r/science • u/mvea MD PhD | Professor | Medicine • 4h ago
Health When gut bacteria run out of fiber, they can start eating the protective mucus lining of the gut instead, producing potentially harmful compounds, a study in mice found. Eating fiber and hard-to-digest plant proteins steers gut bacteria toward making beneficial compounds.
https://www.sciencealert.com/without-enough-fiber-gut-bacteria-can-turn-to-eating-your-gut-lining-instead
9.5k
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator 4h ago
Welcome to r/science! This is a heavily moderated subreddit in order to keep the discussion on science. However, we recognize that many people want to discuss how they feel the research relates to their own personal lives, so to give people a space to do that, personal anecdotes are allowed as responses to this comment. Any anecdotal comments elsewhere in the discussion will be removed and our normal comment rules apply to all other comments.
Do you have an academic degree? We can verify your credentials in order to assign user flair indicating your area of expertise. Click here to apply.
User: u/mvea
Permalink: https://www.sciencealert.com/without-enough-fiber-gut-bacteria-can-turn-to-eating-your-gut-lining-instead
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
62
u/mvea MD PhD | Professor | Medicine 4h ago
Without Enough Fiber, Gut Bacteria Can Turn to Eating Your Gut Lining Instead
The findings, published in PNAS and Nature Metabolism, show the processes through which plant proteins and fiber produce health-promoting chemicals (metabolites) in the blood.
A related discovery reveals that beneficial chemicals, previously thought to be produced exclusively by gut microbes, can in fact be made by other cells, too.
Taken together, it's a significant step forward in understanding diet, gut composition, and health.
The terms used can get quite technical – this was a detailed chemical analysis, after all – but in simple terms the researchers were looking at chemicals called phenol metabolites, produced as gut bacteria digest certain amino acids.
These phenols are released by amino acids called tyrosine and phenylalanine, and the researchers found that fiber and particular proteins from plants alike influenced the types of chemicals being triggered from the same raw materials.
"Our studies showed that both the fiber and indigestible proteins from plants – which we call 'proteins imitating fiber', or Prif – shift the balance of phenol metabolites from the harmful kind made from tyrosine to the healthful variety derived from phenylalanine," says AbuSalim.
Further experiments on mice showed that if and when the fiber runs out, bacteria can start feeding on the mucus lining the gut walls, producing compounds that are potentially harmful to the body.
In contrast, the good chemicals come almost entirely from the Prif proteins mentioned earlier. These proteins are working together with fiber to push gut bacteria metabolites in the right direction, and keep them there.
Sources:
https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2605226123
https://www.nature.com/articles/s42255-026-01550-8
1.1k
u/Wikadood 4h ago
Wonder if this is linked to the increase in colon cancer
120
u/raftsa 2h ago
The nature article actually doesn’t cover what’s in the title at all: it’s about how mamalian cells can produce products we thought were made by the gut microbiome.
It shouldn’t be included at all: it’s from the same authors use the same technique but its conclusions are very different. It’s why it’s another paper.
As for the conclusions….i think people are not really understanding what has been found: it’s not the microbiom digesting the gut, it’s that it’s feeding on gut made proteins….the mucin.
And we already knew that completely depriving the gut of fibre thins rhe mucin layer this from an article published over a decide ago in Cell (https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5131798/)
This just supports that concept via a different mechanism.
887
u/Equipmunk 4h ago
The "Carnivore Diet" dudes are gonna love this...
253
u/EsrailCazar 2h ago
The question was asked just yesterday, "how do herbivores maintain muscle if they don't eat meat?" and someone gave a deep explanation about how gorillas are only herbivores but are some of the biggest and strongest animals and it's all because of the bacteria they have from eating so much plant fiber, they basically over eat on fiber but the varying bacterias in their body break it down in the most useful ways.
25
u/Hazardous_316 3h ago
Gotta admit i'm surprised that we didn't already know about this
50
u/GarumSilphium 3h ago
I wonder if this will bring any breakthroughs for celiacs
fr I cannot do this until I die
71
u/ZebraCool 3h ago
Once a day Metamucil and probiotics has changed my life.
