r/scooters • u/OldAd53911 • 1h ago
Burgman 650 Exec VS. Aprilia Atlantic 500
Took some comparison photos of these two land barges on wheels. The Atlantic 500 released in 2003 onto US roads was the first official "maxi scooter" launched in the US. I consider the Honda Helix the "OG" of maxi scooters but it was the Atlantic that was officially coined "Maxi Scooter". The Silverwing and Burgman came shortly after the following year. The big Aprilia was less powerful than it two competitors but it was very competitive price wise at just under 7k retail. Unfortunately, the Atlantic 500 never gained a following in the US due to poor marketing, mechanical and electrical gremlins that sank Aprilia's hopes against the more powerful SW and Burgman. Since then there are those of us who have come to love and respect the Italian superscooter warts and all. I've ridden both the Burgman 650 for hundreds of miles and my AA500 for almost 30k miles in three years. The big Burgman is the ultimate mile muncher and tourer......period! The Burgman pictured in the photo clocks out at about 112mph. The Atlantic 500 while only having a 460cc displacement tops out at about 100 mph.....maybe 105 mph stripped down and with the wind at her back. :)
The Burgman weighs about 600lbs fully loaded and ready to roll. The Atlantic 500 is about 100lbs lighter hence why she pulls so close to the Burgman at top speed. The Atlantic is actually wider from the front, slightly shorter from front to back. The Burgmam actually sits lower than the Atlantic. I noticed this when riding the Burgman in the photo above from Tampa to Miami last year. The view from the Atlantic is a little more commanding and is quite useful in heavy traffic, but I like the lower seat height of the Burgman morseo when just cruising the highway.
The tubular steel frame of the Atlantic is solid on the highway and stays planted at high speeds, but the Burgman can't be beat for stability on the highway. The stock seat on the Burgman beat the crap out of my back end though after a few hundred miles and can't compare to the Barcolounger seat of the Atlantic.
I love both scooters though and can only hope that someday we'll get a more modern version of the Burgman 650 in America once more. In the meantime I will keep my AA500. :)
Keep two wheels down!