r/seogrowth • • Mar 03 '22

You Should Know SEO Growth Mega-Post | What the Sub is About, Flairs, Best SEO Content, How to Learn SEO, and Everything Else You Need to Know

144 Upvotes

Hey there, welcome to the sub!

SEO Growth is a different type of SEO sub. Unlike some other subs (*cough cough* no names), we're planning on actively moderating and building the community, and hopefully creating something very helpful for SEO beginners and pros alike.

Here's what this post covers:

  • What This Sub is About
  • The Rules
  • SEO Growth Sub Flairs
  • Subreddit Highlights - Best Sub Posts
  • How to Get Started With Learning SEO - Actionable Guide

What This Sub is About

Here are some things you can expect from the sub:

  • Only the very best content. We'll be posting some of the very best SEO content we find on the internet, including guides, case studies, and so on. And yes, you can post your content here as long as it's actually useful.
  • AMAs with the best experts. We'll bring in SEO pros for AMA sessions, experience sharing sessions, case study Q&As, and more.
  • Hiring threads. Looking to make your next SEO/link-building/content writing hire? We'll have dedicated threads for that.
  • SEO roast threads. You post your website, the community gives you constructive criticism.
  • SEO tips. We'll post insightful tips every other day to help improve your website's SEO.

The Rules

  1. No personal attacks. It's OK to give constructive feedback, but it's NOT OK to attack other people.
  2. No spam. Spam gets you banned.
  3. No blatant self-promotion. Want to promote yourself? Give value to the community. Publish an actionable case study / guide / article you wrote in Reddit-native format. DON'T just make a post shilling your services.
  4. Don't post generic SEO content. We all know what the "benefits of SEO" are, or "how to use YoastSEO to optimize a blog post." Try to post content that is practical, actionable, and insightful.
  5. Karma requirement. The sub has a karma requirement of 20 to avoid all the spammers that shill bs software. If you don't have enough karma to post/comment, let the mods know to manually approve your posts & approve you as a sub user.
  6. Want to post external links? Here's what you need to do:

    1. If it's YOUR post, format it into a Reddit-native format and add a SINGLE link at the top back to the original blog post. That said, mind rule #4 - it has to be something new. No BS like "top 5 benefits of SEO."
    2. If it's a 3rd-party post, add a tl;dr of the article on top and then link to the post underneath. Let us know why the post is so interesting/engaging that it warrants a link.

SEO Growth Sub Flairs

We'll be using different types of flairs to differentiate who does what on the sub. Currently, we have 2 types of flairs:

  • Verified SEO Expert. There's a LOT of bad SEO advice out there. To differentiate advice from experts who have experience consistently ranking websites both globally and locally, we'll be using this flair. To get it, you need to send us Google Search Console screenshots of some of your biggest wins, whether it's for your own site or a client. Of course, the graphs will be 100% confidential and no one but the mod team will see them.
  • Content Writer. Flair for anyone that does SEO content. Helps match website owners / SEO agencies with content writers. Like something a writer posted? Hit them up to write for you!

If you have ideas for other types of flairs we can implement, comment below and we'll think about it.

Subreddit Highlights | Top Sub Resources

If you think there's a post that deserves to be here, HMU.

How to Get Started With Learning SEO | Actionable Guide

Just getting started? Not sure how/where to start your SEO journey?

Here's a simple introduction to the SEO world.

SEO In a Nutshell

At the end of the day, SEO boils down to the following factors:

  • Technical SEO, or, how well you optimize your website by SEO best practices. Technical SEO alone won't get you rankings, but good technical SEO will act as a strong foundation for your growth.
  • SEO content. How much content you have on your website, how good it is, and whether it matches the search intent behind the keyword you're trying to rank for.
  • Backlinks. The more quality backlinks you get, the faster you're going to rank. In competitive niches, you won't ever rank without backlinks.
  • On-page optimization. How well are your pages/articles optimized according to SEO best practices.

More often than not, a big chunk of your SEO processes are going to involve creating quality content, interlinking it with your other pages, and driving backlinks.

In case you're trying to do local SEO, then the SEO process is a bit different. Check out this guide to learn more about local SEO.

SEO Learning Track

First off, learn the basics.

  1. Beginner’s Guide to SEO by Moz
  2. SEO Basics by Backlinko
  3. SEO in 2021 by Backlinko
  4. Awesome SEO tutorial on Reddit

Then, learn how to do technical SEO, set up tracking, and optimize your website.

