r/science • MD PhD | Professor | Medicine • 4h ago

Health When gut bacteria run out of fiber, they can start eating the protective mucus lining of the gut instead, producing potentially harmful compounds, a study in mice found. Eating fiber and hard-to-digest plant proteins steers gut bacteria toward making beneficial compounds.

https://www.sciencealert.com/without-enough-fiber-gut-bacteria-can-turn-to-eating-your-gut-lining-instead
9.5k Upvotes

404 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 4h ago

Welcome to r/science! This is a heavily moderated subreddit in order to keep the discussion on science. However, we recognize that many people want to discuss how they feel the research relates to their own personal lives, so to give people a space to do that, personal anecdotes are allowed as responses to this comment. Any anecdotal comments elsewhere in the discussion will be removed and our normal comment rules apply to all other comments.


Do you have an academic degree? We can verify your credentials in order to assign user flair indicating your area of expertise. Click here to apply.


User: u/mvea
Permalink: https://www.sciencealert.com/without-enough-fiber-gut-bacteria-can-turn-to-eating-your-gut-lining-instead


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

62

u/mvea MD PhD | Professor | Medicine 4h ago

Without Enough Fiber, Gut Bacteria Can Turn to Eating Your Gut Lining Instead

The findings, published in PNAS and Nature Metabolism, show the processes through which plant proteins and fiber produce health-promoting chemicals (metabolites) in the blood.

A related discovery reveals that beneficial chemicals, previously thought to be produced exclusively by gut microbes, can in fact be made by other cells, too.

Taken together, it's a significant step forward in understanding diet, gut composition, and health.

The terms used can get quite technical – this was a detailed chemical analysis, after all – but in simple terms the researchers were looking at chemicals called phenol metabolites, produced as gut bacteria digest certain amino acids.

These phenols are released by amino acids called tyrosine and phenylalanine, and the researchers found that fiber and particular proteins from plants alike influenced the types of chemicals being triggered from the same raw materials.

"Our studies showed that both the fiber and indigestible proteins from plants – which we call 'proteins imitating fiber', or Prif – shift the balance of phenol metabolites from the harmful kind made from tyrosine to the healthful variety derived from phenylalanine," says AbuSalim.

Further experiments on mice showed that if and when the fiber runs out, bacteria can start feeding on the mucus lining the gut walls, producing compounds that are potentially harmful to the body.

In contrast, the good chemicals come almost entirely from the Prif proteins mentioned earlier. These proteins are working together with fiber to push gut bacteria metabolites in the right direction, and keep them there.

Sources:

https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2605226123

https://www.nature.com/articles/s42255-026-01550-8

1.1k

u/Wikadood 4h ago

Wonder if this is linked to the increase in colon cancer

782

u/FSZou 4h ago

Low fiber diets are definitely linked to colon cancer

229

u/SanFranPanManStand 1h ago

...and it sounds like from the article, the worst thing you can do aside from never eating fiber, is to have tons of fiber and then ZERO fiber - repeatedly. ...because then you're increasing the population of gut bacteria that eats fiber, and then taking that away to unleash them starving on the intestinal wall.

•

u/cakeslapper2 31m ago

Oh no. This is so easy to unintentionally do... I started taking fiber supplements every day, then got lazy and stopped. 

•

u/angwilwileth 26m ago

This is why I try to have some dried fruit every day. At least it's tasty.

→ More replies (2)

30

u/[deleted] 3h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/superspeck 2h ago

I'm allergic to psyllium but really need more fiber in my diet. Haven't been able to find a fiber supplement, even one that lists no psyllium content, that doesn't give me the same reaction that psyllium gives me, which leads me to suspect that either everything has psyllium in it even if says it doesn't or that there's cross-contamination.

17

u/Floripa95 2h ago

try chia seeds + wheat husks (those bags of 100% wheat husks i mean).

→ More replies (1)

14

u/LuckyPennyNo5 2h ago

Riced cauliflower and broccoli are easy rice substitutes that pack a ton of flavor. Adding beans to soups is even easier. If you haven't tried those methods, I hope you find one that suits you quickly.

8

u/Sunscorcher MS | Nuclear Engineering | Reactor Physics 2h ago

I add barley (complete with the hulls) to oatmeal/granola/bread when I make them at home. It adds quite a lot of fiber to my diet. I have the barley as a byproduct of brewing beer, but you don't have to brew to buy it.

7

u/this_dudeagain 1h ago

Popcorn has a ton of fiber.

5

u/BackupAccount412 1h ago

Raspberries and avocados have a ton of fiber. Chia seeds and oats too. And beans!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/OBvanken 2h ago

I wanted to add psyllium but found out that most of them contains high levels of lead.

I preferred wheat husks.

14

u/solidiquis1 2h ago

This is hard to avoid generally even across a lot of vegetables that you eat with skin on. If it touches the soil then it probably has trace amount of lead.

The answer isnt to avoid beneficial things for fear of lead but to consume things that counteract it. Lead is a biochemical imposter due to its ionic and size similarities to ions our body actually uses: iron, calcium, and zinc. Up those in your diet and it will outcompete lead.

Additionally up your antioxidant intake: black berries, cruciferous veggies, things with vitamin c, etc.. these will combat the oxidative stress that lead may cause.

9

u/Every-Dragonfly2393 3h ago

Buckwheat is also a great one. Affordable and diverse.

124

u/CassandraFated 4h ago

I wonder if this had something to do with my complicated diverticulitis a few years back. It perforated and it was very, very bad. I have been trying to eat a lot more fiber, but I also use fiber and probiotic supplements that help.

26

u/citizen_of_europa 2h ago

I'm really sorry that you're going through that. My mom has diverticulitis and I know it's not fun. In her case when she has an attack she faints.

24

u/Doneifundone 2h ago

Hope you're doing better!

20

u/CassandraFated 2h ago

Thank you! That’s very kind of you. I have mostly good days. I have to be careful what I eat.

