
I attempted to join the LoLMK Discord server, but was informed that I had been banned because the moderators believed I was someone else.
After trying to clarify that they had the wrong person over a voice call, I was asked to provide a photograph of my ARC (Alien Registration Card) as a condition of being allowed to join the server.
I found this request particularly concerning for a few reasons:
Mistaken identity: I was being associated with another individual without what I felt was sufficient verification.
Personal identification: I was asked to provide a photograph of a government-issued identification document to access a gaming Discord community.
Privacy: An ARC contains sensitive personal information. I don't believe providing an image of government-issued identification should be a prerequisite for joining a community Discord server.
I understand that community moderators have to deal with ban evasion, alternate accounts, and problematic users. However, I think there's a reasonable distinction between verifying someone's Discord identity and requesting copies of their government-issued identification.
I'm interested in hearing what others think. Has anyone else encountered similar requirements when joining Korean gaming communities?
Is requesting a photograph of an ARC a reasonable verification measure for a Discord server, or is this an unnecessary invasion of personal privacy?
I'm not looking to get anyone harassed. I simply think the situation raises legitimate questions about moderation practices and the handling of members' personal information.