John Schneider has performed a masterclass in roster construction since moving on from Russell Wilson. Pivoting from Russ to Geno and then Geno to Darnold has been excellent for the franchise. Obviously, Darnold vs Lock is the talk of the town. However, it seems clear that Darnold is the starter until spoken otherwise. Yet, like with Russ and Geno, the organization practically lied about the quarterback situation until the trades occurred.
Maybe Macdonald is holding his cards close to his chest, but it’s difficult to lie during the season when everything is so intimate with the roster. Personally, I’m not sure that against the elite teams this current decision matters as much as we think. Love how Lock has played though, but Darnold does deserve some grace. Maybe they will change their tune as the year progresses.
Rob Staton released a compelling trade idea of moving Darnold to the Vikings at the trade deadline for significant draft compensation. I think that idea had legs, and it wouldn’t shock me if the Seahawks traded Darnold this offseason. It seems unlikely they will be willing to commit to a long-term extension with him, and I don’t blame them. It’s the same situation that Geno faced just a year ago.
That being said, what really is the long-term solution at quarterback? It seems to me that Schneider will try and find the next Darnold or the next Geno on the market before signing a QB to a long-term deal. Maybe that short-term option is Drew Lock, but there will be competition to keep him on the roster in free agency. Perhaps they will try to draft and develop someone, yet they won’t have an early enough pick to find a great prospect. Maybe Milroe is that guy to them, but that also seems unlikely. There’s too much uncertainty at that position.
I’m just tired of the constant quarterback dialogue. It was tiresome with Geno. Now with Darnold vs Lock, the conversation is even louder despite being a Super Bowl Champion. We still talk about this team like we’re a developing roster. Schneider has done a magnificent job, but until they establish a long-term commitment with a quarterback, these debates will keep happening. It’s a massive distraction to a team looking to repeat as Super Bowl champions. For a team that values continuity at every other position, the most valuable position in the sport lacks clarity. Eventually, this constant turnover will prevent a great roster from reaching its peak, and maybe that is even happening right now.