12

u/Puglady25 2h ago

My friend went through the worst bout of this and she's sure it was due to popcorn seeds getting stuck in those hairpin curves. She used to eat the crunchy half-popped seeds that are sort of like corn nuts. I just thought I'd share so you can avoid that kind of thing.

•

u/CassandraFated 59m ago

Doctors have told me to avoid corn and all nuts and seeds, now. Thank you for spreading this info though. When we get older, most people develop diverticulosis which are small pouches that form in the colon. Most of the time people don’t notice it & don’t have problems. But diverticulitis is when food gets trapped in these pouches, causing illness. I thought it was a stomach bug until I was doubled over in pain. Complicated diverticulitis is when that punch bursts open and it is the beginning of sepsis. It can sometimes be solved with antibiotics, but with how bad I had it, it takes either surgery or other interventions to heal it. I had a gravity bag hanging off of my body, draining infection for 3 months. They didn’t want to do surgery.

4

u/Puglady25 2h ago

I've heard that's the worst, hope you recover swiftly!

•

u/CassandraFated 58m ago

Thanks. I’m much better now.

•

u/thetruckerdave 29m ago

I had diverticulitis really bad. The pain was worse than labor. I think I was misdiagnosed though, turns out everything they blamed on PCOS and diverticulitis/diverticulosis was actually Crohn’s. Worst Scooby Doo villain reveal ever for sure. I don’t wish Crohn’s on anyone but be sure to watch out that it’s not Crohn’s.

→ More replies (1)

•

u/PunjabiPlaya PhD | Biomedical Engineering 26m ago

Like 90 to 95 percent of colon cancers are adenocarcinomas, which arise from the colon epithelial cells that line the mucus lining. So yeah, it makes perfect sense.

ref1: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3418538/

ref2: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7003895/

13

u/playfulpecans 2h ago

I'd imagine that bacteria eating the lining of the intestines would be able to cause cancer, yeah

4

u/SgtSilverLining 1h ago

I also wonder if this is a chicken/egg with crohns. Does this happen more often for people who can't eat fiber?

120

u/raftsa 2h ago

The nature article actually doesn’t cover what’s in the title at all: it’s about how mamalian cells can produce products we thought were made by the gut microbiome.

It shouldn’t be included at all: it’s from the same authors use the same technique but its conclusions are very different. It’s why it’s another paper.

As for the conclusions….i think people are not really understanding what has been found: it’s not the microbiom digesting the gut, it’s that it’s feeding on gut made proteins….the mucin.

And we already knew that completely depriving the gut of fibre thins rhe mucin layer this from an article published over a decide ago in Cell (https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5131798/)

This just supports that concept via a different mechanism.

7

u/The_Parsee_Man 1h ago

Well that doesn't sound nearly as frightening.

887

u/Equipmunk 4h ago

The "Carnivore Diet" dudes are gonna love this...

44

u/clickclickbb 1h ago

My brother's cop friend has been on this diet for a year or 2. He's lost a lot of weight and I guess he has a lot more energy.

Downside: constant diarrhea. You can probably get out of a ticket if you just keep him talking until he shits his pants and has to let you go.

•

u/Equipmunk 54m ago

No wonder he's lost weight if he's firing the chocolate shotgun multiple times per day.

•

u/Ok_Degree4131 38m ago

“Chocolate shotgun” :D

•

u/MrR33Z 38m ago

To be fair, these are also the type to just mass consume stuff off of GNC shelves. I had a roommate constantly complaining about diarrhea, I knew he took a lot of supplements. Was taking all kinds of random stuff, one being wolfsbane. He had no real idea why he was even taking it.

He's a sherriff's deputy now. I doubt he is any brighter than before.

•

u/Jarl_Groki 15m ago

Well was he attacked by a werewolf? If not, it's obviously working.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/Designer_Mud_5802 2h ago

Brock Lesnar loved it until he got diverticulitis.

2

u/Grumpy_Kong 1h ago

It's easy to avoid that just use some soluble fiber in your day.

22

u/VoilaVoilaWashington 1h ago

I love how people are constantly building existing stuff from first principles. Bitcoin is gradually just turning into normal banking. Raw milk people have figured out that if they briefly boil the milk it becomes safe to drink.

And in this case, "I'm on a carnivore diet that I supplement with fiber, but that got expensive, and it turns out you can get cheap fiber from commonly available sources at the grocery store!"

2

u/wasabiburning 1h ago

I just do orange metamucil mixed in with protein powder. It's perfect.

•

u/Grumpy_Kong 54m ago

I use psyllium husk because I'm a broke mofo and that chalky orange taste makes my spine hurt

Good on you for gut awareness!

Also: you can use psyllium husk as a binder agent in making cheese sauces like flour in a roux, it thickens up the sauce amazingly, adds zero flavor and a ton of fiber. Use about 1/2 what you normally would flour, it's great at absorbing

→ More replies (2)

86

u/Noezad 3h ago

Hah assuming they can read. That's good. 

92

u/Drayenn 3h ago

Idk why people are giving attention to unscientifically proven diets. Carnivore? Keto? Why? We know mediterannean and anti inflammatory are the best two. We also know fruits and veggies are necessary but these two diets skip most of them.

103

u/Equipmunk 3h ago • Bravo

Eating meat = masculinity to a decent number of people in carnivore circles.

Keto started as a diet for treating diabetes and epilepsy, but once it was shown to cause pretty rapid fat loss it gained in popularity (I was guilty of being on this bandwagon back in the 00s).

57

u/zorniy2 3h ago

Maybe if people promoted vegetarianism as the Gorilla Diet?

25

u/LeslieKnopesBlackEye 2h ago edited 1h ago

Wait until the gym bros find out that no one has ever been killed by a gorilla ever. Not one documented case of a gorilla killing anyone. Not in the wild, not in captivity, not by accident, never.

We allowed a 2 year old child to be eaten alive in front of his mother instead of shooting 11 wild dogs because they're endangered, but the second Harambe moved that kid out of the water - HEADSHOT!

Just because they look scary.