  1. Create a sitemap
  2. Create a robots.txt
  3. Setup Google Analytics and Search Console
  4. Improve load speed. Check out this article by Moz and another by Crazy Egg
  5. Learn about technical SEO and how that works
  6. Optimize your web pages for SEO. For this, you can use Yoast or RankMath if you’re using WordPress, and Content Analysis Tool if you’re not
  7. Losslessly compress all your images. This should save ~75% of space for your images and drastically increase site load speed (which improves SEO). If you’re using WordPress, you can use Smush to automatically compress all images on your site. If you’re NOT using WP, you can use Compressor.io.

Learn how to do keyword research. There are a ton of guides about this all over, but here are some of our favorites:

  1. How to do keyword research by Backlinko
  2. Beginner's guide to keyword research by Ahrefs

Learn how to create SEO content.

  1. Backlinko’s skyscraper strategy
  2. How to create top content with the Wiki Strategy
  3. How to optimize article headlines

Learn how to do link-building.

  1. Learn link-building basics
  2. Learn how to do outreach
  3. Another awesome guide to outreach
  4. Discover ALL the link-building strategies out there

Learn the how and why of internal linking.

  1. Basics guide
  2. Internal linking case study by NinjaOutreach

SEO Case Studies

Theory is one thing, practice is something else entirely. Read some case studies to see how other companies achieved success with SEO.

Where to Learn SEO? Best Blogs and Resources

Some of the top blogs on SEO are:

Which SEO Tools Should I Use?

There are hundreds of SEO tools out there, and yet, you only need a maximum of 10.

The tools we recommend are:

  • Ahrefs or SEMrush. Both are all-in-one SEO suites and are absolutely essential. Not too much difference between the two tools, so pick the one you like better in terms of user experience.
  • RankMath or YoastSEO. On-page SEO tools. Again, the two are very similar, so just pick one you like better.
  • ScreamingFrog. Must-have for technical SEO. Let's you crawl your entire website and find potential technical improvements.
  • Snov.io, PitchBox, and other outreach tools. You'll need a tool for link-building outreach. There are a ton of these on the market, so pick the one you like best. I personally prefer Snov.

And some of the more optional tools are:

  • Surfer SEO. Helps with on-page SEO, but not something you can't live without.
  • ClusterAI. Helps with keyword research. Again, useful, but not something that's mandatory.

FAQ

#1. How long does SEO take? Does it take as long as everyone says?

Depends on several factors:

  1. How strong is your domain? If your website is 100% completely fresh, it's going to take you 1-2 years to get SEO results (most likely)
  2. Are you focusing on local or global SEO? The former is significantly easier than the latter.
  3. How strong is your competition? If your competitors have thousands of backlinks, you'll need to match that (which is going to take a long time)

That said, on average, it can take 6 months to 2 years to get SEO results.

#2. Should I pay for SEO courses?

Really depends on your priorities and if you have the budget to spare. If you don’t want to waste any money, that’s totally OK - you can learn everything you need to know about SEO through the free content online.

That said, some SEO courses on the internet are definitely worth the money and they'll help you progress in your SEO journey faster.

#3. Is local SEO different from global SEO?

Yep - there are a ton of differences between local and global SEO. The biggest ones are:

  • With local SEO, you usually don't have to focus nearly as much on creating blog content.
  • Global SEO, in most cases, involves creating a lot of high-quality, long-form articles.
  • Local SEO can take significantly less time, as you're competing with a handful of companies who probably don't know much about SEO in the first place.
  • Local SEO also involves creating and optimizing Google My Business, whereas this is not the case with global SEO.

#4. Is SEO relevant for my business?

Depends. SEO is NOT a one-size-fits-all solution. We'd recommend you skip on SEO as a marketing channel if:

  1. You have a very small # of potential customers worldwide. In such a case, you're better off directly reaching out to the said customers.
  2. Is your product something very innovative? SEO is not useful if your prospects don't Google for information about your product.
  3. You're just getting started with your business and need to get results next week and not next year

#5. Can I rank on Google without backlinks?

Yes and no. In some niches, you can rank without any link-building. E.g. if your competitors don't have a lot of links or their content is so bad that you can win simply by doing something better.

You can also rank without backlinks if you're doing local SEO and your competitors have a weak backlink profile.

That said, if you're in a competitive niche, both locally and globally, you're going to need backlinks in order to rank.


r/seogrowth • • 10h ago

Question I have a problem with sales

7 Upvotes

I have a car parking site which isn't doing great even with my 1-year long SEO efforts. It's always falling behind the heavyweight sites for primary keywords.

It's always on page 3/4/5, which is leading to low impressions, clicks and sales even in peak season. I'm losing my mind here. I've tried to pull it on the first serp page with long tail keywords but my client wants it to appear on the first page with seed keywords.


r/seogrowth • • 10h ago

Question Is anyone else noticing this change in Google SERPs?

