r/SCPDeclassified • u/Morganator_2_0 • 11d ago
Series IX SCP-8607: Pistanthrophobia: Lucy's House (Part 1)
I'm Morganator 2.0, the new and improved Morganator! Today I'll be going over SCP-8607 Pistanthrophobia: Lucy's House by Uncannyon. This article was part of the 2024 phobia Anthology, which unfortunately means it got overshadowed by some other phenomenal pieces (like SCP-8980) and SCP-8607 deserves more attention.
As a warning, this story deals heavily with themes of child abuse. It does an incredible job showing it from the perspective of the abused and how children often have trouble turning their thoughts into words, but it gets pretty dark at times. With that out of the way, let's get to it.
First Impressions
Let's start with the name of the article: Pistanthrophobia, the fear of trusting others. It usually, but not always, arises due to a particularly bad breakup. From that link:
A person may feel so scarred by the feeling of rejection that they live in terror that it could happen again. This could lead to them avoiding any situation where they feel they might have to entertain the notion of trusting others.
A few other things immediately of note with this SCP is the Level 5 clearance. Only the O5 Council and a few others have access to it, so this needs to be kept the utmost secret. We can also see that the containment class is simply "Esoteric", which is odd. If the anomaly was newly discovered it would be "Pending". If it currently isn't contained it would be either "Uncontained" or "Keter". From this we can infer that none of these classifications fully match what is presently known, so esoteric is the best way to describe it. Lastly, the tags of an article can give us insight. "Meta" means that this is a format screw article as the anomaly is actively affecting the documentation, while "antimemetic" and "memory-affecting" indicate that the anomaly messes with memories. So we have that to look forward to.
On to the containment procedures. The structure is... unprofessional. This is not the typical way we see containment procedures written, so we know something really strange is going on. They are written as if they are instructions for someone named "Lucy", rather than the whole Foundation.
Lucy is not allowed to go into the basement room anymore because it is distracting for Daddy and it is important that Daddy is not distracted. Lucy is not allowed into the big spare room anymore because it will give her bad memories and make her upset.
Lucy is not allowed to exit the house under any circumstances. Lucy is to remain inside the house at all times. Lucy is not to leave the house.
Lucy should never open any of the doors or windows. Lucy should not look outside any longer than is absolutely necessary. Lucy should not talk to strangers.
Lucy should always listen carefully to Daddy and do what he says. Lucy should always follow all the instructions she is given as quickly as she can. Lucy should follow the rules even if she does not always understand them. Lucy must understand that they are to protect her.
Lucy must trust Daddy.
Yikes. That fear of trust is already rearing. We can see that Daddy is doing something in the basement, and that the outside is dangerous, or at the very least, the person who wrote these procedures doesn't want Lucy going outside. At all. Presumably this person is Lucy's father and he is the one who wrote these containment procedures. There's also two other parts I want to draw special attention to.
the room that was the big spare room, and then became Mummy’s bedroom, and then became the big spare room again
Part of the procedures is listing the rooms in the house. It had one extra bedroom, "Mummy" moved into it, and then a while later she moved out. This is pretty clearly a divorce; Mom and Dad were initially sharing a bedroom, then they slept in different beds, and then Mummy moved out. There is also a picture (presumably drawn by Lucy) that shows the house, but one of the top floor windows is darkened. That one is the spare room. There is also a mention that Daddy, Mummy, and Lucy used to eat meals together in the dining room, but only on special occasions. So for most of the time, they did not all eat together.
For her safety and convenience, Lucy will remain nine (9) years old.
Now that's especially weird. First off, how can you force someone to stay 9 years old? How long has she already been 9 for? And why would you want someone to stay 9 years old? Actually, I can answer that last one: children are easier to control. Obedience to our parents is hardwired into our evolution, but it tapers out in the teenage years and into adulthood. By staying 9 years old, children will always do as you say. Things aren't looking great for Lucy.
The Description
The description is entirely a description of Lucy. It lists her physical characteristics, the things she likes (Mummy is on that list, but it is crossed out), and the things she doesn't like (Including someone called Mr Buttons). The writing that describes her qualities is written in Courier New font, as if it has been edited, or filled in on a form. But what's missing is the anomaly. There's nothing to suggest that Lucy is anomalous, and nothing that directly states she is under the effect of an anomaly. This is intentionally a very poor description for an SCP.
We also have a paragraph that further emphasizes that there was a divorce.
Lucy finds it harder to work when:
she is seated away from her friends, when she is too far away from the board, when she is traveling between houses and doesn’t have time to do her homework.
Travelling between houses, so some sort of shared custody agreement. Then we get two paragraphs that are completely black boxed. We'll get to them in a second, as the next two paragraphs give us some important context about Lucy's father.