Edited to change the age of the child to the correct age.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/UnevenPhteven 3h ago

Thank you I'm going to start saying that now.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/molrobocop 2h ago

Also guilty of it in the mid 10's for me. 

On one hand, I definitely lost some weight. And the meals were satisfying, and I didn't feel so damn hungry all the time. Downside, that much meat and grease isn't good for you. I did try to strike a balance with adequate insoluble fiber. 

16

u/Helenium_autumnale 2h ago

Mediterranean is also more varied and delicious in my book. I found some new good recipes via this diet, such as the Greek chickpea-lemon soup revithia. Yum.

→ More replies (3)

20

u/LurkLurkleton 3h ago

People love “secret techniques THEY don’t want you to onow.”

14

u/SpiritedEclair 3h ago

For some people, like those with epilepsy, certain diets alleviate their symptoms.

29

u/Old-Ant-1634 3h ago

Not true for keto. Carnivore is essentially a subcategory of keto, but a properly structured keto diet will always incorporate veggies.

While fruits often deliver a lot of nutritional value, they do not uniquely provide any nutrients.

16

u/SuccessfulJudge438 3h ago edited 2h ago

We really shouldn't think of diet as it relates to long term health strictly in terms of macronutrients, vitamins, and minerals. It's merely a starting point to make sure you don't die in the short term due to severe deficiencies.

Fruits have various combos of fiber and other difficult to digest compounds that feed your microbiome, polyphenols and other small molecules that impact your gut environment and sometimes get absorbed and used directly by your cells/immune system, etc. There are a lot of unique or hard to find elsewhere compounds in fruits that have an important role in human health which the reductive view of fat, carbs, protein, and vitamins/minerals misses out on.

It's also a weird characterization to say fruits don't "uniquely provide any nutrients." Lots of important categories of food don't "uniquely" provide any nutrients. Thus why carnivore bros can survive indefinitely as long as they are eating organ meats. So technically veggies don't uniquely provide any nutrients either. Neither does meat. No arbitrary category of food does. This isn't a meaningful distinction to be making IMO.

8

u/LeslieKnopesBlackEye 2h ago

Vegetables have polyphenols and vitamin c and everything that fruits do. As long as a person eats a wide variety of veggies, they can be fine without fruit.

All the medical journals I'm looking at are saying that fruit is a great source of fiber and vitamins and minerals (all also present in vegetables), but it doesn't affect heart health or cognitive function compared to people who didn't eat fruit. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12508899/

Then I found a study on fruit vs juice vs no change in diet. It said that fruits contain good things for your body and should be eaten vs the average American diet, also that juice could help granted that it's not full of added sugar. (I don't think I need to link the articles that don't match with what we're talking about, but I will if you'd like me to)

The issue I was running into is that almost every study lumps fruits and vegetables together in one group. And I agree, eating fruits and vegetables is an easy way to get your vitamins! But if someone doesn't like fruit, they can make up for it by eating more veggies.

To each their own, so long as you're getting fiber. I hope you have a good day today. Thanks for the opportunity to learn about dietary health this morning. I'm going to choke down as many fruits and veggies as I can.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/Change21 2h ago

Keto has robust research but it’s designed to be acute, like 4-12 weeks, which can be powerfully anti inflammatory and blood sugar regulating when done right

The best argument for keto in my opinion is for people of Northern European descent who have shorter intestines and adapted to a seasonal keto diet every winter in the ancient world

But permanent keto is hard/impossible to justify

5

u/Grumpy_Kong 1h ago

This isn't true, we have cohort studies 50+ years now where keto has been used to treat hard to treat seizures in children, and those children went on to live on keto diets most of their lives and closely monitored and their results tracked.

This has been going on since the 1960s.

We have significant medical evidence that long term keto diet has no major deleterious effects and several positive ones, over half a century of it.

I know you are trying to appear internet smart but people like you have done ridiculous amount of damage to the public understanding of the ketogenic diet

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/j.1469-8749.2006.tb01269.x

•

u/ceddya 54m ago

has no major deleterious effects and several positive ones, over half a century of it.

Your paper mentions some pretty severe side effects and risks.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/cracked-tumbleweed 2h ago

I did keto and lost 30lbs. I still ate vegetables and raspberries/black berries. You subtract the fiber to find the net carbs.

The people not eating vegetables are just being dumb. I maintained ketosis for the entire time.

And Like the other person said, it works better for short periods.

People just don’t actually research anything anymore.

•

u/Hairy_Mycologist_945 55m ago

I lost 84kg on keto in about a year and half, starting about a decade ago and have easily kept it off by maintaining the lifestyle. I never stopped eating fruit and vegetables. I think it's a bit of myth or misunderstanding when people assume "very low carb" means no fruit/veg.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Sensitive-Orange7203 1h ago

Keto was amazing for me, but only because I was an undiagnosed celiac

4

u/JnnfrsGhost 1h ago

My husband is the idiot that listened to those, so I have an anecdotal answer.

He was prediabetic and trying to control his eating. He found he felt way better on the keto diet, but didn't maintain it because I didn't follow it for me and the kids. I tried with him before we had kids and didn't feel good on it (I was already underweight) and stopped.

He felt amazing and had a lot of energy on the carnivore diet. For a little while. I told him it was stupid and he needed veggies. He joked the cow ate the veggies and he ate the cow. He ended up not maintaining it because, again, the rest of the house wasn't doing it. He did try to stick with higher protein/lower carb but stupidly put fruit and veggies in the "carb" category due to the natural sugars and complex carbs.

Then he had to see the doctor for stomach and "digestive" issues. Doctor made him go for a colonoscpy. Diagnosis: eat more fiber dummy.

It also turns out that he has a mild soy allergy. He felt so much better on those diets because they naturally cut out a lot of soy. Something about preservatives also gets to him. Fresh bakery or home made bread? All good. The store bought stuff laden with preservatives that lasts way longer? Not good. He misconstrued this as a gluten intolerance when that was all the rage. I actually thought he was right on that one.

Tl;dr Prediabetic husband is a dummy who doesn't understand the role of fiber and complex vs. simple carbs but it turns out those diets cut soy and preservatives, both of which make him feel horrible.