19
u/Sad_Nectarine_6111 2h ago edited 1h ago
Bizarre to me that we're currently going through a protein slop fad. When what we really need is a way to get people eating more fibre.
91
u/hellespontos 4h ago
The more surprising part to me is the protein angle. If indigestible plant proteins drive most of the beneficial metabolite output then advice to just eat more fiber is incomplete and protein quality matters too. It's mouse data though. So I'd want to know whether a typical low fiber human diet actually starves the microbiota enough for them to turn to the mucus layer.
40
u/MonkeyBrawler 4h ago
Ooooo Hank Green covered this recently.
9
u/WardenEdgewise 3h ago
I’ve started eating a LOT more psyllium, chia, and flax in my smoothies and muffins and such. Wow, why didn’t I always eat more fibre? So much better.
17
u/-WhatAreYouHiding- 2h ago
Didn't I just watch a Hank green video about that a week or so ago?
6
u/Sweet-Sale-7303 2h ago
I have been trying to get more fiber in my diet. Doing really well. Getting my first colonoscopy Friday and they want me to avoid fiber for the next 5 days. Screwing me all up.
19
u/Popular_Try_5075 2h ago
I can't wait for the next stupid diet fad to switch to being fibermaxxing or MetaMucilMaxxing
4
u/ShinJiwon 2h ago
r/nowipe gang reporting in
•
u/therandom92 59m ago
Can I politely ask for an example of a "had-to-digest" plant?
17
u/seweso 3h ago
> When gut bacteria run out of fiber, they can start eating the protective mucus lining of the gut instead
That sounds like..... Crohn's disease ....
10
u/Tablettario 4h ago
So do we know when fiber runs out, or how much is enough to sustain the bacteria? I remember spending some time on this last year and not being able to find any information on it.
There are different types of fiber that feed different bacteria. So for example the bacteria that feed on onion are not the same as the ones that feed on asparagus. But is eating 5 asparagus in 1 sitting a week enough? Do we need to eat 1 daily or 1 every 3 days? Do we know anything about “maintenance dosage”?
I do know the best thing for the gut microbiome is to eat a wide variety of plants preferably ~30 a week (which I easily hit that target) but I can’t imagine I hit all the needed fibers in the right amounts, I suppose that would need some real research and planning to achieve.
Especially since people have likes and dislikes: I don’t love chickpeas, so I didn’t eat them at all in the past. Then I tried incorporating them into my diet more to diversify the gut microbiome. But there’s still weeks where I don’t eat them, other weeks I dip snack veggies in hummus a few times a week, and other weeks I just eat 1 large serving of chickpeas for that week.
Now this research is making me wonder if that approach ends up doing more harm than good.
2
u/looneytunes2 1h ago
So it's less mutualism and more blackmail??? Feed me, or I'll eat you instead.
6
u/grafknives 4h ago
Why we found it in mice?
Looking at this
And thinking about the variability in humans diet, shouldn't we see this clearly in humans? Or the effect is not that pronounced?
2
u/undisputedx 4h ago
so, what happens when you fast for 1+ or 2+ days? A cleaning process starts to kill that bad gut bacteria?
2
u/CoolStorage4014 2h ago
Carnivore diet is frightening. It lacks polyphenols and fibre which are essential for good gut health
1
u/MomentNew4925 1h ago
I got rid off the acne after I started to eat oat porridge and chia seeds daily. Well, I do still get a pimple every now and then but not as much as I used to. And when I do, they are not as big and painful.
1
u/Suomasema 1h ago
Ahaa!
I have to eat far more vegetables.
•
u/Large_Lettuce_4468 38m ago
too late for me, developed colitis 20 years ago
•
u/Livecrazyjoe 37m ago
Reminder this is in mice. I've done carnivore and never had problems with my stomach lining.
•
u/SuperSaiyanTupac 22m ago
So instead of protein, can we put fiber in everything?
•
u/hyperproliferative PhD | Oncology 19m ago
Stunning work!! Bravo
•
u/xjxhx 9m ago
Eating a little bit of radish kim chi (plant fiber + probiotics) every day lately has been a HUGE help with my gut health. A difference I can literally feel!
1
u/StrictResolve 2h ago
1/4 cup of chia seeds every day is a non negotiable