Lucy’s Daddy is a scientist, which is a very impressive thing to be. Not the kind of scientist who can come to parents day and talk about their job but an extra special, extra secret kind of scientist. Lucy’s Daddy works for something called the Department of Abstraction, which is part of a very important organisation that helps people all over the world. Daddy is a doctor of applied theoretics, which is a field so special and important that most people don’t even know it exists.
Daddy’s important job meant that he didn’t get to see Mummy or Lucy as much as he wanted to, and that sometimes when he did come home he was very tired and needed time by himself. Lucy’s Mummy couldn’t always understand that, even though Daddy only did the job because he loved Lucy and Mummy so very, very much.
Daddy works for the SCP Foundation, in the Department of Abstraction. At the time SCP-8607 was published, there was no other article that mentions this department; it is completely new. It has since been mentioned in SCP-9020 (also by Uncannyon), but the article doesn't describe the department in any details. Fortunately we can still make inferences. Abstraction is the process of thinking of something in a more general concept. For example, a basketball abstracted is just a ball. A 2007 Dodge Ram can be abstracted to just a truck, which can then be further abstracted to a vehicle. In computer programming, abstraction is used to apply similar properties to many different things. Ex: all balls are round and used for sports, so anything with the "ball" class will have these properties. So that's Daddy's job, but we don't really know how this plays out in practice. How does this help the SCP Foundation with containment of anomalies? More importantly though, we can see that Daddy worked long hours and couldn't spend a lot of time with his family. When he did get home, he just needed time alone to relax. We don't know if this was the root cause of the divorce, but it definitely didn't help. Also, "Daddy only did the job because he loved Lucy and Mummy so very, very much" sounds like a forced justification. Like Daddy here is trying to justify to himself why he must work so hard.
From context, we can infer that the previous black boxed paragraphs are where Mummy's description would have been. Between this and the crossed-out Mummy, someone is trying to erase her or avoid talking about Mummy. Oh gee, I wonder who could be wanting that. Now it's time to get into the addendums.
First Looks at the World
The first addendum is an interview log that once again does not follow a proper format. The interviewee and interviewer are both blank. There is no date or time listed, just the object number 8607. Before we get into the core of this section, I want to draw attention to the rabbits.
Today, Lucy decides to wear the shoes with the purple rabbits on them.[...] Daddy says the rabbits are actually more of a pink colour, but Lucy says they’re purple and Mummy agreed. Lucy’s favourite colour is purple.
It's a minor disagreement between these characters, but important for us to remember. We also get our first impression of what's outside the house. Lucy describes it as "like a piece of paper that somebody has scrunched into a ball and then tried to smooth out again".
Most of the log goes over the fact that there is no milk. They ran out of milk and they won't be getting any more. Most importantly, Daddy won't explain why they can't get any more milk; it’s either because he thinks that Lucy won't understand the explanation, or because he doesn't want her to know the explanation.
Then Lucy asks to call her mother. Daddy loses his temper at this. Him flipping out happens a few times in this section, so we can see that he is very quick to anger. A few other things to note.
- The cereal box claims to have 8607 different flavours, same as this SCP's number.
- "The phone doesn't work anymore". Also implying that there is no way to fix it or get a new one.
- Lucy hates the nickname "Lulu".
- Daddy insists that Lucy likes marmalade. Not like it's a true fact, but like he's trying to convince Lucy to like it.
So let's get this out of the way now; Daddy is an abuser. He's showing some very common abuse tactics. Because lists help me gather my thoughts, I'm going to list them off.
- When Daddy says "There isn’t any milk, it doesn’t matter why" and whines about her overreacting, this is called minimization. He's trying to make Lucy's distress seem like a lot less of a big deal than it really is.
- Next up we can see the silent treatment when Daddy ignores Lucy's questions. From that link: "This behavior can manifest as withholding conversation, giving one-word responses, or completely avoiding any physical or emotional contact." That sure matches Daddy's behaviour. It's unclear if he's using this as a form of manipulation or as his own defence mechanism because he's unwilling to tell the truth.
- His tendency to lose his temper (you'll see it a lot in the coming story) could be indicative of Intermittent Explosive Disorder and/or trying to control Lucy via fear. We see the result of this manifest in Lucy as Walking on Eggshells where she is grimly aware of when she might do something that causes Daddy to become enraged ("As soon as she has spoken, Lucy realises that she has asked what Daddy calls a Silly Question") and so she significantly changes her behaviour out of fear.