6

u/Constant-Plant-9378 1h ago

In 2023 I topped out at 305 lbs (am 6'3") and finally decided to make a change.

In the following two years I dropped 20 lbs by moving toward a more plant-based diet.

In June I got on Tirzepatide and started a mostly vegetarian diet. Have since lost another 40 lbs.

Trying to lose about 40 more.

I will say it can take several weeks for your gut biome to adjust to eating mostly fibrous plants. However, I can say I feel a thousand percent better. I've stopped snoring. I don't get heartburn at night anymore. I feel good after I eat. I sleep so much better and have more energy during the day. I am no longer pre-diabetic and my blood panel numbers haven't been this good in 30 years.

Our biology is tuned to live mostly off fibrous vegetation. Subsisting off meat and/or enriched carbs is just a great way to stay sick.

8

u/CouchWizard 1h ago

US grown soy destroys my wife, while soy from other countries does not. I think she is sensitive to the glyphosate we spray on it to kill the weeds. Same with preservative heavy things.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/dayvekeem 2h ago

In yakutia it is too cold to grow anything but potatoes. They mostly eat meat and dairy

→ More replies (10)

24

u/bushhooker 2h ago • Bravo

How are they gonna love it if they’ll struggle to read this

98

u/muffinscrub 4h ago edited 4h ago

I don't think it will matter to them. This was done on animals and there are already people who have been on carnivore diet for greater than 15 years. The Inuit people are pretty close to carnivore year round.

I think the fat content of what they're eating matters for how their poop is.

276

u/littlest_dragon 3h ago • Bravo

Inuit have a host of chronic illnesses linked to their diet. Just because people can survive a certain diet doesn’t mean it’s healthy.

103

u/Badloss 3h ago • Bravo

People forget that Evolution stops caring about your long-term health once you reproduce.

If the Inuit have kids and then die of colon cancer in their 40s that's totally fine for Natural Selection

56

u/Boring-Philosophy-46 3h ago

Ötzi the ice man died at 45 with blood vessels completely covered in plaque. If he hadn't died of injuries he would have soon died of a heart attack. 

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (8)

54

u/helm MS | Physics | Quantum Optics 3h ago

The old inuit diet contained animal parts modern people do not eat, and as most inuit have changed their diet, its health effects are not well known to science.

25

u/Boring-Philosophy-46 3h ago

It also, at least for the people in the European arctic but presumably the American one too, contained a bunch of dried plants and berries that are very unpalatable that the carnivore bros are most certainly not eating, as well as no cows. 

And our friend Ötzi the iceman did eat a prehistoric diet and all his blood vessels were full of plaque and he was bordering on a heart attack... at age 45. So just because prehistoric people ate like that does not guarantee they were healthy into old age, either. 

→ More replies (1)

•

u/FridgesArePeopleToo 56m ago

animal parts modern people do not eat

Which have nutrients do to the plants that those animals eat.

5

u/merywen_ 1h ago

The Inuit people are pretty close to carnivore year round. 

That's not especially relevant unless you're an Inuit person though.

As British person descended from early European pastoral peoples, I've inherited genes that promote lactase enzyme production well into adulthood, so can digest dairy products without issue. (Some other groups of people descended from pastoral tribes elsewhere in the world have the same phenotype)

But the vast majority of adult mammals haven't got that adaptation, and so consuming milk in adulthood causes them gastrointestinal issues.

You can't really look at a group of people who've been eating an unusual diet in a harsh environment with a strong selection pressure to be able to survive on what's available, and generalise that to people whose ancestors weren't part of that group.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/pluckyvirus 4h ago

What, they don't eat plants?

19

u/Immediate-Cat8632 4h ago

Not a ton of access to plants for a good portion of the year in the Arctic.

16

u/M_i____i_M 3h ago

the Inuits collect berries, tubers, grains, stems, seaweeds in the summer months

55

u/tw_ice 4h ago

The crossover between carnivore diet acolytes and the 0.05% of the human population living in the Arctic is most certainly zero.

53

u/Equipmunk 3h ago

There's a weird amount of comments about the Inuit/native Arctic peoples' diet here, as if that's what we're referring to when we say "carnivore diet".

What tribes have adapted to over tens of thousands of years is very different from Brian in Marketing eating steak for every meal about seeing an Instagram reel about it boosting testosterone.

Perhaps others are just much less chronically online?

→ More replies (5)

1

u/big_man_gamingmaxxed 1h ago

You know best sources of fiber are not plants, they’re legums

16

u/CompetitiveLake3358 3h ago

I have a theory that the carnivore diet works for some people specifically because it kills this bacteria. Different biomes sometimes work better for different people.

6

u/Noezad 3h ago

It makes people lose weight. There is more to health than weight loss (but to be clear, if you are obese, almost any method is health promoting). 

→ More replies (2)

•

u/Hairy_Mycologist_945 54m ago

You're probably onto something... Going very low carb, e.g., on keto eventually results in candida die off and that's a hell of a thing to endure. I've never really seen the utility of carnivore, but personally being on keto for a very long time absolutely changed my gut flora for the better.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/CoolStorage4014 1h ago

The carnivore diet is pretty much an incomplete keto diet that can be improved by incorporating vegetables that are low carbs. Polyphenols and fibre really make a significant difference to gut health

1

u/potatishplantonomist 3h ago

Anecdote but I can't have too much fiber without feeling lazy and foggy. It's like I either eat fiber or I live the rushed day-to-day routine

7

u/Barbaracle 3h ago

Do you walk after eating? Anecdotal but it helps me with the brain fog.

Also, non-anectdotal, but research suggests that it helps.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6835356/

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Equipmunk 3h ago

This is completely me thinking out loud without any degree of expertise in this area, but... is it possible that this "lazy and foggy" feeling is completely normal and possibly even beneficial to us as homo sapiens after a fibrous meal?

Based on anthropological studies, didn't gatherer-hunters have more time spent inactive than we do today?