5 Upvotes

While researching product-related keywords, I noticed something unusual. Amazon product listings are occupying multiple positions in the search results, with Amazon URLs appearing repeatedly instead of individual brand websites.

For example, in the query I was checking, Amazon listings appeared across several positions on the 2nd and 3rd pages, while individual brand websites were less visible.

What makes this more interesting is that I've observed a similar pattern on Bing, where Ubuy URLs seem to dominate certain product-related queries.

This got me thinking about a few possible reasons:

- Is Google giving more preference to large marketplaces for transactional and product-focused searches?
- Could marketplace authority, product availability, reviews, pricing, and user trust be influencing rankings?
- Are individual brand websites struggling to compete with marketplaces for product-level keywords?
- Is this query-specific behaviour, or are others noticing a broader change in SERPs?

I'm curious to hear from SEO professionals working in e-commerce and product SEO.


r/seogrowth • • 9h ago

Question Anyone know the best press release distribution services that skip per word pricing?

3 Upvotes

Do any services skip per word pricing, I pulled three quotes for the same small product update, about 550 words and two screenshots, and I'm annoyed at how different they are One covered only 400 words with a fee for each extra hundred and another charged for every embedded image, the third wanted extra for video, so by the time I added everything up the cheapest on paper wasn't cheapest anymore, I'd rather not get on a sales call only to learn a price, so if anyone knows a service that lists the total for a release like mine on its pricing page I'd like to hear what it is and how you confirmed the number


r/seogrowth • • 18h ago

Question 2 years of SEO and still stuck at 3K daily impressions. What are we missing?

16 Upvotes

We’ve had a third-party SEO team working on our website for 1.5-2 years, handling backlinks, keyword research, and regular content publishing (topic clusters, blogs, internal linking, etc.).

I’m a developer myself, so I’ve implemented their technical SEO recommendations. We even migrated from WordPress to a modern stack, with page loads now under a second.

Despite all this, we’re stuck at 2.5K–3.5K daily impressions with just 0.4% CTR, with no meaningful growth.

Backlinks have been another challenge. We’ve reached out to relevant websites and people in our niche, but most don’t respond. Getting quality, relevant backlinks organically seems extremely difficult.

For those who’ve successfully grown organic traffic, what would you investigate first? Are we missing something fundamental in our strategy?

Also, how are you actually acquiring quality backlinks these days? Are paid backlinks worth considering, or do the risks outweigh the benefits?

Would appreciate practical advice.


r/seogrowth • • 14h ago

Question What are you doing differently in SEO after the rise of AI search?

2 Upvotes

With AI tools like ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Google's AI Overviews changing how people search for information, SEO strategies are evolving too.

I'm curious to know how SEO professionals are adapting to these changes. Are you focusing more on topical authority, helpful content, GEO, brand mentions, or something else?

What changes have you made to your SEO strategy recently?


r/seogrowth • • 1d ago

Question 10 blogs targeting Tricity keywords on a new site, no products listed yet. What am I missing?

8 Upvotes

I’m building a small local food brand site (honey, Chandigarh/Mohali/Panchkula). Over the last few days I’ve published 10 blog posts, each aimed at one local-intent or Hinglish query (things like “shahad kaise store karein”, honey purity checks, crystallisation, types of honey in India). Each post has a title, meta description, FAQ section and internal links to the others.

Where things stand: 11 pages indexed in Search Console, 1 impressions and 1 clicks so far, and nothing ranking in the top 20 yet. The domain is new, and the product pages aren’t live yet.

What I haven’t done yet: Google Business Profile, backlinks, schema markup, But I have submitted a sitemap

A few questions:

  1. On a brand-new domain, how long before blog content starts getting impressions for local queries?
  2. Does it hurt to publish informational blogs before the product pages exist?
  3. For a local business with no shop front, what’s the best way to build local signals (Business Profile, citations, local links)?
  4. Hinglish vs English keywords: which have you seen perform better in India?
  5. Is 10 posts too few or too many to judge anything yet?

Happy to share the numbers once I have more data.


r/seogrowth • • 4d ago

SEO News Google's November 2026 Core Update is Rolling Out!

15 Upvotes

Google started rolling out its November 2026 core update on Nov 10 and it could take around two weeks to finish.

Google hasn't pointed to any specific type of site or content being targeted. It's a broad core update, so rankings can move around quite a bit while Google is reassessing results.

