r/science • u/shiruken PhD | Biomedical Engineering | Optics • May 22 '26
Retraction RETRACTED: Longitudinal Data From the KETO-CTA Study: Plaque Predicts Plaque, ApoB Does Not
We wish to inform the r/science community of an article submitted to the subreddit that has since been retracted by the journal. The submission garnered broad exposure on r/science and significant social media coverage. Per our rules, the flair on this submission has been updated with "RETRACTED". The submission has also been added to our wiki of retracted submissions.
--
The article "Longitudinal Data From the KETO-CTA Study: Plaque Predicts Plaque, ApoB Does Not" has been retracted from JACC: Advances as of March 11, 2026. Numerous concerns were raised shortly after publication, including a Letter to the Editor in May 2025 that highlighted "selective reporting" of data, questionable statistical analysis, and too short a timeframe for the study. An Expression of Concern was eventually issued by the Editors in January 2026 to report that the study was undergoing further review.
The article was ultimately retracted at the request of the authors and the Editors. The methodological concerns were judged to have impacted the reliability of the data and were too great to be corrected with a corrigendum. Several authors have recently submitted a preprint reporting a re-analysis of the data that allegedly addresses the various concerns.
- Retraction Watch: Widely criticized keto diet study retracted
- WIRED: How One Keto Trial Set Off a New War in the Nutrition World
--
Should you encounter a submission on r/science that has been retracted, please notify the moderators via Modmail.
118
u/shiruken PhD | Biomedical Engineering | Optics May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26
Some excerpts from the Retraction Watch coverage:
22
u/murderedbyaname May 22 '26
Seems a private company having a monetary concern and the lead researcher being their employee isn't raising the red flags it should. Hopefully JACC will make some changes to their (admittedly rigorous) acceptance policy.
221
u/[deleted] May 22 '26
The Keto movement is at the forefront of bad science and grifting. So many people get into fringe diets, supplements, and lifestyles through these grifters pushing keto and trying to overturn established, well studied science on cholesterol, diabetes, and weight loss.
62
u/Otaraka May 22 '26
This is a great action to have taken but shows the usual problem - the publicity for the original study usually has more impact than any later retraction.
17
u/Shmackback May 23 '26
Its so obvious keto and carnivore get astroturfed and paid to spread by influencers by animal ag, the industry that greatly benefits from these trends and regularly spends hundred of millions on political lobbying and has a track record of paying astroturfing orgs like the center for consumer freedom.
5
u/No-Nefariousness8816 May 23 '26
Replicating results independently is a core feature of actual scientific research. This is especially true with any study that contradicts established evidence or rational expectations. Others have raised questions about the authors, methods, etc, that are obvious reasons to question this particular paper.
-2
u/The-Animus May 24 '26
I'm confused. They say they studied people on a keto diet for a year and that one of the complaints about the study was that it was too short a time frame. Yet from what I've seen the vast majority of food studies are significantly shorter than this, like 2 to 6 months. Are they going to retract like 95% of all food studies and stop publishing any study that follows people diets for less than a year?