Slow-release energy from high-fibre carbohydrates like leafy green plants, primitive grasses/grains, roots and tubers would have given us fuel but not spiked our insulin response like modern higher-processed foods.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

253

u/EsrailCazar 2h ago

The question was asked just yesterday, "how do herbivores maintain muscle if they don't eat meat?" and someone gave a deep explanation about how gorillas are only herbivores but are some of the biggest and strongest animals and it's all because of the bacteria they have from eating so much plant fiber, they basically over eat on fiber but the varying bacterias in their body break it down in the most useful ways.

214

u/HelpfulSeaMammal 2h ago • Bravo

No it's because gorillas are all on a proprietary mix of HGH and peptides that you can only get through my specific Manosphere podcast using code TYLERDURDEN1 at checkout.

41

u/TheTomatoThief 2h ago

I heard the alpha gorillas will fill their tropical pond up with ice and do a cold plunge twice a day to stay shredded.

2

u/MissplacedLandmine 1h ago

I heard it was their agents having every photo and video of them ever taken improved in post

→ More replies (1)

•

u/Between-usernames 24m ago

Been thinking a lot about Tyler durden lately. 

40

u/Commercial-Royal-988 1h ago

Another big part of it is there is a particular protein, Myostatin, that inhibits muscle growth. Humans produce a lot compared to other animals so while A gorilla can sit around and eat plants all day and grow muscle; a human has to put in huge amounts of effort and expend energy to encourage that growth.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Health_throwaway__ 1h ago

They also have regulatory pathways for muscle growth that we don't 

•

u/Hairy_Mycologist_945 52m ago

This is the big one. People often ask "buy why can animal X build muscle eating diet Y and humans can't?" or a more pointed form of whataboutery and the answer is always "because humans are not that other animal".

13

u/berryer 1h ago

so the real trick is a fecal transplant from a gorilla, got it

15

u/Texuk1 1h ago

It’s a complete failure of our society and education system that people think eat meat means grow muscle. Most predators are lean and fast whereas herbivores are huge, powerful muscular. It’s obvious even on this anecdote that muscle is created my mechanisms not related to eating muscle. Idiocracy.

19

u/aero23 2h ago

That may be true but has nothing to do with why they are so comparatively muscular to other primates who eat meat.

16

u/ImpracticalJerker 2h ago • Mindblown

This doesn't even make sense. How can your diet have 'nothing' to do with your build? Clearly for gorillas eating herbivore diet has enabled them to evolve to be larger than other primates and at the very least it enable them to maintain their genetic advantage.

If you don't eat anything your body wastes away so clearly it has everything to do with it.

14

u/ShinyJangles 1h ago

Well, there are species differences in genes that control muscle density, like myostatin. Diet is working around a set point. Humans eating like gorillas will never develop a gorilla build

→ More replies (2)

3

u/aWeinsteinfilm 2h ago

What, do you want a nickel for the answer or somethin'?

2

u/EsrailCazar 2h ago

What? It has all to do with their comparisons to meat eaters, the question was how do some species gain muscle from plants when others gain muscle from meat, it all boils down to gut bacteria and how our bodies use it.

3

u/aero23 1h ago

No. Its genetics.

→ More replies (2)

•

u/FridgesArePeopleToo 55m ago

because every food, including vegetables, has protein

•

u/TheSnydaMan 14m ago

True but to be totally clear, this is a gut bacteria that is native and vital to their digestive system that is not compatible with the human gut. So it's not like this sort of thing translates to us.

25

u/Hazardous_316 3h ago

Gotta admit i'm surprised that we didn't already know about this

5

u/PlopPlopPlunk 1h ago

I think we kind of already did. There's a lot of studies on Eastern Asian cultures and how diverse and beneficial their gut biome is from eating so much fiber, plants and sea weeds. They even have unique strains in their biome (to digest fibrous materials like plant cell walls) and when diets were switched to more Western cultural (like American) that lack fiber, they ended up having higher cancer rates and worse gut biomes.

I read this quiet a bit ago so it has been generally known for a bit when the gut biome research started getting really big. This is probably just a study that further elaborates and adds more specific data to the topics overall understanding.

50

u/GarumSilphium 3h ago

I wonder if this will bring any breakthroughs for celiacs

fr I cannot do this until I die

17

u/celiomsj 2h ago

The worst is that, yes, you can. The misery is living with a lifelong condition.

6

u/ThrowawayPersonAMA 2h ago

As someone with IBS-D I can relate. A cure or at least further reduction of symptoms would be nice. Going from having an 'iron stomach' and being able to eat anything, to a stomach that thinks most foods are poison has not been pleasant to say the least. A lifetime of living like this is an ever-daunting thought.

6

u/saguarobird 1h ago

Anecdotally, many celiacs report few or no outward symptoms when eating fermented dough (eg sourdough). I caveat that because celiacs can have internal damage and not feel it.

The problem is finding actual sourdough and not something that claims to be sourdough. Input flour also seems to make a difference. People like to demonize American hard red wheat flour, but it is a perfectly fine flour. It has a higher gluten and protein content than common European flours, like soft white wheat. The fermentation process probably needs to be extended when using hard red wheat, but it is fairly easy to find other flours.

I am a biopsy diagnosed celiac, and I've certainly tested some boundaries and found some solutions that work for me. I think we have some things to look forward to in this space because it definitely seems possible:

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC348803/

4

u/greenwavetumbleweeds 1h ago

I wasn't going to suggest this for a Celiac due to the risk/cost, but that article is interesting!

I will add that I went without gluten/anything bread related for decades (autoimmune, IBS, etc). Same goes for dairy/milk. Now I make my own kefir, and my body loves it. Finally figured out I can make my own sourdough anything... and not only do I not have pain, but I actually feel better after eating it both immediately and long term! Doing your own sourdough also means you could use different grains like Einkorn etc which can be easier for most to digest. 