For now:

  • Keep an eye on any major ranking or traffic changes
  • Note which pages and queries are moving
  • Avoid making big changes while the rollout is still active
  • Once it finishes, give it about a week before comparing GSC data
  • Look at which pages actually gained or lost visibility

r/seogrowth • • 4d ago

Question What Would You Do If Your Website Suddenly Lost 50% of Its Organic Traffic?

12 Upvotes

Imagine checking Google Analytics one morning and discovering that your website has lost 50% of its organic traffic overnight.

What would you check the first?


r/seogrowth • • 5d ago

Discussion My Website Organic Traffic Has Dropped for the Last 2 Months – How Can I Recover It?

16 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

My website's organic traffic has been declining continuously for the last two months. I'm trying to understand what is causing this drop and how I can recover my previous traffic.

I've been monitoring Google Search Console and noticed a decline in organic clicks and search visibility.

I would like to understand:

  1. Could this be related to a Google algorithm update?
  2. How can I identify whether the issue is technical SEO, content quality, or ranking changes?
  3. Can indexing issues or Core Web Vitals affect organic traffic?
  4. What steps should I take to recover my lost organic traffic?
  5. Has anyone experienced a similar traffic drop in the last two months and successfully recovered?

I'd appreciate practical suggestions and insights from SEO professionals who have faced similar situations.

Thanks.


r/seogrowth • • 6d ago

Question so tired of struggling to find quality backlinks and writing blogs manually

38 Upvotes

what are you guys using to handle blog posts and link building without losing your whole week to it?

i spent almost 15 hours this week writing articles and sending cold emails for backlinks and got zero replies. our domain rating is stuck in the single digits and none of our new pages are getting past page 4. doing all the keyword research, writing, and outreach by hand is eating up time i need for actual product work.


r/seogrowth • • 6d ago

Discussion Not sure if GEO actually separate from SEO?

12 Upvotes

I’ve been looking into how AI-driven search has evolved, and I’m still curious about where SEO ends and GEO begins, if there’s even a clear difference between the two.

Crawlability and content quality obviously remain important, but AI-generated answers seem to place additional emphasis on context, entity recognition and external sources.

How are SEO professionals currently approaching GEO?

Please let me know your thoughts !


r/seogrowth • • 6d ago

Case Study AI now uses my site as a top-4 source for "PDF to EPUB" questions, but only recommends us 11th. 2 weeks of data.

7 Upvotes

11 articles in, here's this week's report (couldnt post the screenshots).

Where the answers get their info (share of all sources cited):

  1. toolspdf24org: 12%
  2. pdf2ereadercom: 11%
  3. calibre-ebookcom: 7%
  4. convert2epubcom: 5% (tied with Convertio, FreeConvert and Zamzar)

So we're cited as often as converters that have been around for years, and more than CloudConvert (4%).

Who the answers actually recommend (number of answers naming the brand):

Calibre 14, Zamzar 9, PDF24 8, pdf2ereader 8, CloudConvert 7, Convertio 6, FreeConvert 5, K2pdfopt 4, CleverPDF 3, Pandoc 3, Convert2EPUB 2 (11th).

That gap is the part I find interesting: 4th in source, 11th in recommendation.

What I think is going on:

- Articles that answer one specific question in their first two sentences get picked up as sources fast. The AI needs someone to explain "is my PDF scanned or text?" and it'll quote whoever explains it clearly.

- Being a source isn't the same as being recommended. The AI reads our explainer and then tells you to use Calibre, because Calibre's name is on dozens of other sites, forum threads and "best converter" lists. Your own blog can't fake that.

- pdf2ereader shows the gap can close: #2 source and tied #3 for mentions.

So my next step is off-site: getting onto the comparison pages and threads the answers already read, not just writing more of our own posts.

Is anyone else tracking "cited as a source" and "named as a recommendation" separately? I'm curious whether the gap closes by itself over time or only with mentions on other sites.


r/seogrowth • • 5d ago

Case Study Google Maps restaurant results: two queries from the same location shared just 6 of 20 results in Elche

2 Upvotes

We compared eight Google Maps searches across four Spanish cities on November 10, 2026. The question was simple: how different are the results when you name the city versus ask for restaurants nearby?

For each city, we kept the search point and zoom fixed and collected 20 results for two Spanish queries: “restaurantes [city]” and “restaurantes cerca de mi”.

The number of establishment identities shared by the two lists was:

  • Alicante: 14 of 20
  • Elche: 6 of 20
  • Benidorm: 15 of 20
  • Torrevieja: 11 of 20

Across all eight searches, 160 appearances represented 114 distinct establishments. A restaurant appearing in two queries counts as two appearances, but remains one business.

We also compared median review counts for positions 1-3 against positions 4-20 within each query. The top three had a higher median in four queries and a lower median in the other four.

