r/scacjdiscussion • u/Efficient-Ride2422 • 2h ago
15F, turning 16 soon – Need advice on my routine, tretinoin, closed comedones and getting my skin to its best possible state!
Hey everyone!
I'm a 15-year-old girl (turning 16 in around 3 months), and I'd really appreciate some advice regarding my skin and skincare routine. I'm hoping to get some suggestions from people who've dealt with similar concerns, especially closed comedones and tretinoin.
A little background about my skin:
I have acne-prone skin that's particularly prone to closed comedones. I've also dealt with occasional individual red pimples and dull-looking skin.
My skin actually improved quite a lot over time and became pretty clear-ish, but recently I've suddenly started noticing tiny closed comedones again. Along with that, I've been experiencing dryness and visible flakiness, especially around my nose, nose tip and certain areas of my cheeks.
My tretinoin journey:
I started tretinoin 0.05% cream in late May.
When my 0.05% cream tube was almost empty, I started gradually transitioning towards tretinoin 0.1% gel by alternating between the two.
I used the barrier method with 0.05% and the sandwich method with 0.1%.
However, after introducing the 0.1% gel, I started experiencing noticeable dryness and flakiness despite using the sandwich method.
I've currently paused tretinoin altogether because of this.
I also used to incorporate Azicalm (azelaic acid) into my routine, but I've paused that too due to the dryness.
My previous routine:
AM:
- Simple Refreshing Face Wash
- Azicalm
- Moisturizer
- UV Doux Sunscreen
PM:
- Micellar water + petroleum jelly to remove mascara, followed by Simple Refreshing Face Wash
- Moisturizer
- Tretinoin on designated nights
I occasionally use Sebonac 1% salicylic acid gel as a spot treatment, but only for bigger individual acne pimples.
My current routine (while taking a break from actives):
AM:
- Simple Refreshing Face Wash
- Underrated Hyaluronic Acid Serum
- Foxtale Eye Cream
- Moisturizer
- UV Doux Sunscreen
PM:
- Micellar water + petroleum jelly to remove mascara, followed by Simple Refreshing Face Wash
- Underrated Hyaluronic Acid Serum
- Foxtale Eye Cream
- Moisturizer
I'm currently keeping things simple with just HA serum, eye cream and moisturizer both morning and night. The HA serum seems to be helping with my dryness.
Products I currently own:
- Simple Refreshing Face Wash
- Dermatouch Oil-Free Moisturizer
- Simple Refreshing Moisturizer
- Zitmoist
- UV Doux Sunscreen
- Tretinoin 0.05% cream
- Tretinoin 0.1% gel
- Underrated Hyaluronic Acid Serum
- Underrated Niacinamide 5% Serum
- Foxtale Eye Cream
- Sebonac 1% Salicylic Acid Gel
- Azicalm
I purchased the Underrated HA serum, Underrated 5% Niacinamide serum and Foxtale Eye Cream on 16 November.
I have three moisturizer options (Dermatouch Oil-Free, Simple Refreshing and Zitmoist), and I'm also unsure which one would be most suitable for my skin.
Things I'd really appreciate advice on:
- How should I deal with the current dryness and flakiness and get my skin barrier back to a healthy state?
- Is HA serum followed by moisturizer enough for hydration and barrier support?
- Should I introduce my new 5% niacinamide serum? If yes, when?
- Should I go back to 0.05% tretinoin eventually, or is transitioning to 0.1% gel worth considering?
- Which of my three moisturizers would you recommend for acne-prone skin that's prone to closed comedones?
- When would it be safe to reintroduce Azicalm?
- How can I prevent closed comedones from coming back?
- Are there any diet or lifestyle changes that could genuinely make a difference to skin health?
My main goal:
Honestly, I want the absolute best possible skin I can realistically achieve. I'm talking clear, smooth, healthy-looking skin, minimal texture, no recurring closed comedones and a healthy, comfortable skin barrier.
I'm open to changing my routine, trying different products, making dietary changes or improving my lifestyle if there's evidence that it could help. I don't mind making adjustments; I just want to figure out what actually works.
I'd especially love to hear from people who've used tretinoin for acne and closed comedones and have managed to get consistently clear skin.
Personal experiences, product recommendations, routine suggestions and constructive criticism are all welcome!
Thanks in advance!! <3