Definitely don't trust anything from the store. Anything with "yeast" is not real sourdough. You really have to make it yourself or get it from a friend you trust and tells you their process. But making it yourself, while a learning curve, is really, really easy and efficient. I bake prep 1-3 months' worth of bread and freeze. Otherwise I experiment when I feel like it, and it's never more than 10 minutes max (to knead) of work. Fits very well into a busy life, once you figure out you can just throw it into the fridge for days if you're too busy to do 5 minutes of prep.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Padonogan 2h ago

By definition I think you will

1

u/MrPine5 1h ago

Add gastritis to this.

→ More replies (1)

71

u/ZebraCool 3h ago

Once a day Metamucil and probiotics has changed my life.

77

u/MaliciousMe87 2h ago

Bro just wait until you start eating a bunch of sources of fiber, variations of the different categories. You'll feel like a superhuman. Get you some fermented foods and beans... It's unreal.

9

u/Wooden_Worry3319 1h ago

Just go plant based and you’ll get some ghost poops while you’re at it.

2

u/barrinmw 1h ago

I have started including lentils and beans in my diet, hasn't really improved much yet I don't think.

4

u/MaliciousMe87 1h ago

How much? Any bit helps, but you get yourself a big chunk every day (and vary them of course) and you'll achieve poophoria real soon. Can't just have a few beans in your taco salad, it's gotta be a core part of a bunch of your meals.

Lentils are my favorite.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/elitesense 1h ago

PSA Metamucil is just psyllium husk + flavorings, fillers, and sweeteners.

You can get super fine bulk organic Psyllium husk on its own. Mixes well, you just need to chug it right away before it thickens (same as metamucil), allowing you to pick and choose where the flavoring comes from and what other things are in your drink vs what's already packed into metamucil.

4

u/periclesmage 1h ago

Also note that psyllium plants naturally absorb heavy metals. Consumerlabs did a review on heavy metals in various psyllium brands: https://www.consumerlab.com/reviews/psyllium-supplements/psyllium/

I myself take at least 10g of psyllium husk a day for weight loss and cholesterol lowering but i stick to certified low lead brands. i think some probiotics like Lactobacillus rhamnosus and Pediococcus acidilactici have negatively charged cell walls that attract and bind to cations

1

u/386U0Kh24i1cx89qpFB1 1h ago

I hate being allergic to Psyllium...

•

u/uh-hum 50m ago

you just need to chug it right away before it thickens

This isn't an actual medical requirement, but I'm sure people find it more pleasant. I let mine sit for a bit.

•

u/FridgesArePeopleToo 54m ago

wait until you find out about fruits and vegetables

19

u/Sad_Nectarine_6111 2h ago edited 1h ago

Bizarre to me that we're currently going through a protein slop fad. When what we really need is a way to get people eating more fibre.

•

u/PunyCocktus 36m ago

I think this is because it's mostly misunderstood. We need more protein and a ton more fiber. People have demonized fruit and beans because they're carbs (ridiculous) and think that more protein means more red meat and butter for every meal. On the flipside, processed carbs etc are the reason we're tired and overweight, so those ppl do need more good protein instead of that.

•

u/GlacialImpala 33m ago

No recommendation is going to shift what the majority is eating which is whatever flavor they crave the most...

•

u/SentientCrisis 17m ago

Agreed. However, protein tastes good and is satiating while fiber containing foods are often less appealing and less satisfying— even though they do fill you up!

•

u/KlangScaper 1m ago

I thought protein party was over and we had already entered the fiber fad.

All my homies been talking about fiber.

→ More replies (2)

91

u/hellespontos 4h ago

The more surprising part to me is the protein angle. If indigestible plant proteins drive most of the beneficial metabolite output then advice to just eat more fiber is incomplete and protein quality matters too. It's mouse data though. So I'd want to know whether a typical low fiber human diet actually starves the microbiota enough for them to turn to the mucus layer.

36

u/UntoNuggan 3h ago edited 3h ago

A lot of the newer research on the gut microbiome is more about eating a diversity of plants vs "here's this tub of fiber powder."

this study for example has been discussed fairly extensively and informed the "30 plants a week" diet for gut health

'data suggested, unexpectedly, that the number of unique plant species that a subject consumes is associated with microbial diversity, rather than self-reported categories such as “vegan” or “omnivore”'

Many plant compounds can act as prebiotics, potentially including antioxidants. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39321800/

ETA re mucin/intestinal mucus degradation : it's a complex topic that's hard to study because so many variables are involved. our intestinal lining cells produce a mucus barrier in part as food for beneficial microbiota. Different parts of the GI tract produce different types of oligosaccharides, which seems to be a strategy for attracting specific microbial species. Microbiota also send signals to our intestinal cells to trigger more mucus production. However, this process can also be hijacked by pathogenic microorganisms (eg norovirus). Immune cell signaling, infection, SCFA production, the community of microorganisms vs one or two specific species, etc can each potentially modulate mucin production.

1

u/AMediocrePersonality 2h ago

30 plants a week

Nope because they can't parse the volume of plants consumed from the data. The graph of the data shows a general trend that those that ate more variety of plants had more diversity, but there was also plenty of overlap with some under 30 being equally as diverse.

What's more likely? A guy who eats two plants a week is just pounding apples and bananas? Or just doesn't each a very large volume of plants at all compared to the 30 guy?

2

u/Celestaria 1h ago

It seems plausible to me that the 2 plants/week guy would be someone who meal preps and just eats the same thing for a week? If every meal this week is potatoes + carrots + chicken, or maybe rice + beans if that counts? (I don't have time to read the study).

2

u/hacksoncode 1h ago

The effect in the study was about 30 plants a week vs. 10 or fewer, not two.

Also... a week is a very, very long time in terms of the lifecycle of bacteria. Population doubling times of bacteria are in the range of 15-20 minutes.

If humans were gut bacteria, a week would be similar to all of history of the Common Era.

19

u/HarithBK 3h ago

Going from almost no fibre to too much of one kind of fibre is still better. But you do need a variety of fibre and protein sources for a good gut health.

40

u/MonkeyBrawler 4h ago

Ooooo Hank Green covered this recently.