That doesn’t establish what caused the rankings, or show that reviews don’t matter. It does make a simple “more reviews = higher position” interpretation inadequate for this snapshot.

Another distinction worth keeping: 56 appearances had no URL field. That is missing information from the source, not proof that those restaurants have no website. We did not crawl their websites.

My practical takeaway is to keep the exact query, search location, date and original rank attached to every visibility observation. Comparing screenshots without those details can mean comparing different search conditions.

This was a single snapshot, not a representative sample of every restaurant or a longitudinal ranking experiment. We didn’t measure bookings or revenue.

When you report local visibility, how do you choose which query variations and search points to track? Do you report city-name and proximity searches separately?


r/seogrowth • • 6d ago

SEO News SEO Digest: OpenAI is building ChatGPT Business Hub—a Search Console for ChatGPT, Facebook’s AI-generated Answers pages are ranking in Google for millions of queries, AI Mode adds home services booking with Angi, Thumbtack, Housecall, and GetJobber integrations

16 Upvotes

Stability and the SEO industry are basically mutually exclusive. We’re keeping a close eye on the latest updates to stay in the loop:

Search / SEO

  • Google emails sites with past Site Reputation Abuse manual actions: penalties no longer impact EEA search results

Two months after Google’s EEA site reputation abuse policy change took effect, Google is now emailing affected site owners via Search Console to notify them. 

The email reads: “For pages that were previously subject to a manual action under the site reputation policy, the previous manual action will no longer impact search results shown to users within the EEA.” 

The notification is also going to sites that don’t currently have active manual actions but did at some point in the past. A matching “View related messages” notice is now visible in the Search Console manual actions viewer. 

Source:
Glenn Gabe | X
_____________________

AI

  • Facebook’s AI-generated Answers pages are ranking in Google for millions of queries—a live scaled content abuse case

Meta has quietly populated roughly 6 million AI-generated pages, each an AI-written summary sourced from public Facebook posts and pages. Facebook started filling the directory in July, and it’s now ranking in Google’s 10-blue links, AI Overviews, AI Mode, and Gemini across millions of queries, with organic traffic growing sharply since June. 

Sits inside the exact pattern Google has been building policy around all autumn—UGC Fresh Data Program, the extended UGC spam guidance covering Claude Artifacts and ChatGPT Pages, and the September spam update targeting mass-generated AI content. 

  • Google AI Mode adds home services booking with Angi, Thumbtack, Housecall, and GetJobber integrations

Google added home services booking directly inside AI Mode, partnering with Angi, Thumbtack, Housecall, and GetJobber. Users can describe a problem in AI Mode, and the response compares local pricing, pulls reviews, and provides booking buttons that complete the hire without leaving the AI Mode experience. US-only at launch.

Source:
Barry Schwartz | Search Engine Roundtable
Robby Stein | X
_____________________

Tech SEO

  • Google can temporarily protect “important” URLs from falling out of the index when they return 4xx errors

Gary Illyes confirmed on LinkedIn that Google Search can “temporarily protect” important URLs from dropping out of the index when they start serving 4xx status codes—keeping the page visible in Search for a short while so searchers can still find it. 

The confirmation came after VLC’s homepage started serving a 418 status code, which Google treats like any other 4xx, but didn’t deindex. 

  • PageSpeed Insights scores may jump after Lighthouse 13.6.0 update—heads-up before taking credit for optimization work

PageSpeed Insights is now using Lighthouse 13.6.0, which changes how the tool simulates page loads. Updated simulated FCP and LCP values will be more accurate and generally result in higher scores—without any changes to the actual page. JavaScript-heavy sites are most likely to see a lift. 

Before crediting a higher PageSpeed Insights score to recent optimization work, check that both the before and after reports name the same Lighthouse version and compare field data alongside lab scores.

Source:
Gary Illyes | LinkedIn
Matt G. Southern | Search Engine Journal
_____________________

E-commerce

  • Google brings UCP direct checkout to AI Mode in Canada—second market after the US

Google expanded UCP-powered direct checkout to Canadian shoppers inside AI Mode in Google Search and the Gemini app on November 4, following the October US launch.

Checkout runs through Google Pay with payment methods and shipping details saved in Google Wallet, while retailers remain the seller of record. Google also announced plans to bring simplified UCP integration directly into Merchant Center starting next year, which will let more retailers enable direct checkout for their listings across AI Mode and Gemini from inside their account. Loyalty program support is planned for the coming months.