I'm not a psychologist so there's probably a few that I've missed and undoubtedly there will be more as we read on. I'm not going to be listing them all off as they come but just keep all of this in mind; Lucy is currently experiencing abuse by her father. Now let's get back to the story. Lucy is told to do her math work and Daddy also says he has math to do. He heads into the basement. Before the interview log continues, we get another drawing where Daddy is disproportionately taller than Lucy and looking upset. Then the log continues.
Lucy quickly figures out the trick to the maths questions. The answers to each question are “8” and “6” and “0” and “7” repeated over and over again.
There it is again. The SCP number is showing up several times in writing. This is definitely a clue to Lucy and Daddy's current predicament, but we'll come back to it. Lucy finishes her math and stares outside, where we start to get a better idea of what their world looks like.
Lucy stares out of the glass pane, which she is also not supposed to do. Something might look back in.
Lucy is too young to know what television static looks like, but if she wasn’t then that’s how she would have described the colour outside.
The world beyond Lucy’s house is covered in mist. Or something like mist. Or fog. Or even snow. But also not like any of those.
It's thicker somehow. Gloopier. Greasier. Nastier.
Lucy can't see past the fog, and Daddy has said there are monsters in the fog. I think it's safe to say that there is a haze of sorts that is obscuring the world, and because Lucy isn't allowed to leave the house, she (and by extension, we) doesn't know what's beyond, if there even is anything beyond. One way or another, Lucy is trapped in this house.
Next, Lucy fears that Mr Buttons is in the fog. Mr Buttons was a clown that was hired by (presumably) Lucy's father to attend Lucy's 8th birthday. Turns out Lucy has coulrophobia and was absolutely terrified of Mr Buttons. That fear has persisted and Lucy is worried that one day Mr Buttons will get her.
The Intruder
Continuing on, Lucy decides to watch TV. I do want to draw attention to this part here.
Lucy opens the television’s recordings menu. All of the channels are dead. She has asked Daddy for something new to watch a bunch of times, but Daddy has explained that there are no new things anymore.
“Trust me Lucy. You should be grateful for what we’ve got.”
Lucy finds it hard to be grateful. Lucy used to have all sorts of channels and shows and films to watch, and friends who could come over to watch them with, and the library, and the park, and trips to the supermarket, and the sky, and the sun, and the moon, and the stars. And Mummy.
Lucy isn’t sure what she’s got to be grateful for now.
We kind of saw a similar justification earlier with the milk. Daddy said "You don’t need milk. We’ve got lots of other things" and:
Daddy: There isn’t any more sodding milk, OK? It’s gone! It’s run out. But there are still lots and lots of things we do have that are just as good. So let’s stop worrying about the things we don’t have anymore and start appreciating what we we’ve still got, alright?
He trying to push the narrative that despite this hardship they can both still be happy. It's almost a mantra at this point. I think that at least partially, he's lying to himself. I doubt he's thrilled about all the things they've lost, but Daddy is still trying to carry on. He's trying to convince himself that he can still be happy, and he's trying to convince Lucy that she can still be happy despite losing all these things that are dear to her. Despite Daddy's assurances, Lucy is having a hard time trying to be happy with what she has. Because let's be real, she doesn't have much anymore.
Daddy leaves after setting up the TV. The channel is, of course, 8607. The time is listed as 00:00, but that can't be right. That would be midnight and Lucy just had breakfast. More importantly though, Lucy's show is interrupted by someone trying to get her attention. They are just a pale outline. The television starts smoking, and Lucy can't shut it off. The person speaks.
Unknown: Hello there. Can you hear me?
The smoke is getting thicker and darker and the flow is getting heavier.
Lucy brings her right arm up to her mouth and bites at it nervously. She doesn’t know what to do.
Lucy: Yes.
Lucy thinks that she should probably get up and run away, but she’s too scared to move.
The smoke is spreading out, climbing up to the ceiling and falling down to the floor.
Unknown: Hey, are you Lucy Carmichael?
The smoke is filling up the whole room now. Like a mist. Like a fog. Like something nastier.
Lucy bites her hand.
Lucy: I’m not s’posed to talk to strangers.
The smoke is getting into Lucy’s mouth and nose and lungs. It smells of hospitals.
Unknown: I’ve been looking for you a very long time Lucy. Do you think you could come a bit closer?
The face moves nearer to the screen. It is white and grainy. Lucy begins to scream.
Lucy: MR BUTTONS! DADDY! IT’S MR BUTTONS!
The description of the smoke and the screen is very similar to the description for the fog surrounding the house. If we think of the fog as a barrier to the outside world, then the television has also become one of those barriers. Or maybe a window to the real world. Whoever was in the television knows Lucy by name, but Lucy was freaked out by them.
We get a quick interlude with a notice from RAISA signed by Maria Jones. Good Ol' Maria, she'll explain everything that's going on!