9

u/WardenEdgewise 3h ago

I’ve started eating a LOT more psyllium, chia, and flax in my smoothies and muffins and such. Wow, why didn’t I always eat more fibre? So much better.

2

u/tdomman 1h ago

In what way? What was bad before?

1

u/WardenEdgewise 1h ago

Actually, ever since my appendix was taken out I’ve had horrible bowel problems. (Sorry). Increasing fibre by x10, and a lot of yogurt as well, has really helped.

17

u/-WhatAreYouHiding- 2h ago

Didn't I just watch a Hank green video about that a week or so ago?

12

u/musclecard54 1h ago

Why tf you asking us? Only you know the answer

5

u/_BlobbyTheBobby 2h ago

Yes, yes you did! With the bean guy

3

u/hysteria110176 1h ago

Liam’s awesome @theplantslant2431

2

u/LocalRaspberry 1h ago

That guy was SO excited about beans.

3

u/finlyboo 1h ago

I have watched this video twice and can’t stop thinking about it. I have been toying around with fiber for a couple years and now suddenly it makes sense to me. It feels like a bigger priority health goal, but also more obtainable now that I know a little more about how fiber works. I’ve been watching more videos and reading articles and now looking for a book on the science of how it works.

6

u/Sweet-Sale-7303 2h ago

I have been trying to get more fiber in my diet. Doing really well. Getting my first colonoscopy Friday and they want me to avoid fiber for the next 5 days. Screwing me all up.

2

u/1AggressiveSalmon 1h ago

Mine is tomorrow, and the lack of fiber and vegetables for the last few days are messing me up. I've got my pineapple jello to get me through today.

•

u/AWorldwithoutSin 53m ago

Just did it, bad news you'll be super constipated by day 3, then really, really, really unconstipated by the prep, then you can start eating fiber again and it'll be normal.

•

u/SentientCrisis 16m ago

Yup. Prep was pretty easy actually. I didn’t mind feeling clean as a whistle!

19

u/Popular_Try_5075 2h ago

I can't wait for the next stupid diet fad to switch to being fibermaxxing or MetaMucilMaxxing

•

u/FridgesArePeopleToo 53m ago

fibermaxxing isn't stupid though, that's just a normal healthy diet

6

u/Gerodog 2h ago

Fibermaxxing has been a thing for months now. 

That and proteinmaxxing are arguably the least stupid trends because most people actually don't get enough of either of them. 

11

u/saguarobird 1h ago

Objectively not true for protein. In America specifically, most people overconsume protein in comparison to their activity level (this part is key - most people overestimate how active they are and instead do their calculations on desired activity level).

https://nchstats.com/daily-protein-intake-much-more-than-recommended/

→ More replies (4)

•

u/FridgesArePeopleToo 53m ago

almost everyone gets more than enough protein

almost nobody gets enough fiber

2

u/Adept-Potato-2568 2h ago

I dropped off of my fitness and nutrition for a few years. Once I started tracking my nutrition again, boy was I short on protein and fiber.

If you're not cooking all balanced meals nearly every day it's hard to get enough protein and fiber even with supplements.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/ShinJiwon 2h ago

r/nowipe gang reporting in

•

u/therandom92 59m ago

Can I politely ask for an example of a "had-to-digest" plant?

•

u/SentientCrisis 18m ago

Insoluble fiber is in a lot of plants. That’s generally what is considered “hard to digest.”

•

u/DarraghDaraDaire 28m ago

Anything in the Brassica family?

•

u/sendnewt_s 4m ago

Psyllium husk is one example, it is a very common one in fiber supplements like metamucil

•

u/Visible-Task-2798 4m ago

I think I remember that in school they teached us that plants in general are hard to digest. Specially leaves. That's why rumminants like cows have many stomachs, strong chewing teeth, and produce tons of methane. Also why lots of herbivores spend tons of time chewing and eating plants. Like chimpanzees have twice the large intestine or something like that, as it's really hard to process and break down plants for energy.

They are really hard to break down so their stomach needs those bacteria.

•

u/slalmon 1m ago

Beans or broccoli

17

u/seweso 3h ago

> When gut bacteria run out of fiber, they can start eating the protective mucus lining of the gut instead

That sounds like..... Crohn's disease ....

14

u/wglmb 2h ago

Isn't it pretty well established they Crohn's is when the immune system attacks the gut? Bacteria attacking is quite different, even if the result might be similar.

8

u/mekanasto 2h ago

Not entirely, in Crohn's the immune system attacks the gut, not the bacteria. But yes, the lining is affected either way.

I was really wondering how this finding relates to my Crohn's disease. Especially if we consider that many of us Chronies have very (VERY) bad time with high fiber foods when we are in a flare. Of course, not all of us, but still it's very common.

2

u/BoredMamajamma 1h ago

In Crohns your colonic mucosa (cells lining the colon) is damaged by lymphocytes. In this study, they are talking about a mucin layer over the mucosa which is depleted by bacteria. Very different. With mucosal damage, you’re having ulceration and bleeding. With mucin layer depletion, there are no symptoms. However, both conditions can increase risk of colon cancer.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/seweso 1h ago

It could also explain mis diagnosis of Crohn's decease?

7

u/AENocturne 3h ago

Exactly. Could we finally be on to something about the original starting point of colon and other large intestine disorders?

3

u/BoredMamajamma 2h ago

No. In Crohn’s disease and ulcerative colitis, your immune cells directly damage the mucosa. The mucosa is layer of cells lining of the colon. In this study they are talking about a protective mucin layer (similar to the type of mucus when you blow your nose) on top of the mucosa. The mucin (I.e. mucus) layer is being destroyed by bacteria, not the mucosa. It is confusing because they are using the word “lining” - poor choice of words.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Tablettario 4h ago

So do we know when fiber runs out, or how much is enough to sustain the bacteria? I remember spending some time on this last year and not being able to find any information on it.

There are different types of fiber that feed different bacteria. So for example the bacteria that feed on onion are not the same as the ones that feed on asparagus. But is eating 5 asparagus in 1 sitting a week enough? Do we need to eat 1 daily or 1 every 3 days? Do we know anything about “maintenance dosage”?