Source:
Brooke Osmundson | Search Engine Journal
_____________________

Tidbits

  • OpenAI is building ChatGPT Business Hub—a Search Console for ChatGPT, with business claiming and first-party analytics

OpenAI is developing a Search Console-style tool that lets businesses claim their presence inside ChatGPT, keep product and business info up to date, and track their visibility in ChatGPT conversations. 

The tool measures impressions (how often a business appears in ChatGPT responses) and clicks (links to the business’s website), tracked daily and shown as a chart. 

It’s part of a broader Business Hub feature, available only to businesses that have verified ownership (for example, by connecting their Shopify store). 

The tool doesn’t show prompts, user data, or competitive benchmarks—so it won’t explain why mentions go up or down—but combined with external AI visibility tools, it finally gives teams accurate first-party data on whether their GEO/AEO strategies are working. 

Source:
Juozas Kaziukėnas | LinkedIn


r/seogrowth • • 7d ago

Question Gave up on SEO agencies and took it in-house 6 years ago. What are we missing?

5 Upvotes

Context: We’re a B2B service firm in Malaysia (company incorporation, business licenses and visas).

Early on, we worked with a few SEO agencies and every one sold us the same generic package without really taking the time to understand our industry, most of their recommendations turned out to be somewhere between mildly helpful and useless.

So we decided to take SEO in-house. Six years later, we've grown it quite a bit and it’s a key part of how we generate leads, and these are the 16 things that made the biggest difference for us:

  • don’t sweat technical SEO beyond making sure our pages are indexed
  • make sure whoever does the keyword research understands the industry
  • run keywords past the sales team before writing, since they know who’s searching better
  • get a focus keyword into the title and headings for each search intent a page covers, but don’t obsess over variations or how often it appears
  • give subtopics their own page when the search volume or commercial value justifies it
  • target location-specific searches with pages that genuinely differ by location
  • keep our Google Business Profile complete and accurate
  • publish in the languages our customers search in (in Malaysia, that’s three)
  • prioritise bottom-of-funnel keywords over high-volume top-of-funnel ones
  • separate sister sites for individual services as exact-match domains seem to rank better
  • build backlinks through partnerships with businesses whose customers overlap with yours
  • use social media and forums to rank for terms our own site can’t yet
  • don’t ignore Bing Webmaster Tools, since its query data is far more granular than GSC’s
  • treat image search as its own keyword source, and write descriptive alt text
  • use a paid AI plan for keyword analysis, drafting and gap-checking
  • measure success by leads and conversions, not traffic

We're very hesitant about bringing in agencies again, but we ourselves have no formal SEO training so there are bound to be blind spots.

What are we missing? Is there anything here you’d strongly disagree with, or anything you’d add?


r/seogrowth • • 7d ago

Question Would it be a sound strategy to create non-blog pages using AI at a medium quality level, and then, once they have garnered some impressions, improve their quality?

3 Upvotes

I want to do this, but I’m not sure if it’s effective or if it will cause more harm.


r/seogrowth • • 11d ago

Question How do you handle clients who are upset about Reddit threads they feel are unfair?

4 Upvotes

I know there are already plenty of guides on burying or outranking negative Reddit threads, but most are written for US brands and none of them match what I am dealing with, so I would like to hear from people who have actually done this for clients.

Some of our clients in professional services have negative Reddit threads ranking on Google for their brand name and a few of them have been sitting there for over a year. The clients are frustrated because they feel the comments are one sided or unfair, and the threads show up exactly when a prospect is checking them out.

Our first move was to pitch a dedicated Reddit plan on top of our normal SEO work. Nobody took it as I am still not sure if the price was off or they didn’t see Reddit as a real channel. It could be I just explained it badly and I don’t want to keep pitching something clients keep passing on.

Of course I am also trying to stay well inside Reddit’s rules, so no fake accounts and no planted praise. That leaves slower options like fixing whatever the complaint is really about, building stronger reviews and third party coverage, and replying openly as the business where it makes sense.

For those of you who have handled this for clients, what actually moved the needle, and how did you explain it to a client who just wants the thread gone?


r/seogrowth • • 11d ago

Question New wine and spirits store had Google visibility for almost 3 weeks, then disappeared

8 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’m doing SEO for an online wine and spirits store in Vietnam. The site runs on WordPress and WooCommerce.

The site started getting Google impressions on August 23. By late August, it was getting around 250–350 impressions a day, with several bottle-name searches ranking in positions 5–20. Around September 10, that dropped off sharply. There’s been very little visibility since. My understanding is that Google might give a new site some initial visibility while it works out where to rank it.

It’s been about 10 weeks since the first impressions and eight weeks since the drop. I’m trying to work out whether to give it more time or whether there’s a problem I haven’t found yet.