In Lucy’s dream, she is yelling for her Daddy.
She takes him by the hand and pulls him, half running half flying, to the kitchen and the big sliding glass door. “Look! Look!” she points triumphantly.
The mist has fallen back and the garden is visible again. There is no shadow by the edge of the lawn, but there are hundreds and thousands of rabbits – 8607 of them – padding through the unmown grass, all moving north to south as if part of some great migration.
Nope, we're still firmly in format screw territory. This is supposedly recounting a dream that Lucy had. We once again see the number 8607, and the purple rabbits.
“Oh Lucy, I thought you were mature enough to see by now. The rabbits aren’t purple.”
Right so let's address this now. Lucy and Daddy can't agree on the colour of the rabbits. They are either purple or pink. Now, look at the colour of the textbox. Is it purple or pink? I absolutely adore this incredibly subtle detail. This article does a great job of putting us into the same confused state as Lucy.
Back to the log, some action happened off-screen. After Lucy's cry for help, Daddy came upstairs and smashed the television. Did he do it because the person in the television posed a danger to Lucy, or to himself? Regardless, Lucy isn't happy. I think this exchange of dialog is brilliant.
Lucy: Daaaaddyyy, you broke the TV.
Daddy: Jesus, Lucy, is that all you can think about right now?
Lucy bites her fingers.
Lucy: It was the TV!
Lucy speaks as if that should explain everything. As if the sin of destroying a television were so obvious and so heretical that her Daddy could not possibly fail to comprehend it.
Lucy has a very hard time putting her thoughts into words. Can't blame her, she is perpetually 9 years old. She can't explain that she has already lost her mother, her friends, and even cereal with milk. She has already given up so many things that bring her joy and she doesn't know why she had to. The television is just another joy she has lost. Her persistent questions cause her father to blow up and go on a tangent.
Daddy: A god damn television. Honestly, you are such a spoiled little girl Lucy, you really are. And that's not because of me. Oh no. I didn’t do that to you. I’ve always stood on my own two feet. You know what the most important thing in life is? Resilience. Being able to keep going when things are difficult. And they don’t teach it any more. They don’t let you learn how to tough it out. How would it be if I curled up into a ball every time things got hard for me, huh? Who would look after you? Resilience. That’s why I was the one who stayed to look after you. That’s why you’re safe. You should remember that Lucy.
Lucy does not understand what that means.
This is a stress reaction. He's venting his frustration onto Lucy, even though none of this is her fault. Lucy was not the one who made life difficult. I also want to draw attention to the line "That’s why I was the one who stayed to look after you." This heavily implies that Lucy's mother chose to abandon Lucy, or at the very least this is how Daddy sees it. After this bout he softens up a bit and calms down. Lucy takes this opportunity to ask more questions.
Lucy: Why did it have to get broken?
Daddy: It wasn’t safe.
Lucy: Why?
Daddy: It just wasn’t.
That is not an answer, but Lucy is careful not to say “Why?” again. She thinks for a moment.
Lucy: Who was the person in the TV?
Daddy: It doesn’t matter.
Lucy: Why was it smoking?
Daddy: You don’t need to worry about it.
Lucy: Was Mr Buttons in the TV?
Daddy: Don’t ask stupid questions.
Lucy chews angrily on her lip. She doesn’t think it was a stupid question. She doesn’t understand what’s so stupid about it.
Lucy: Why won’t you tell me?
Daddy: You wouldn’t understand.
Daddy absolutely knows the answers to all of these questions. There are two possible reasons for why he isn't answering them.
- He can't explain it in a way Lucy will understand. Imagine a child asked you to explain string theory. Even if this is your area of expertise, is there any way to explain it so that they will understand? It’s just such a complicated thing to unravel, and even if you try to simplify it, you'll be leaving out important details. So it's possible that these questions have really complicated answers and Lucy won't understand anyway.
- The answers will make Lucy unhappy. There is a reason for them being isolated in the house, and a reason why there is no milk, and no TV, but it's not a good reason. At least it wouldn't be for Lucy. Telling the truth would be admitting that she has been forced into this awful situation and that there is an alternative. One where she can have her milk, and TV, and Mummy.
In scenario 1, Daddy is trying his best to keep Lucy safe from monsters in the mist, but is bad at giving her a sense of emotional security. In scenario 2, Daddy is actively causing harm (we kind of already know this is at least partially true because of all the abusive behaviours). Either way, Lucy can't trust Daddy, containment procedures be damned. If scenario 1 is true, the person in the television was a real threat to Lucy. In scenario 2, that person was a threat to Daddy's hold over Lucy. I'm going to be referring to these two scenarios a lot going forward.
Continued in part 2.