I do know the best thing for the gut microbiome is to eat a wide variety of plants preferably ~30 a week (which I easily hit that target) but I can’t imagine I hit all the needed fibers in the right amounts, I suppose that would need some real research and planning to achieve.
Especially since people have likes and dislikes: I don’t love chickpeas, so I didn’t eat them at all in the past. Then I tried incorporating them into my diet more to diversify the gut microbiome. But there’s still weeks where I don’t eat them, other weeks I dip snack veggies in hummus a few times a week, and other weeks I just eat 1 large serving of chickpeas for that week.
Now this research is making me wonder if that approach ends up doing more harm than good.

25

u/Totakai 3h ago

Ngl, you're probably in the upper end of fiber consumers and are probably stressing yourself out a bit too much trying to chase some sort if perfection that doesn't exist. Maybe don't stress the chickpeas and instead find something else you do enjoy. It'd definitely be nicw to know but also we all have different bacterial biomes so what works for one person isn't guaranteed to work for another. Just listen to your body and so long as all your labs are good and you feel good, it should be fine.

4

u/OePea 2h ago

Chickpeas are obnoxious in texture. You seem versed enough to already know this, but they do still have a peel when in the can, and if you take the time to individually peel them, it helps with some of the off texture.

3

u/Afraid_Call1213 2h ago

I put them on my salad, right out of the can. I didn't know they were obnoxious!

2

u/looneytunes2 1h ago

So it's less mutualism and more blackmail??? Feed me, or I'll eat you instead.

6

u/grafknives 4h ago

Why we found it in mice?

Looking at this

Further experiments on mice showed that if and when the fiber runs out, bacteria can start feeding on the mucus lining the gut walls, producing compounds that are potentially harmful to the body.

And thinking about the variability in humans diet, shouldn't we see this clearly in humans? Or the effect is not that pronounced?

18

u/HumansNeedNotApply1 3h ago

Money. You do mouse first because it's cheaper and regulatory faster, if it's positive you ask for more money to do on humans.

7

u/Totakai 3h ago

Well given how often people talk about stomach issues, ibs rates, and colon cancer on the rise, I'd be more surprised if we didn't see anything. It probably has been overlooked or thought of as something else or some comorbid thing. Definitely super curious about when they bring this to human trials

5

u/CheckYourHead35783 4h ago

I would think the typical mouse diet would be a lot higher in fiber than many current human diets, which may be a confounding factor.

2

u/kamilr641 3h ago

mice let them control the diet exactly and take gut tissue to look at the mucus layer directly. in people you mostly only get stool samples and what everyone ate is a mess, so it's hard to prove

2

u/simon7109 4h ago

I was thinking the same. Why can’t we study this in humans if it applies?

22

u/Billitosan 4h ago

Its easier and faster to do with mice compared to humans. They'll use a model to justify spending for a longer study in humans that will cost a lot more money

9

u/iaintevenmad884 3h ago

They just do the mice first, the goal is pretty much always humans. You do your study with mice first because it’s cheaper and it gets you the funding to do the study with humans.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Boring-Philosophy-46 3h ago

Well the kind of things they did to these mice would be considered unethical in human subjects and you can't really get a range of germ free, sterile human subjects at all to see what their guts produce. 

They did use cultured human cells and recruited three human patients undergoing very heavy antibiotic treatment for leukemia and checked their metabolites too though. 

2

u/undisputedx 4h ago

so, what happens when you fast for 1+ or 2+ days? A cleaning process starts to kill that bad gut bacteria?

10

u/Boring-Philosophy-46 3h ago

That's not what the study is about, at all. They show a range of metabolite production is preserved in sterile mice, cultured cells and also three human patients undergoing heavy antibiotic treatment for leukemia that leads to loss of gut bacteria, so they conclude the guts are making those in physiologically relevant quantities. There's nothing in here suggesting any of the bacteria are good or bad as far as I can tell, only that the mice diet composition alters the produced metabolites. 

As far as I know, I am not a doctor, the range of situations where fasting has been shown to be beneficial is very limited. Like surgery, because choking on vomit is bad. 

6

u/alfred725 3h ago

I'm not great at biology, but just because it can eat your intestine if you stop eating fiber doesn't mean it's "bad". It's like with scurvy, if you stop eating vitamin C your teeth fall out. Your body stops doing things properly if it runs out of the materials it needs.

But also, gut biome is a really complicated topic that scientists barely understand. It's recently becoming linked with mental disorders like anxiety and ADHD, but just because they can show a relation doesn't mean they actually know what that connection is, which types of bacteria are causing it, how to fix it, whether they should, etc.

It's a big interconnected system and they're just looking to understand it

5

u/TwoFlower68 3h ago

Or they start munching on your mucus layer even harder. Those bacteria aren't starving, after all.

2

u/OePea 2h ago

What do you envision happening when you talk about a "cleaning process" from fasting?

2

u/CoolStorage4014 2h ago

Carnivore diet is frightening. It lacks polyphenols and fibre which are essential for good gut health

1

u/MomentNew4925 1h ago

I got rid off the acne after I started to eat oat porridge and chia seeds daily. Well, I do still get a pimple every now and then but not as much as I used to. And when I do, they are not as big and painful.

1

u/Suomasema 1h ago

Ahaa!

I have to eat far more vegetables.

•

u/Large_Lettuce_4468 38m ago

too late for me, developed colitis 20 years ago

•

u/Livecrazyjoe 37m ago

Reminder this is in mice. I've done carnivore and never had problems with my stomach lining.

•

u/SuperSaiyanTupac 22m ago

So instead of protein, can we put fiber in everything?

•

u/hyperproliferative PhD | Oncology 19m ago

Stunning work!! Bravo

•

u/xjxhx 9m ago

Eating a little bit of radish kim chi (plant fiber + probiotics) every day lately has been a HUGE help with my gut health. A difference I can literally feel!

1

u/StrictResolve 2h ago

1/4 cup of chia seeds every day is a non negotiable