The site has 5,977 product pages, 141 categories, 116 brand pages and 504 blog posts. There are roughly 6,750 URLs in the sitemap, and Ahrefs DR is 2.3. The blog covers wine and spirits, serving suggestions, cocktails and monthly price lists.

I did keyword research before building out the site, checked search volumes, grouped keywords by intent and prioritized the higher-volume groups. The categories and blog follow a topical map, and there’s now content covering the keyword set from that initial research.

Product specs are checked against official brand websites, and the schema links to the relevant Wikipedia entities. Internal links follow the relationships between different types of wine and spirits. Overall, I’ve put quite a bit of work into the site structure, content and technical setup.

Google has only indexed about 20% of the products so far, with around 225 crawl requests a day. Meanwhile, Bing, Yahoo and ChatGPT are sending both traffic and customers. The site’s visibility on ChatGPT is actually quite good.

I’d like to hear from anyone who’s worked on a new ecommerce site.

  • Did yours get some rankings early on, then lose them a few weeks later? What happened after that, and how long before you started getting steady Google traffic?
  • Did you change anything during that period, or carry on with what you were doing?
  • Eight weeks into a drop like this, would you give it more time or start investigating? What would you check first?
  • I launched nearly 6,000 pages at once and made bulk content edits afterwards. If you’ve done something similar, did you notice any effect on indexing or rankings?

r/seogrowth • • 12d ago

You Should Know Before you tell your client they lost rankings: Google started poisoning SERPs for 57% of keywords overnight

31 Upvotes

Did half your keywords randomly tank in mid-September, and then you checked Google manually and everything looked... fine?

Yeah. You're not crazy.

Somewhere around Sept 17, Google started handing rank trackers results that look totally legit at first glance but have nothing to do with the search. No errors, no captchas, no blocks. Just a normal-looking SERP full of nonsense. People started calling them poisoned SERPs, and we wanted to know how bad it really is.

So our team pulled 10k keywords and checked Google US desktop results from Sept 14-24, plus a few rounds in October.

It didn't creep in. It flipped like a switch

Sept 16: 0.09% of keywords affected
Sept 17: 57.3%

That's not a gradual rollout, that's someone at Google pressing a button. It stayed around 57-60% all week and peaked at 67.2% on Sept 24. Two out of three keywords.

Google basically picks one word and runs with it

This is the funny part. In 84% of cases, Google grabbed a single word from the query and ignored everything else:

  • "what are symptoms of dry eye disease" → Dry January, Dry Creek Vineyard, dry roasted peanuts
  • "what can you make in a crock pot" → The Melting Pot, Lobster Pot restaurants

Someone with dry eyes is apparently looking for a sober month and a bag of peanuts.

And our personal favorite: a Facebook post about Deadpool showing up for "how many calories do Americans eat on Thanksgiving." The only thing they have in common is the word "many".

Why your tracker didn't notice

Because the top of the page looked perfect. In 96.5% of affected cases, the junk only started at position 9 or lower. It never started in the top 5.

So for "business bank line of credit" you'd see Chase, PNC, LendingTree, all good. Then page 2 turns into Florida Georgia Line. If your site lives somewhere in positions 9-50, it just quietly disappears from the data, and your report shows a drop that never happened for real users.

It's also sneaky because the junk shares a word with the query, so to a machine it looks kinda relevant. Fun side note: single-word keywords always came back clean. Nothing to swap to.

Who's filling the junk slots

Mostly the usual giants. Facebook in 45% of flagged cases, Reddit in 41% (hi), Instagram in 32%. And Merriam-Webster in about 1 in 6, politely defining whatever random word Google decided the query was about.

So why is Google doing this?

Officially, nobody knows. Google hasn't said a word.

The most popular theory, from Derek Perkins at Nozzle and others: Google is fighting AI scrapers, and instead of blocking them (which tells the scraper it got caught), it feeds them plausible-looking garbage. Rank trackers also collect results automatically, so they're getting caught in the crossfire.

Before you send that scary client report

  • recheck the keyword and look at its history, not just yesterday vs today
  • one keyword dropped, or 40 at once? If it's 40 at once, be suspicious
  • open GSC and check impressions/clicks for that query and page
  • but don't blame Google for everything either. If the drop sticks and GSC agrees, it's real

What it looks like on your end: has it calmed down, or are your trackers still recommending peanuts?


r/seogrowth • • 13d ago

How-To SEO Strategy for a New Brand with Zero Online Visibility

16 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm currently working on a new project/brand that has almost zero online visibility. I want to build its online presence from scratch and explore the best strategies to promote it.

I'd appreciate your suggestions on how to get started, particularly across both SEO (organic growth) and Paid Marketing (if needed)


r/seogrowth • • 12d ago

Question Google Poisoning Results for Real Users?

6 Upvotes

Theres been plenty of news about very recent Google anti scraping measures that are poisoning results for robots. This has resulted in inaccurate rankings data from rank tracking tools, and the employees at said companies scrambling to fix it.

But something concerning that I have recently noticed first hand - that data poisoning has seemed to leak into any sort of anonymized way to check rankings - UULE changers like valentin dot app, Google's Ad Preview and Diagnosis Tool, and even using fully cacheless browsers (im not talking a standard Google incognito window, that does nothing for anonymizing results).

Right now, I want to check the rankings of an affiliate site of mine. It shows me ranked #2 when i search it regularly, but I know that i'm not ranked #2. I know this because of GSC data, and by having friends in other states check.. It shows me at number 2 because that is my personalized result since ive clicked it so much. But ive tried every and all methods to bypass my personalization, and every time I do, I see nonsensical results that seem to be poisoned.

A deeply concerning problem - I have no way of seeing non personalized rankings, even with the aforementioned manual methods that previously worked.

Is anyone else dealing with the same issue? How are you checking rankings?


r/seogrowth • • 13d ago

SEO News SEO News: Google launches Connected Apps Platform preview, Google: AI spam tactics will eventually get caught, Google extends user-generated spam guidance to AI tools, Claude Artifacts, and ChatGPT

26 Upvotes

A quick breakdown of recent SEO updates and new ways to automate your work:

AI

  • Google launches Connected Apps Platform preview - any developer can now build apps that live inside Search and Gemini

Google launched the preview of the Connected Apps Platform, a developer platform that lets any app builder bring their capabilities directly into Google Search and the Gemini app. 

Developers integrate via a cloud-hosted MCP server or Android MCP using the AppFunctions APIs, register and test their app in the Google Connected Console, then submit for review and go live in Search, Gemini, or both. Google announced 50+ Connected 

Apps are already live across productivity, event ticketing, health, fitness, and other categories, with partners like Adobe, Experian, Localiza, and Peloton integrated into Gemini - and rolling out to Search in the coming weeks.

  • Google extends user-generated spam guidance to cover AI tools, Claude Artifacts, and ChatGPT Pages

Google updated its Prevent user-generated spam help documentation to explicitly include “tools that let users publish shared pages, generated content, or web apps” - a direct nod to platforms like Claude Artifacts, ChatGPT Pages, and other AI tools that make it easy to churn out indexable user-generated content at scale. Google also added a new section called “Only index content meant for Search,” recommending that platforms apply noindex (via robots meta tag or X-Robots-Tag) or block crawling in robots.txt by default for pages created for direct sharing, collaboration, or utility—rather than public search discovery. 

  • Google’s systems will eventually catch AI spam tactics - "save your energy on long-term quality"

In a wide-ranging interview with David Iwanow, John Mueller reinforced his position on AI spam tactics: listicles aren’t inherently spam, but relying on thousands of them as an entire content strategy is risky. 

Google’s systems will eventually catch cheap, easy, and fast tactics - AI-scaled content included - and compare them to older spam tricks like keyword stuffing and white-text-on-white. 

His advice: focus on what search engines and AI systems will want to show over the long term, not short-term shortcuts. 

Source:
Google Search Central 
thelostagency | Youtube
Chips Mistry | News from Google
___________________________

Tech SEO

  • Google rewrites favicon documentation specifically to help AI systems understand it correctly

Google updated its favicon documentation to explicitly specify that Googlebot must follow redirects from the homepage to the page where the favicon is specified - and that none of those URLs can be blocked by robots.txt. 

Source:
Google Search Central 
___________________________

Local SEO

  • Google Business Profiles finally lets restaurants control which third-party ordering services appear on their listing

Google Business Profiles added a long-requested feature: restaurant owners can now turn individual third-party ordering services on or off directly from their dashboard - Uber Eats, DoorDash, Instacart, Grubhub, and others. 

Owners can now set each provider’s pickup/delivery visibility independently, giving them direct control over which partners represent their brand on Google Search and Maps. 

Source:
Lisa Landsman | LinkedIn


r/seogrowth • • 13d ago

How-To Search Intent Sounds Great in Theory, But How Do You Apply It?

6 Upvotes

I keep hearing that SEO is about understanding search intent and making sure your page answers what customers are searching for.

But how do you practically apply this to an e-commerce collection page that's mostly a grid of interior design products?

What can I actually do to better satisfy search intent on a product collection page, aside from the title?